Language and theory of mind: meta-analysis of the relation between language ability and false-belief understanding.

Numerous studies show that children's language ability is related to false-belief understanding. However, there is considerable variation in the size of the correlation reported. Using data from 104 studies (N=8,891), this meta-analysis determines the strength of the relation in children under age 7 and examines moderators that may account for the variability across studies--including aspect of language ability assessed, type of false-belief task used, and direction of effect. The results indicate a moderate to large effect size overall that remains significant when age is controlled. Receptive vocabulary measures had weaker relations than measures of general language. Stronger effects were found from earlier language to later false belief than the reverse. Significant differences were not found among types of false-belief task.

[1]  C. Hughes,et al.  Nature, Nurture, and Individual Differences in Early Understanding of Mind , 1999 .

[2]  Jacob Cohen.  Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences , 1969, The SAGE Encyclopedia of Research Design.

[3]  H. Wellman,et al.  Children Talk About the Mind , 1995 .

[4]  Charles Fernyhough,et al.  Security of Attachment as a Predictor of Symbolic and Mentalising Abilities: A Longitudinal Study , 2001 .

[5]  J. Astington,et al.  A longitudinal study of the relation between language and theory-of-mind development. , 1999, Developmental psychology.

[6]  L. Moses,et al.  Demographics, Parenting, and Theory of Mind in Preschool Children , 2003 .

[7]  J. Singer,et al.  Preschoolers' pretend play and theory of mind: The role of jointly constructed pretence , 1999 .

[8]  Uta Frith,et al.  Theory of mind , 2001, Current Biology.

[9]  Josef Perner,et al.  Implicit Understanding of Belief , 1994 .

[10]  R. Rosenthal.  Meta-analytic procedures for social research , 1984 .

[11]  de Villiers,et al.  Can Language Acquisition Give Children a Point of View , 2005 .

[12]  P. Fisher,et al.  Emotion understanding and theory of mind among maltreated children in foster care: Evidence of deficits , 2005, Development and Psychopathology.

[13]  J. Dunn,et al.  Trick or treat?: uneven understanding of mind and emotion and executive dysfunction in "hard-to-manage" preschoolers. , 1998, Journal of child psychology and psychiatry, and allied disciplines.

[14]  Peter Carruthers,et al.  Language and Thought , 1998 .

[15]  S. M. Carlson,et al.  Executive function and theory of mind: stability and prediction from ages 2 to 3. , 2004, Developmental psychology.

[16]  de Villiers,et al.  The Role of Language in Theory-of-Mind Development: What Deaf Children Tell Us. , 2005 .

[17]  J. A. Fodor.  A theory of the child's theory of mind , 1992, Cognition.

[18]  Ellen Bialystok,et al.  Executive processes in appearance-reality tasks: the role of inhibition of attention and symbolic representation. , 2004, Child development.

[19]  M. Bornstein,et al.  Longitudinal Relations Between 2-Year-Olds' Language and 4-Year-Olds' Theory of Mind , 2001 .

[20]  Annette M. E. Henderson,et al.  Executive Function and False-Belief Understanding in Preschool Children: Two Tasks Are Harder Than One , 2003 .

[21]  J. Astington,et al.  Mental language and understanding of epistemic and emotional mental states: contextual aspects , 2006 .

[22]  H. Wimmer,et al.  Against the Cartesian view on mind: Young children's difficulty with own false beliefs , 1991 .

[23]  L. Hedges,et al.  The Handbook of Research Synthesis , 1995 .

[24]  S. Curenton.  Low-Income Preschoolers' False-Belief Performance , 2003, The Journal of genetic psychology.

[25]  D. Symons,et al.  Executive functioning and theory of mind in children clinically referred for attention and behavior problems , 2003 .

[26]  Charles Fernyhough,et al.  Maternal mind-mindedness and attachment security as predictors of theory of mind understanding. , 2002, Child development.

[27]  R. Varley.  Aphasic language, aphasic thought: an investigation of propositional thinking in an a-propositional aphasic , 1998 .

