The Mentor’s Dilemma: Providing Critical Feedback Across the Racial Divide

Two studies examined the response of Black and White students to critical feedback presented either alone or buffered with additional information to ameliorate its negative effects. Black students who received unbuffered critical feedback responded less favorably than White students both in ratings of the evaluator’s bias and in measures of task motivation. By contrast, when the feedback was accompanied both by an invocation of high standards and by an assurance of the student’s capacity to reach those standards, Black students responded as positively as White students and both groups reported enhanced identification with relevant skills and careers. This “wise,” two-faceted intervention proved more effective than buffering criticism either with performance praise (Study 1) or with an invocation of high standards alone (Study 2). The role of stigma in mediating responses to critical feedback, and the implications of our results for mentoring and other teacher-student interactions, are explored.

[1]  Steven J. Karau,et al.  PERSONALITY AND SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY BULLETIN , 1999 .

[2]  S. Spencer,et al.  Stereotype Threat and Women's Math Performance , 1999 .

[3]  K. Harber.  Feedback to minorities: evidence of a positive bias. , 1998, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[4]  C. Dweck,et al.  Praise for intelligence can undermine children's motivation and performance. , 1998, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[5]  C. Steele.  A threat in the air. How stereotypes shape intellectual identity and performance. , 1997, The American psychologist.

[6]  E. Cose.  Color-Blind: Seeing Beyond Race in a Race-Obsessed World , 1996 .

[7]  Paul W. Richardson.  The culture of education , 1996 .

[8]  C. Steele,et al.  Stereotype threat and the intellectual test performance of African Americans. , 1995, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[9]  C. Dweck,et al.  Implicit Theories and Their Role in Judgments and Reactions: A Word From Two Perspectives , 1995 .

[10]  B. Lewis,et al.  House of Cards: Psychology and Psychotherapy Built on Myth , 1995 .

[11]  R. Dawes,et al.  House of Cards: Psychology and Psychotherapy Built on Myth. , 1995 .

[12]  Sandra Graham,et al.  Motivation in African Americans , 1994 .

[13]  Robert J. Crutcher,et al.  The role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance. , 1993 .

[14]  Abbas Tashakkori,et al.  Race, gender and pre-adolescent self-structure: a test of construct-specificity hypothesis , 1993 .

[15]  Deborah A. Prentice,et al.  Pluralistic ignorance and alcohol use on campus: some consequences of misperceiving the social norm. , 1993, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[16]  M. Lepper,et al.  Motivational techniques of expert human tutors: Lessons for the design of computer-based tutors. , 1993 .

[17]  Claude M. Steele,et al.  Race and the Schooling of Black Americans. , 1992 .

[18]  Kristin E. Voelkl,et al.  Social Stigma: The Affective Consequences of Attributional Ambiguity , 1991 .

[19]  A. Tashakkori,et al.  Race differences in self-perception and locus of control during adolescence and early adulthood: methodological implications. , 1990, Genetic, social, and general psychology monographs.

[20]  P. Christopher Earley,et al.  IMPACT OF PROCESS AND OUTCOME FEEDBACK ON THE RELATION OF GOAL SETTING TO TASK PERFORMANCE , 1990 .

[21]  C. Sansone,et al.  Effects of instruction on intrinsic interest: the importance of context. , 1989, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[22]  R. Koestner,et al.  Attributional Focus of Praise and Children's Intrinsic Motivation , 1989 .

[23]  H. Weisinger.  The Critical Edge: How to Criticize Up and Down Your Organization and Make It Pay Off , 1989 .

[24]  J. Crocker,et al.  Social stigma and self-esteem: The self-protective properties of stigma. , 1989 .

[25]  M. Lepper.  Motivational Considerations in the Study of Instruction , 1988 .

[26]  James P. Comer,et al.  Educating Poor Minority Children. , 1988 .

[27]  J. Mathews.  Escalante: The Best Teacher in America , 1988 .

