Analytical decision model for the cost-effective management of solitary pulmonary nodules.

PURPOSE AND METHODS Multiple strategies are currently being used to manage patients who present with indeterminate solitary pulmonary nodules (SPN). We have used decision-analysis models to assess the cost-effectiveness of various strategies for the diagnosis and management of SPN. Four decision strategies were compared: a wait and watch strategy, a surgery strategy, a computed tomography (CT)-based strategy, and a CT-plus-positron emission tomography (PET) strategy. An incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was used to compare all strategies to the wait and watch strategy. RESULTS A CT-plus-PET strategy was the most cost-effective over a large pretest likelihood (probability of having a malignant nodule), with a range of 0.12 to 0.69. Furthermore, within this likelihood range, the potential cost savings of using the CT-plus-PET strategy over the CT strategy ranged from $91 to $2,200 per patient. This translates to a yearly national savings of approximately $62.7 million. CONCLUSION Decision-analysis modeling indicates the potential cost-effectiveness of [18F]2-fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose (FDG)-PET in the management of SPN. Furthermore, the decision trees developed can be used to model various features of the management of SPN, including modeling the cost-effectiveness of other newly emerging technologies.

[1]  R. Harris,et al.  The diagnostic and therapeutic utility of thoracoscopy. A review. , 1995, Chest.

[2]  S. Hazelrigg,et al.  Video Assisted Thoracic Surgery Study Group data. , 1993, The Annals of thoracic surgery.

[3]  Ko-pen Wang,et al.  Staging of bronchogenic carcinoma by bronchoscopy. , 1994, Chest.

[4]  G. Weber.  Enzymology of cancer cells (first of two parts). , 1977, The New England journal of medicine.

[5]  MD@: a physician-friendly decision analysis tool. , 1998, M.D. computing : computers in medical practice.

[6]  Flemming Mc,et al.  Computed tomography of pulmonary nodule using a standard reference chest phantom. , 1988 .

[7]  G. Lillington,et al.  Management of solitary pulmonary nodules. , 1991, Disease-a-month : DM.

[8]  S. Hessel,et al.  The diagnostic accuracy and complications of closed lung biopsies. , 1977, Radiology.

[9]  D. Hansell,et al.  The value of negative needle biopsy in suspected operable lung cancer. , 1991, Clinical radiology.

[10]  N. Milman,et al.  Percutaneous transthoracic fine-needle lung biopsy with 3 different needles. A retrospective study of results and complications in 224 patients. , 1993, Respiration; international review of thoracic diseases.

[11]  D Blume,et al.  Pulmonary nodule: evaluation with spiral volumetric CT. , 1991, Radiology.

[12]  R. Coleman,et al.  Focal pulmonary abnormalities: evaluation with F-18 fluorodeoxyglucose PET scanning. , 1993, Radiology.

[13]  D. Fryback,et al.  Screening for Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm in Men Ages 60 to 80 Years: A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis , 1993, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[14]  J. H. Montgomery,et al.  Mediastinal needle biopsy. , 1984, AJR. American journal of roentgenology.

[15]  V J Lowe,et al.  Detection of primary and recurrent lung cancer by means of F-18 fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography (FDG PET). , 1995, The Journal of thoracic and cardiovascular surgery.

[16]  J S Fowler,et al.  A FLUORINATED GLUCOSE ANALOG, 2‐FLUORO-2‐DEOXY-D‐GLUCOSE (F‐18): NONTOXIC TRACER FOR RAPID TUMOR DETECTION , 1980, Journal of nuclear medicine : official publication, Society of Nuclear Medicine.

[17]  L. Santambrogio,et al.  Videothoracoscopy versus thoracotomy for the diagnosis of the indeterminate solitary pulmonary nodule. , 1995, The Annals of thoracic surgery.

[18]  M. Weinstein,et al.  Clinical Decision Analysis , 1980 .

[19]  E A Zerhouni,et al.  A standard phantom for quantitative CT analysis of pulmonary nodules. , 1983, Radiology.

[20]  N. Müller,et al.  Solitary pulmonary nodule: high-resolution CT and radiologic-pathologic correlation. , 1991, Radiology.

[21]  J D Habbema,et al.  Analysing clinical decision analyses. , 1990, Statistics in medicine.

[22]  E A Zerhouni,et al.  CT of the solitary pulmonary nodule. , 1980, AJR. American journal of roentgenology.

[23]  M. Phelps,et al.  Applications of Positron Emission Tomography (PET) in Tumor Management , 1988 .

[24]  S J Swensen,et al.  Lung nodule enhancement at CT: prospective findings. , 1996, Radiology.

[25]  E. Buonocore,et al.  Characterization of Chest Masses by FDG Positron Emission Tomography , 1995, Clinical nuclear medicine.

[26]  S. Cummings,et al.  Managing solitary pulmonary nodules. The choice of strategy is a "close call". , 1986, The American review of respiratory disease.

[27]  Lillington Ga,et al.  Evaluation and management of solitary and multiple pulmonary nodules , 1993 .

