The Effects of Moral and Pragmatic Arguments Against Torture on Demands for Judicial Reform

Torture can be opposed on the basis of pragmatic (e.g., torture does not work) or moral arguments (e.g., torture violates human rights). Three studies investigated how these arguments affect U.S. citizens' attitudes toward U.S.-committed torture. In Study 1, participants expressed stronger demands for redressing the injustice of torture when presented with moral rather than pragmatic or no arguments against torture. Study 2 replicated this finding with an extended justice measure and also showed the moderating role of ingroup glorification and attachment. Moral arguments increased justice demands among those who typically react most defensively to ingroup-committed wrongdoings: the highly attached and glorifying. Study 3 showed that the effect of moral arguments against torture on justice demands and support for torture among high glorifiers is mediated by moral outrage and empathy but not guilt.

[1]  M. Kendall.  Statistical Methods for Research Workers , 1937, Nature.

[2]  L. Festinger,et al.  A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance , 2017 .

[3]  P. Tannenbaum,et al.  Theories of cognitive consistency: a sourcebook. , 1968 .

[4]  M. Brewer.  In-group bias in the minimal intergroup situation: A cognitive-motivational analysis. , 1979 .

[5]  J. Cacioppo,et al.  Issue involvement can increase or decrease persuasion by enhancing message-relevant cognitive responses. , 1979 .

[6]  John T. Cacioppo,et al.  Effects of Forwarning of Persuasive Intent and Involvement on Cognitive Responses and Persuasion , 1979 .

[7]  J. Cooper,et al.  A New Look at Dissonance Theory , 1984 .

[8]  Ronald P. Carver,et al.  How Good Are Some of the World's Best Readers?. , 1985 .

[9]  P. O’Gorman,et al.  The Expanding Circle: Ethics and Sociobiology , 1986 .

[10]  C. Steele.  The Psychology of Self-Affirmation: Sustaining the Integrity of the Self , 1988 .

[11]  Richard Reardon,et al.  Forewarning of content and involvement: Consequences for persuasion and resistance to persuasion , 1992 .

[12]  Shelly Chaiken,et al.  Defensive Processing of Personally Relevant Health Messages , 1992 .

[13]  R. Baumeister,et al.  Self-Awareness and Attitude Change: Seeing Oneself on the Central Route to Persuasion , 1992 .

[14]  John Gastil.  Why We Believe in Democracy: Testing Theories of Attitude Functions and Democracy , 1992 .

[15]  Jacob Cohen.  The earth is round (p < .05) , 1994 .

[16]  R. Kirk.  Practical Significance: A Concept Whose Time Has Come , 1996 .

[17]  Duane T. Wegener,et al.  Attitudes and attitude change. , 1997, Annual review of psychology.

[18]  Klaus R. Scherer,et al.  The Role of Injustice in the Elicitation of Differential Emotional Reactions , 1998 .

[19]  K. A. Finlay,et al.  The role of empathy in improving intergroup relations. , 1999 .

[20]  Jolanda Jetten,et al.  Guilty by Association : When One ' s Group Has a Negative History , 2001 .

[21]  J. Rivera,et al.  The Justice Motive in Everyday Life: Acting Righteously: The Influence of Attitude, Moral Responsibility, and Emotional Involvement , 2002 .

[22]  L. Skitka,et al.  The Dark Side of Moral Conviction , 2002 .

[23]  J. Darley,et al.  The Psychology of Compensatory and Retributive Justice , 2003, Personality and social psychology review : an official journal of the Society for Personality and Social Psychology, Inc.

[24]  Russell Spears,et al.  Put your money where your mouth is! Explaining collective action tendencies through group-based anger and group efficacy. , 2004, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[25]  H. Kelman.  The policy context of torture: A social-psychoioqical analysis , 2005, International Review of the Red Cross.

[26]  Toni Schmader,et al.  Vicarious Shame and Guilt , 2005 .

[27]  M. Hornsey.  Why being right is not enough: Predicting defensiveness in the face of group criticism , 2005 .

[28]  When Outcomes Prompt Criticism of Procedures: An Analysis of the Rodney King Case , 2006 .

[29]  A. Keller.  Torture in Abu Ghraib , 2006, Perspectives in biology and medicine.

