Hidden costs of a typical embodied energy analysis: Brazilian sugarcane ethanol as a case study.

Abstract Worldwide human production systems are tightly coupled to fossil-based energy, the source of which will not be available at low cost in the foreseeable future. Alternative energy sources are being sought for, among which those derived from biomass are considered to have great potential. Brazilian ethanol sugarcane produced at a large scale is being classified in scientific papers and politics as a renewable energy source. However, only the energy return on investment (EROI) and/or the amount of CO 2 released to atmosphere have been considered as indicators of renewability. This work aims to discuss some theoretical points, within an embodied energy analysis, that make its use inappropriate for answering all issues related to the concept of renewability. Emergy accounting (with an “m”) is used as a comparative tool and the Brazilian sugarcane ethanol is evaluated as case study. An EROI of 6.7 for ethanol was obtained, showing that for each unit of “commercial energy” invested within the process, 6.7 units of another kind of energy is obtained – this index shows an excellent value for energy efficiency, but it does not reflect the renewability of ethanol. On the other hand, emergy accounting shows a renewability index of 19%, indicating a low rating for sugarcane ethanol. All scientific methodologies available to assess potential energy sources have their pros and cons, but the analyst must be aware that each methodology supplies different indicators with different meanings. Energy analysts should use methodologies appropriately, avoiding wider conclusions not actually represented by indices calculated.

[1]  Sergio Ulgiati,et al.  Emergy and ecosystem complexity , 2009 .

[2]  R. O'Neill,et al.  The value of the world's ecosystem services and natural capital , 1997, Nature.

[3]  Torbjörn Rydberg,et al.  Emergy evaluation on the production, processing and export of coffee in Nicaragua , 2006 .

[4]  C. Cleveland.  Net energy from the extraction of oil and gas in the United States , 2005 .

[5]  Sergio Ulgiati,et al.  A Comprehensive Energy and Economic Assessment of Biofuels: When “Green” Is Not Enough , 2001 .

[6]  Thomas R. Dye,et al.  Power and Society , 2008 .

[7]  Sergio Ulgiati,et al.  Emergy Analysis and Environmental Accounting , 2004 .

[8]  G. Pillet.  Emternalities as counterpart to economic externalities ... , 2004 .

[9]  Amalia Zucaro,et al.  Material, energy and environmental performance of technological and social systems under a Life Cycle Assessment perspective , 2011 .

[10]  Silvia Bargigli,et al.  An emergy evaluation of complexity, information and technology, towards maximum power and zero emissions , 2007 .

[11]  J. Metzger,et al.  Brazilian law: full speed in reverse? , 2010, Science.

[12]  Charles Francis,et al.  Plan B 2.0: Rescuing a Planet under Stress and a Civilization in Trouble , 2006 .

[13]  Handan Akcaoz,et al.  ENERGY REQUIREMENT AND ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF CITRUS PRODUCTION IN TURKEY , 2004 .

[14]  Silvia Bargigli,et al.  Overcoming the inadequacy of single-criterion approaches to Life Cycle Assessment , 2006 .

[15]  A. A. Jensen.  Life cycle assessment (LCA) : a guide to approaches, experiences and information sources , 1998 .

[16]  David R. Tilley,et al.  Integrated energy, environmental and financial analysis of ethanol production from cellulosic switchgrass , 2009 .

[17]  Robert A. Herendeen,et al.  Energy analysis and EMERGY analysis—a comparison , 2004 .

[18]  B. Bakshi,et al.  Promise and problems of emergy analysis , 2004 .

[19]  C. Hall,et al.  Energy and the U.S. Economy: A Biophysical Perspective , 1984, Science.

[20]  Tadeusz W Patzek,et al.  Ethanol Production: Energy and Economic Issues Related to U.S. and Brazilian Sugarcane , 2007 .

[21]  Wim Turkenburg,et al.  The sustainability of Brazilian ethanol - an assessment of the possibilities of certified production , 2007 .

[22]  O. Edenhofer,et al.  Renewable energy sources and climate change mitigation : special report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change , 2011 .

[23]  Mark T. Brown,et al.  Updated evaluation of exergy and emergy driving the geobiosphere: A review and refinement of the emergy baseline , 2010 .

[24]  Fernando Galembeck,et al.  Synergy in food, fuels and materials production from biomass , 2010 .

[25]  O. Edenhofer.  Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitigation , 2011 .

[26]  Marcio Giannini Pereira,et al.  The renewable energy market in Brazil: Current status and potential , 2012 .

[27]  Enrico Sciubba,et al.  Emergy and exergy analyses: Complementary methods or irreducible ideological options? , 2005 .

