World Health Organization Estimates of the Relative Contributions of Food to the Burden of Disease Due to Selected Foodborne Hazards: A Structured Expert Elicitation

Background The Foodborne Disease Burden Epidemiology Reference Group (FERG) was established in 2007 by the World Health Organization (WHO) to estimate the global burden of foodborne diseases (FBDs). This estimation is complicated because most of the hazards causing FBD are not transmitted solely by food; most have several potential exposure routes consisting of transmission from animals, by humans, and via environmental routes including water. This paper describes an expert elicitation study conducted by the FERG Source Attribution Task Force to estimate the relative contribution of food to the global burden of diseases commonly transmitted through the consumption of food. Methods and Findings We applied structured expert judgment using Cooke’s Classical Model to obtain estimates for 14 subregions for the relative contributions of different transmission pathways for eleven diarrheal diseases, seven other infectious diseases and one chemical (lead). Experts were identified through international networks followed by social network sampling. Final selection of experts was based on their experience including international working experience. Enrolled experts were scored on their ability to judge uncertainty accurately and informatively using a series of subject-matter specific ‘seed’ questions whose answers are unknown to the experts at the time they are interviewed. Trained facilitators elicited the 5th, and 50th and 95th percentile responses to seed questions through telephone interviews. Cooke’s Classical Model uses responses to the seed questions to weigh and aggregate expert responses. After this interview, the experts were asked to provide 5th, 50th, and 95th percentile estimates for the ‘target’ questions regarding disease transmission routes. A total of 72 experts were enrolled in the study. Ten panels were global, meaning that the experts should provide estimates for all 14 subregions, whereas the nine panels were subregional, with experts providing estimates for one or more subregions, depending on their experience in the region. The size of the 19 hazard-specific panels ranged from 6 to 15 persons with several experts serving on more than one panel. Pathogens with animal reservoirs (e.g. non-typhoidal Salmonella spp. and Toxoplasma gondii) were in general assessed by the experts to have a higher proportion of illnesses attributable to food than pathogens with mainly a human reservoir, where human-to-human transmission (e.g. Shigella spp. and Norovirus) or waterborne transmission (e.g. Salmonella Typhi and Vibrio cholerae) were judged to dominate. For many pathogens, the foodborne route was assessed relatively more important in developed subregions than in developing subregions. The main exposure routes for lead varied across subregions, with the foodborne route being assessed most important only in two subregions of the European region. Conclusions For the first time, we present worldwide estimates of the proportion of specific diseases attributable to food and other major transmission routes. These findings are essential for global burden of FBD estimates. While gaps exist, we believe the estimates presented here are the best current source of guidance to support decision makers when allocating resources for control and intervention, and for future research initiatives.

[1]  R. M. Cooke,et al.  Evaluation of a Performance-Based Expert Elicitation: WHO Global Attribution of Foodborne Diseases , 2016, PloS one.

[2]  N. Speybroeck,et al.  Methodological Framework for World Health Organization Estimates of the Global Burden of Foodborne Disease , 2015, PloS one.

[3]  N. Speybroeck,et al.  World Health Organization Global Estimates and Regional Comparisons of the Burden of Foodborne Disease in 2010 , 2015, PLoS medicine.

[4]  H. van Loveren,et al.  World Health Organization estimates of the global and regional disease burden of four foodborne chemical toxins, 2010: a data synthesis , 2015, F1000Research.

[5]  Tine Hald,et al.  World Health Organization Estimates of the Global and Regional Disease Burden of 22 Foodborne Bacterial, Protozoal, and Viral Diseases, 2010: A Data Synthesis , 2015, PLoS medicine.

[6]  Arie Havelaar,et al.  World Health Organization Estimates of the Global and Regional Disease Burden of 11 Foodborne Parasitic Diseases, 2010: A Data Synthesis , 2015, PLoS medicine.

[7]  Roger M. Cooke,et al.  Messaging climate change uncertainty , 2015 .

[8]  H. Loveren,et al.  World Health Organization estimates of the global and regional disease burden of four foodborne chemical toxins , 2010 : a data synthesis [ version 1 ; referees : awaiting peer review ] , 2015 .

[9]  Margaret Chan Food safety must accompany food and nutrition security , 2014, The Lancet.

