Directive Versus Participative Leadership: Two Complementary Approaches to Managing School Effectiveness

Purpose: The educational literature reflects the widely shared belief that participative leadership has an overwhelming advantage over the contrasting style of directive leadership in organizational and team effectiveness. The purpose of this study was to examine the relative effect of a directive leadership approach as compared with a participative leadership approach on school-staff teams’ motivational mechanisms (empowerment and organizational commitment) and effectiveness (team in-role performance and team innovation). Method: Data, which were obtained through a survey, were collected from 140 teams selected from 140 different elementary schools in northern Israel. Results: The results of the Structural Equation Model indicated a positive relation between directive leadership and organizational commitment, as well as a positive relation between directive leadership and school-staff team in-role performance. In addition, organizational commitment served as a mediator in the directive leadership-performance relationship. With respect to participative leadership, the results indicated a positive relation between participative leadership and teachers’ empowerment, and a positive relation between participative leadership and school-staff team innovation, and empowerment served as a mediator in the participative leadership-innovation relationship. Implications: These results suggested that managing tensions between directive and participative activities, bottom-up and top-down processes, and flexibility and discipline may provide a key to teachers’ high performance.

[1]  Anit Somech,et al.  Explicating the Complexity of Participative Management: An Investigation of Multiple Dimensions , 2002 .

[2]  P. M. Podsakoff,et al.  Self-Reports in Organizational Research: Problems and Prospects , 1986 .

[3]  G. Spreitzer.  PSYCHOLOGICAL EMPOWERMENT IN THE WORKPLACE: DIMENSIONS, MEASUREMENT, AND VALIDATION , 1995 .

[4]  J. Chapman.  School-Based Decision-Making and Management. , 1990 .

[5]  Liane Brouilletie.  Who Defines “Democratic Leadership”?: Three High School Principals Respond to Site-Based Reforms , 1997 .

[6]  P. Reeves,et al.  Empowerment , 2006, Encyclopedia of the UN Sustainable Development Goals.

[7]  David G. Schwartz,et al.  An empirical assessment of the loose–tight leadership model: quantitative and qualitative analyses , 2002 .

[8]  Eric M. Olson,et al.  Organizing for effective new product development: The moderating role of product innovativeness. , 1995 .

[9]  Shelley A. Kirkpatrick,et al.  Locus of Knowledge as a Determinant of the Effects of Participation on Performance, Affect, and Perceptions , 1995 .

[10]  Michael A. West,et al.  Handbook of Work Group Psychology , 1996 .

[11]  P. Short,et al.  Leadership in Empowered Schools: Themes from Innovative Efforts. Second Edition. , 2001 .

[12]  L. Porter,et al.  The Measurement of Organizational Commitment. , 1979 .

[13]  Abraham Sagie,et al.  Leader Direction and Employee Participation in Decision Making: Contradictory or Compatible Practices? , 1997 .

[14]  C. D. De Dreu,et al.  Minority dissent and team innovation: the importance of participation in decision making. , 2001, The Journal of applied psychology.

[15]  G. Spreitzer.  Social structural characteristics of psychological empowerment , 1996 .

[16]  M. Erez,et al.  Challenge versus threat effects on the goal–performance relationship , 2002 .

[17]  P. Short,et al.  Job Satisfaction and Empowerment among Teacher Leaders, Reading Recovery Teachers, and Regular Classroom Teachers. , 1993 .

[18]  A. Somech,et al.  Antecedents and Consequences of Teacher Organizational and Professional Commitment , 2002 .

[19]  John A. Wagner,et al.  Participation's Effects On Performance and Satisfaction: A Reconsideration Of Research Evidence , 1994 .

[20]  P. Short,et al.  School Participant Empowerment Scale: Assessment of Level of Empowerment within the School Environment , 1992 .

[21]  Michael Burda,et al.  Revolutionizing product development , 1993 .

[22]  James S. Rinehart,et al.  School-Based Decision Making and the Empowerment of Secondary School Teachers , 1998 .

[23]  Mariann Jelinek,et al.  The Innovation Marathon: Lessons from High Technology Firms , 1990 .

[24]  Paula A. White.  Teacher Empowerment Under “Ideal” School-Site Autonomy , 1992 .

[25]  John J. Sosik,et al.  EFFECTS OF LEADERSHIP STYLE AND PROBLEM STRUCTURE ON WORK GROUP PROCESS AND OUTCOMES IN AN ELECTRONIC MEETING SYSTEM ENVIRONMENT , 1997 .

[26]  P. Goldman,et al.  Rethinking Power in Schools , 1991 .

[27]  William D. Greenfield.  Toward a Theory of School Administration: The Centrality of Leadership , 1995 .

[28]  J Hogan,et al.  What we know about leadership. Effectiveness and personality. , 1994, The American psychologist.

