Quantifying sustainable intensification of agriculture: The contribution of metrics and modelling

Abstract Sustainable intensification (SI) of agriculture is a promising strategy for boosting the capacity of the agricultural sector to meet the growing demands for food and non-food products and services in a sustainable manner. Assessing and quantifying the options for SI remains a challenge due to its multiple dimensions and potential associated trade-offs. We contribute to overcoming this challenge by proposing an approach for the ex-ante evaluation of SI options and trade-offs to facilitate decision making in relation to SI. This approach is based on the utilization of a newly developed SI metrics framework (SIMeF) combined with agricultural systems modelling. We present SIMeF and its operationalization approach with modelling and evaluate the approach’s feasibility by assessing to what extent the SIMeF metrics can be quantified by representative agricultural systems models. SIMeF is based on the integration of academic and policy indicator frameworks, expert opinions, as well as the Sustainable Development Goals. Structured along seven SI domains and consisting of 37 themes, 142 sub-themes and 1128 metrics, it offers a holistic, generic, and policy-relevant dashboard for selecting the SI metrics to be quantified for the assessment of SI options in diverse contexts. The use of SIMeF with agricultural systems modelling allows the ex-ante assessment of SI options with respect to their productivity, resource use efficiency, environmental sustainability and, to a large extent, economic sustainability. However, we identify limitations to the use of modelling to represent several SI aspects related to social sustainability, certain ecological functions, the multi-functionality of agriculture, the management of losses and waste, and security and resilience. We suggest advancements in agricultural systems models and greater interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary integration to improve the ability to quantify SI metrics and to assess trade-offs across the various dimensions of SI.

[1]  Chris Murphy,et al.  APSIM - Evolution towards a new generation of agricultural systems simulation , 2014, Environ. Model. Softw..

[2]  J. Geleijnse,et al.  Assessing Sustainable Food and Nutrition Security of the EU Food System—An Integrated Approach , 2018, Sustainability.

[3]  Frank Ewert,et al.  Crop modelling for integrated assessment of risk to food production from climate change , 2015, Environ. Model. Softw..

[4]  W. Parton,et al.  Agricultural intensification and ecosystem properties. , 1997, Science.

[5]  David Morley,et al.  Rural development and challenges establishing sustainable land use in Eastern European countries , 2013 .

[6]  J. Pretty,et al.  Sustainable intensification in African agriculture , 2011 .

[7]  C. A. van Diepen,et al.  User's guide for the WOFOST 7.1 crop growth simulation model and WOFOST Control Center 1.5. , 1998 .

[8]  Eoin White,et al.  An environmental analysis of options for utilising wasted food and food residue. , 2016, Journal of environmental management.

[9]  W. Mirschel,et al.  The MONICA model: Testing predictability for crop growth, soil moisture and nitrogen dynamics , 2011 .

[10]  M. Donatelli,et al.  Integrated assessment of agricultural systems: a component - based framework for the European Union (Seamless) , 2008 .

[11]  M. Ittersum,et al.  On the development and use of farm models for policy impact assessment in the European Union – A review , 2018 .

[12]  Buckwell,et al.  The Sustainable Intensification of European Agriculture. , 2014 .

[13]  Rob Knapen,et al.  A goal oriented indicator framework to support integrated assessment of new policies for agri-environmental systems. , 2009 .

[14]  S. Robinson,et al.  Global and regional health effects of future food production under climate change: a modelling study , 2016, The Lancet.

[15]  M. Ittersum,et al.  Assessing the impact of the Nitrate Directive on farming systems using a bio-economic modelling chain , 2011 .

[16]  Carol X. Song,et al.  Global Gridded Crop Model evaluation: benchmarking, skills, deficiencies and implications , 2016 .

[17]  N. Ramankutty,et al.  Closing yield gaps through nutrient and water management , 2012, Nature.

[18]  C. Müller,et al.  Climate‐driven simulation of global crop sowing dates , 2012 .

[19]  I. Bateman,et al.  Sustainable Intensification in Agriculture: Premises and Policies , 2013, Science.

[20]  R. Moss,et al.  Ecosystems and human well-being: a framework for assessment , 2003 .

[21]  G. Lair,et al.  Indicators for the definition of land quality as a basis for the sustainable intensification of agricultural production , 2015, International Soil and Water Conservation Research.

[22]  Esther S. Parish,et al.  Engaging stakeholders to assess landscape sustainability , 2019, Landscape Ecology.

[23]  John M. Antle,et al.  Evaluating agricultural trade-offs in the age of sustainable development , 2016, Agricultural Systems.

[24]  Tommy Dalgaard,et al.  A model for simulating the timelines of field operations at a European scale for use in complex dynamic models , 2012 .

