The Role of Carbon Ion Therapy in the Changing Oncology Landscape—A Narrative Review of the Literature and the Decade of Carbon Ion Experience at the Italian National Center for Oncological Hadrontherapy

Simple Summary Carbon ion radiotherapy offers ballistic and radiobiological advantages over conventional photon-based radiotherapy, making it an effective option in case of rare, radioresistant, and difficult-to-treat tumours. The current narrative review aims to critically report the state-of-the-art application of carbon ion radiotherapy in oncological settings, highlighting the clinical activity on carbon ion radiotherapy at the National Center for Oncological Hadrontherapy (CNAO). CNAO is the only Italian facility, and one of four located in Europe using both protons and carbon ions for oncological treatments. Proton and CIRT became fully operational at CNAO starting in 2011 and November 2012, respectively. After an initial ramp-up period, CNAO has progressively honed its clinical, technical, and dosimetric skills and contributed to increasing knowledge on the efficacy, feasibility, and safety of CIRT in selected tumour types, demonstrating the mild rate of toxicities also in case of re-irradiation and tolerance in case of association with systemic treatments. Abstract Background: Currently, 13 Asian and European facilities deliver carbon ion radiotherapy (CIRT) for preclinical and clinical activity, and, to date, 55 clinical studies including CIRT for adult and paediatric solid neoplasms have been registered. The National Center for Oncological Hadrontherapy (CNAO) is the only Italian facility able to accelerate both protons and carbon ions for oncological treatment and research. Methods: To summarise and critically evaluate state-of-the-art knowledge on the application of carbon ion radiotherapy in oncological settings, the authors conducted a literature search till December 2022 in the following electronic databases: PubMed, Web of Science, MEDLINE, Google Scholar, and Cochrane. The results of 68 studies are reported using a narrative approach, highlighting CNAO’s clinical activity over the last 10 years of CIRT. Results: The ballistic and radiobiological hallmarks of CIRT make it an effective option in several rare, radioresistant, and difficult-to-treat tumours. CNAO has made a significant contribution to the advancement of knowledge on CIRT delivery in selected tumour types. Conclusions: After an initial ramp-up period, CNAO has progressively honed its clinical, technical, and dosimetric skills. Growing engagement with national and international networks and research groups for complex cancers has led to increasingly targeted patient selection for CIRT and lowered barriers to facility access.

[1]  J. Seuntjens,et al.  An international approach to estimating the indications and number of eligible patients for carbon ion radiation therapy (CIRT) in Australia. , 2023, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[2]  M. Ciocca,et al.  OC-0110 Head and neck adenoid cystic carcinoma treated with raster scanning carbon ion radiotherapy at CNAO , 2023, Radiotherapy and Oncology.

[3]  S. Molinelli,et al.  PD-0810 Pilot study on carbon-ion radiotherapy for recurrent/refractory ovarian/salpinx cancer , 2023, Radiotherapy and Oncology.

[4]  L. Licitra,et al.  The SINTART 1 study. A phase II non-randomised controlled trial of induction chemotherapy, surgery, photon-, proton- and carbon ion-based radiotherapy integration in patients with locally advanced resectable sinonasal tumours. , 2023, European journal of cancer.

[5]  A. Cavallo,et al.  The SINTART 2 Study. A phase II non-randomised controlled trial of induction chemotherapy, photon-, proton- and carbon-ion-based radiotherapy integration in patients with locally advanced unresectable sinonasal tumours. , 2023, European journal of cancer.

[6]  A. Barcellini,et al.  In Vitro Effects of Photon Beam and Carbon Ion Radiotherapy on the Perineural Invasion of Two Cell Lines of Neurotropic Tumours , 2023, Life.

[7]  G. Baroni,et al.  A Dosiomics Analysis Based on Linear Energy Transfer and Biological Dose Maps to Predict Local Recurrence in Sacral Chordomas after Carbon-Ion Radiotherapy , 2022, Cancers.

[8]  M. Ciocca,et al.  Factors released by low and high-LET irradiated fibroblasts modulate migration and invasiveness of pancreatic cancer cells , 2022, Frontiers in Oncology.

[9]  G. Baroni,et al.  Exploring the role of neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio and blood chemistry in head and neck adenoid cystic carcinomas treated with carbon ion radiotherapy. , 2022, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[10]  K. Herfarth,et al.  Proton and carbon ion beam treatment with active raster scanning method in 147 patients with skull base chordoma at the Heidelberg Ion Beam Therapy Center—a single-center experience , 2022, Strahlentherapie und Onkologie.

[11]  C. Paganelli,et al.  The role of multiple anatomical scenarios in plan optimization for carbon ion radiotherapy of pancreatic cancer. , 2022, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[12]  G. Baroni,et al.  Role of diffusion-weighted MRI in recurrent rectal cancer treated with carbon ion radiotherapy. , 2022, Future oncology.

