Designing and Evaluating mHealth Interventions for Vulnerable Populations: A Systematic Review

Diverse disciplines, including Human-Computer Interaction have explored how mobile health (mHealth) applications can transform healthcare and health promotion. Increasingly, research has explored how mHealth tools can promote healthy behaviors within vulnerable populations-groups that disproportionately experience barriers to wellness. We conducted a systematic review of 83 papers from diverse disciplines to characterize the design and impact of mHealth tools in low-socioeconomic (low-SES) and racial/ethnic minority individuals. Our findings highlight that the diversity within low-SES and racial/ethnic minority groups was not reflected in the populations studied. Most studies focused on improving the health of individuals, often neglecting factors at the community and society levels that influence health disparities. Moreover, few improvements in health outcomes were demonstrated. We further discuss factors that acted as barriers and facilitators of mHealth intervention adoption. Our findings highlight trends that can drive critically needed digital health innovations for vulnerable populations.

[1]  Beenish Chaudry,et al.  The design of a mobile portion size estimation interface for a low literacy population , 2011, 2011 5th International Conference on Pervasive Computing Technologies for Healthcare (PervasiveHealth) and Workshops.

[2]  Catherine Lu,et al.  Tablet-based education to reduce depression-related stigma , 2016 .

[3]  Silvia Lindtner,et al.  Fish'n'Steps: Encouraging Physical Activity with an Interactive Computer Game , 2006, UbiComp.

[4]  B. Fjeldsoe,et al.  Behavior change interventions delivered by mobile telephone short-message service. , 2009, American journal of preventive medicine.

[5]  P. Himmel Health Behavior and Health Education: Theory, Research, and Practice , 1992, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[6]  David K Vawdrey,et al.  Influenza vaccine text message reminders for urban, low-income pregnant women: a randomized controlled trial. , 2014, American journal of public health.

[7]  Rachel Jones,et al.  Streaming Weekly Soap Opera Video Episodes to Smartphones in a Randomized Controlled Trial to Reduce HIV Risk in Young Urban African American/Black Women , 2012, AIDS and Behavior.

[8]  Kevin H Kim,et al.  A Feasibility Study to Develop a Diabetes Prevention Program for Young Adults With Prediabetes by Using Digital Platforms and a Handheld Device , 2014, The Diabetes educator.

[9]  Matthew P Buman,et al.  The Stanford Healthy Neighborhood Discovery Tool: a computerized tool to assess active living environments. , 2013, American journal of preventive medicine.

[10]  Melanie Hingle,et al.  Texting for health: the use of participatory methods to develop healthy lifestyle messages for teens. , 2013, Journal of nutrition education and behavior.

[11]  Mary A Whooley,et al.  Psychosocial factors and medication adherence among patients with coronary heart disease: A text messaging intervention , 2015, European journal of cardiovascular nursing : journal of the Working Group on Cardiovascular Nursing of the European Society of Cardiology.

[12]  Frank Dong,et al.  Text Messaging to Motivate Exercise Among Latino Adults at Risk for Vascular Disease: A Pilot Study, 2013 , 2014, Preventing chronic disease.

[13]  M. Paasche-Orlow,et al.  Education level, not health literacy, associated with information needs for patients with cancer. , 2011, Patient education and counseling.

[14]  V. Guilamo-Ramos,et al.  Potential for Using Online and Mobile Education with Parents and Adolescents to Impact Sexual and Reproductive Health , 2014, Prevention Science.

[15]  Katie A. Siek,et al.  Snack Buddy: Supporting Healthy Snacking in Low Socioeconomic Status Families , 2015, CSCW.

[16]  J. S. St. Lawrence,et al.  Receptivity of African American adolescents to an HIV-prevention curriculum enhanced by text messaging. , 2009, Journal for specialists in pediatric nursing : JSPN.

[17]  Ben S. Gerber,et al.  Mobile phone text messaging to promote healthy behaviors and weight loss maintenance: a feasibility study , 2009, Health Informatics J..

[18]  Sanjay Arora,et al.  Trial to examine text message-based mHealth in emergency department patients with diabetes (TExT-MED): a randomized controlled trial. , 2014, Annals of emergency medicine.

[19]  Ben Jelen,et al.  Evaluation of a Food Portion Size Estimation Interface for a Varying Literacy Population , 2016, CHI.

