The role of the anterior insula in social norm compliance and enforcement: Evidence from coordinate-based and functional connectivity meta-analyses

HIGHLIGHTSDifferent anterior insula (AI) regions underlie social behaviors in economic games.Dorsal AI activation is related to expectancy of norm compliance.Ventral AI is associated with negative feelings motivating norm enforcement. ABSTRACT Economic games —trust (TG) and ultimatum game (UG)— combined with fMRI have shown the importance of the anterior insula (AI) in social normative behaviors. However, whether different AI subregions are engaged in different cognitive and affective processes for social norm compliance and norm enforcement during social exchange remains elusive. Here, we investigated the role of the dorsal AI (dAI) and ventral AI (vAI), combining a coordinate‐based meta‐analysis of fMRI studies using the TG and UG with meta‐analytic task‐based and task‐free connectivity analyses. Our findings showed that the right dAI and vAI were the only common brain regions consistently activated across games. These clusters were part of two functionally distinguishable connectivity networks associated with cognitive (dAI) and emotional (vAI) processes. In conclusion, we propose that dAI mediates cognitive processes that generate expectancy for norm compliance, whereas vAI mediates aversive feelings that generate motivation to norm enforcement. The identified functional differentiation of the right AI in the social domain contributes to a better understanding of its role in basic and clinical neuroscience.

[1]  Dirk Semmann,et al.  Strategic investment in reputation , 2004, Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology.

[2]  Luke J. Chang,et al.  Triangulating the Neural, Psychological, and Economic Bases of Guilt Aversion , 2011, Neuron.

[3]  Lutz Jäncke,et al.  Neural correlates of a ‘pessimistic’ attitude when anticipating events of unknown emotional valence , 2007, NeuroImage.

[4]  Bradley R. Postle,et al.  Localization of load sensitivity of working memory storage: Quantitatively and qualitatively discrepant results yielded by single-subject and group-averaged approaches to fMRI group analysis , 2007, NeuroImage.

[5]  Brent Simpson,et al.  Perceptions of unfairness in allocations between multiple recipients , 2011, Cognitive Psychology.

[6]  S. Zamir.  Rationality and Emotions in Ultimatum Bargaining , 2001 .

[7]  E. Fehr,et al.  Altruistic punishment in humans , 2002, Nature.

[8]  Stefan Koelsch,et al.  Bach Speaks: A Cortical “Language-Network” Serves the Processing of Music , 2002, NeuroImage.

[9]  Katia M. Harlé,et al.  The neural mechanisms of affect infusion in social economic decision-making: A mediating role of the anterior insula , 2012, NeuroImage.

[10]  Nick F. Ramsey,et al.  Test–retest reliability of fMRI activation during prosaccades and antisaccades , 2007, NeuroImage.

[11]  K. Zilles,et al.  A link between the systems: functional differentiation and integration within the human insula revealed by meta-analysis , 2010, Brain Structure and Function.

[12]  Angela R. Laird,et al.  A seed-based cross-modal comparison of brain connectivity measures , 2016, Brain Structure and Function.

[13]  S. Petersen,et al.  Role of the anterior insula in task-level control and focal attention , 2010, Brain Structure and Function.

[14]  The spiral of distrust: (Non‐)cooperation in a repeated trust game is predicted by anger and individual differences in negative reciprocity orientation , 2017, International journal of psychology : Journal international de psychologie.

[15]  R. Marois,et al.  The roots of modern justice: cognitive and neural foundations of social norms and their enforcement , 2012, Nature Neuroscience.

[16]  Aya Ihara,et al.  Selective Increase of Intention-Based Economic Decisions by Noninvasive Brain Stimulation to the Dorsolateral Prefrontal Cortex , 2015, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[17]  Angela R. Laird,et al.  Behavior, sensitivity, and power of activation likelihood estimation characterized by massive empirical simulation , 2016, NeuroImage.

[18]  Lei Zhu,et al.  Increased neural responses to unfairness in a loss context , 2013, NeuroImage.

[19]  J. O'Doherty,et al.  Empathic neural responses are modulated by the perceived fairness of others , 2006, Nature.

[20]  Claus Tempelmann,et al.  Tit-for-tat: The neural basis of reactive aggression , 2007, NeuroImage.

