Expertise Reversal Effect and Its Implications for Learner-Tailored Instruction

The interactions between levels of learner prior knowledge and effectiveness of different instructional techniques and procedures have been intensively investigated within a cognitive load framework since mid-90s. This line of research has become known as the expertise reversal effect. Apart from their cognitive load theory-based prediction and explanation, patterns of empirical findings on the effect fit well those in studies of Aptitude Treatment Interactions (ATI) that were originally initiated in mid-60s. This paper reviews recent empirical findings associated with the expertise reversal effect, their interpretation within cognitive load theory, relations to ATI studies, implications for the design of learner-tailored instructional systems, and some recent experimental attempts of implementing these findings into realistic adaptive learning environments.

[1]  G. A. Miller.  THE PSYCHOLOGICAL REVIEW THE MAGICAL NUMBER SEVEN, PLUS OR MINUS TWO: SOME LIMITS ON OUR CAPACITY FOR PROCESSING INFORMATION 1 , 1956 .

[2]  H. Simon,et al.  Motivational and emotional controls of cognition. , 1967, Psychological review.

[3]  Lee J. Cronbach,et al.  Individual Differences in Learning Ability as a Function of Instructional Variables. Final Report. , 1969 .

[4]  Glenn H. Bracht.  Experimental Factors Related to Aptitude-Treatment Interactions , 1970 .

[5]  Allen Newell,et al.  Human Problem Solving. , 1973 .

[6]  Richard C. Boutwell,et al.  Toward an Adaptive Learner-Controlled Model of Instruction: A Place for the New Cognitive Aptitudes. , 1974 .

[7]  M. Merrill.  Learner control: Beyond aptitude-treatment interactions , 1975 .

[8]  Robert D. Tennyson,et al.  Adaptive instructional models for concept acquisition , 1975 .

[9]  Richard E. Mayer,et al.  Acquisition of understanding and skill in relation to subjects' preparation and meaningfulness of instruction. , 1975 .

[10]  S. Tobias.  Achievement Treatment Interactions , 1976 .

[11]  R. Shiffrin,et al.  Controlled and automatic human information processing: I , 1977 .

[12]  Walter Schneider,et al.  Controlled and automatic human information processing: II. Perceptual learning, automatic attending and a general theory. , 1977 .

[13]  L. Cronbach,et al.  Aptitudes and instructional methods: A handbook for research on interactions , 1977 .

[14]  Esther R. Steinberg,et al.  Review of Student Control in Computer-Assisted Instruction , 1977 .

[15]  Robert D. Tennyson,et al.  Management of Computer-Based Instruction: Design of an Adaptive Control Strategy. , 1979 .

[16]  R. Tennyson.  Instructional control strategies and content structure as design variables in concept acquisition using computer-based instruction. , 1980 .

[17]  R. Tennyson.  Use of Adaptive Information for Advisement in Learning Concepts and Rules Using Computer-assisted Instruction , 1981 .

[18]  M. Eysenck,et al.  Attention and Arousal , 1982 .

[19]  M. Eysenck.  Attention And Arousal, Cognition And Performance , 1982 .

[20]  J. Sweller,et al.  Development of expertise in mathematical problem solving. , 1983 .

[21]  R. Snow,et al.  Lecture 2: Toward a Theory of Cognitive Aptitude for Learning from Instruction , 1984 .

[22]  H. Simon,et al.  Why are some problems hard? Evidence from Tower of Hanoi , 1985, Cognitive Psychology.

[23]  David L. Lohman.  Predicting Mathemathanic Effects in the Teaching of Higher-Order Thinking Skills , 1986 .

[24]  J. Sweller,et al.  Effects of schema acquisition and rule automation on mathematical problem-solving transfer. , 1987 .

[25]  Sigmund Tobias,et al.  Mandatory Text Review and Interaction with Student Characteristics. , 1987 .

[26]  S. Tobias.  Teaching strategic text review by computer and interaction with student characteristics , 1988 .

[27]  R. A. Tarmizi,et al.  Guidance during Mathematical Problem Solving. , 1988 .

[28]  John Sweller,et al.  Cognitive Load During Problem Solving: Effects on Learning , 1988, Cogn. Sci..

[29]  E. R. Steinberg.  Cognition and learner control: a literature review, 1977–1988 , 1989 .

[30]  R. Mayer.  Models for Understanding , 1989 .

[31]  S. Tobias.  Another Look at Research on the Adaptation of Instruction to Students Characteristics , 1989 .

[32]  R. Snow.  Aptitude-treatment interaction as a framework for research on individual differences in learning. , 1989 .

[33]  Joan K. Gallini,et al.  When Is an Illustration Worth Ten Thousand Words , 1990 .

[34]  Fred Paas,et al.  Automation and schema acquisition in learning elementary computer programming : implications for the design of practice , 1990 .

[35]  P. Chandler,et al.  Cognitive load as a factor in the structuring of technical material. , 1990 .

[36]  Jeroen J. G. van Merriënboer,et al.  Strategies for Programming Instruction in High School: Program Completion vs. Program Generation , 1990 .

