Return-based style analysis is applied to identify the style benchmarks of 12 property companies in Hong Kong from 1984 through 2001, and their performance is then assessed. Unlike style analysis of mutual funds, the cash component is not constrained to be non-negative so as to reflect their debt-financed capital structures. The other feature of style analysis of property companies is the inclusion of direct property returns in the implied portfolio. This is achieved by transaction-based monthly property price indices over the period of observation. Our results suggest that the implied portfolio is able to explain an important part of the variation in the property companies’ returns. Although non-property investment has been the major component of the implied portfolio, the proportion of direct properties has increased over time. Therefore, property companies are becoming a closer substitute for direct property investment. One of the implications of the results is that investors can avoid the high transaction costs of direct property investment, but at the same time enjoy the liquidity and diversification benefits through investing in the shares of property companies. Our results also suggest that the performance of most property companies is not significantly different from the performance of the underlying implied portfolio before transaction cost is taken into account. This implies that the overall performance of a property company is mainly attributable to investment style characterized by the implied portfolio rather than management skills.
[1]
S. Stevenson.
Evaluating the investment attributes and performance of property companies
,
2001
.
[2]
Stephen Lee.
Style analysis and property fund performance
,
1999
.
[3]
John C. Bogle.
The Implications of Style Analysis for Mutual Fund Performance Evaluation
,
1998
.
[4]
John G. Gallo,et al.
Benefits of Proper Style Classification of Equity Portfolio Managers
,
1997
.
[5]
G. Newell,et al.
Linkages between direct and indirect property performance in Hong Kong
,
1996
.
[6]
Andrew Rudd,et al.
Does Historical Performance Predict Future Performance
,
1995
.
[7]
Jon A. Christopherson.
Equity Style Classifications
,
1995
.
[8]
Richard F. Muth,et al.
A Regression Method for Real Estate Price Index Construction
,
1963
.
[9]
William F. Sharpe,et al.
ASSET ALLOCATION: MANAGEMENT STYLE AND PERFORMANCE MEASUREMENT
,
2002
.
[10]
James Webb,et al.
Management Styles of REIT Funds
,
2000
.
[11]
James Webb,et al.
Management Style and Asset Allocation in Real Estate Portfolios
,
1996
.