[29]  M. West.  Sparkling Fountains or Stagnant Ponds: An Integrative Model of Creativity and Innovation Implementation in Work Groups , 2002 .

[30]  A. Somech,et al.  The Work Behavior of Israeli Elementary School Principals: Expectations Versus Reality , 1998 .

[31]  Marianne W. Lewis,et al.  PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT TENSIONS: EXPLORING CONTRASTING STYLES OF PROJECT MANAGEMENT , 2002 .

[32]  F. Fiedler.  The Effective Utilization of Intellectual Abilities and Job‐relevant Knowledge in Group Performance: Cognitive Resource Theory and an Agenda for the Future , 1989 .

[33]  Thomas J. Naughton,et al.  Individualized and Group-Based Views of Participation in Decision Making , 1992 .

[34]  P. Short,et al.  Creating Empowered Schools , 1994 .

[35]  Jane V. Wheeler,et al.  MANAGING FROM THE BOUNDARY: THE EFFECTIVE LEADERSHIP OF SELF-MANAGING WORK TEAMS. , 2001 .

[36]  Anil Gaba,et al.  Coda : Creativity and Improvisation in Jazzand Organizations: Implications Fororganizational Learning , 1998 .

[37]  Beverly M. Klecker,et al.  Another Look at the Dimensionality of the School Participant Empowerment Scale , 1998 .

[38]  M. O'Hair,et al.  Restructuring Schools for Democracy: Principals’ Perspectives , 1997 .

[39]  A. Bandura,et al.  Social Cognitive Theory of Organizational Management , 1989 .

[40]  Karen Seashore Louis,et al.  Does Teacher Empowerment Affect the Classroom? The Implications of Teacher Empowerment for Instructional Practice and Student Academic Performance , 1997 .

[41]  Fred M. Newmann,et al.  Continuing the bifurcation of affect and cognition , 1996 .

[42]  Abraham Sagie,et al.  Effects of Leader's Communication Style and Participative Goal Setting on Performance and Attitudes , 1996 .

[43]  F. Barrett.  Creativity and Improvisation in Jazz and Organizations: Implications for Organizational Learning , 1998 .

[44]  Larry E. Greiner,et al.  Organizational Transitions: Managing Complex Change , 1979 .

[45]  Jennifer A. Chatman,et al.  The Influence of Demographic Heterogeneity on the Emergence and Consequences of Cooperative Norms in Work Teams , 2001 .

[46]  Joseph F. Murphy,et al.  School-Based Management as School Reform: Taking Stock , 1995 .

[47]  John Godard,et al.  High Performance and the Transformation of Work? The Implications of Alternative Work Practices for the Experience and Outcomes of Work , 2001 .

[48]  Ulrich Reitzug.  A Case Study of Empowering Principal Behavior , 1994 .

[49]  H. Gaziel,et al.  School-Based Management as a Factor in School Effectiveness , 1998 .

[50]  Mark A. Smylie,et al.  Instructional Outcomes of School-Based Participative Decision Making , 1996 .

[51]  G. Yukl,et al.  Leadership in Organizations , 1981 .

[52]  H. P. Sims,et al.  Leading Workers to Lead Themselves: The External Leadership of Self-Managing Work Teams. , 1987 .

[53]  Michael A. West,et al.  Reflexivity, Effectiveness, and Mental Health in BBC-TV Production Teams , 1998 .

[54]  T. Mitchell,et al.  PATH-GOAL THEORY OF LEADERSHIP , 1975 .

[55]  Michael A. West,et al.  Job satisfaction and teamwork: The role of supervisor support , 2001 .

[56]  Eduardo Salas,et al.  Team Effectiveness and Decision Making in Organizations , 1995 .

[57]  G. Stasser,et al.  Effects of information load and percentage of shared information on the dissemination of unshared information during group discussion. , 1987 .

[58]  S. Wilson,et al.  How High and Low Self-Empowered Teachers Work with Colleagues and School Principals. , 1996 .

[59]  Henry L. Tosi.  A Theory of Goal Setting and Task Performance , 1991 .

[60]  K. Sirotnik,et al.  Preparing Educators for Leadership: In Praise of Experience1 , 1996 .

[61]  F. Fiedler,et al.  Leadership theory and research: A report of progress. , 1994 .

[62]  Deborah G. . Ancona,et al.  Bridging the Boundary: External Activity and Performance in Organizational Teams. , 1992 .

[63]  Edwin A. Locke,et al.  Effects of Leader Role, Team-Set Goal Difficulty, Efficacy, and Tactics on Team Effectiveness , 1997 .

[64]  E. Deines.  Participative management. , 1981, Nursing management.

[65]  S. Harris,et al.  Creating Readiness for Organizational Change , 1993 .

[66]  D. Rousseau.  Issues of level in organizational research: Multi-level and cross-level perspectives. , 1985 .

