Composing Software from Multiple Concerns : Composability and Composition Anomalies

It is generally acknowledged that separation of concerns is a key requirement for effective software engineering: it helps in managing the complexity of software and supports the maintainability of a software system. Separation of concerns makes only sense if the realizations in software of these concerns can be composed together effectively into a working program. The ability to compose systems from independently developed components that can be adapted and extended easily is a long-standing goal in the software engineering discipline. However, both research and practice have shown that composability of software is far from trivial and fails repeatedly. Typically this occurs when components exhibit complex behavior, in particular when multiple concerns are involved in a single component. We believe that, to address the composability problems, we need a better understanding of the requirements involved in successful composition, and in addition define the situations where composition fails. To this aim, in this paper we (a) introduce a general model of composing systems from multiple concerns, (b) introduce a number of requirements for design-level composability and (c) define a category of composability problems that are inherent for given composition models, which we term as composition anomalies.