Juvenile crime is a serious problem for which treatment approach has been found to be reliably effective. This outcome evaluation assessed during and posttreatment effectiveness of Teaching-Family group home treatment programs for juvenile offenders. The evaluation included the original Achievement Place program, which was the prototype for the development of the Teaching-Family treatment approach, 12 replications of Achievement Place, and 9 comparison group home programs. Primary dependent measures were retrieved from court and police files and included number of alleged offenses, percentage of youths involved in those alleged offenses, and percentage of youths institutionalized. Other dependent measures were subjective ratings of effectiveness obtained from the program consumers, including the group home residents. The results showed difference during treatment favoring the Teaching-Family programs on rate of alleged criminal offenses, percentage of youths involved in those offenses, and consumer ratings of the programs. The consumer ratings provided by the youths and their school teachers were found to be inversely and significantly correlated with the reduction of criminal offenses during treatment. There were no significant differences during treatment on measures of noncriminal offenses (e.g., truancy, runaway, and curfew violations). In the posttreatment year, none of the differences between the groups was significant on any of the outcome measures. The results are discussed in terms of measurement and design issues in the evaluation of delinquency treatment programs and in relation to the evaluation; of Teaching-Family group homes by Richard Jones and his colleagues.
[1]
Curtis J. Braukmann,et al.
The relationship between parent-youth interaction and delinquency in group homes
,
1981,
Journal of abnormal child psychology.
[2]
K. O’leary,et al.
Conceptual, methodological, and ethical problems of placebo groups in psychotherapy research.
,
1978,
The American psychologist.
[3]
M. Wolf,et al.
Social validity: the case for subjective measurement or how applied behavior analysis is finding its heart.
,
1978,
Journal of applied behavior analysis.
[4]
D. Fixsen,et al.
Teaching conversation-related skills to predelinquent girls.
,
1976,
Journal of applied behavior analysis.
[5]
D. Fixsen,et al.
The social validation and training of conversational skills.
,
1976,
Journal of applied behavior analysis.
[6]
D. Fixsen,et al.
Achievement Place: development of the elected manager system.
,
1973,
Journal of applied behavior analysis.
[7]
J. F. Alexander,et al.
Short-term behavioral intervention with delinquent families: impact on family process and recidivism.
,
1973,
Journal of abnormal psychology.
[8]
D. Fixsen,et al.
Achievement Place: experiments in self-government with pre-delinquents.
,
1973,
Journal of applied behavior analysis.
[9]
E. L. Phillips,et al.
Achievement Place: token reinforcement procedures in a home-style rehabilitation setting for "pre-delinquent" boys.
,
1968,
Journal of applied behavior analysis.