[28]  U. Goswami.  Blackwell handbook of childhood cognitive development , 2002 .

[29]  Thomas R. Keenan.  Memory Span as a Predictor of False Belief Understanding , 1998 .

[30]  C. Dissanayake,et al.  The Relationship Between Theory of Mind and Conservation Abilities in Children Using an Active/Inactive Paradigm , 2003 .

[31]  L. Mo,et al.  Relative roles of general and complementation language in theory-of-mind development: evidence from Cantonese and English. , 2004, Child development.

[32]  Marjorie Taylor,et al.  The relation between individual differences in fantasy and theory of mind. , 1997, Child development.

[33]  H. Wellman,et al.  The acquisition of mental verbs: A systematic investigation of the first reference to mental state , 1983, Cognition.

[34]  D. Howe,et al.  Social understanding, attachment security of preschool children and maternal mental health , 2001 .

[35]  Katherine Nelson,et al.  Entering a Community of Minds: An Experiential Approach to ‘Theory of Mind’ , 2003, Human Development.

[36]  P. Harris.  Conversation, Pretense, and Theory of Mind. , 2005 .

[37]  J. Astington,et al.  Cognitive Factors and Family Structure Associated with Theory of Mind Development in Young Children. , 1996 .

[38]  R. Baillargeon,et al.  Do 15-Month-Old Infants Understand False Beliefs? , 2005, Science.

[39]  T. Ruffman,et al.  The relation between children's and mothers' mental state language and theory-of-mind understanding. , 2002, Child development.

[40]  Virginia Slaughter,et al.  Theory of Mind and Mental State Discourse during Book Reading and Story-Telling Tasks. , 2005 .

[41]  B. Repacholi,et al.  Attachment and preschool children's understanding of maternal versus non-maternal psychological states , 2004 .

[42]  H. Wimmer,et al.  Beliefs about beliefs: Representation and constraining function of wrong beliefs in young children's understanding of deception , 1983, Cognition.

[43]  Josef Perner,et al.  Want that is understood well before say that, think that, and false belief: a test of de Villiers's linguistic determinism on German-speaking children. , 2003, Child development.

[44]  J. Dunn,et al.  Communication, Relationships, and Individual Differences in Children's Understanding of Mind. , 2005 .

[45]  Michael Siegal,et al.  Signposts to development: theory of mind in deaf children. , 2002, Child development.

[46]  L. Murray,et al.  Children’s Social Representations in Dolls’ House Play and Theory of Mind Tasks, and their Relation to Family Adversity and Child Disturbance , 2001 .

[47]  Ş. Çelimli,et al.  The role of institution and home contexts in theory of mind development , 2005 .

[48]  Kevin Durkin,et al.  Central coherence in typically developing preschoolers: does it cohere and does it relate to mindreading and executive control? , 2005, Journal of child psychology and psychiatry, and allied disciplines.

[49]  Paul L. Harris,et al.  A lag between understanding false belief and emotion attribution in young children: Relationships with linguistic ability and mothers' mental‐state language , 2004 .

[50]  K. Cassidy,et al.  The Relationship Between Psychological Understanding and Positive Social Behaviors , 2003 .

[51]  J. Flavell.  The development of children's knowledge about the appearance-reality distinction. , 1986, The American psychologist.

[52]  K. Hird,et al.  Is grammatical competence a precondition for belief-desire reasoning? Evidence from typically developing children and those with autism , 2004 .

[53]  Henry M. Wellman,et al.  Understanding the Psychological World: Developing a Theory of Mind , 2007 .

[54]  N. Freeman.  Children's early understanding of mind , 1994 .

[55]  Nicole R Guajardo,et al.  Narrative Discourse and Theory of Mind Development , 2002, The Journal of genetic psychology.

[56]  Helen Tager-Flusberg,et al.  The influence of language on theory of mind: a training study. , 2003, Developmental science.