[28]  Simone Bastianoni,et al.  The solar transformity of oil and petroleum natural gas , 2005 .

[29]  J. Seabra,et al.  Green house gases emissions in the production and use of ethanol from sugarcane in Brazil: the 2005/2006 averages and a prediction for 2020. , 2008 .

[30]  Fausto Freire,et al.  Renewability and life-cycle energy efficiency of bioethanol and bio-ethyl tertiary butyl ether (bioETBE): Assessing the implications of allocation , 2006 .

[31]  Simone P. Souza,et al.  Life cycle assessment of sugarcane ethanol and palm oil biodiesel joint production. , 2012 .

[32]  I. Boustead,et al.  Handbook of industrial energy analysis , 1979 .

[33]  Dirk Wascher,et al.  474 Ecosystems and Human Well-being : Current State and Trends , 2006 .

[34]  Mark T. Brown,et al.  A picture is worth a thousand words: energy systems language and simulation , 2004 .

[35]  J. Goldemberg,et al.  Are biofuels a feasible option , 2009 .

[36]  Howard T. Odum,et al.  Environment, Power, and Society , 1972 .

[37]  Anders Hammer Strømman,et al.  Influence of allocation methods on the environmental performance of biorefinery products—A case study , 2011 .

[38]  Enrique Ortega,et al.  The use of emergy assessment and the Geographical Information System in the diagnosis of small family farms in Brazil , 2008 .

[39]  Howard T. Odum,et al.  Environmental Accounting: Emergy and Environmental Decision Making , 1995 .

[40]  Enrique Ortega,et al.  Integrated food, energy and environmental services production as an alternative for small rural properties in Brazil , 2012 .

[41]  Luis Augusto Barbosa Cortez,et al.  Can Brazil replace 5% of the 2025 gasoline world demand with ethanol? , 2009 .

[42]  David Biello,et al.  The false promise of biofuels. , 2011, Scientific American.

[43]  Enrique Ortega,et al.  Integrated environmental assessment of biodiesel production from soybean in Brazil , 2010 .

[44]  J. Laherrère,et al.  The End of Cheap Oil , 1998 .

[45]  Mario Giampietro,et al.  Multi-scale integrated analysis of societal and ecosystem metabolism (MuSIASEM): Theoretical concepts and basic rationale , 2009 .

[46]  B. E. Vaughan,et al.  Ethanol as Fuel: Energy, Carbon Dioxide Balances, and Ecological Footprint , 2005 .

[47]  Mario Giampietro,et al.  Comments on “The Energetic Metabolism of the European Union and the United States” by Haberl and Colleagues: Theoretical and Practical Considerations on the Meaning and Usefulness of Traditional Energy Analysis , 2006 .

[48]  Tim Lang,et al.  Farm costs and food miles: an assessment of the full cost of the UK weekly food basket , 2005 .

[49]  Enrique Ortega,et al.  Sustainability assessment of large-scale ethanol production from sugarcane , 2010 .

[50]  Elisabeth C. Odum,et al.  Ecology and Economy: "Emergy" Analysis and Public Policy in Texas, PRP 78 , 1987 .

[51]  F. Agostinho,et al.  Sustainability of nations by indices: Comparative study between environmental sustainability index, ecological footprint and the emergy performance indices , 2008 .

[52]  O. Edenhofer,et al.  Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitigation , 2011 .

[53]  Janis Gravitis,et al.  Integration of biorefinery clusters towards zero emissions. , 2008 .

[54]  Luis Augusto Barbosa Cortez,et al.  The Brazilian sugarcane innovation system , 2011 .

[55]  Sergio Ulgiati,et al.  Sustainable biomass production: A comparison between Gross Energy Requirement and Emergy Synthesis methods , 2009 .

[56]  H. Odum,et al.  Self-Organization, Transformity, and Information , 1988, Science.

[57]  Shu-li Huang,et al.  Theory of urban energetics and mechanisms of urban development , 2005 .

[58]  Jack Santa Barbara,et al.  the false promise of , 2007 .

[59]  P. Nilsson.  Environmental Accounting—EMERGY and Environmental Decision Making , 1997, Forest Science.

[60]  Enrique Ortega,et al.  Assessment of a large watershed in Brazil using Emergy Evaluation and Geographical Information System , 2010 .

[61]  Charles A. S. Hall,et al.  What is the Minimum EROI that a Sustainable Society Must Have , 2009 .

[62]  Wesley W. Ingwersen,et al.  Uncertainty characterization for emergy values , 2010 .