Effects of Indirectly and Directly Competing Reference Group Messages and Persuasion Knowledge: Implications for Educational Placements

Educational placements increasingly appear to replace public service announcements as a means of communication, but their efficacy seems questionable because they contain mixed messages. Two experiments, conducted with 2850 adolescents, test versions of a real television program with an antismoking educational placement against a control program. Typical antismoking programs contain three indirectly competing messages: Smokers are attractive and prevalent but also worthy of disapproval. Experiment 1 tests several program versions with these three messages and reveals that the disapproval message dominates and elicits negative smoker thoughts and beliefs, despite the otherwise potent smoker attractiveness message. Experiment 2 indicates corresponding effects for intent but shows that adding a directly competitive smoker approval message nullifies this effect. Furthermore, Experiment 2 tests an educational epilogue designed to reinforce the disapproval message, but this message instead induces boomerang effects among smokers. That is, among smokers, an educational placement is counterattitudinal, so when the epilogue discloses the placement and evokes persuasion knowledge, smokers generate more positive smoker beliefs and intentions. These findings contribute to research regarding competing referent messages, disclosures, and persuasion knowledge.

[1]  R. Cialdini.  CURRENT DIRECTIONS IN PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE Crafting Normative Messages to Protect the Environment , 2022 .

[2]  C. Pechmann,et al.  The Impact of Regulatory Focus on Adolescents’ Response to Antismoking Advertising Campaigns , 2007 .

[3]  L. J. Shrum,et al.  The Role of Television in the Construction of Consumer Reality , 1997 .

[4]  William B. Hansen,et al.  Social Projection and Social Conformity in Adolescent Alcohol Use: A Longitudinal Analysis , 1992 .

[5]  Richard E. Petty,et al.  Elastic Shifts of Opinion: Determinants of Direction and Durability , 1976 .

[6]  V. Callan,et al.  Parent, peer and personal determinants of adolescent drinking. , 1989, British journal of addiction.

[7]  L. Johnston,et al.  Monitoring the Future national survey results on drug use, 1975-2019: Volume II, college students and adults ages 19-60 , 2000 .

[8]  Patrick M. O'Malley,et al.  Monitoring the Future National Results on Adolescent Drug Use: Overview of Key Findings, 2004. , 2003 .

[9]  J. Forster,et al.  Adolescent smoking behavior: measures of social norms. , 2003, American journal of preventive medicine.

[10]  Neil Vidmar,et al.  Archie Bunker's Bigotry: A Study in Selective Perception and Exposure , 1974 .

[11]  M. Goldberg,et al.  What to Convey in Antismoking Advertisements for Adolescents: The use of Protection Motivation Theory to Identify Effective Message Themes , 2003 .

[12]  W. Mcguire,et al.  The relative efficacy of various types of prior belief-defense in producing immunity against persuasion. , 1961, Journal of abnormal and social psychology.

[13]  Miguel Sabido,et al.  The Origins of Entertainment-Education , 2003 .

[14]  Carl A. Kallgren,et al.  A focus theory of normative conduct: Recycling the concept of norms to reduce littering in public places. , 1990 .

[15]  Claudia Lampert,et al.  Arvind Singhal / Michael J. Cody / Everett M. Rogers / Miguel Sabido (Hrsg.) (2004): Entertainment-Education and Social Change. History, Research, and Practice. Mahwah, NJ, London / Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 2004 , 2005 .

[16]  Eileen Fischer,et al.  An Examination of the Effects of Activating Persuasion Knowledge on Consumer Response to Brands Engaging in Covert Marketing , 2008 .

[17]  Betty J. Diener,et al.  The Frequency and Context of Alcohol and Tobacco Cues in Daytime Soap Opera Programs: Fall 1986 and Fall 1991 , 1993 .

[18]  J. Reis,et al.  Considerations for more effective social norms based alcohol education on campus: an analysis of different theoretical conceptualizations in predicting drinking among fraternity men. , 2003, Journal of studies on alcohol.

[19]  Peter Wright,et al.  Persuasion Knowledge , 2022 .

[20]  Robert B Cialdini.  Elastic Shifts of Opinion: Determinants of Direction and Durability , 1976 .

[21]  Sarah Moser,et al.  Entertainment-education and social change: History, research, and practice , 2004, Z. für Medienpsychologie.