[57]  John E. Hunter,et al.  Fixed Effects vs. Random Effects Meta‐Analysis Models: Implications for Cumulative Research Knowledge , 2000 .

[58]  J. Dunn,et al.  Young children's understanding of other people's beliefs and feelings and their connected communication with friends. , 1996 .

[59]  M. Chandler,et al.  Small-scale deceit: deception as a marker of two-, three-, and four-year-olds' early theories of mind. , 1989, Child development.

[60]  P. Harris,et al.  Young Children's Theory of Mind and Emotion , 1989 .

[61]  C. Peterson.  Kindred spirits: Influences of siblings' perspectives on theory of mind , 2000 .

[62]  Alan Garnham,et al.  How language relates to belief, desire, and emotion understanding , 2003 .

[63]  H. Wimmer,et al.  Three-year-olds' difficulty with false belief: The case for a conceptual deficit , 1987 .

[64]  Jodie A. Baird,et al.  Why Language Matters for Theory of Mind , 2005 .

[65]  Kimberly Wright Cassidy,et al.  Theory of mind may be contagious, but you don't catch it from your twin. , 2005, Child development.

[66]  A. Karmiloff-Smith.  Précis of Beyond modularity: A developmental perspective on cognitive science , 1994, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[67]  J. Perner,et al.  How Parenting Style Affects False Belief Understanding , 2001 .

[68]  V. Slaughter,et al.  Opening windows into the mind: mothers’ preferences for mental state explanations and children’s theory of mind , 2003 .

[69]  B. Repacholi,et al.  Individual differences in theory of mind : implications for typical and atypical development , 2003 .

[70]  V. Reddy,et al.  Teaching Three Year-Olds to Pass False Belief Tests: A Conversational Approach , 1996 .

[71]  D. Bowler,et al.  Understanding the Mind or Predicting Signal-Dependent Action? Performance of Children With and Without Autism on Analogues of the False-Belief Task , 2005 .

[72]  Ian Apperly,et al.  False belief reasoning and the acquisition of relative clause sentences. , 2003, Child development.

[73]  Amy A. Weimer,et al.  False Belief, Emotion Understanding, and Social Skills Among Head Start and Non-Head Start Children , 2005 .

[74]  A. L. Jackson.  Language facility and theory of mind development in deaf children. , 2001, Journal of deaf studies and deaf education.

[75]  C. Nixon,et al.  Social interaction skills and theory of mind in young children. , 1999, Developmental psychology.

[76]  Claire O'Malley,et al.  A longitudinal, microgenetic study of the emergence of false belief understanding and inhibition skills. , 2004, Developmental science.

[77]  H. Wellman,et al.  Infant social attention predicts preschool social cognition. , 2004, Developmental science.

[78]  Douglas Frye,et al.  Theory of mind and rule-based reasoning , 1995 .

[79]  Dare A. Baldwin,et al.  Learning words from knowledgeable versus ignorant speakers: links between preschoolers' theory of mind and semantic development. , 2001, Child development.

[80]  P. Fonagy,et al.  The relationship between belief-desire reasoning and a projective measure of attachment security (SAT) , 1997 .

[81]  H. Tager-Flusberg,et al.  How Language Facilitates the Acquisition of False-Belief Understanding in Children with Autism. , 2005 .

[82]  Michael Siegal,et al.  Representing Inner Worlds: Theory of Mind in Autistic, Deaf, and Normal Hearing Children , 1999 .

[83]  Stephen C. Want,et al.  Severe Impairment in Grammar Does Not Preclude Theory of Mind , 2001, Neurocase.

[84]  Stephan M. Koplan.  The Fugitive Literature , 1979 .

[85]  P. Garner,et al.  Predictors of mental state understanding in preschoolers of varying socioeconomic backgrounds , 2005 .

[86]  Ted Ruffman,et al.  How language does (and does not) relate to theory of mind: A longitudinal study of syntax, semantics, working memory and false belief , 2005 .

[87]  H. Wellman,et al.  Meta-analysis of theory-of-mind development: the truth about false belief. , 2001, Child development.