[28]  C. Dweck,et al.  A social-cognitive approach to motivation and personality , 1988 .

[29]  Reuben M. Baron,et al.  An ecological perspective on integrating personality and social psychology. , 1987 .

[30]  R. Butler.  Task-involving and ego-involving properties of evaluation: Effects of different feedback conditions on motivational perceptions, interest, and performance. , 1987 .

[31]  R. Koestner,et al.  Praise, involvement, and intrinsic motivation. , 1987 .

[32]  Sandra Graham,et al.  Developmental Study of Praise and Blame as Attributional Cues. , 1987 .

[33]  P. Earley.  An examination of the mechanisms underlying the relation of feedback to performance , 1986 .

[34]  M. Holt,et al.  Effective teaching and mentoring , 1986 .

[35]  Carol S. Dweck,et al.  Motivational processes affecting learning. , 1986 .

[36]  T. Horn.  Coaches' Feedback and Changes in Children's Perceptions of Their Physical Competence. , 1985 .

[37]  I. Berlin.  School Power: Implications of an Intervention Project , 1982 .

[38]  W. Meyer,et al.  The informational value of evaluative behavior: Influences of praise and blame on perceptions of ability. , 1979 .

[39]  J. Gibson.  The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception , 1979 .

[40]  John G. Nicholls,et al.  The Development of the Concepts of Effort and Ability, Perception of Academic Attainment, and the Understanding that Difficult Tasks Require More Ability. , 1978 .

[41]  William S. Davidson,et al.  Sex Differences in Learned Helplessness: II. The Contingencies of Evaluative Feedback in the Classroom and III. An Experimental Analysis , 1978 .

[42]  C. Dweck,et al.  An Analysis of Learned Helplessness: Continuous Changes in Performance, Strategy, and Achievement Cognitions Following Failure. , 1978 .

[43]  William S. Davidson,et al.  Sex differences in learned helplessness: II. The contingencies of evaluative feedback in the classroom and III. An experimental analysis. , 1978 .

[44]  A. Bandura.  Self-efficacy: toward a unifying theory of behavioral change. , 1977, Psychology Review.

[45]  W. Banks,et al.  Perceived objectivity and the effects of evaluative reinforcement upon compliance and self-evaluation in blacks , 1977 .

[46]  S. Dornbusch,et al.  Racism without Racists: Institutional Racism in Urban Schools , 1975 .

[47]  Mark R. Lepper,et al.  Perseverance in self-perception and social perception: biased attributional processes in the debriefing paradigm. , 1975, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[48]  Celestino Fernández.  Factors Perpetuating the Low Academic Status of Chicano High School Students. Research and Development Memorandum No. 138. , 1975 .

[49]  J. Kleinfeld.  Effective Teachers of Eskimo and Indian Students , 1975, The School Review.

[50]  A. Whimbey,et al.  Intelligence can be taught , 1975 .

[51]  B. Weiner.  Achievement Motivation and Attribution Theory , 1974 .

[52]  B. Weiner.  Theories of motivation : from mechanism to cognition , 1972 .

[53]  D. J. Lee.  Society and the Adolescent Self-Image , 1969 .

[54]  N. Gage,et al.  Center for Research and Development in Teaching. , 1968 .

[55]  R. Kleck,et al.  Physical Stigma and Nonverbal Cues Emitted in Face-to-face Interaction , 1968 .

[56]  R. Weiss.  Ingratiation. A social psychological analysis , 1967 .

[57]  M. Rosenberg.  Society and the adolescent self-image , 1966 .

[58]  Elliot Aronson,et al.  Gain and loss of esteem as determinants of interpersonal attractiveness , 1965 .

[59]  E. Goffman.  Stigma; Notes On The Management Of Spoiled Identity , 1964 .

[60]  Rubin Gotesky,et al.  On knowing; essays for the left hand , 1963 .