[30]  Sonia Roccas,et al.  The paradox of group-based guilt: modes of national identification, conflict vehemence, and reactions to the in-group's moral violations. , 2006, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[31]  R. Giner-Sorolla,et al.  Not quite human: infrahumanization in response to collective responsibility for intergroup killing. , 2006, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[32]  Anne Pedersen,et al.  Anger and Guilt About Ingroup Advantage Explain the Willingness for Political Action , 2006, Personality & social psychology bulletin.

[33]  H. Kelman,et al.  Interests, relationships, identities: three central issues for individuals and groups in negotiating their social environment. , 2006, Annual review of psychology.

[34]  L. Skitka,et al.  Exploring the psychological underpinnings of the moral mandate effect: motivated reasoning, group differentiation, or anger? , 2006, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[35]  Mark A. Costanzo,et al.  Psychologists and the Use of Torture in Interrogations , 2007 .

[36]  B. Tabachnick,et al.  Using multivariate statistics, 5th ed. , 2007 .

[37]  T. Tyler,et al.  Moral Outrage Mediates the Dampening Effect of System Justification on Support for Redistributive Social Policies , 2007, Psychological science.

[38]  R. Janoff-Bulman,et al.  Erroneous Assumptions: Popular Belief in the Effectiveness of Torture Interrogation , 2007 .

[39]  B. Lickel,et al.  Why Individuals Protest the Perceived Transgressions of Their Country , 2007, Personality & social psychology bulletin.

[40]  X. Bosch.  The Lucifer Effect: Understanding How Good People Turn Evil , 2007 .

[41]  Naomi Ellemers,et al.  Group virtue: the importance of morality (vs. competence and sociability) in the positive evaluation of in-groups. , 2007, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[42]  J. Rivera,et al.  The Emotional Climate of Nations and Their Culture of Peace , 2007 .

[43]  Dominic J. Packer,et al.  On Being Both With Us and Against Us: A Normative Conflict Model of Dissent in Social Groups , 2008, Personality and social psychology review : an official journal of the Society for Personality and Social Psychology, Inc.

[44]  Roger E. Kirk,et al.  The Importance of Effect Magnitude , 2008 .

[45]  T. Malinowski.  Restoring Moral Authority: Ending Torture, Secret Detention, and the Prison at Guantanamo Bay , 2008 .

[46]  Rupert Brown,et al.  On Positive Psychological Outcomes: What Helps Groups With a History of Conflict to Forgive and Reconcile With Each Other? , 2008, Personality & social psychology bulletin.

[47]  T. Postmes,et al.  Toward an integrative social identity model of collective action: a quantitative research synthesis of three socio-psychological perspectives. , 2008, Psychological bulletin.

[48]  G. Skoll.  Torture and the Fifth Amendment , 2008 .

[49]  Emanuele Castano.  On the Perils of Glorifying the In‐group: Intergroup Violence, In‐group Glorification, and Moral Disengagement , 2008 .

[50]  Rupert Brown,et al.  Forgive and Forget? Antecedents and Consequences of Intergroup Forgiveness in Bosnia and Herzegovina , 2008 .

[51]  C. Batson,et al.  Pursuing moral outrage: Anger at torture , 2009 .

[52]  Mark A. Costanzo,et al.  The Effects and Effectiveness of Using Torture as an Interrogation Device: Using Research to Inform the Policy Debate , 2009 .

[53]  T. Singer,et al.  The Social Neuroscience of Empathy , 2009, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[54]  L. Skitka,et al.  Status quo framing increases support for torture , 2009 .

[55]  D. Packer,et al.  Avoiding Groupthink , 2009, Psychological science.

[56]  Kenneth I. Mavor,et al.  Transforming “Apathy Into Movement”:The Role of Prosocial Emotions in Motivating Action for Social Change , 2009, Personality and social psychology review : an official journal of the Society for Personality and Social Psychology, Inc.

[57]  Thomas Craemer.  Possible Implicit Mechanisms of Minority Representation , 2010 .

[58]  David G. Rand,et al.  The online laboratory: conducting experiments in a real labor market , 2010, ArXiv.

[59]  Nigel Young.  The Oxford international encyclopedia of peace , 2010 .

[60]  James D. Johnson,et al.  EMPATHY AND INTERGROUP RELATIONS , 2010 .