[22]  W. Bearden,et al.  Correlates of conformity in the consumption of illicit drugs and alcohol , 1994 .

[23]  Cornelia Pechmann,et al.  An Experimental Investigation of the Joint Effects of Advertising and Peers on Adolescents' Beliefs and Intentions about Cigarette Consumption , 2002 .

[24]  Arnold B. Bakker,et al.  Extradyadic sex: The role of descriptive and injunctive norms , 1995 .

[25]  E. Rogers,et al.  Entertainment-Education: A Communication Strategy for Social Change , 1999 .

[26]  C. Pechmann,et al.  An assessment of US and Canadian smoking reduction objectives for the year 2000. , 1998, American journal of public health.

[27]  Darren W. Dahl,et al.  Deliberative and Automatic Bases of Suspicion: Empirical Evidence of the Sinister Attribution Error , 2007 .

[28]  K. Aune,et al.  Effects of a Daytime Serial and a Public Service Announcement in Promoting Cognitions, Attitudes, and Behaviors Related to Bone-Marrow Testing , 1994 .

[29]  Chuan-Fong Shih,et al.  Smoking Scenes in Movies and Antismoking Advertisements before Movies: Effects on Youth , 1999 .

[30]  S. Campo,et al.  Stepping Back from Social Norms Campaigns: Comparing Normative Influences to Other Predictors of Health Behaviors , 2006, Health communication.

[31]  J. Freedman,et al.  WARNING, DISTRACTION, AND RESISTANCE TO INFLUENCE. , 1965, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[32]  J. Grube,et al.  Nature and Impact of Alcohol Messages in a Youth-Oriented Television Series , 2009, Journal of advertising.

[33]  Alan G. Sawyer,et al.  Statistical Power and Effect Size in Marketing Research , 1981 .

[34]  R. Kirk.  Experimental Design: Procedures for the Behavioral Sciences , 1970 .

[35]  Albert Bandura,et al.  Social Cognitive Theory for Personal and Social Change by Enabling Media , 2003 .

[36]  Chester A. Insko,et al.  The Cognitive Mediation Hypothesis Revisited: An Empirical Response to Methodological and Theoretical Criticism , 1996 .

[37]  E. Gilpin,et al.  Validation of susceptibility as a predictor of which adolescents take up smoking in the United States. , 1996, Health psychology : official journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association.

[38]  Edward B. Royzman,et al.  Negativity Bias, Negativity Dominance, and Contagion , 2001 .

[39]  C. Russell.  Investigating the Effectiveness of Product Placements in Television Shows: The Role of Modality and Plot Connection Congruence on Brand Memory and Attitude , 2002 .

[40]  Robert B. Cialdini,et al.  The transsituational influence of social norms. , 1993 .

[41]  Richard Reardon,et al.  Forewarning of content and involvement: Consequences for persuasion and resistance to persuasion , 1992 .

[42]  V. Beck.  Working With Daytime and Prime-Time Television Shows in the United States to Promote Health , 2003 .

[43]  K. Mullen.  Smoking in Adolescence: Images and Identities , 2000, Journal of health psychology.

[44]  John T. Cacioppo,et al.  Effects of Forwarning of Persuasive Intent and Involvement on Cognitive Responses and Persuasion , 1979 .

[45]  E. Cowley,et al.  When Product Placement Goes Wrong: The Effects of Program Liking and Placement Prominence , 2008 .

[46]  C. Whan Park,et al.  Students and Housewives: Differences in Susceptibility to Reference Group Influence , 1977 .

[47]  Richard G. Netemeyer,et al.  Measurement of Consumer Susceptibility to Interpersonal Influence , 1989 .

[48]  W. Wood,et al.  Social Norms and Identity Relevance: A Motivational Approach to Normative Behavior , 2004 .

[49]  Amna Kirmani,et al.  Consumers' Use of Persuasion Knowledge: The Effects of Accessibility and Cognitive Capacity on Perceptions of an Influence Agent , 2000 .

[50]  K. Vohs,et al.  Case Western Reserve University , 1990 .

[51]  Wendy Wood,et al.  Forewarned and forearmed? Two meta-analytic syntheses of forewarnings of influence appeals. , 2003, Psychological bulletin.

[52]  Andrea C. Morales.  Giving Firms an “E” for Effort: Consumer Responses to High-Effort Firms , 2005 .