Large animal-vehicle collisions in the Central Canadian Rocky Mountains: patterns and characteristics

The trends of increasing traffic volumes and road densities will only magnify the already adverse effects roads have on large mammals and other vertebrates. Development of practical highway mitigation will rely on an understanding of patterns and processes that result from highway accidents, which involve elk Cervus elaphus and other large animals. This paper specifically address three areas relating to the patterns and characteristics of large-animal vehicle collisions on different road-types in the Central Canadian Rocky Mountains. First, it investigates the spatial error associated with reported wildlife-vehicle collisions (WVCs). Second, it looks at the demographic and temporal patterns of elk and wildlife-vehicle collisions on different road-types. Finally, the type of vehicles involved in WVCs and what conditions contribute to injury-related accidents are investigated. The paper found that the average reporting error from park wardens, highway maintenance contractors and from Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) data ranged from 300m-2000m. The sex ratio of elk-vehicle collisions (EVCs) was significantly different from that found in the population, and highly skewed towards greater male mortality during the 15-year period. The age ratio of EVCs was highly skewed towards greater subadult mortality. No difference in marrow fat content between highway and railway killed elk were found, but both had higher fat content than predator-killed elk. EVCs were significantly higher on the Trans-Canada Highway (TCH) in the province, which had the highest traffic volumes. The TCH in Banff National Park (BNP) had a significantly higher rate of EVCs than the secondary highway (93S) in Kootenay National Park. EVCs declined over time on the unmitigated section of TCH in BNP and on highway 93S, even though traffic volumes were increasing. The paper found that local elk abundance was decreasing and was the driving force in EVC rates; however, traffic volume determined the rate of EVCs on different road types. WVCs occur more often than expected at dusk and night periods and on weekends. Injury-related WVCs are more likely to occur in dry conditions than in slush, snow or icy conditions. Injury-related WVCs are more likely to occur with smaller vehicles than in larger vehicles. Further, larger vehicles were involved in more WVCs than expected on two of our road-types. In conclusion, spatial road-kill data can aid in determining location of mitigation measures, e.g., wildlife signage and crossing structures. Patterns of WVCs can be valuable in devising mitigation based on specific hour of day or season when collision frequencies are highest, and what individuals within a population are most susceptible to road-kills. Factors contributing to WVCs, such as traffic volumes and elk abundance, can help managers predict long-term viability of wildlife populations with incurring road mortality.