[37]  P. Chandler,et al.  Cognitive Load Theory and the Format of Instruction , 1991 .

[38]  V. Shute,et al.  Cognitive Approaches To Automated Instruction , 1992 .

[39]  Donald F. Dansereau,et al.  Effects of Knowledge Maps and Prior Knowledge on Recall of Science Lecture Content , 1992 .

[40]  Fred G. W. C. Paas,et al.  The Efficiency of Instructional Conditions: An Approach to Combine Mental Effort and Performance Measures , 1992 .

[41]  C. Reigeluth,et al.  Instructional prescriptions for learner control , 1992 .

[42]  Robert J. Crutcher,et al.  The role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance. , 1993 .

[43]  D. Leutner.  Guided discovery learning with computer-based simulation games: Effects of adaptive and non-adaptive instructional support , 1993 .

[44]  Robert J. Sternberg,et al.  Mind in context : interactionist perspectives on human intelligence , 1994 .

[45]  Wilhelmina C. Savenye,et al.  Effects of learner control, advisement, and prior knowledge on young students' learning in a hypertext environment , 1994 .

[46]  R. Mayer,et al.  A generative theory of textbook design: Using annotated illustrations to foster meaningful learning of science text , 1995 .

[47]  John R. Anderson,et al.  General Principles for an Intelligent Tutoring Architecture. , 1995 .

[48]  K. A. Ericsson,et al.  Long-term working memory. , 1995, Psychological review.

[49]  J. Sweller,et al.  Reducing cognitive load by mixing auditory and visual presentation modes , 1995 .

[50]  W. Kintsch,et al.  Are Good Texts Always Better? Interactions of Text Coherence, Background Knowledge, and Levels of Understanding in Learning From Text , 1996 .

[51]  Kevin A. Gluck,et al.  Individual Differences in Patterns of Spontaneous Online Tool Use , 1996 .

[52]  John R. Anderson,et al.  How people learn to skip steps. , 1996 .

[53]  Herbert J. Walberg,et al.  Learner-Control Effects: A Review of Reviews and a Meta-Analysis , 1996 .

[54]  Alexander Renkl,et al.  Learning from Worked-Out-Examples: A Study on Individual Differences , 1997, Cogn. Sci..

[55]  Alison Ollerenshaw,et al.  Is an Illustration Always Worth Ten Thousand Words? Effects of Prior Knowledge, Learning Style and Multimedia Illustrations on Text Comprehension , 1997 .

[56]  Sharon K Tindall-Ford,et al.  When two sensory modes are better than one , 1997 .

[57]  R. Mayer,et al.  Multimedia learning: Are we asking the right questions? , 1997 .

[58]  Yeung,et al.  Cognitive Load and Learner Expertise: Split-Attention and Redundancy Effects in Reading with Explanatory Notes , 1998, Contemporary educational psychology.

[59]  Paul Chandler,et al.  Levels of Expertise and Instructional Design , 1998, Hum. Factors.

[60]  Licia Calvi,et al.  AHA! An open Adaptive Hypermedia Architecture , 1998, New Rev. Hypermedia Multim..

[61]  F. Paas,et al.  Cognitive Architecture and Instructional Design , 1998 .

[62]  Pat-Anthony Federico,et al.  Hypermedia Environments and Adaptive Instruction , 1999 .

[63]  Amy M. Shapiro,et al.  The Relationship between Prior Knowledge and Interactive Overviews during Hypermedia-Aided Learning , 1999 .

[64]  J. Tuovinen,et al.  A comparison of cognitive load associated with discovery learning and worked examples , 1999 .

[65]  A. Yeung.  Cognitive Load and Learner Expertise: Split-Attention and Redundancy Effects in Reading Comprehension Tasks With Vocabulary Definitions , 1999 .

[66]  Slava Kalyuga,et al.  Incorporating Learner Experience into the Design of Multimedia Instruction. , 2000 .

[67]  Fred Paas,et al.  Dynamic problem selection in air traffic control training: a comparison between performance, mental effort and mental efficiency , 2001, Comput. Hum. Behav..

[68]  Slava Kalyuga,et al.  Learner Experience and Efficiency of Instructional Guidance , 2001 .

[69]  R. Mayer,et al.  Multimedia Learning: The Promise of Multimedia Learning , 2001 .

[70]  Richard E. Mayer,et al.  Multimedia Learning , 2001, Visible Learning Guide to Student Achievement.

[71]  R. Mayer,et al.  Cognitive constraints on multimedia learning: When presenting more material results in less understanding. , 2001 .

[72]  N. Cowan.  The magical number 4 in short-term memory: A reconsideration of mental storage capacity , 2001, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[73]  Slava Kalyuga,et al.  When problem solving is superior to studying worked examples. , 2001 .

[74]  Bradford S. Bell,et al.  2. Developing adaptability: A theory for the design of integrated-embedded training systems , 2001 .

[75]  Sharon K Tindall-Ford,et al.  Learning by imagining. , 2001, Journal of experimental psychology. Applied.

[76]  S. Kozlowski,et al.  Adaptive Guidance: Enhancing Self-Regulation, Knowledge, and Performance in Technology-Based Training , 2002 .

