A Review of Contemporary Work on the Ethics of Ambient Assisted Living Technologies for People with Dementia

Ambient assisted living (AAL) technologies can provide assistance and support to persons with dementia. They might allow them the possibility of living at home for longer whilst maintaining their comfort and security as well as offering a way towards reducing the huge economic and personal costs forecast as the incidence of dementia increases worldwide over coming decades. However, the development, introduction and use of AAL technologies also trigger serious ethical issues. This paper is a systematic literature review of the on-going scholarly debate about these issues. More specifically, we look at the ethical issues involved in research and development, clinical experimentation, and clinical application of AAL technologies for people with dementia and related stakeholders. In the discussion we focus on: (1) the value of the goals of AAL technologies, (2) the special vulnerability of persons with dementia in their private homes, (3) the complex question of informed consent for the usage of AAL technologies.

[1]  Heather Draper,et al.  Telecare, Surveillance, and the Welfare State , 2012, The American journal of bioethics : AJOB.

[2]  H. Remmers,et al.  Environments for ageing, assistive technology and self-determination: ethical perspectives , 2010, Informatics for health & social care.

[3]  Rose-Marie Dröes,et al.  Assistive Technologies and Issues Relating to Privacy, Ethics and Security , 2010 .

[4]  Alan F. Smeaton,et al.  Dem@Care: a proposed system for the home-based ambient monitoring and enablement of older adults with dementia. , 2012 .

[5]  David Wright,et al.  A framework for the ethical impact assessment of information technology , 2011, Ethics and Information Technology.

[6]  Larry Stapleton,et al.  Ethical decision making in technology development: a case study of participation in a large-scale information systems development project , 2007, AI & SOCIETY.

[7]  Diane J. Cook,et al.  Author's Personal Copy Pervasive and Mobile Computing Ambient Intelligence: Technologies, Applications, and Opportunities , 2022 .

[8]  M. Toboso.  Rethinking disability in Amartya Sen’s approach: ICT and equality of opportunity , 2011, Ethics and Information Technology.

[9]  Eija Kaasinen,et al.  Supporting Independent Living of the Elderly with Mobile-Centric Ambient Intelligence: User Evaluation of Three Scenarios , 2007, AmI.

[10]  Stefan Sävenstedt,et al.  Professional Caregivers’ Perceptions on how Persons with Mild Dementia Might Experience the Usage of a Digital Photo Diary , 2012, The open nursing journal.

[11]  S C Hunt.  Professional caregivers? , 1989, Midwives chronicle.

[12]  Robert Sparrow,et al.  In the hands of machines? The future of aged care , 2006, Minds and Machines.

[13]  P. Robert,et al.  Automatic video monitoring system for assessment of Alzheimer's disease symptoms. , 2012, The journal of nutrition, health & aging.

[14]  Cathal Gurrin,et al.  Automatically recommending multimedia content for use in group reminiscence therap , 2013, MIIRH '13.

[15]  Somaya Ben Allouch,et al.  The Influence of Control on the Acceptance of Ambient Intelligence by Elderly People: An Explorative Study , 2008, AmI.

[16]  Wolfgang L. Zagler,et al.  A Videophone Prototype System Evaluated by Elderly Users in the Living Lab Schwechat , 2009, USAB.

[17]  C. N. Scanaill,et al.  A Review of Approaches to Mobility Telemonitoring of the Elderly in Their Living Environment , 2006, Annals of Biomedical Engineering.

[18]  L. Lipsitz,et al.  In Situ Monitoring of Health in Older Adults: Technologies and Issues , 2010, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[19]  Anthony Fleury,et al.  Smart Sweet Home… A Pervasive Environment for Sensing our Daily Activity? , 2011 .

[20]  Stephen H. Fairclough,et al.  Fundamentals of physiological computing , 2009, Interact. Comput..

[21]  H. Goeller,et al.  Population Projections , 2006 .

[22]  Eric Dishman,et al.  Perspective on everyday technologies for Alzheimer’s care: Research findings, directions, and challenges , 2007, Alzheimer's & Dementia.

[23]  L. J. Camp,et al.  Privacy, Technology, and Aging: A Proposed Framework , 2011 .

[24]  Ilkka Korhonen,et al.  Estimating Older People's Physical Functioning with Automated Health Monitoring Technologies at Home: Feature Correlations and Multivariate Analysis , 2011, GPC Workshops.

[25]  N. Sharkey,et al.  Granny and the robots: ethical issues in robot care for the elderly , 2012, Ethics and Information Technology.