[13]  G. Volpi,et al.  PD-0489 Effect of C-ions on activation of mucosal melanoma cells through alterations in Ca2+ signaling , 2022, Radiotherapy and Oncology.

[14]  G. Baroni,et al.  Time‐resolved MRI for off‐line treatment robustness evaluation in carbon‐ion radiotherapy of pancreatic cancer , 2022, Medical physics.

[15]  M. Ciocca,et al.  In Silico Feasibility Study of Carbon Ion Radiotherapy With Simultaneous Integrated Boost for Head and Neck Adenoid Cystic Carcinoma , 2021, Frontiers in Oncology.

[16]  B. Vischioni,et al.  Biological Rationale and Clinical Evidence of Carbon Ion Radiation Therapy for Adenoid Cystic Carcinoma: A Narrative Review , 2021, Frontiers in Oncology.

[17]  F. Valvo,et al.  Mixed-Beam Approach for High-Risk Prostate Cancer Carbon-Ion Boost Followed by Photon Intensity-Modulated Radiotherapy: Preliminary Results of Phase II Trial AIRC-IG-14300 , 2021, Frontiers in Oncology.

[18]  H. Ueno,et al.  Carbon Ion Radiotherapy for Locally Recurrent Rectal Cancer of Patients with Prior Pelvic Irradiation , 2021, Annals of Surgical Oncology.

[19]  G. Baroni,et al.  Dosimetric Impact of Inter-Fraction Anatomical Changes in Carbon Ion Boost Treatment for High-Risk Prostate Cancer (AIRC IG 14300) , 2021, Frontiers in Oncology.

[20]  M. Del Vecchio,et al.  Toxicity of carbon ion radiotherapy and immune checkpoint inhibitors in advanced melanoma. , 2021, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[21]  M. Ciocca,et al.  How LEM-based RBE and dose-averaged LET affected clinical outcomes of sacral chordoma patients treated with carbon ion radiotherapy. , 2021, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[22]  S. Gandini,et al.  Particle Radiotherapy for Skull Base Chondrosarcoma: A Clinical Series from Italian National Center for Oncological Hadrontherapy , 2021, Cancers.

[23]  S. Fröhling,et al.  Neoadjuvant irradiation of retroperitoneal soft tissue sarcoma with ions (Retro-Ion): study protocol for a randomized phase II pilot trial , 2021, Trials.

[24]  M. Durante,et al.  Carbon Ion Radiobiology , 2020, Cancers.

[25]  A. Mahajan,et al.  Estimating the Number of Patients Eligible for Carbon Ion Radiotherapy in the United States , 2020, International journal of particle therapy.

[26]  H. Yoshikawa,et al.  Complication rate, functional outcomes, and risk factors associated with carbon ion radiotherapy for patients with unresectable pelvic bone sarcoma. , 2020, Cancer.

[27]  K. Herfarth,et al.  Carbon ion reirradiation compared to intensity-modulated re-radiotherapy for recurrent head and neck cancer (CARE): a randomized controlled trial , 2020, Radiation oncology.

[28]  F. Valvo,et al.  Outcome and Toxicity of Carbon Ion Radiotherapy for Axial Bone and Soft Tissue Sarcomas , 2020, AntiCancer Research.

[29]  F. Valvo,et al.  Re-irradiation With Carbon Ion Radiotherapy for Pelvic Rectal Cancer Recurrences in Patients Previously Irradiated to the Pelvis , 2020, In Vivo.

[30]  F. Valvo,et al.  Proton and carbon ions radiotherapy in skull base chordomas: a prospective study based on a dual particle and a patient-customized treatment strategy. , 2020, Neuro-oncology.

[31]  F. Valvo,et al.  Predictive role of Apparent Diffusion Coefficient (ADC) from Diffusion Weighted MRI in patients with sacral chordoma treated with carbon ion radiotherapy (CIRT) alone. , 2020, European journal of radiology.

[32]  F. Valvo,et al.  Reirradiation of salivary gland tumors with carbon ion radiotherapy at CNAO. , 2020, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[33]  M. Fujimoto,et al.  Local and disease control for nasal melanoma treated with radiation and concomitant anti‐programmed death 1 antibody , 2020, The Journal of dermatology.

[34]  T. Nakano,et al.  Significance of concurrent use of weekly cisplatin in carbon‐ion radiotherapy for locally advanced adenocarcinoma of the uterine cervix: A propensity score‐matched analysis , 2019, Cancer medicine.

[35]  F. Valvo,et al.  Hypofractionation in prostate cancer radiotherapy: a step forward towards clinical routine. , 2019, Translational andrology and urology.