[25]  Peter D. Kemp,et al.  Hatching new ideas about herb pastures: Learning together in a community of New Zealand farmers and agricultural scientists , 2014 .

[26]  The blurred boundaries of ecological, sustainable, and agroecological intensification: a review , 2015, Agronomy for Sustainable Development.

[27]  Argyris Kanellopoulos,et al.  Climate change impact and adaptation research requires integrated assessment and farming systems analysis: a case study in the Netherlands , 2015 .

[28]  Marco Bindi,et al.  Physical robustness of canopy temperature models for crop heat stress simulation across environments and production conditions. , 2018 .

[29]  Rudolf de Groot,et al.  A conceptual framework for selecting environmental indicator sets , 2008 .

[30]  D. Jackson‐Smith.  Toward Sustainable Agricultural Systems in the 21st Century , 2010 .

[31]  D. Tilman,et al.  Global food demand and the sustainable intensification of agriculture , 2011, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[32]  W. Sutherland,et al.  Reaping the Benefits: Science and the sustainable intensification of global agriculture , 2009 .

[33]  M. Trnka,et al.  Implications of crop model ensemble size and composition for estimates of adaptation effects and agreement of recommendations , 2019, Agricultural and forest meteorology.

[34]  K. L. Zimmermann,et al.  Metrics, models and foresight for European sustainable food and nutrition security: The vision of the SUSFANS project , 2016, Agricultural Systems.

[35]  Dominic Moran,et al.  Modelling Common Agricultural Policy-Water Framework Directive interactions and cost-effectiveness of measures to reduce nitrogen pollution. , 2010, Water science and technology : a journal of the International Association on Water Pollution Research.

[36]  F. Areal,et al.  Evaluating the Sustainable Intensification of arable farms. , 2015, Journal of environmental management.

[37]  S. Rolinski,et al.  Large-scale bioenergy production: how to resolve sustainability trade-offs? , 2018 .

[38]  T. Palosuo,et al.  Production of cereals in northern marginal areas: An integrated assessment of climate change impacts at the farm level. , 2018 .

[39]  C. Müller,et al.  Modelling cropping periods of grain crops at the global scale , 2019, Global and Planetary Change.

[40]  G. Bélanger,et al.  Timothy Yield and Nutritive Value by the CATIMO Model , 2002 .

[41]  T. Reeves,et al.  Sustainable intensification of agriculture , 1998 .

[42]  M. Vanclooster,et al.  SAFE - A hierarchical framework for assessing the sustainability of agricultural systems , 2007 .

[43]  L. Firbank,et al.  How scalable is sustainable intensification? , 2016, Nature Plants.

[44]  Reimund P. Rötter,et al.  Adaptation response surfaces for managing wheat under perturbed climate and CO2 in a Mediterranean environment , 2018 .

[45]  Mark Harvey,et al.  The new competition for land: Food, energy, and climate change , 2011 .

[46]  A. Agrawal,et al.  Bridging the practitioner-researcher divide: Indicators to track environmental, economic, and sociocultural sustainability of agricultural commodity production , 2017 .

[47]  L. Scherer,et al.  Conceptualising fields of action for sustainable intensification – A systematic literature review and application to regional case studies , 2018 .

[48]  John M. Antle,et al.  Biophysical and economic implications for agriculture of +1.5° and +2.0°C global warming using AgMIP Coordinated Global and Regional Assessments , 2018, Climate research.

[49]  Zhenhong Lin,et al.  Improving the behavioral realism of global integrated assessment models: An application to consumers’ vehicle choices , 2017 .

[50]  C. Müller,et al.  LPJmL4 – a dynamic global vegetation model with managed land – Part 1: Model description , 2017 .

[51]  S. Carpenter,et al.  Solutions for a cultivated planet , 2011, Nature.

[52]  James W. Jones,et al.  Multimodel ensembles of wheat growth: many models are better than one , 2015, Global change biology.

[53]  Thomas Heckelei,et al.  Multi-scale resilience of a communal rangeland system in South Africa , 2017 .

[54]  J. W. Thomas,et al.  Ecological Uses of Vertebrate Indicator Species: A Critique , 1988 .

[55]  Les G. Firbank,et al.  Evidence of sustainable intensification among British farms , 2013 .

[56]  J. Pretty,et al.  Sustainable intensification in agricultural systems. , 2014, Annals of botany.

[57]  S. Snapp,et al.  What is sustainable intensification? Views from experts , 2015 .

[58]  H. Lotze-Campen,et al.  MAgPIE 4 – A modular open source framework for modeling global land-systems , 2018 .

[59]  Thomas Heckelei,et al.  Cooperation and collapse in a communal livestock production SES model - A case from South Africa , 2016, Environ. Model. Softw..