[61]  Roger Giner-Sorolla,et al.  Ingroup Glorification, Moral Disengagement, and Justice in the Context of Collective Violence , 2010 .

[62]  Jeremy Rifkin,et al.  The Empathic Civilization : The Race to Global Consciousness in a World in Crisis , 2010 .

[63]  H. Kelman.  Peace Research: Beginnings , 2010 .

[64]  Michael D. Buhrmester,et al.  Amazon's Mechanical Turk , 2011, Perspectives on psychological science : a journal of the Association for Psychological Science.

[65]  Linda R. Tropp.  The Oxford handbook of intergroup conflict , 2012 .

[66]  George Y. Bizer,et al.  Belief in a just world and social dominance orientation: Evidence for a mediational pathway predicting negative attitudes and discrimination against individuals with mental illness , 2012 .

[67]  Peter H. Ditto,et al.  What Dilemma? Moral Evaluation Shapes Factual Belief , 2011 .

[68]  Emanuele Castano,et al.  Morality shifting in the context of intergroup violence , 2012 .

[69]  H. Kelman.  Social Psychology and The Study of Peace: Personal Reflections , 2012 .

[70]  Emanuele Castano.  Antisocial Behavior in Individuals and Groups , 2012 .

[71]  Amar Cheema,et al.  Data collection in a flat world: the strengths and weaknesses of mechanical turk samples , 2013 .

[72]  Ruth H. Warner,et al.  Social identity and perceptions of torture: It's moral when we do it ☆ , 2012 .

[73]  G. Viki,et al.  Dehumanization and self-reported proclivity to torture prisoners of war. , 2013 .

[74]  Linda R. Tropp,et al.  Bringing science to bear--on peace, not war: elaborating on psychology's potential to promote peace. , 2013, The American psychologist.

[75]  B. Leidner,et al.  Dehumanization, Retributive and Restorative Justice, and Aggressive Versus Diplomatic Intergroup Conflict Resolution Strategies , 2013, Personality & social psychology bulletin.

[76]  Christopher R. Chartier,et al.  Pseudo-dyadic “interaction” on Amazon’s Mechanical Turk , 2013, Behavior research methods.

[77]  Laura Smart Richman,et al.  An online daily diary study of alcohol use using Amazon's Mechanical Turk. , 2014, Drug and alcohol review.

[78]  Jesse Chandler,et al.  Nonnaïveté among Amazon Mechanical Turk workers: Consequences and solutions for behavioral researchers , 2013, Behavior Research Methods.

[79]  Victoria Savalei,et al.  Shame and the motivation to change the self. , 2014, Emotion.

[80]  C. Jackson,et al.  Occupational niches and the Dark Triad traits , 2014 .

[81]  Aaron C. Kay,et al.  Solution aversion: On the relation between ideology and motivated disbelief. , 2014, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[82]  Jesse J. Chandler,et al.  Inside the Turk , 2014 .

[83]  M. Andover,et al.  Non-suicidal self-injury disorder in a community sample of adults , 2014, Psychiatry Research.

[84]  Alice J. Lee,et al.  Tortured beliefs: How and when prior support for torture skews the perceived value of coerced information , 2015 .

[85]  B. Leidner,et al.  How to (Re)Build Human Rights Consciousness and Behavior in Postconflict Societies: An Integrative Literature Review and Framework for Past and Future Research , 2015 .

[86]  Emanuele Castano,et al.  The danger of “new norms” and the continuing relevance of IHL in the post-9/11 era , 2015, International Review of the Red Cross.

[87]  Nikos Ntoumanis,et al.  Predicting the brighter and darker sides of interpersonal relationships: Does psychological need thwarting matter? , 2015 .

[88]  B. Leidner.  America and the Age of Genocide , 2015, Personality & social psychology bulletin.

[89]  B. Leidner,et al.  Meaning threat can promote peaceful, not only military-based approaches to intergroup conflict: The moderating role of ingroup glorification , 2016 .

[90]  Diana Adler,et al.  Using Multivariate Statistics , 2016 .

[91]  Johannes Lutz.  The Validity of Crowdsourcing Data in Studying Anger and Aggressive Behavior , 2016 .

[92]  B. Leidner,et al.  A Whole Other Story , 2016, Personality & social psychology bulletin.