[20]  Rebecca E. Grinter,et al.  EatWell: sharing nutrition-related memories in a low-income community , 2008, CSCW.

[21]  Katherine K. Kim,et al.  Youth-centered design and usage results of the iN Touch mobile self-management program for overweight/obesity , 2014, Personal and Ubiquitous Computing.

[22]  Wanda Pratt,et al.  Healthcare in the pocket: Mapping the space of mobile-phone health interventions , 2012, J. Biomed. Informatics.

[23]  Nicola Dell,et al.  The Ins and Outs of HCI for Development , 2016, CHI.

[24]  Nancy Krieger Epidemiologic Theory Counts , 2011 .

[25]  V. Conn,et al.  Interventions to promote physical activity among African American women. , 2002, Public health nursing.

[26]  Sally Findley,et al.  An Interprofessional Collaborative Approach in the Development of a Caries Risk Assessment mobile tablet application: My Smile Buddy , 2013, Journal of health care for the poor and underserved.

[27]  Rebecca E. Grinter,et al.  Let's play!: mobile health games for adults , 2010, UbiComp.

[28]  Mark W. Lipsey,et al.  Practical Meta-Analysis , 2000 .

[29]  Suzanne M. Miller,et al.  Preventing Postpartum Smoking Relapse Among Inner City Women: Development of a Theory-Based and Evidence-Guided Text Messaging Intervention , 2014, JMIR research protocols.

[30]  Judy Robertson,et al.  iFitQuest: a school based study of a mobile location-aware exergame for adolescents , 2012, Mobile HCI.

[31]  M. Eberhardt,et al.  The importance of place of residence: examining health in rural and nonrural areas. , 2004, American journal of public health.

[32]  Susan L. Moore,et al.  A mobile health infrastructure to support underserved patients with chronic disease. , 2014, Healthcare.

[33]  David Akopian,et al.  Assessing Media Access and Use Among Latina Adolescents to Inform Development of a Physical Activity Promotion Intervention Incorporating Text Messaging , 2014, Health promotion practice.

[34]  Sheana Bull,et al.  Text messaging for HIV prevention with young Black men: formative research and campaign development , 2011, AIDS care.

[35]  Yvonne Rogers,et al.  When Do We Eat? An Evaluation of Food Items Input into an Electronic Food Monitoring Application , 2006, 2006 Pervasive Health Conference and Workshops.

[36]  Bertrand Schneider,et al.  Phylo-Genie: engaging students in collaborative 'tree-thinking' through tabletop techniques , 2012, CHI.

[37]  Jasjit S Ahluwalia,et al.  Mobile Phone Text Messaging Intervention for Cervical Cancer Screening: Changes in Knowledge and Behavior Pre-Post Intervention , 2014, Journal of medical Internet research.

[38]  R. Lau,et al.  Factors that influence the implementation of e-health: a systematic review of systematic reviews (an update) , 2016, Implementation Science.

[39]  Paula M Castaño,et al.  Effect of Daily Text Messages on Oral Contraceptive Continuation: A Randomized Controlled Trial , 2012, Obstetrics and gynecology.

[40]  Robert Phillips,et al.  The Cellular Generation and a New Risk Environment: Implications for Texting-Based Sexual Health Promotion Interventions among Minority Young Men Who Have Sex with Men , 2012, AMIA.

[41]  Andrea G. Parker,et al.  Spaceship Launch: Designing a Collaborative Exergame for Families , 2015, CSCW.

[42]  G. Bennett,et al.  Using technology to promote postpartum weight loss in urban, low-income mothers: a pilot randomized controlled trial. , 2014, Journal of nutrition education and behavior.

[43]  Andrea G. Parker,et al.  Collectivistic health promotion tools: Accounting for the relationship between culture, food and nutrition , 2014, Int. J. Hum. Comput. Stud..

[44]  Andrew D. Miller,et al.  Assessing Health Games in Secondary Schools: An Investigation of the American Horsepower Challenge 2009-2010 , 2011 .

[45]  A. Haines,et al.  The Effectiveness of Mobile-Health Technology-Based Health Behaviour Change or Disease Management Interventions for Health Care Consumers: A Systematic Review , 2013, PLoS medicine.

[46]  Cynthia Kratzke,et al.  Ethnic Differences in Breast Cancer Prevention Information-Seeking Among Rural Women: Will Provider Mobile Messages Work? , 2014, Journal of Cancer Education.