[67]  D. Magnusson,et al.  Personality at the crossroads : current issues in interactional psychology , 1977 .

[68]  Sharon K. Parker,et al.  Job and work design : organizing work to promote well-being and effectiveness , 1998 .

[69]  Daniel A. Levinthal,et al.  ABSORPTIVE CAPACITY: A NEW PERSPECTIVE ON LEARNING AND INNOVATION , 1990 .

[70]  Edward F. McDonough,et al.  Speeding Up New Product Development: The Effects of Leadership Style and Source of Technology , 1991 .

[71]  M. West,et al.  Sharing the burden - teamwork in health care settings , 1999 .

[72]  David Dryden Henningsen,et al.  The Impact of Directive Leadership on Group Information Sampling, Decisions, and Perceptions of the Leader , 1999 .

[73]  K. Eisenhardt,et al.  Accelerating Adaptive Processes: Product Innovation in the Global Computer Industry , 1995 .

[74]  Randall P. Settoon,et al.  Social Exchange in Organizations: Perceived Organizational Support, Leader-Member Exchange, and Employee Reciprocity , 1996 .

[75]  J. Blase.  Facilitative school leadership and teacher empowerment: Teacher's perspectives , 1996 .

[76]  Bernard M. Bass,et al.  Does the Transactional-Transformational Leadership Paradigm Transcend Organizational and National Boundaries? , 1997 .

[77]  C. Cooper,et al.  International review of industrial and organizational psychology , 1986 .

[78]  Clint Chadwick,et al.  TO AGREE OR NOT TO AGREE: THE EFFECTS OF VALUE CONGRUENCE, INDIVIDUAL DEMOGRAPHIC DISSIMILARITY, AND CONFLICT ON WORKGROUP OUTCOMES , 1997 .

[79]  M. Brown,et al.  Commonalities between Perceptions and Practice in Models of School Decision-Making Systems in Secondary Schools in England and Wales. , 1999 .

[80]  S. Conley,et al.  From School-Site Management to Participatory School-Site Management. , 1990 .

[81]  D. Tjosvold,et al.  Interdependence and Controversy in Group Decision Making: Antecedents to Effective Self-Managing Teams. , 1998, Organizational behavior and human decision processes.

[82]  F. Fiedler,et al.  Cognitive resource theory and the utilization of the leader's and group members' technical competence , 1992 .

[83]  Randall S. Peterson,et al.  A directive leadership style in group decision making can be both virtue and vice: Evidence from elite and experimental groups. , 1997 .

[84]  I. Ajzen,et al.  Belief, Attitude, Intention, and Behavior: An Introduction to Theory and Research , 1977 .

[85]  Cultivating Innovation: How a Charter/District Network is Turning Professional Development into Professional Practice , 2002 .

[86]  L. James,et al.  rwg: An assessment of within-group interrater agreement. , 1993 .

[87]  James R. Pennell,et al.  Teacher Commitment, Working Conditions, and Differential Incentive Policies , 1993 .

[88]  K. Thomas,et al.  Cognitive Elements of Empowerment: An “Interpretive” Model of Intrinsic Task Motivation , 1990 .

[89]  Gene I. Maeroff,et al.  Teacher Empowerment: a Step Toward Professionalization , 1988 .

[90]  Jennifer M. George,et al.  Personality, affect, and behavior in groups. , 1990 .

[91]  Michael A. West,et al.  The social psychology of innovation in groups. , 1990 .

[92]  Vivian Wu,et al.  The relationship of empowerment to teacher job commitment and job satisfaction. , 1996 .

[93]  A. Bryk.  The State of Chicago School Reform. , 1994 .

[94]  Jonathan Nook,et al.  ["A Model for New Product Development: An Empirical Test"] , 2007 .

[95]  A. Hargreaves.  Restructuring restructuring: postmodernity and the prospects for educational change , 1994 .

[96]  R. Payne,et al.  Stress in health professionals : psychological and organizational causes and interventions , 1999 .

[97]  A. Edmondson.  Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams , 1999 .

[98]  Milton D. Rosenau,et al.  Managing the Development of New Products: Achieving Speed and Quality Simultaneously Through Multifunctional Teamwork (Управление разработкой новых продуктов: использование многофункциональных команд для одновременного достижения скорости и качества) , 1993 .

[99]  B. Avolio,et al.  Effects of Leadership Style and Followers' Cultural Orientation on Performance in Group and Individual Task Conditions , 1999 .

[100]  Bernard M. Bass,et al.  Handbook of Leadership , 1990 .

[101]  K. Weick.  Educational organizations as loosely coupled systems , 1976, Gestión y Estrategia.

[102]  Debra L. Shapiro,et al.  Maximizing cross-functional new product teams' innovativeness and constraint adherence: A conflict communications perspective. , 2001 .