[36]  K. Herfarth,et al.  Carbon Ion Re-Irradiation for Recurrent Head-and-Neck Cancer: A Single-Institutional Experience. , 2019, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[37]  F. Valvo,et al.  P178 Carbon-Ion radiotherapy for malignant gynecological melanoma , 2019, International Journal of Gynecological Cancer.

[38]  J. Debus,et al.  Treatment Outcome of 227 Patients with Sinonasal Adenoid Cystic Carcinoma (ACC) after Intensity Modulated Radiotherapy and Active Raster-Scanning Carbon Ion Boost: A 10-Year Single-Center Experience , 2019, Cancers.

[39]  F. Valvo,et al.  EP696 Inoperable pelvic sidewall recurrence of gynecological cancer treated with proton and carbon ion radiotherapy: CNAO preliminary experience , 2019, International Journal of Gynecological Cancer.

[40]  K. Shirai,et al.  Carbon‐ion radiotherapy combined with chemotherapy for head and neck mucosal melanoma: Prospective observational study , 2019, Cancer medicine.

[41]  D. Aoki,et al.  Significance of PD-L1 expression in carbon-ion radiotherapy for uterine cervical adeno/adenosquamous carcinoma , 2019, Journal of gynecologic oncology.

[42]  Catherine Klersy,et al.  Preoperative chemotherapy and carbon ions therapy for treatment of resectable and borderline resectable pancreatic adenocarcinoma: a prospective, phase II, multicentre, single-arm study , 2019, BMC Cancer.

[43]  F. Valvo,et al.  RBE-weighted dose in carbon ion therapy for ACC patients: Impact of the RBE model translation on treatment outcomes. , 2019, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[44]  K. Shirabe,et al.  Prospective Observational Study of High-Dose Carbon-Ion Radiotherapy for Pelvic Recurrence of Rectal Cancer (GUNMA 0801) , 2019, Front. Oncol..

[45]  P. Casali,et al.  Rare cancers: from centralized referral to networking. , 2019, Annals of oncology : official journal of the European Society for Medical Oncology.

[46]  J. Debus,et al.  Results of a combination treatment with intensity modulated radiotherapy and active raster-scanning carbon ion boost for adenoid cystic carcinoma of the minor salivary glands of the nasopharynx. , 2019, Oral oncology.

[47]  T. Nakano,et al.  Long-Term Outcomes of Carbon-Ion Radiotherapy for Malignant Gynecological Melanoma , 2019, Cancers.

[48]  W. Mendenhall,et al.  Proton therapy for skull-base chondrosarcoma, a single-institution outcomes study , 2019, Journal of Neuro-Oncology.

[49]  Y. Shioyama,et al.  Carbon-ion radiotherapy for locally recurrent rectal cancer: Japan Carbon-ion Radiation Oncology Study Group (J-CROS) Study 1404 Rectum. , 2019, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[50]  F. Valvo,et al.  Feasibility of Carbon Ion Radiotherapy in the Treatment of Gynecological Melanoma , 2019, In Vivo.

[51]  J. Debus,et al.  Carbon-ion radiotherapy in accelerated hypofractionated active raster-scanning technique for malignant lacrimal gland tumors: feasibility and safety , 2019, Cancer management and research.

[52]  M. Tonogi,et al.  Feasibility of carbon‐ion radiotherapy for oral non‐squamous cell carcinomas , 2019, Head & neck.

[53]  C. Karger,et al.  Radiobiological issues in prospective carbon ion therapy trials , 2018, Medical physics.

[54]  M. Ciocca,et al.  FRoG—A New Calculation Engine for Clinical Investigations with Proton and Carbon Ion Beams at CNAO , 2018, Cancers.

[55]  J. Debus,et al.  Accelerated Hypofractionated Active Raster-Scanned Carbon Ion Radiotherapy (CIRT) for Laryngeal Malignancies: Feasibility and Safety , 2018, Cancers.

[56]  Tatsuya Ohno,et al.  Multi-institutional Study of Carbon-ion Radiotherapy for Locally Advanced Pancreatic Cancer: Japan Carbon-ion Radiation Oncology Study Group (J-CROS) Study 1403 Pancreas. , 2018, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[57]  F. Valvo,et al.  Morphological Analysis of Amoeboid–Mesenchymal Transition Plasticity After Low and High LET Radiation on Migrating and Invading Pancreatic Cancer Cells , 2018, AntiCancer Research.

[58]  N. Araki,et al.  Carbon ion radiotherapy for unresectable localized axial soft tissue sarcoma , 2018, Cancer medicine.

[59]  T. Nakano,et al.  Carbon-ion radiotherapy for inoperable endometrial carcinoma , 2018, Journal of radiation research.

