Preferential Loading of the ACL Compared With the MCL During Landing

Background: Strong biomechanical and epidemiological evidence associates knee valgus collapse with isolated, noncontact anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries. However, a concomitant injury to the medial collateral ligament (MCL) would be expected under valgus collapse, based on the MCL’s anatomic orientation and biomechanical role in knee stability. Purpose/Hypothesis: The purpose of this study was to investigate the relative ACL to MCL strain patterns during physiological simulations of a wide range of high-risk dynamic landing scenarios. We hypothesized that both knee abduction and internal tibial rotation moments would generate a disproportionate increase in the ACL strain relative to the MCL strain. However, the physiological range of knee abduction and internal tibial rotation moments that produce ACL injuries are not of sufficient magnitude to compromise the MCL’s integrity consistently. Study Design: Controlled laboratory study. Methods: A novel in sim approach was used to test our hypothesis. Seventeen cadaveric lower extremities (mean age, 45 ± 7 years; 9 female and 8 male) were tested to simulate a broad range of landings after a jump under anterior tibial shear force, knee abduction, and internal tibial rotation at 25° of knee flexion. The ACL and MCL strains were quantified using differential variable reluctance transducers. An extensively validated, detailed finite element model of the lower extremity was used to help better interpret experimental findings. Results: Anterior cruciate ligament failure occurred in 15 of 17 specimens (88%). Increased anterior tibial shear force and knee abduction and internal tibial rotation moments resulted in significantly higher ACL:MCL strain ratios (P < .05). Under all modes of single-planar and multiplanar loading, the ACL:MCL strain ratio remained greater than 1.7, while the relative ACL strain was significantly higher than the relative MCL strain (P < .01). Relative change in the ACL strain was demonstrated to be significantly greater under combined multiplanar loading compared with anterior tibial shear force (P = .016), knee abduction (P = .018), and internal tibial rotation (P < .0005) moments alone. Conclusion: While both the ACL and the MCL resist knee valgus during landing, physiological magnitudes of the applied loads leading to high ACL strain levels and injuries were not sufficient to compromise the MCL’s integrity. Clinical Relevance: A better understanding of injury mechanisms may provide insight that improves current risk screening and injury prevention strategies. Current findings support multiplanar knee valgus collapse as a primary factor contributing to a noncontact ACL injury.

[1]  J. Mink,et al.  Occult cartilage and bone injuries of the knee: detection, classification, and assessment with MR imaging. , 1989, Radiology.

[2]  M. Hull,et al.  Strain inhomogeneity in the anterior cruciate ligament under application of external and muscular loads. , 1998, Journal of biomechanical engineering.

[3]  Kevin R Ford,et al.  Valgus knee motion during landing in high school female and male basketball players. , 2003, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[4]  J S Torg,et al.  Video analysis of trunk and knee motion during non-contact anterior cruciate ligament injury in female athletes: lateral trunk and knee abduction motion are combined components of the injury mechanism , 2009, British Journal of Sports Medicine.

[5]  C. Spritzer,et al.  Osseous injury associated with acute tears of the anterior cruciate ligament , 1992, The American journal of sports medicine.

[6]  E. Grood,et al.  Primary and coupled motions in the intact and the ACL‐deficient knee: An in vitro study in the goat model , 1992, Journal of orthopaedic research : official publication of the Orthopaedic Research Society.

[7]  P. Walker,et al.  Ligament length patterns, strength, and rotational axes of the knee joint. , 1976, Clinical orthopaedics and related research.

[8]  James A Ashton-Miller,et al.  The effect of an impulsive knee valgus moment on in vitro relative ACL strain during a simulated jump landing. , 2006, Clinical biomechanics.

[9]  F. Noyes,et al.  The Effect of Neuromuscular Training on the Incidence of Knee Injury in Female Athletes , 1999, The American journal of sports medicine.

[10]  R J Johnson,et al.  The effect of weightbearing and external loading on anterior cruciate ligament strain. , 2001, Journal of biomechanics.

[11]  T. Hewett,et al.  Biomechanical Measures of Neuromuscular Control and Valgus Loading of the Knee Predict Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury Risk in Female Athletes: A Prospective Study , 2005, The American journal of sports medicine.

[12]  Thomas P Andriacchi,et al.  The effect of isolated valgus moments on ACL strain during single-leg landing: a simulation study. , 2009, Journal of biomechanics.

[13]  Roger C Haut,et al.  Excessive compression of the human tibio-femoral joint causes ACL rupture. , 2005, Journal of biomechanics.

[14]  Youkeun K. Oh,et al.  What Strains the Anterior Cruciate Ligament During a Pivot Landing? , 2012, The American journal of sports medicine.

[15]  S. McLean,et al.  Sagittal plane biomechanics cannot injure the ACL during sidestep cutting. , 2004, Clinical biomechanics.

[16]  C. Prodromos,et al.  A meta-analysis of the incidence of anterior cruciate ligament tears as a function of gender, sport, and a knee injury-reduction regimen. , 2007, Arthroscopy : the journal of arthroscopic & related surgery : official publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association.

[17]  T. Hewett,et al.  Cartilage Pressure Distributions Provide a Footprint to Define Female Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury Mechanisms , 2011, The American journal of sports medicine.

[18]  W. Garrett,et al.  The Effects of a Valgus Collapse Knee Position on In Vivo ACL Elongation , 2012, Annals of Biomedical Engineering.

[19]  K. Markolf,et al.  Combined knee loading states that generate high anterior cruciate ligament forces , 1995, Journal of orthopaedic research : official publication of the Orthopaedic Research Society.

