Interplay of sketching & prototyping in early stage product design

Abstract Research suggests that, for the design of simple mechanisms, sketching and prototyping are somewhat interchangeable in terms of their influence on idea quantity and quality. This study explores whether this interchangeability holds true for a consumer product design activity. Three conditions are compared: sketching only, prototyping only, and free prototyping & sketching. Eighteen novice designers participated in a one-hour individual design activity. Their resulting design ideas were evaluated by both design experts and potential users. A design evaluation metric, idea distance, is proposed to measure the breadth and depth of design space exploration. Results showed that individuals who only sketched, on average, generated more ideas, explored broader design space, and had more novel final designs. However, participants who were allowed to both sketch and build prototypes explored the design space in more depth and tended to have final ideas that were perceived as more creative. Individuals who only prototyped generated designs that were perceived to be aesthetically more pleasing and performed better functionally. Exploring broader design space was found to correlate with more unique ideas. However, exploring too broad a design space reduced the depth of idea exploration, and was negatively linked to the functional performance of the final designs.

[1]  Rosario Vidal,et al.  Effectiveness of the means of expression in creative problem-solving in design groups , 2004 .

[2]  Julie S. Linsey,et al.  Physical Models and Design Thinking: A Study of Functionality, Novelty and Variety of Ideas. , 2012 .

[3]  Erik Kaestner,et al.  The Mechanical Design Process , 2016 .

[4]  Teresa M. Amabile,et al.  Assessing the Work Environment for Creativity , 1996 .

[5]  G. Goldschmidt.  The dialectics of sketching , 1991 .

[6]  Alice M. Agogino,et al.  Insights on Designers’ Sketching Activities in New Product Design Teams , 2004 .

[7]  Aniket Kittur,et al.  Crowdsourcing user studies with Mechanical Turk , 2008, CHI.

[8]  Julie S. Linsey,et al.  Role of Sunk Cost in Engineering Idea Generation: An Experimental Investigation , 2013 .

[9]  Elizabeth M. Starkey,et al.  Abandoning creativity: The evolution of creative ideas in engineering design course projects , 2016 .

[10]  Karl T. Ulrich,et al.  Idea Generation and the Quality of the Best Idea , 2009, Manag. Sci..

[11]  Anne Römer,et al.  Support value of sketching in the design process , 2003 .

[12]  David Craig,et al.  The importance of drawing in the mechanical design process , 1990, Comput. Graph..

[13]  Maria C. Yang,et al.  Observations on concept generation and sketching in engineering design , 2009 .

[14]  Randy F. Pausch,et al.  Generating 3D interaction techniques by identifying and breaking assumptions , 2006, Virtual Reality.

[15]  G. S. Alʹtshuller,et al.  The Innovation Algorithm:TRIZ, systematic innovation and technical creativity , 1999 .

[16]  L. Cronbach.  Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests , 1951 .

[17]  Irem Y. Tumer,et al.  The Potential of Creativity Metrics for Mechanical Engineering Concept Design , 2009 .

[18]  Remko van der Lugt,et al.  How sketching can affect the idea generation process in design group meetings , 2005 .

[19]  Hideyoshi Yanagisawa,et al.  Perception of Aesthetics in Consumer Products , 2013 .

[20]  Mel Yamamoto,et al.  The impact of product aesthetics on the evaluation of industrial products , 1994 .

[21]  Masaki Suwa,et al.  What do architects and students perceive in their design sketches? A protocol analysis , 1997 .

[22]  John S. Gero,et al.  To sketch or not to sketch? That is the question , 2006 .

[23]  Arthur B. Markman,et al.  Design by Analogy: A Study of the WordTree Method for Problem Re-Representation , 2012 .

[24]  Scarlett R. Miller,et al.  Choosing creativity: the role of individual risk and ambiguity aversion on creative concept selection in engineering design , 2016, Research in Engineering Design.

[25]  V. Goel.  Sketches of thought , 1995 .

[26]  Imre Horváth,et al.  Testing shape manipulation tools using abstract prototypes , 1998 .

[27]  Maria C. Yang,et al.  Connections Between the Design Tool, Design Attributes, and User Preferences in Early Stage Design , 2015 .

[28]  Eugene S. Ferguson,et al.  Engineering and the Mind's Eye , 1994 .

[29]  Donald A. Schön.  Designing as reflective conversation with the materials of a design situation , 1992, Knowl. Based Syst..

[30]  Maria C. Yang,et al.  A study of prototypes, design activity, and design outcome , 2005 .

[31]  Karl T. Ulrich,et al.  Product Design and Development , 1995 .

[32]  Kristin L. Wood,et al.  A Quantitative Similarity Metric for Design-by-Analogy , 2002 .

[33]  Jonathan Cagan,et al.  The Meaning of “Near” and “Far”: The Impact of Structuring Design Databases and the Effect of Distance of Analogy on Design Output , 2012 .

[34]  Steven M. Smith,et al.  Metrics for measuring ideation effectiveness , 2003 .

[35]  David H. Cropley,et al.  Engineering Creativity: A Systems Concept of Functional Creativity , 2005 .

[36]  John Baer,et al.  A Comparison of Expert and Nonexpert Raters Using the Consensual Assessment Technique , 2008 .

[37]  W. Kruskal,et al.  Use of Ranks in One-Criterion Variance Analysis , 1952 .

[38]  Low,et al.  PRELIMINARY SKETCHING AND PROTOTYPING: COMPARISONS IN EXPLORATORY DESIGN-AND-BUILD ACTIVITIES , 2014 .

[39]  E. Gerber,et al.  The psychological experience of prototyping , 2012 .

[40]  John Baer,et al.  Extension of the Consensual Assessment Technique to Nonparallel Creative Products , 2004 .

[41]  Donald A. Schön,et al.  Kinds of seeing and their functions in designing , 1992 .

[42]  Siddharth Suri,et al.  Conducting behavioral research on Amazon’s Mechanical Turk , 2010, Behavior research methods.

[43]  Douglas L. Dean,et al.  Identifying Good Ideas: Constructs and Scales for Idea Evaluation , 2006 .

[44]  Michael Schrage,et al.  The Culture(s) of PROTOTYPING , 2010 .

[45]  G. Goldschmidt,et al.  How good are good ideas? Correlates of design creativity , 2005 .

[46]  Rivka Oxman,et al.  Materializing design: the implications of rapid prototyping in digital design , 2006 .

[47]  T. M. Amabile.  Social psychology of creativity: A consensual assessment technique. , 1982 .

[48]  G. R. Oldham,et al.  The curvilinear relation between experienced creative time pressure and creativity: moderating effects of openness to experience and support for creativity. , 2006, The Journal of applied psychology.

[49]  Klaus Krippendorff,et al.  Content Analysis: An Introduction to Its Methodology , 1980 .

[50]  Gabriela Goldschmidt,et al.  On visual design thinking: the vis kids of architecture , 1994 .

[51]  Yang Maria,et al.  Interplay Of Sketching & Prototyping In Early Stage Product Design , 2016 .

[52]  Teresa M. Amabile,et al.  Creativity under the gun. , 2002, Harvard business review.

[53]  Maria C. Yang,et al.  Building Fast to Think Faster: Exploiting Rapid Prototyping to Accelerate Ideation During Early Stage Design , 2013 .

[54]  M. Runco,et al.  The Standard Definition of Creativity , 2012 .

[55]  Arthur B. Markman,et al.  An Experimental Study of Group Idea Generation Techniques: Understanding the Roles of Idea Representation and Viewing Methods , 2011 .

[56]  Charles Hill,et al.  What do Prototypes Prototype , 1997 .