[21]  C. Frith,et al.  Experiencing Oneself vs Another Person as Being the Cause of an Action: The Neural Correlates of the Experience of Agency , 2002, NeuroImage.

[22]  Simon B. Eickhoff,et al.  Multimodal connectivity of motor learning-related dorsal premotor cortex , 2015, NeuroImage.

[23]  Tania Singer,et al.  Differential pattern of functional brain plasticity after compassion and empathy training. , 2014, Social cognitive and affective neuroscience.

[24]  Iris Bohnet,et al.  Trust, Risk and Betrayal , 2004 .

[25]  G. Fink,et al.  The role of the right temporoparietal junction in attention and social interaction as revealed by ALE meta-analysis , 2014, Brain Structure and Function.

[26]  W. Güth,et al.  Trust and reciprocity in the investment game with indirect reward , 2000 .

[27]  E. Fehr,et al.  Changing Social Norm Compliance with Noninvasive Brain Stimulation , 2013, Science.

[28]  Colin Camerer,et al.  EXPERIMENTAL TESTS OF A SEQUENTIAL EQUILIBRIUM REPUTATION MODEL , 1988 .

[29]  G. Rizzolatti,et al.  Both of Us Disgusted in My Insula The Common Neural Basis of Seeing and Feeling Disgust , 2003, Neuron.

[30]  J. Decety,et al.  The Emerging Social Neuroscience of Justice Motivation , 2017, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[31]  V. Smith,et al.  Friend-or-foe intentionality priming in an extensive form trust game , 2000 .

[32]  Jessica A. Turner,et al.  Neuroinformatics Original Research Article , 2022 .

[33]  Serge A. R. B. Rombouts,et al.  Dissociable brain networks involved in development of fairness considerations: Understanding intentionality behind unfairness , 2011, NeuroImage.

[34]  Patrik Vuilleumier,et al.  Cross-modal representations of first-hand and vicarious pain, disgust and fairness in insular and cingulate cortex , 2016, Nature Communications.

[35]  D. Ariely,et al.  Doing Good or Doing Well? Image Motivation and Monetary Incentives in Behaving Prosocially , 2007, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[36]  H. Oosterbeek,et al.  Cultural Differences in Ultimatum Game Experiments: Evidence from a Meta-Analysis , 2001 .

[37]  Matthew D. Lieberman,et al.  The Sunny Side of Fairness , 2008, Psychological science.

[38]  Bernd Weber,et al.  Neural signatures of betrayal aversion: an fMRI study of trust , 2014, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[39]  Jian Li,et al.  Neural responses to sanction threats in two-party economic exchange , 2009, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[40]  Thomas Baumgartner,et al.  Article the Neural Circuitry of a Broken Promise , 2022 .

[41]  C. Bicchieri.  Norms, Conventions, and the Power of Expectations , 2014 .

[42]  Lutz Jäncke,et al.  Modulation of anticipatory emotion and perception processing by cognitive control , 2007, NeuroImage.

[43]  Yue-Jia Luo,et al.  Neural signatures of fairness‐related normative decision making in the ultimatum game: A coordinate‐based meta‐analysis , 2015, Human brain mapping.

[44]  Jill Keane,et al.  Disgust sensitivity predicts the insula and pallidal response to pictures of disgusting foods , 2007, The European journal of neuroscience.

[45]  Daniel Houser,et al.  Harnessing the Benefits of Betrayal Aversion , 2013 .

[46]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Anterior insula coordinates hierarchical processing of tactile mismatch responses , 2016, NeuroImage.

[47]  W. Güth,et al.  An experimental analysis of ultimatum bargaining , 1982 .

[48]  Kristina M. Visscher,et al.  A Core System for the Implementation of Task Sets , 2006, Neuron.

[49]  Tianzi Jiang,et al.  Determination of the posterior boundary of Wernicke's area based on multimodal connectivity profiles , 2015, Human brain mapping.

[50]  B. T. Thomas Yeo,et al.  Topographic organization of the cerebral cortex and brain cartography , 2017, NeuroImage.

[51]  Terry Lohrenz,et al.  To Detect and Correct: Norm Violations and Their Enforcement , 2007, Neuron.

[52]  Ananish Chaudhuri,et al.  An Experimental Analysis of Trust and Trustworthiness , 2007 .