[26]  Wolfgang L. Zagler,et al.  A Living Lab for Ambient Assisted Living in the Municipality of Schwechat , 2008, ICCHP.

[27]  Eric M. Meslin,et al.  The SAGE handbook of health care ethics : core and emerging issues , 2011 .

[28]  Athena McLean,et al.  Ethical frontiers of ICT and older users: cultural, pragmatic and ethical issues , 2011, Ethics and Information Technology.

[29]  Michael Friedewald,et al.  Ubiquitous computing: An overview of technology impacts , 2011, Telematics Informatics.

[30]  Michele Rapoport.  Being a body or having one: automated domestic technologies and corporeality , 2012, AI & SOCIETY.

[31]  Winslow Burleson,et al.  Empowering Independent Living for People with Autism: Designing Supportive, Low-Cost, Interactive E-Health Environments , 2012, PERSUASIVE.

[32]  Boris E. R. de Ruyter,et al.  The Persuasiveness of Ambient Intelligence , 2007, Security, Privacy, and Trust in Modern Data Management.

[33]  Sally McClean,et al.  Video Reminders as Cognitive Prosthetics for People with Dementia , 2011 .

[34]  Ilse Kryspin-Exner,et al.  Technology in Old Age from a Psychological Point of View , 2007, USAB.

[35]  Kieran Walsh,et al.  Perceptions, Preferences, and Acceptance of Information and Communication Technologies in Older-Adult Community Care Settings in Ireland: A Case-Study and Ranked-Care Program Analysis , 2011 .

[36]  Patricia A. Urban,et al.  Coping with Diversity , 2003 .

[37]  Vincent Rialle,et al.  Environmental Cognitive Remediation in Schizophrenia: Ethical Implications of “Smart Home” Technology , 2005, Canadian journal of psychiatry. Revue canadienne de psychiatrie.

[38]  Kush Wadhwa,et al.  Senior citizens and the ethics of e-inclusion , 2009, Ethics and Information Technology.

[39]  C. Nugent,et al.  Review of ICT-based services for identified unmet needs in people with dementia , 2007, Ageing Research Reviews.

[40]  R. S. Pearce,et al.  Bioethics - An Introduction for the Biosciences , 2005 .

[41]  WrightDavid,et al.  Mainstreaming the e-excluded in Europe , 2010 .

[42]  Andrew Sixsmith,et al.  Ageing in Place in the United Kingdom , 2008 .

[43]  Edith Maier,et al.  AAL in the Wild - Lessons Learned , 2009, HCI.

[44]  S. Zwijsen,et al.  Ethics of using assistive technology in the care for community-dwelling elderly people: An overview of the literature , 2011, Aging & mental health.

[45]  Ahmed Nabil Belbachir,et al.  Biologically-inspired stereo vision for elderly safety at home , 2010, Elektrotech. Informationstechnik.

[46]  N. Kowall,et al.  The Handbook Of Alzheimer's Disease And Other Dementias (Softcover) , 2013 .

[47]  Alois Ferscha,et al.  Constructing Ambient Intelligence - AmI 2007 Workshops Darmstadt, Germany, November 7-10, 2007 Revised Papers , 2008, AmI Workshops.

[48]  Pardeep Kumar,et al.  Security Issues in Healthcare Applications Using Wireless Medical Sensor Networks: A Survey , 2011, Sensors.

[49]  Joanna McGrenere,et al.  Involving domain experts in assistive technology research , 2008, Universal Access in the Information Society.

[50]  Andreas Holzinger,et al.  An Investigation on Acceptance of Ubiquitous Devices for the Elderly in a Geriatric Hospital Environment: Using the Example of Person Tracking , 2008, ICCHP.

[51]  Robert C. Green,et al.  1. Alzheimer's Disease , 2011 .

[52]  Vic Grout,et al.  The Easyline+ project: evaluation of a user interface developed to enhance independent living of elderly and disabled people , 2011, Universal Access in the Information Society.

[53]  Inmaculada Plaza,et al.  Mobile applications in an aging society: Status and trends , 2011, J. Syst. Softw..

[54]  Ben Mepham,et al.  Bioethics: An Introduction for the Biosciences , 2005 .

[55]  Laura M. Roa,et al.  Personalizing Care: Integration of Hospital and Homecare , 2009 .

[56]  Richard M Satava,et al.  Biomedical, ethical, and moral issues being forced by advanced medical technologies. , 2003, Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society.

[57]  Aimee van Wynsberghe,et al.  Designing Robots for Care: Care Centered Value-Sensitive Design , 2013, Sci. Eng. Ethics.