[77]  Richard K. Staley,et al.  From Example Study to Problem Solving: Smooth Transitions Help Learning , 2002 .

[78]  P. Chandler,et al.  Assimilating complex information , 2002 .

[79]  Daniel H. Robinson,et al.  The Relative Involvement of Visual and Auditory Working Memory When Studying Adjunct Displays , 2002 .

[80]  Nancy J. Cooke,et al.  Advances in Human Performance and Cognitive Engineering Research , 2002 .

[81]  R. Atkinson,et al.  Structuring the Transition From Example Study to Problem Solving in Cognitive Skill Acquisition: A Cognitive Load Perspective , 2003 .

[82]  Jean-François Rouet,et al.  Effects of content representation and readers' prior knowledge on the comprehension of hypertext , 2003, Int. J. Hum. Comput. Stud..

[83]  Slava Kalyuga,et al.  The Expertise Reversal Effect , 2003 .

[84]  F. Paas,et al.  Cognitive Load Measurement as a Means to Advance Cognitive Load Theory , 2003 .

[85]  Tina Seufert.  Supporting Coherence Formation in Learning from Multiple Representations , 2003 .

[86]  P. Chandler,et al.  When imagining information is effective , 2003 .

[87]  J. Sweller.  Evolution of human cognitive architecture , 2003 .

[88]  Fethi Calisir,et al.  Influence of text structure and prior knowledge of the learner on reading comprehension, browsing and perceived control , 2003, Comput. Hum. Behav..

[89]  P. Kirschner,et al.  Taking the Load Off a Learner's Mind: Instructional Design for Complex Learning , 2003 .

[90]  Slava Kalyuga,et al.  Measuring Knowledge to Optimize Cognitive Load Factors During Instruction. , 2004 .

[91]  Fred Paas,et al.  Mental Effort and Performance as Determinants for the Dynamic Selection of Learning Tasks in Air Traffic Control Training , 2004 .

[92]  J. Sweller.  Instructional Design Consequences of an Analogy between Evolution by Natural Selection and Human Cognitive Architecture , 2004 .

[93]  Slava Kalyuga.  The Cambridge Handbook of Multimedia Learning: Prior Knowledge Principle in Multimedia Learning , 2005 .

[94]  Slava Kalyuga,et al.  Rapid dynamic assessment of expertise to improve the efficiency of adaptive e-learning , 2005 .

[95]  F. Paas,et al.  A motivational perspective on the relation between mental effort and performance: Optimizing learner involvement in instruction , 2005 .

[96]  Wolfgang Schnotz,et al.  Enabling, facilitating, and inhibiting effects of animations in multimedia learning: Why reduction of cognitive load can have negative results on learning , 2005 .

[97]  John Sweller,et al.  The impact of sequencing and prior knowledge on learning mathematics through spreadsheet applications , 2005 .

[98]  Richard Mayer,et al.  Multimedia Learning , 2001, Visible Learning Guide to Student Achievement.

[99]  J. Sweller,et al.  Cognitive Load Theory and Complex Learning: Recent Developments and Future Directions , 2005 .

[100]  J. Sweller,et al.  Interactions among the imagination, expertise reversal, and element interactivity effects. , 2005, Journal of experimental psychology. Applied.

[101]  B. Homer,et al.  Optimizing cognitive load for learning from computer-based science simulations , 2006 .

[102]  Slava Kalyuga.  Instructing And Testing Advanced Learners: A Cognitive Load Approach , 2006 .

[103]  Liesbeth Kester,et al.  Towards a personalized task selection model with shared instructional control , 2006 .

[104]  Slava Kalyuga.  Assessment of learners' organised knowledge structures in adaptive learning environments , 2006 .

[105]  Martin Reisslein,et al.  Encountering the expertise reversal effect with a computer-based environment on electrical circuit analysis , 2006 .

[106]  Fred Paas,et al.  Personalised adaptive task selection in air traffic control: Effects on training efficiency and transfer , 2006 .

[107]  Tina Seufert,et al.  Cognitive load and the format of instructional aids for coherence formation , 2006 .

[108]  Slava Kalyuga,et al.  Rapid cognitive assessment of learners' knowledge structures , 2006 .

[109]  Slava Kalyuga,et al.  Rapid Assessment of Learners’ Proficiency: A cognitive load approach , 2006 .

[110]  Jo-Anne LeFevre,et al.  Cognitive load in hypertext reading: A review , 2007, Comput. Hum. Behav..

[111]  Arthur C. Graesser,et al.  When Are Tutorial Dialogues More Effective Than Reading? , 2007, Cogn. Sci..

[112]  Martin Reisslein,et al.  Learner Achievement and Attitudes under Different Paces of Transitioning to Independent Problem Solving , 2007 .

[113]  Slava Kalyuga,et al.  When Less Is More in Cognitive Diagnosis : A Rapid Online Method for Diagnosing Learner Task-Specific Expertise , 2008 .

[114]  Slava Kalyuga,et al.  Relative effectiveness of animated and static diagrams: An effect of learner prior knowledge , 2008, Comput. Hum. Behav..