[53]  Angela R. Laird,et al.  Across-study and within-subject functional connectivity of a right temporo-parietal junction subregion involved in stimulus–context integration , 2012, NeuroImage.

[54]  W. Nelson.  Equity or intention: it is the thought that counts , 2002 .

[55]  D. Mobbs,et al.  Overlapping and distinct representations of advantageous and disadvantageous inequality , 2013, Human brain mapping.

[56]  M. Nowak,et al.  Evolution of indirect reciprocity by image scoring , 1998, Nature.

[57]  Guinevere F. Eden,et al.  Meta-Analysis of the Functional Neuroanatomy of Single-Word Reading: Method and Validation , 2002, NeuroImage.

[58]  Matthew D. Lieberman,et al.  Does Rejection Hurt? An fMRI Study of Social Exclusion , 2003, Science.

[59]  Gereon R Fink,et al.  Disentangling self- and fairness-related neural mechanisms involved in the ultimatum game: an fMRI study. , 2013, Social cognitive and affective neuroscience.

[60]  M. Milinski,et al.  Reputation helps solve the ‘tragedy of the commons’ , 2002, Nature.

[61]  T. Lohrenz,et al.  Computational Substrates of Norms and Their Violations during Social Exchange , 2013, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[62]  A. Schulze-Bonhage,et al.  Functional organization of the human anterior insular cortex , 2009, Neuroscience Letters.

[63]  Serge A R B Rombouts,et al.  What motivates repayment? Neural correlates of reciprocity in the Trust Game. , 2009, Social cognitive and affective neuroscience.

[64]  Alexandra A. Mislin,et al.  Trust games: A meta-analysis , 2011 .

[65]  N. Tzourio-Mazoyer,et al.  Automated Anatomical Labeling of Activations in SPM Using a Macroscopic Anatomical Parcellation of the MNI MRI Single-Subject Brain , 2002, NeuroImage.

[66]  Simon B Eickhoff,et al.  Minimizing within‐experiment and within‐group effects in activation likelihood estimation meta‐analyses , 2012, Human brain mapping.

[67]  Meghan L. Meyer,et al.  Why Social Pain Can Live on: Different Neural Mechanisms Are Associated with Reliving Social and Physical Pain , 2015, PloS one.

[68]  Luke J. Chang,et al.  Decoding the role of the insula in human cognition: functional parcellation and large-scale reverse inference. , 2013, Cerebral cortex.

[69]  Aldo Rustichini,et al.  Equality versus self-interest in the brain: Differential roles of anterior insula and medial prefrontal cortex , 2012, NeuroImage.

[70]  Martin Dufwenberg,et al.  Promises and Partnership , 2006 .

[71]  Michael P. Milham,et al.  A convergent functional architecture of the insula emerges across imaging modalities , 2012, NeuroImage.

[72]  Li Zheng,et al.  Neural responses to unfairness and fairness depend on self-contribution to the income. , 2014, Social cognitive and affective neuroscience.

[73]  Simon B Eickhoff,et al.  Neural signatures of trust in reciprocity: A coordinate‐based meta‐analysis , 2017, Human brain mapping.

[74]  U. Fischbacher,et al.  The Neural Signature of Social Norm Compliance , 2007, Neuron.

[75]  Madan M. Pillutla,et al.  Unfairness, Anger, and Spite: Emotional Rejections of Ultimatum Offers , 1996 .

[76]  A. Sanfey.  Social Decision-Making : Insights from Game Theory and Neuroscience , 2022 .

[77]  P. Fox,et al.  Identification of a common neurobiological substrate for mental illness. , 2015, JAMA psychiatry.

[78]  K. Zilles,et al.  Coordinate‐based activation likelihood estimation meta‐analysis of neuroimaging data: A random‐effects approach based on empirical estimates of spatial uncertainty , 2009, Human brain mapping.

[79]  Rainer Goebel,et al.  Common neural substrates for visual working memory and attention , 2007, NeuroImage.

[80]  Angela R. Laird,et al.  Activation likelihood estimation meta-analysis revisited , 2012, NeuroImage.

[81]  Serge A R B Rombouts,et al.  Changing Brains, Changing Perspectives , 2011, Psychological science.

[82]  Joyce E. Berg,et al.  Trust, Reciprocity, and Social History , 1995 .