[60]  K. Ogawa,et al.  Efficacy and safety of carbon-ion radiotherapy for lacrimal gland carcinomas with extraorbital extension: a retrospective cohort study , 2018, Oncotarget.

[61]  T. Nakano,et al.  Clinical Impact of Re-irradiation with Carbon-ion Radiotherapy for Lymph Node Recurrence of Gynecological Cancers. , 2017, Anticancer research.

[62]  R. Sasaki,et al.  Particle Therapy Using Protons or Carbon Ions for Unresectable or Incompletely Resected Bone and Soft Tissue Sarcomas of the Pelvis. , 2017, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[63]  Y. Shioyama,et al.  Multicenter Study of Carbon-Ion Radiation Therapy for Mucosal Melanoma of the Head and Neck: Subanalysis of the Japan Carbon-Ion Radiation Oncology Study Group (J-CROS) Study (1402 HN). , 2017, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[64]  Mitsugu Sekimoto,et al.  Carbon-Ion Radiation Therapy for Pelvic Recurrence of Rectal Cancer. , 2016, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[65]  R. Orecchia,et al.  Dose prescription in carbon ion radiotherapy: How to compare two different RBE-weighted dose calculation systems. , 2016, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[66]  T. Nakano,et al.  Carbon-ion radiotherapy for locally advanced cervical cancer with bladder invasion , 2016, Journal of radiation research.

[67]  A. Lomax,et al.  Long term outcomes of patients with skull-base low-grade chondrosarcoma and chordoma patients treated with pencil beam scanning proton therapy. , 2016, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[68]  Marco Durante,et al.  New Ions for Therapy. , 2015, International journal of particle therapy.

[69]  K. Herfarth,et al.  Re-irradiation of adenoid cystic carcinoma: analysis and evaluation of outcome in 52 consecutive patients treated with raster-scanned carbon ion therapy. , 2015, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[70]  Oliver Jäkel,et al.  Highly effective treatment of skull base chordoma with carbon ion irradiation using a raster scan technique in 155 patients: First long‐term results , 2014, Cancer.

[71]  Alfred R. Smith,et al.  The more important heavy charged particle radiotherapy of the future is more likely to be with heavy ions rather than protons. , 2013, Medical physics.

[72]  O. Jaekel,et al.  MO-E-500-01: Point and Counter Point Debate: The More Important Heavy Charged Particle Radiotherapy of the Future Is More Likely to Be with Heavy Ions Rather Than Protons. , 2013, Medical physics.

[73]  Roberto Orecchia,et al.  Dose prescription in carbon ion radiotherapy: a planning study to compare NIRS and LEM approaches with a clinically-oriented strategy , 2012, Physics in medicine and biology.

[74]  Tadashi Kamada,et al.  Results of carbon ion radiotherapy for head and neck cancer. , 2012, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[75]  Johannes A Langendijk,et al.  Systematic review and meta-analysis of radiotherapy in various head and neck cancers: comparing photons, carbon-ions and protons. , 2011, Cancer treatment reviews.

[76]  Y. Nakasu,et al.  Feasibility of Proton Beam Therapy for Chordoma and Chondrosarcoma of the Skull Base , 2011, Skull base : official journal of North American Skull Base Society ... [et al.].

[77]  Alessandra Bolsi,et al.  Effectiveness and safety of spot scanning proton radiation therapy for chordomas and chondrosarcomas of the skull base: first long-term report. , 2009, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[78]  T. Onda,et al.  Carbon ion radiotherapy for skull base chordoma. , 2009, Skull base : official journal of North American Skull Base Society ... [et al.].

[79]  Tohru Okada,et al.  Carbon ion radiotherapy for unresectable retroperitoneal sarcomas. , 2007, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[80]  A. Rosenberg,et al.  Proton radiation therapy for chordomas and chondrosarcomas of the skull base. , 1999, Journal of neurosurgery.

[81]  J. Munzenrider,et al.  Proton therapy for tumors of the skull base , 1999, Strahlentherapie und Onkologie.

[82]  Y. Shioyama,et al.  Multicenter Study of Carbon-Ion Radiation Therapy for Adenoid Cystic Carcinoma of the Head and Neck: Subanalysis of the Japan Carbon-Ion Radiation Oncology Study Group (J-CROS) Study (1402 HN). , 2018, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[83]  M. Büchler,et al.  Reirradiation Using Carbon Ions in Patients with Locally Recurrent Rectal Cancer at HIT: First Results , 2014, Annals of Surgical Oncology.

[84]  H. Honda,et al.  Phase 1 trial of preoperative, short‐course carbon‐ion radiotherapy for patients with resectable pancreatic cancer , 2013, Cancer.