[20]  K. Markolf,et al.  Direct in vitro measurement of forces in the cruciate ligaments. Part I: The effect of multiplane loading in the intact knee. , 1993, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[21]  B. Sennett,et al.  Combined Anterior Cruciate Ligament and Medial Collateral Ligament Injuries in Adolescents , 2006, Journal of pediatric orthopedics.

[22]  T. Hewett,et al.  Noncontact anterior cruciate ligament injuries: risk factors and prevention strategies. , 2000, The Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons.

[23]  Scott G McLean,et al.  The relationship between anterior tibial acceleration, tibial slope, and ACL strain during a simulated jump landing task. , 2011, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[24]  Anthony I. Beutler,et al.  Comparing the Incidence of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury in Collegiate Lacrosse, Soccer, and Basketball Players , 2006, The American journal of sports medicine.

[25]  F. Noyes,et al.  Ligamentous and capsular restraints preventing straight medial and lateral laxity in intact human cadaver knees. , 1981, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[26]  F R Noyes,et al.  Plyometric Training in Female Athletes , 1996, The American journal of sports medicine.

[27]  K. Miyasaka The incidece of knee ligament injuries in the general population , 1991 .

[28]  Nick Caplan,et al.  Stiffness and Laxity of the Knee: The Contributions of the Supporting Structures: A Quantitative In Vitro Study , 2014 .

[29]  Antonie J van den Bogert,et al.  Investigating isolated neuromuscular control contributions to non-contact anterior cruciate ligament injury risk via computer simulation methods. , 2008, Clinical biomechanics.

[30]  Choongsoo S. Shin,et al.  Valgus plus internal rotation moments increase anterior cruciate ligament strain more than either alone. , 2011, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[31]  Y. Toyama,et al.  Coordination of the anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments in constraining the varus–valgus and internal–external rotatory instability of the knee , 2002, Journal of orthopaedic science : official journal of the Japanese Orthopaedic Association.

[32]  Troy Blackburn,et al.  Aggressive Quadriceps Loading Can Induce Noncontact Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury , 2004, The American journal of sports medicine.

[33]  T. Hewett,et al.  Clinically Relevant Injury Patterns After an Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury Provide Insight Into Injury Mechanisms , 2013, The American journal of sports medicine.

[34]  K. Spindler,et al.  Prospective study of osseous, articular, and meniscal lesions in recent anterior cruciate ligament tears by magnetic resonance imaging and arthroscopy , 1993, The American journal of sports medicine.

[35]  Lars Engebretsen,et al.  Injury Mechanisms for Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injuries in Team Handball , 2004, The American journal of sports medicine.

[36]  K. Markolf,et al.  In vivo knee stability. A quantitative assessment using an instrumented clinical testing apparatus. , 1978, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[37]  T. Hewett,et al.  A ‘Plane’ Explanation of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury Mechanisms , 2010, Sports medicine.

[38]  James A. Ashton-Miller,et al.  The Relationship between Quadriceps Muscle Force, Knee Flexion, and Anterior Cruciate Ligament Strain in an in Vitro Simulated Jump Landing , 2006, The American journal of sports medicine.

[39]  B. Seedhom,et al.  Roles of the anterior cruciate ligament and the medial collateral ligament in preventing valgus instability , 2001, Journal of orthopaedic science : official journal of the Japanese Orthopaedic Association.

[40]  Thomas P Andriacchi,et al.  The influence of deceleration forces on ACL strain during single-leg landing: a simulation study. , 2007, Journal of biomechanics.

[41]  Carmen E. Quatman,et al.  The anterior cruciate ligament injury controversy: is “valgus collapse” a sex-specific mechanism? , 2009, British Journal of Sports Medicine.

[42]  T. Krosshaug,et al.  Mechanisms for Noncontact Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injuries , 2010, The American journal of sports medicine.

[43]  T. Hewett,et al.  Mechanisms of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury in Basketball , 2007, The American journal of sports medicine.

[44]  R. Hawkins,et al.  Tension studies of human knee ligaments. Yield point, ultimate failure, and disruption of the cruciate and tibial collateral ligaments. , 1976, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[45]  B. Boden,et al.  Mechanisms of anterior cruciate ligament injury. , 2000, Orthopedics.

[46]  T. Sanders,et al.  Bone contusion patterns of the knee at MR imaging: footprint of the mechanism of injury. , 2000, Radiographics : a review publication of the Radiological Society of North America, Inc.

[47]  K. Shelbourne,et al.  The O'Donoghue triad revisited , 1991, The American journal of sports medicine.

[48]  C. Kaeding,et al.  Intra-articular findings in the reconstructed multiligament-injured knee. , 2005, Arthroscopy : the journal of arthroscopic & related surgery : official publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association.

[49]  Ata M. Kiapour,et al.  The Effect of Ligament Modeling Technique on Knee Joint Kinematics: A Finite Element Study , 2013, Applied mathematics.

[50]  K. Markolf,et al.  Direct measurement of resultant forces in the anterior cruciate ligament. An in vitro study performed with a new experimental technique. , 1990, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[51]  J. Agel,et al.  Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury in National Collegiate Athletic Association Basketball and Soccer: A 13-Year Review , 2005, The American journal of sports medicine.

[52]  J G Howe,et al.  Arthroscopic strain gauge measurement of the normal anterior cruciate ligament. , 1990, Arthroscopy : the journal of arthroscopic & related surgery : official publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association.

[53]  F. Noyes,et al.  Ligamentous restraints to anterior-posterior drawer in the human knee. A biomechanical study. , 1980, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.