[10]  Martyn D Kirk,et al.  Proportion of illness acquired by foodborne transmission for nine enteric pathogens in Australia: an expert elicitation. , 2014, Foodborne pathogens and disease.

[11]  Tine Hald,et al.  Source attribution of human salmonellosis: an overview of methods and estimates. , 2014, Foodborne pathogens and disease.

[12]  T. Hald,et al.  Attributing foodborne salmonellosis in humans to animal reservoirs in the European Union using a multi-country stochastic model , 2014, Epidemiology and Infection.

[13]  R Core Team,et al.  R: A language and environment for statistical computing. , 2014 .

[14]  T. Hald,et al.  Source attribution of human campylobacteriosis in Denmark , 2013, Epidemiology and Infection.

[15]  Willy P Aspinall,et al.  An expert judgement assessment of future sea level rise from the ice sheets , 2013 .

[16]  Sara M Pires,et al.  Assessing the applicability of currently available methods for attributing foodborne disease to sources, including food and food commodities. , 2013, Foodborne pathogens and disease.

[17]  John A. Painter,et al.  Attribution of Foodborne Illnesses, Hospitalizations, and Deaths to Food Commodities by using Outbreak Data, United States, 1998–2008 , 2013, Emerging infectious diseases.

[18]  E. Nielsen,et al.  Attributing foodborne salmonellosis in humans to animal reservoirs in the European Union using a multi-country stochastic mode , 2013 .

[19]  Roger M. Cooke,et al.  Expert judgement and re-elicitation for prion disease risk uncertainties , 2012 .

[20]  T. Hald,et al.  Attributing human foodborne illness to food sources and water in Latin America and the Caribbean using data from outbreak investigations. , 2012, International journal of food microbiology.

[21]  T. Hald,et al.  Source attribution of human campylobacteriosis using a meta-analysis of case-control studies of sporadic infections , 2012, Epidemiology and Infection.

[22]  T. Hald,et al.  Source attribution of human salmonellosis using a meta-analysis of case-control studies of sporadic infections , 2011, Epidemiology and Infection.

[23]  Franco Flandoli,et al.  Comparison of a new expert elicitation model with the Classical Model, equal weights and single experts, using a cross-validation technique , 2011, Reliab. Eng. Syst. Saf..

[24]  M. W. Reij,et al.  Risk-based Estimate of Effect of Foodborne Diseases on Public Health, Greece , 2011, Emerging infectious diseases.

[25]  André Ravel,et al.  Food-specific attribution of selected gastrointestinal illnesses: estimates from a Canadian expert elicitation survey. , 2011, Foodborne pathogens and disease.

[26]  Craig W. Hedberg,et al.  Foodborne Illness Acquired in the United States , 2011, Emerging infectious diseases.

[27]  K. Ong,et al.  Application of Bayesian techniques to model the burden of human salmonellosis attributable to U.S. food commodities at the point of processing: adaptation of a Danish model. , 2011, Foodborne pathogens and disease.

[28]  Susie ElSaadany,et al.  Expert Elicitation for the Judgment of Prion Disease Risk Uncertainties , 2011, Journal of toxicology and environmental health. Part A.

[29]  André Ravel,et al.  Foodborne proportion of gastrointestinal illness: estimates from a Canadian expert elicitation survey. , 2010, Foodborne pathogens and disease.

[30]  T. Hald,et al.  Using outbreak data for source attribution of human salmonellosis and campylobacteriosis in Europe. , 2010, Foodborne pathogens and disease.

[31]  G. Nichols,et al.  Attribution of human Listeria monocytogenes infections in England and Wales to ready-to-eat food sources placed on the market: adaptation of the Hald Salmonella source attribution model. , 2010, Foodborne pathogens and disease.

[32]  C. Stein,et al.  Evolving public health approaches to the global challenge of foodborne infections. , 2010, International journal of food microbiology.

[33]  P. Cressey,et al.  Risk Ranking for Foodborne Microbial Hazards in New Zealand: Burden of Disease Estimates , 2010, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis.

[34]  Tine Hald,et al.  Integrated Approaches for the Public Health Prioritization of Foodborne and Zoonotic Pathogens , 2010, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis.

[35]  Isaac CH Fung,et al.  Water, sanitation and hygiene for the prevention of diarrhoea , 2010, International journal of epidemiology.