[47]  Alison Bowes,et al.  Effectiveness of telemedicine: A systematic review of reviews , 2010, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[48]  E. Phillips,et al.  Exploring Potential Use of Internet, E-mail, and Instant Text Messaging to Promote Breast Health and Mammogram Use among Immigrant Hispanic Women in Los Angeles County , 2013, The American surgeon.

[49]  Bernadette Mazurek Melnyk,et al.  Systematic review of text-messaging interventions to promote healthy behaviors in pediatric and adolescent populations: implications for clinical practice and research. , 2012, Worldviews on evidence-based nursing.

[50]  Rebecca E. Grinter,et al.  Exploring the use of large displays in american megachurches , 2007, CHI Extended Abstracts.

[51]  Andrew D. Miller,et al.  Design strategies for youth-focused pervasive social health games , 2013, 2013 7th International Conference on Pervasive Computing Technologies for Healthcare and Workshops.

[52]  Seth M Noar,et al.  Efficacy of text messaging-based interventions for health promotion: a meta-analysis. , 2013, Social science & medicine.

[53]  H. Cole-Lewis,et al.  Text messaging as a tool for behavior change in disease prevention and management. , 2010, Epidemiologic reviews.

[54]  B. Lee Green,et al.  Affecting African American Men’s Prostate Cancer Screening Decision-making through a Mobile Tablet-Mediated Intervention , 2014, Journal of health care for the poor and underserved.

[55]  Julie Maitland,et al.  Bridging the information gap: collaborative technology design with low-income at-risk families to engender healthy behaviors , 2009, OZCHI.

[56]  David K Vawdrey,et al.  Effect of a text messaging intervention on influenza vaccination in an urban, low-income pediatric and adolescent population: a randomized controlled trial. , 2012, JAMA.

[57]  Bradley C. Love,et al.  Patient education on mobile devices: an e-health intervention for low health literate audiences , 2009, J. Inf. Sci..

[58]  R. Estacio,et al.  Health Promotion Text Messaging Preferences and Acceptability Among the Medically Underserved , 2015, Health promotion practice.

[59]  Robert A. Vigersky,et al.  Mobile Phone-Based Video Messages for Diabetes Self-Care Support , 2012, Journal of diabetes science and technology.

[60]  Melicia C Whitt-Glover,et al.  Systematic Review of Interventions to Increase Physical Activity and Physical Fitness in African-Americans , 2009, American journal of health promotion : AJHP.

[61]  Yvonne Rogers,et al.  Pride and prejudice: learning how chronically ill people think about food , 2006, CHI.

[62]  M. Petticrew,et al.  Systematic Reviews in the Social Sciences: A Practical Guide , 2005 .

[63]  Emily M. Cramer,et al.  A two-way text-messaging system answering health questions for low-income pregnant women. , 2013, Patient education and counseling.

[64]  Melinda S Bender,et al.  Designing a Culturally Appropriate Visually Enhanced Low-Text Mobile Health App Promoting Physical Activity for Latinos , 2016, Journal of transcultural nursing : official journal of the Transcultural Nursing Society.

[65]  Richard Schulz,et al.  A videophone psychosocial intervention for dementia caregivers. , 2013, The American journal of geriatric psychiatry : official journal of the American Association for Geriatric Psychiatry.

[66]  Anup Amatya,et al.  Differences Among College Women for Breast Cancer Prevention Acquired Information-Seeking, Desired Apps and Texts, and Daughter-Initiated Information to Mothers , 2014, Journal of Community Health.

[67]  Mary Beth Rosson,et al.  CHI '07 Extended Abstracts on Human Factors in Computing Systems , 2007, CHI 2007.

[68]  E. Murphy,et al.  Qualitative research methods in health technology assessment: a review of the literature. , 1998, Health technology assessment.

[69]  B. Yates,et al.  Health Promotion Text Blasts for Minority Adolescent Mothers , 2014, MCN. The American journal of maternal child nursing.

[70]  Ralph Vacca,et al.  Bicultural: Examining Teenage Latinas' Perspectives on Technologies for Emotional Support , 2017, IDC.

[71]  JoEllen Wilbur,et al.  Using photos to develop text messages to promote walking. , 2013, Journal of nursing scholarship : an official publication of Sigma Theta Tau International Honor Society of Nursing.