[28]  J. Stoller,et al.  Computerized tomographic densitometry of the solitary pulmonary nodule using a nodule phantom. , 1989, Chest.

[29]  S S Sagel,et al.  CT of the pulmonary nodule: a cooperative study. , 1986, Radiology.

[30]  O. Warburg.  [Origin of cancer cells]. , 1956, Oncologia.

[31]  D. Rappaport,et al.  The solitary pulmonary nodule. Is it malignant or benign? , 1996, Postgraduate medicine.

[32]  S. Schabel,et al.  Lung lesions: cytologic diagnosis by fine-needle biopsy. , 1987, Radiology.

[33]  R Iwata,et al.  Differential diagnosis of lung tumor with positron emission tomography: a prospective study. , 1990, Journal of nuclear medicine : official publication, Society of Nuclear Medicine.

[34]  A S Detsky,et al.  Cost and Health Implications of Cholesterol Lowering , 1992, Circulation.

[35]  A. Steinbach,et al.  The role of staging bronchoscopy in the preoperative assessment of a solitary pulmonary nodule. , 1993, Chest.

[36]  E. Rosenow,et al.  Evaluation and management of solitary and multiple pulmonary nodules. , 1992, Clinics in chest medicine.

[37]  Jackson Cb,et al.  Physicians' Current Procedural Terminology. , 1973 .

[38]  J. Remy,et al.  Pulmonary nodules: detection with thick-section spiral CT versus conventional CT. , 1993, Radiology.

[39]  S J Swensen,et al.  Solitary pulmonary nodule: CT evaluation of enhancement with iodinated contrast material--a preliminary report. , 1992, Radiology.

[40]  S. Swensen,et al.  An integrated approach to evaluation of the solitary pulmonary nodule. , 1990, Mayo Clinic proceedings.

[41]  M P Frick,et al.  Diagnostic efficacy of PET-FDG imaging in solitary pulmonary nodules. Potential role in evaluation and management. , 1993, Chest.

[42]  B. Hillner,et al.  Efficacy and cost-effectiveness of cancer treatment: rational allocation of resources based on decision analysis. , 1993, Journal of the National Cancer Institute.

[43]  L. Tao,et al.  Percutaneous fine-needle aspiration biopsy of mediastinal lesions. , 1984, AJR. American journal of roentgenology.

[44]  E. Gunel,et al.  Probability of malignancy in solitary pulmonary nodules using fluorine-18-FDG and PET. , 1996, Journal of nuclear medicine : official publication, Society of Nuclear Medicine.

[45]  F. García-Río,et al.  Use of spirometry to predict risk of pneumothorax in CT-guided needle biopsy of the lung. , 1996, Journal of computer assisted tomography.

[46]  E. Fishman,et al.  Solitary pulmonary nodules: CT assessment. , 1986, Radiology.

[47]  E. Kazerooni,et al.  Dual kV CT to Detect Calcification in Solitary Pulmonary Nodule , 1995, Journal of computer assisted tomography.

[48]  J. R. Muhm,et al.  Solitary pulmonary nodules: evaluation with a CT reference phantom. , 1989, Radiology.

[49]  D. Cavouras,et al.  Image analysis methods for solitary pulmonary nodule characterization by computed tomography. , 1992, European journal of radiology.

[50]  K. Torrington,et al.  The utility of fiberoptic bronchoscopy in the evaluation of the solitary pulmonary nodule. , 1993, Chest.

[51]  M. Mack,et al.  Thoracoscopy for the diagnosis of the indeterminate solitary pulmonary nodule. , 1993, The Annals of thoracic surgery.

[52]  J C Eggleston,et al.  Transthoracic needle aspiration biopsy of benign and malignant lung lesions. , 1985, AJR. American journal of roentgenology.

[53]  M. Mack,et al.  Diagnosing the indeterminate pulmonary nodule: percutaneous biopsy versus thoracoscopy. , 1995, Surgery.

[54]  J. F. Fiastro,et al.  Quantitative computed tomography evaluation of benign solitary pulmonary nodules. , 1987, The Journal of computed tomography.

[55]  H. Ward,et al.  The impact of phantom CT scanning on surgery for the solitary pulmonary nodule. , 1989, Surgery.

[56]  J R Beck,et al.  A convenient approximation of life expectancy (the "DEALE"). I. Validation of the method. , 1982, The American journal of medicine.

[57]  J R Beck,et al.  A convenient approximation of life expectancy (the "DEALE"). II. Use in medical decision-making. , 1982, The American journal of medicine.

[58]  N. Gupta,et al.  PET-FDG imaging and transthoracic needle lung aspiration biopsy in evaluation of pulmonary lesions. A comparative risk-benefit analysis. , 1995, Chest.

[59]  A. Wright,et al.  Pulmonary nodules: effect on detection of spiral CT pitch. , 1996, Radiology.

[60]  B R Luce,et al.  Methods of cost-effectiveness analysis: areas of consensus and debate. , 1995, Clinical therapeutics.

[61]  C. Henschke,et al.  The solitary pulmonary nodule: update 1995. , 1995, The American journal of medicine.