[58]  Peter Gregor,et al.  User-Sensitive Inclusive Design , 2011, Universal Access in the Information Society.

[59]  Brigitte Meillon,et al.  Design and evaluation of a smart home voice interface for the elderly: acceptability and objection aspects , 2011, Personal and Ubiquitous Computing.

[60]  Mark Coeckelbergh,et al.  How I learned to love the robot: capabilities, information technologies, and elderly care , 2012 .

[61]  Sandrine Balbo,et al.  Towards co-design with users who have autism spectrum disorders , 2009, Universal Access in the Information Society.

[62]  Eleni Kosta,et al.  Mobile-Centric Ambient Intelligence in Health- and Homecare—Anticipating Ethical and Legal Challenges , 2010, Sci. Eng. Ethics.

[63]  Julio Abascal,et al.  Fundamentals of Inclusive HCI Design , 2007, HCI.

[64]  C. Grady,et al.  What makes clinical research ethical? , 2000, JAMA.

[65]  Maurice Mulvenna,et al.  ICT Interface Design for Ageing People and People with Dementia , 2010 .

[66]  L. J. Miller,et al.  Informed consent: I. , 1980, JAMA.

[67]  Ezekiel J Emanuel,et al.  What makes clinical research in developing countries ethical? The benchmarks of ethical research. , 2004, The Journal of infectious diseases.

[68]  Deryck Beyleveld.  Privacy, Confidentiality and Data Protection , 2011 .

[69]  Robin Mackenzie,et al.  Challenges of ethical and legal responsibilities when technologies’ uses and users change: social networking sites, decision-making capacity and dementia , 2012, Ethics and Information Technology.

[70]  Klaus Miesenberger,et al.  Design for All in Information Technology: A Universal Concern , 2005, DEXA.

[71]  K Panico,et al.  Care in the community , 1995, Nature.

[72]  P. Uhlenberg.  International handbook of population aging , 2009 .

[73]  Marion Hersh,et al.  Assistive Technology for the Hearing-impaired, Deaf and Deafblind , 2003, Springer London.

[74]  Katie Brittain,et al.  Balancing rights and risks: Conflicting perspectives in the management of wandering in dementia , 2007 .

[75]  Goshiro Yamamoto,et al.  User interaction in smart ambient environment targeted for senior citizen , 2010, 2010 3rd International Symposium on Applied Sciences in Biomedical and Communication Technologies (ISABEL 2010).

[76]  Morten Kyng,et al.  On participatory design of home-based healthcare , 2012, Cognition, Technology & Work.

[77]  David England,et al.  Ambient Interfaces for Elderly People at Home , 2006, Ambient Intelligence in Everyday.

[78]  Julio Abascal,et al.  Moving towards inclusive design guidelines for socially and ethically aware HCI , 2005, Interact. Comput..

[79]  Eric Campo,et al.  A review of smart homes - Present state and future challenges , 2008, Comput. Methods Programs Biomed..

[80]  Constantine Stephanidis,et al.  Universal Acess in Human Computer Interaction. Coping with Diversity , 2007 .

[81]  Filippo Cavallo,et al.  AALIANCE Ambient Assisted Living Roadmap , 2010, Ambient Intelligence and Smart Environments.

[82]  Omer Rana,et al.  Simultaneous trend analysis for evaluating outcomes in patient-centred health monitoring services , 2008, Health care management science.

[83]  Mario Toboso-Martín.  Rethinking disability in Amartya Sen’s approach: ICT and equality of opportunity , 2011 .

[84]  Jeffrey Kaye,et al.  Technology and dementia: The way ahead , 2010 .

[85]  K. Daniel,et al.  Emerging technologies to enhance the safety of older people in their homes. , 2009, Geriatric Nursing.

[86]  Chris D. Nugent,et al.  Assessing task compliance following mobile phone-based video reminders , 2011, 2011 Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[87]  Neelke Doorn,et al.  A procedural approach to distributing responsibilities in R&D networks , 2010, Poiesis Prax..

[88]  Michael Decker,et al.  Service robots in the mirror of reflective research , 2012, Poiesis Prax..

[89]  Frank Pallas,et al.  Technology paternalism – wider implications of ubiquitous computing , 2005, Poiesis Prax..

[90]  Martin Fischer,et al.  Service robotics: do you know your new companion? Framing an interdisciplinary technology assessment , 2011, Poiesis Prax..

[91]  Russell Marshall,et al.  A Study of User Needs for the 'Techno Kitchen' , 2011, HCI.

