Assessment of registration accuracy during computer-aided oncologic limb-salvage surgery

PurposeComputer-aided surgery is used in musculoskeletal tumor procedures to improve the surgeon’s orientation to local anatomy during tumor resection. For the navigation system to function correctly, preoperative imaging (e.g., CT, MR) must be registered to the patient in the operating room. The goals of this study were (1) to directly quantify registration accuracy in computer-aided tumor surgery and (2) to validate the “system reported error” (SRE) of the navigation system.MethodsRegistration accuracy was evaluated in eight bone sarcoma cases by determining the location of the anatomical paired-points used for registration following surface matching. Coordinates of specific intraoperative post-registration points were compared with the corresponding coordinates in preoperative CT scans to determine the measurement error (ME).ResultsThe mean difference between post-registration points and planned registration points was $$12.21 \pm 6.52\,\hbox {mm}$$12.21±6.52mm, significantly higher than the mean SRE ($$0.68 \pm 0.15\,\hbox {mm}$$0.68±0.15mm; $$p=0.002$$p=0.002; 95 % CI 6.11–16.96 mm). The SRE poorly correlated with the calculated ME ($$R^2=0.040$$R2=0.040). Anatomical paired-point registration with surface matching results in a substantial shift in the post-registration coordinates of the same paired-points used for registration, and this shift is not represented by the SRE.ConclusionThe SRE of a surgical navigation system was poorly correlated with direct measurements obtained in musculoskeletal tumor surgery. Improvement in registration accuracy is needed to better navigate tumor boundaries and ensure clear margins while maximally preserving the unaffected tissues and reducing operative morbidity.