Moral justifications for surrogate decision making in the intensive care unit: implications and limitations.

Because patients are often unable to participate in the end-of-life decision making, caregivers turn to close family members to participate in discussions regarding care in the intensive care unit. This article describes the moral justifications for families being given considerable decision-making authority. However, embedded within these justifications are also some limitations to surrogate decision making. Rather than attempt to dogmatically resolve these thorny cases regarding a surrogate's request for what healthcare providers believe are unreasonable requests, we believe more attention should be paid to how healthcare providers and intensive care units can promote a surrogate's ability to make ethical decisions. We end by offering a number of specific suggestions for improving communication with surrogates.

[1]  John P. Mullooly,et al.  Physician-Patient Communication: The Relationship With Malpractice Claims Among Primary Care Physicians and Surgeons , 1997 .

[2]  T. Powell,et al.  Extubating Mrs. K: Psychological Aspects of Surrogate Decision Making , 1999, Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics.

[3]  François Lemaire,et al.  Impact of a family information leaflet on effectiveness of information provided to family members of intensive care unit patients: a multicenter, prospective, randomized, controlled trial. , 2002, American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine.

[4]  P. Butow,et al.  Patient participation in the cancer consultation: evaluation of a question prompt sheet. , 1994, Annals of oncology : official journal of the European Society for Medical Oncology.

[5]  A. Abernethy,et al.  Families looking back: One year after discussion of withdrawal or withholding of life-sustaining support , 2001, Critical care medicine.

[6]  G. F. Judisch,et al.  Informed Consent. Legal Theory and Clinical Practice , 1988 .

[7]  R. Veatch,et al.  Medically Futile Care: The Role of the Physician in Setting Limits , 1992, American Journal of Law & Medicine.

[8]  C. Levine,et al.  Hands On/Hands Off: Why Health Care Professionals Depend on Families but Keep Them at Arm's Length , 2000, Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics.

[9]  J. L. Nelson.  Taking families seriously. , 1992, The Hastings Center report.

[10]  B. Lo,et al.  How strictly do dialysis patients want their advance directives followed? , 1992, JAMA.

[11]  E. Emanuel,et al.  Proxy decision making for incompetent patients. An ethical and empirical analysis. , 1992, JAMA.

[12]  J. Kutner,et al.  Information needs in terminal illness. , 1999, Social science & medicine.

[13]  D. Brock.  What is the moral authority of family members to act as surrogates for incompetent patients? , 1996, The Milbank quarterly.

[14]  J. Lynn,et al.  Patients Who Want their Family and Physician to Make Resuscitation Decisions for Them: Observations from SUPPORT and HELP , 2000, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[15]  D. R. Shaffer,et al.  Activity restriction and prior relationship history as contributors to mental health outcomes among middle-aged and older spousal caregivers. , 1998, Health psychology : official journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association.

[16]  S. Miles,et al.  The illusion of futility in clinical practice. , 1989, The American journal of medicine.

[17]  C. Levine,et al.  The Trouble with Families: Toward an Ethic of Accommodation , 1999, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[18]  A. Wu,et al.  Prognosis-based futility guidelines: does anyone win? SUPPORT Investigators. Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences for Outcomes and Risks of Treatment. , 1994, Journal of The American Geriatrics Society.

[19]  D L Patrick,et al.  The family conference as a focus to improve communication about end-of-life care in the intensive care unit: opportunities for improvement. , 2001, Critical care medicine.

[20]  L. Snyder.  When Doctors Say No: The Battleground of Medical Futility , 1999 .

[21]  P. Butow,et al.  Meeting patients' information needs beyond the year 2000 , 1997, Supportive Care in Cancer.

[22]  A. Mosenthal.  Managing Death in the Intensive Care Unit: The Transition from Cure to Comfort: Edited by J. Randall Curtis and Gordon D. Rubenfeld Published by Oxford University Press, New York, 2001 388 pages, $59.95 , 2002 .

[23]  C Dyer,et al.  Right to die. , 1989, BMJ.

[24]  S. Goold,et al.  Conflicts regarding decisions to limit treatment: a differential diagnosis. , 2000, JAMA.

[25]  K. Howe,et al.  An empirical study of proxy consent for elderly persons. , 1990, The Gerontologist.

[26]  P. Butow,et al.  The take-home message: patients prefer consultation audiotapes to summary letters. , 1994, Journal of clinical oncology : official journal of the American Society of Clinical Oncology.

[27]  J. Lynn,et al.  Is economic hardship on the families of the seriously ill associated with patient and surrogate care preferences? SUPPORT Investigators. , 1996, Archives of internal medicine.

[28]  W. Knaus,et al.  Prognosis‐Based Futility Guidelines: Does Anyone Win? , 1994 .

[29]  P. Sjödén,et al.  Quality of life of cancer patients and their spouses in palliative home care , 1998, Palliative medicine.

[30]  M. Kapp.  Commentary: Anxieties as a Legal Impediment to the Doctor-Proxy Relationship , 1999, Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics.

[31]  K. Schroeter.  A Study of Proactive Ethics Consultation for Critically and Terminally Ill Patients with Extended Lengths of Stay , 2000 .

[32]  P. Butow,et al.  Audiotapes of oncology consultations: only for the first consultation? , 2002, Annals of oncology : official journal of the European Society for Medical Oncology.

[33]  J. le Gall,et al.  Symptoms of anxiety and depression in family members of intensive care unit patients: Ethical hypothesis regarding decision-making capacity , 2001, Critical care medicine.

[34]  Consensus report on the ethics of foregoing life‐sustaining treatments in the critically ill TASK FORCE ON ETHICS OF THE SOCIETY OF CRITICAL CARE MEDICINE , 1990, Critical care medicine.

[35]  K. Haley,et al.  An intensive communication intervention for the critically ill. , 2000, The American journal of medicine.

[36]  M. Levy,et al.  End-of-life care in the intensive care unit: can we do better? , 2001, Critical care medicine.

[37]  Michael J Barry,et al.  Health Decision Aids To Facilitate Shared Decision Making in Office Practice , 2002, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[38]  P. Butow,et al.  Promoting patient participation and shortening cancer consultations: a randomised trial , 2001, British Journal of Cancer.

[39]  S. Youngner.  Who defines futility? , 1988, JAMA.

[40]  J. Garrett,et al.  What Is Wrong With End‐of‐Life Care? Opinions of Bereaved Family Members , 1997, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[41]  S Chevret,et al.  Half the families of intensive care unit patients experience inadequate communication with physicians , 2000, Critical care medicine.

[42]  S. Youngner.  Futility in context. , 1990, JAMA.

[43]  R. Truog,et al.  The problem with futility. , 1992, The New England journal of medicine.

[44]  S. Youngner.  Applying Futility: Saying No Is Not Enough , 1994, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[45]  A. Jonsen,et al.  Medical futility: its meaning and ethical implications. , 1990, Annals of internal medicine.