Comparative Evaluation of Three River Water Quality Models 1

Selection of a biochemical oxygen demand (BOD) reaction model to incorporate into dissolved oxygen (DO) water quality models is an overlooked choice available to river water quality modelers. Data from rivers can serve in screening methods to discriminate between competing water quality models. In this study, 15 published BOD and DO datasets based on a 7 year long study of the Bormida River in Italy are used to calibrate three-multiorder BOD models: first-order, three-halves order, and second-order, which are then included in three corresponding DO models which incorporate these BOD models. The adequacy of the first-order, three-halves order and second-order BOD models was evaluated by calculating the root mean square error between a model and data. A similar procedure was followed to evaluate three DO models, each of which incorporated one of the three BOD models. The first-order BOD model most frequently fit the river data best, followed by the three-halves order and the second-order BOD models. The DO model incorporating a first-order BOD model most frequently fit the data best, followed by the DO order incorporating second-order BOD and the DO model incorporating three-halves order BOD.