[92]  Martina Ziefle,et al.  Smart Home Technologies: Insights into Generation-Specific Acceptance Motives , 2009, USAB.

[93]  T. Beauchamp,et al.  Principles of biomedical ethics , 1991 .

[94]  Jason Borenstein,et al.  Robot caregivers: harbingers of expanded freedom for all? , 2010, Ethics and Information Technology.

[95]  Baozhi Chen,et al.  Research challenges in computation, communication, and context awareness for ubiquitous healthcare , 2012, IEEE Communications Magazine.

[96]  Kush Wadhwa,et al.  Mainstreaming the e-excluded in Europe: strategies, good practices and some ethical issues , 2010, Ethics and Information Technology.

[97]  Alan F. Smeaton,et al.  Case study in SenseCam use as an intervention technology for early-stage dementia , 2012, Int. J. Comput. Heal..

[98]  Ben A. M. Schouten,et al.  Smart Home Technology for the Elderly: Perceptions of Multidisciplinary Stakeholders , 2007, AmI Workshops.

[99]  Constantine Stephanidis,et al.  Universal Access in Human-Computer Interaction , 2011 .

[100]  Eleni Kosta,et al.  Ethical-Legal Challenges in User-Centric AmI Services , 2008, 2008 Third International Conference on Internet and Web Applications and Services.

[101]  J. V. Hoofa,et al.  Ageing-in-place with the use of ambient intelligence technology: Perspectives of older users , 2011 .

[102]  Phillip Vaughan,et al.  Involving older people with dementia and their carers in designing computer based support systems: some methodological considerations , 2009, Universal Access in the Information Society.

[103]  M. Chan,et al.  Smart homes - current features and future perspectives. , 2009, Maturitas.

[104]  M. Coeckelbergh,et al.  Health Care, Capabilities, and AI Assistive Technologies , 2010 .

[105]  David A. Hoffman,et al.  Remote home health care technologies: how to ensure privacy? Build it in: Privacy by Design , 2010 .

[106]  Elin Palm,et al.  A Declaration of Healthy Dependence: The Case of Home Care , 2014, Health Care Analysis.

[107]  Darren Reed,et al.  Towards a Sociological Understanding of Robots as Companions , 2010, HRPR.

[108]  Hamideh Afsarmanesh,et al.  Collaborative Ecosystems in Ageing Support , 2011, PRO-VE.

[109]  Bennett Foddy.  The Right and Wrong of Growing Old: Assessing the Argument from Evolution , 2012, Philosophy & technology.

[110]  Michael Friedewald,et al.  Safeguards in a World of Ambient Intelligence (The International Library of Ethics, Law and Technology) , 2008 .

[111]  Bjørn Hofmann,et al.  Ethical Challenges with Welfare Technology: A Review of the Literature , 2012, Science and Engineering Ethics.

[112]  Inger Hagen,et al.  Technology in dementia care , 2007 .

[113]  P. Olivier,et al.  Keeping In Touch Everyday (KITE) project: developing assistive technologies with people with dementia and their carers to promote independence , 2009, International Psychogeriatrics.

[114]  Andrew F. Monk,et al.  Technological opportunities for supporting people with dementia who are living at home , 2008, Int. J. Hum. Comput. Stud..

[115]  Scott M. Lynch,et al.  THE DEMOGRAPHY OF DISABILITY , 1970 .

[116]  R. Landau,et al.  Ethical aspects of using GPS for tracking people with dementia: recommendations for practice , 2011, International Psychogeriatrics.

[117]  Diane Whitehouse,et al.  A 21st Century Ethical Debate: Pursuing Perspectives on Ambient Intelligence , 2005, The Information Society.

[118]  Penny Duquenoy.  Intelligent Ethics , 2004, IFIP Congress Topical Sessions.

[119]  Ashraf Darwish,et al.  Wearable and Implantable Wireless Sensor Network Solutions for Healthcare Monitoring , 2011, Sensors.

[120]  Paul Müller,et al.  Ambient Intelligence in Assisted Living: Enable Elderly People to Handle Future Interfaces , 2007, HCI.

[121]  Michael Friedewald,et al.  Safeguards in a world of ambient intelligence , 2008 .

[122]  C Rayner,et al.  Informed consent. , 2000, British journal of plastic surgery.

[123]  Shannon Vallor.  Carebots and Caregivers: Sustaining the Ethical Ideal of Care in the Twenty-First Century , 2011, Machine Ethics and Robot Ethics.

[124]  W. Dekkers,et al.  On the notion of home and the goals of palliative care , 2009, Theoretical medicine and bioethics.