[36]  W. Aspinall A route to more tractable expert advice , 2010, Nature.

[37]  Paul R Hunter,et al.  Household water treatment in developing countries: comparing different intervention types using meta-regression. , 2009, Environmental science & technology.

[38]  P. Gale,et al.  Assessing the impact of climate change on vector-borne viruses in the EU through the elicitation of expert opinion , 2009, Epidemiology and Infection.

[39]  Simon E F Spencer,et al.  Source Attribution of Food‐Borne Zoonoses in New Zealand: A Modified Hald Model , 2009, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis.

[40]  Tine Hald,et al.  Attributing the human disease burden of foodborne infections to specific sources. , 2009, Foodborne pathogens and disease.

[41]  W. Aspinall,et al.  Developing an Event Tree for probabilistic hazard and risk assessment at Vesuvius , 2008 .

[42]  W. Aspinall,et al.  Emergency planning and mitigation at Vesuvius: A new evidence-based approach , 2008 .

[43]  Roger M Cooke,et al.  Attribution of foodborne pathogens using structured expert elicitation. , 2008, Foodborne pathogens and disease.

[44]  Daniel J. Wilson,et al.  Tracing the Source of Campylobacteriosis , 2008, PLoS genetics.

[45]  Roger M. Cooke,et al.  On the performance of social network and likelihood-based expert weighting schemes , 2008, Reliab. Eng. Syst. Saf..

[46]  Roger M. Cooke,et al.  TU Delft expert judgment data base , 2008, Reliab. Eng. Syst. Saf..

[47]  Evers Eg,et al.  Campylobacter source attribution by exposure assessment , 2008 .

[48]  A. Prüss-Ustün,et al.  The Global Burden of Disease Assessments—WHO Is Responsible? , 2007, PLoS neglected tropical diseases.

[49]  A H Havelaar,et al.  Towards an Integrated Approach in Supporting Microbiological Food Safety Decisions , 2007, Zoonoses and public health.

[50]  Sandra Hoffmann,et al.  Using expert elicitation to link foodborne illnesses in the United States to foods. , 2007, Journal of food protection.

[51]  Olivier Andreoletti,et al.  Scientific Opinion of the Panel on Biological Hazards , 2007 .

[52]  Charles B. Connor,et al.  Statistics in Volcanology , 2006 .

[53]  Roger M. Cooke,et al.  Probabilistic inversion for chicken processing lines , 2006, Reliab. Eng. Syst. Saf..

[54]  Willy P Aspinall,et al.  Structured elicitation of expert judgment for probabilistic hazard and risk assessment in volcanic eruptions , 2006 .

[55]  W. Adger,et al.  Eliciting Information from Experts on the Likelihood of Rapid Climate Change , 2005, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis.

[56]  H. J. van der Fels-Klerx,et al.  A Structured Expert Judgment Study for a Model of Campylobacter Transmission During Broiler‐Chicken Processing , 2005, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis.

[57]  Elizabeth A. Casman,et al.  Elicitation of Expert Judgments of Uncertainty in the Risk Assessment of Herbicide‐Tolerant Oilseed Crops , 2004, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis.

[58]  R. Cooke,et al.  Expert judgement elicitation for risk assessments of critical infrastructures , 2004 .

[59]  Nebojsa Nakicenovic,et al.  Characterizing Climate-Change Uncertainties for Decision-Makers. An Editorial Essay , 2004 .

[60]  Tine Hald,et al.  A Bayesian Approach to Quantify the Contribution of Animal‐Food Sources to Human Salmonellosis , 2004, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis.

[61]  Nebojsa Nakicenovic,et al.  Characterizing Climate-Change Uncertainties for Decision-Makers , 2004 .

[62]  Majid Ezzati,et al.  For Personal Use. Only Reproduce with Permission from the Lancet Publishing Group , 2022 .

[63]  R. Cooke,et al.  Procedures Guide for Structural Expert Judgement in Accident Consequence Modelling , 2000 .

[64]  Roger M. Cooke,et al.  Expert Judgement and the Montserrat Volcano Eruption , 1998 .

[65]  R. Cooke Experts in Uncertainty: Opinion and Subjective Probability in Science , 1991 .

[66]  J. Rice Mathematical Statistics and Data Analysis , 1988 .