[83]  Angela R. Laird,et al.  Meta-analytic connectivity modeling revisited: Controlling for activation base rates , 2014, NeuroImage.

[84]  Joaquim Radua,et al.  Game and the brain : A meta-analysis f neuroimaging studies , 2014 .

[85]  Jonathan D. Cohen,et al.  The Neural Basis of Economic Decision-Making in the Ultimatum Game , 2003, Science.

[86]  Angela M. Uecker,et al.  ALE meta‐analysis: Controlling the false discovery rate and performing statistical contrasts , 2005, Human brain mapping.

[87]  Martin Dufwenberg,et al.  Promises and Partnership , 2006 .

[88]  M. Lindquist,et al.  Meta-analysis of functional neuroimaging data: current and future directions. , 2007, Social cognitive and affective neuroscience.

[89]  H. Ohira,et al.  The positive side of psychopathy: Emotional detachment in psychopathy and rational decision-making in the ultimatum game , 2010 .

[90]  Mark W Woolrich,et al.  Associative learning of social value , 2008, Nature.

[91]  Sun-Hong Kim,et al.  The Insula: An Underestimated Brain Area in Clinical Neuroscience, Psychiatry, and Neurology , 2017, Trends in Neurosciences.

[92]  Li Zheng,et al.  Perceived reputation of others modulates empathic neural responses , 2015, Experimental Brain Research.

[93]  Felix Warneken,et al.  Social Influences on Inequity Aversion in Children , 2013, PloS one.

[94]  Daniel Houser,et al.  What you don’t know won’t hurt you: a laboratory analysis of betrayal aversion , 2012 .

[95]  Colin Camerer.  Behavioral Game Theory: Experiments in Strategic Interaction , 2003 .

[96]  Angela R. Laird,et al.  BrainMap , 2007, Neuroinformatics.

[97]  V. Smith,et al.  Positive reciprocity and intentions in trust games , 2003 .

[98]  Klaus M. Schmidt,et al.  A Theory of Fairness, Competition, and Cooperation , 1999 .

[99]  C. Bicchieri.  The grammar of society: the nature and dynamics of social norms , 2005 .

[100]  U. Fischbacher,et al.  The nature of human altruism , 2003, Nature.

[101]  Angela R Laird,et al.  Meta‐analyses of object naming: Effect of baseline , 2005, Human brain mapping.

[102]  M. Willinger,et al.  THE DETERMINANTS OF TRUSTING AND RECIPROCAL BEHAVIOUR: EVIDENCE FROM AN INTERCULTURAL EXPERIMENT , 2008 .

[103]  P. Dayan,et al.  The social contingency of momentary subjective well-being , 2016, Nature Communications.

[104]  R. Zeckhauser,et al.  Betrayal Aversion: Evidence from Brazil, China, Oman, Switzerland, Turkey, and the United States , 2008 .

[105]  Thomas E. Nichols,et al.  Can parametric statistical methods be trusted for fMRI based group studies? , 2015, 1511.01863.

[106]  P. Blake,et al.  “I had so much it didn’t seem fair”: Eight-year-olds reject two forms of inequity , 2011, Cognition.

[107]  N. Kriegeskorte,et al.  Neural correlates of trust , 2007, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[108]  Naomi B. Pitskel,et al.  Three Systems of Insular Functional Connectivity Identified with Cluster Analysis , 2010, Cerebral cortex.

[109]  Cristina Bicchieri,et al.  Norms of Cooperation , 1990, Ethics.

[110]  Colin Camerer,et al.  Economic Games Quantify Diminished Sense of Guilt in Patients with Damage to the Prefrontal Cortex , 2009, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[111]  K. Amunts,et al.  The human parietal operculum. II. Stereotaxic maps and correlation with functional imaging results. , 2006, Cerebral cortex.

[112]  Matthias Gamer,et al.  Are irrational reactions to unfairness truly emotionally-driven? Dissociated behavioural and emotional responses in the Ultimatum Game task , 2010, Cognition.

[113]  Colin Camerer.  Behavioural studies of strategic thinking in games , 2003, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[114]  J. O'Doherty,et al.  Empathy for Pain Involves the Affective but not Sensory Components of Pain , 2004, Science.

[115]  Luke J. Chang,et al.  Seeing is believing: Trustworthiness as a dynamic belief , 2010, Cognitive Psychology.