[88]  Emma Flynn.  A microgenetic investigation of stability and continuity in theory of mind development , 2006 .

[89]  A. Caspi,et al.  Origins of individual differences in theory of mind: from nature to nurture? , 2005, Child development.

[90]  M. Tomasello,et al.  The role of language in the development of false belief understanding: a training study. , 2003, Child development.

[91]  M. Doherty,et al.  Children's understanding of homonymy: metalinguistic awareness and false belief , 2000, Journal of Child Language.

[92]  K. Turley-Ames,et al.  Preschoolers' generation of different types of counterfactual statements and theory of mind understanding , 2004 .

[93]  R. Razza.  Associations among False-belief Understanding, Executive Function, and Social Competence: A Longitudinal Analysis. , 2009, Journal of applied developmental psychology.

[94]  J. Astington,et al.  Introduction: Why Language Matters. , 2005 .

[95]  M. J. Farrar,et al.  Early language development and the emergence of a theory of mind∗ , 2002 .

[96]  P. Bloom,et al.  Two reasons to abandon the false belief task as a test of theory of mind , 2000, Cognition.

[97]  G. Deák,et al.  Choose and choose again: appearance-reality errors, pragmatics and logical ability. , 2006, Developmental science.

[98]  Claire Hughes,et al.  Executive function in preschoolers: Links with theory of mind and verbal ability , 1998 .

[99]  C. Peterson,et al.  Theory-of-mind development in oral deaf children with cochlear implants or conventional hearing aids. , 2004, Journal of child psychology and psychiatry, and allied disciplines.

[100]  Alan Garnham,et al.  From synonyms to homonyms: exploring the role of metarepresentation in language understanding , 2000 .

[101]  Tony Charman,et al.  Is there a Gender Difference in False Belief Development , 2002 .

[102]  G. Deák,et al.  Children's perseverative appearance-reality errors are related to emerging language skills. , 2003, Child development.

[103]  P. Harris,et al.  Individual differences in children's understanding of emotion: The roles of attachment and language , 2002, Attachment & human development.

[104]  A. Gopnik,et al.  Children's understanding of representational change and its relation to the understanding of false belief and the appearance-reality distinction. , 1988, Child development.

[105]  Antonella Marchetti,et al.  Theory of Mind and Language in Developmental Contexts , 2006 .

[106]  J. Dunn,et al.  Understanding mind and emotion: longitudinal associations with mental-state talk between young friends. , 1998, Developmental psychology.

[107]  J. Dunn,et al.  Understanding Others, and Individual Differences in Friendship Interactions in Young Children , 2001 .

[108]  Jennie E. Pyers,et al.  Complements to cognition: a longitudinal study of the relationship between complex syntax and false-belief-understanding , 2002 .

[109]  Katherine Nelson,et al.  Language Pathways into the Community of Minds , 2005 .

[110]  L. Moses,et al.  Individual differences in inhibitory control and children's theory of mind. , 2001, Child development.

[111]  F. Happé.  The role of age and verbal ability in the theory of mind task performance of subjects with autism. , 1995, Child development.

[112]  Josef Perner,et al.  Theory of mind and self-control: more than a common problem of inhibition. , 2002, Child development.

[113]  Laura J. Claxton,et al.  Individual differences in executive functioning and theory of mind: An investigation of inhibitory control and planning ability. , 2004, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[114]  Carol A. Miller,et al.  False belief understanding in children with specific language impairment. , 2001, Journal of communication disorders.

[115]  K. Durkin,et al.  Belief term development in children with autism, Asperger syndrome, specific language impairment, and normal development: links to theory of mind development. , 1998, Journal of child psychology and psychiatry, and allied disciplines.

[116]  Ulrich Müller,et al.  Executive function and children's understanding of false belief: how specific is the relation? , 2005 .

[117]  C. Blair,et al.  Cortisol reactivity is positively related to executive function in preschool children attending head start. , 2005, Child development.