[60]  Muhammad Muinul Islam,et al.  Towards a broad-based and holistic framework of Sustainable Intensification indicators , 2018, Land Use Policy.

[61]  Andrew Barnes,et al.  Measuring progress towards sustainable intensification: How far can secondary data go? , 2014 .

[62]  P. Struik,et al.  Measuring agricultural sustainability in terms of efficiency: the case of Dutch sugar beet growers. , 2002, Journal of environmental management.

[63]  Is There Sustainability in “Sustainable Intensification”? , 2014 .

[64]  D. Raes,et al.  AquaCrop-The FAO Crop Model to Simulate Yield Response to Water: I. Concepts and Underlying Principles , 2009 .

[65]  J. Hanspach,et al.  Frontiers inEcology and the Environment Putting meaning back into “ sustainable intensification ” , 2014 .

[66]  H. Lehtonen,et al.  Impacts of agri-environmental policy on land use and nitrogen leaching in Finland , 2015 .

[67]  R. Joyce,et al.  1 Mesoamerica : A Working Model for Archaeology , 2003 .

[68]  James W. Jones,et al.  The DSSAT cropping system model , 2003 .

[69]  Timothy D. Aldred,et al.  Biodiversity quality: A paradigm for biodiversity , 2009 .

[70]  Thomas Heckelei,et al.  A methodology for enhanced flexibility of integrated assessment in agriculture , 2009 .

[71]  Reimund P. Rötter,et al.  Lessons from climate modeling on the design and use of ensembles for crop modeling , 2016, Climatic Change.

[72]  Ross M. Monaghan,et al.  A Bayesian Belief Network approach to evaluating complex effects of irrigation-driven agricultural intensification scenarios on future aquatic environmental and economic values in a New Zealand catchment , 2013 .

[73]  T. Hertel,et al.  Understanding the Spatial Distribution of Welfare Impacts of Global Warming on Agriculture and its Drivers , 2019, American Journal of Agricultural Economics.

[74]  T. Carter,et al.  Crop-climate models need an overhaul , 2011 .

[75]  Megan Clark,et al.  Achieving food security in the face of climate change: final report from the Commission on Sustainable Agriculture and Climate Change , 2012 .

[76]  S. J. Beddington,et al.  The Future of Food and Farming , 2001 .

[77]  C. Barrett,et al.  Policy Reforms and Sustainable Agricultural Intensification in Africa , 1999 .

[78]  F. van der Hilst,et al.  Sustainable intensification of crop residue exploitation for bioenergy: Opportunities and challenges , 2019, Global change biology. Bioenergy.

[79]  P. Tittonell.  Ecological intensification of agriculture — sustainable by nature , 2014 .

[80]  D. Gibbon.  Save and Grow: A Policymaker's Guide to the Sustainable Intensification of Smallholder Crop Production . Rome, Italy: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (2011), pp. 112, US$45.00. ISBN 978-92-5-106871-7. , 2011, Experimental Agriculture.

[81]  F. Wagner,et al.  Economic impacts of EU clean air policies assessed in a CGE framework , 2016 .

[82]  Thomas Gaiser,et al.  Modeling biopore effects on root growth and biomass production on soils with pronounced sub-soil clay accumulation , 2013 .

[83]  M. Rounsevell,et al.  Modelling farmer decision-making to anticipate tradeoffs between provisioning ecosystem services and biodiversity , 2015 .

[84]  J. Franks.  Sustainable intensification: A UK perspective , 2014 .

[85]  Regis Chikowo,et al.  Measuring sustainable intensification in smallholder agroecosystems: A review , 2017 .

[86]  H. Godfray,et al.  Sustainable intensification in agriculture. Navigating a course through competing food system priorities , 2012 .

[87]  P. Pinstrup-Andersen,et al.  Food security: definition and measurement , 2009, Food Security.

[88]  G. Daily,et al.  Sustainable intensification of agriculture for human prosperity and global sustainability , 2016, Ambio.

[89]  Miranda P.M. Meuwissen,et al.  Why we need resilience thinking to meet societal challenges in bio-based production systems , 2016 .

[90]  J. Minx,et al.  Analysing interactions among Sustainable Development Goals with Integrated Assessment Models , 2019, Global Transitions.

[91]  H. Godfray,et al.  Food security and sustainable intensification , 2014, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[92]  Dominic Moran,et al.  Mapping public participation in the Water Framework Directive: A case study of the Pinios River Basin, Greece , 2007 .

[93]  P. Kyle,et al.  Land-use futures in the shared socio-economic pathways , 2017 .

[94]  Marco Bindi,et al.  Diverging importance of drought stress for maize and winter wheat in Europe , 2018, Nature Communications.