[72]  JoEllen Wilbur,et al.  Physical activity text messaging interventions in adults: a systematic review. , 2013, Worldviews on evidence-based nursing.

[73]  Beenish Chaudry,et al.  Mobile interface design for low-literacy populations , 2012, IHI '12.

[74]  Chi-Hong Tseng,et al.  Effectiveness of a Smartphone Application for Weight Loss Compared With Usual Care in Overweight Primary Care Patients , 2014, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[75]  Patrick Hogan,et al.  How Do Mobile Phone Diabetes Programs Drive Behavior Change? , 2014, The Diabetes educator.

[76]  Shantanu Nundy,et al.  Developing a behavioral model for mobile phone-based diabetes interventions. , 2013, Patient education and counseling.

[77]  J. S. St. Lawrence,et al.  Adolescents' perceptions of a mobile cell phone text messaging-enhanced intervention and development of a mobile cell phone-based HIV prevention intervention. , 2012, Journal for specialists in pediatric nursing : JSPN.

[78]  W. Evans,et al.  Pilot evaluation of the text4baby mobile health program , 2012, BMC Public Health.

[79]  E. Montague,et al.  Health and Wellness Technology Use by Historically Underserved Health Consumers: Systematic Review , 2012, Journal of medical Internet research.

[80]  G. B. Winbush,et al.  Health Empowerment Technologies (HET): Building a Web-Based Tool to Empower Older African American Patient-Doctor Relationships , 2013, Journal of health care for the poor and underserved.

[81]  Robert Garofalo,et al.  Improving Adherence to Antiretroviral Therapy for Youth Living with HIV/AIDS: A Pilot Study Using Personalized, Interactive, Daily Text Message Reminders , 2012, Journal of medical Internet research.

[82]  Margaret M. Thorsen,et al.  Acceptability, language, and structure of text message-based behavioral interventions for high-risk adolescent females: a qualitative study. , 2014, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[83]  Sanjay Arora,et al.  A mobile health intervention for inner city patients with poorly controlled diabetes: proof-of-concept of the TExT-MED program. , 2012, Diabetes technology & therapeutics.

[84]  Rachel Jones,et al.  Handheld Computers to Run ACASI to Assess HIV Risk and Deliver Tailored Soap Opera Video Feedback: Acceptability Among Young Adult Urban Women , 2012, The Journal of the Association of Nurses in AIDS Care : JANAC.

[85]  Beenish Chaudry,et al.  An offline mobile nutrition monitoring intervention for varying-literacy patients receiving hemodialysis: a pilot study examining usage and usability , 2012, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[86]  Angela Fagerlin,et al.  Comparison of Community Health WorkerLed Diabetes Medication Decision-Making Support for Low-Income Latino and African American Adults With Diabetes Using E-Health Tools Versus Print Materials , 2014, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[87]  Abby C. King,et al.  Comparison of passive versus active photo capture of built environment features by technology naïve Latinos using the SenseCam and Stanford healthy neighborhood discovery tool , 2013, SenseCam '13.

[88]  Michelle Cororve Fingeret,et al.  Long-term outcomes of a cell phone-delivered intervention for smokers living with HIV/AIDS. , 2013, Clinical infectious diseases : an official publication of the Infectious Diseases Society of America.

[89]  Rachel Jones,et al.  Soap Opera Video on Handheld Computers to Reduce Young Urban Women’s HIV Sex Risk , 2008, AIDS and Behavior.

[90]  Susan L. Moore,et al.  Care by cell phone: text messaging for chronic disease management. , 2012, The American journal of managed care.

[91]  Paula M Castaño,et al.  Exploring pregnant women's views on influenza vaccination and educational text messages. , 2011, Preventive medicine.

[92]  Jeffrey D. Klausner,et al.  SEXINFO: a sexual health text messaging service for San Francisco youth. , 2008, American journal of public health.

[93]  Atsushi Matsumoto,et al.  Exploring healthy eating among ethnic minority students using mobile technology: Feasibility and adherence , 2016, Health Informatics J..

[94]  Nir Menachemi,et al.  Text messaging in health care: a systematic review of impact studies. , 2011, Advances in health care management.

[95]  Cynthia Kratzke,et al.  Reaching Rural Women: Breast Cancer Prevention Information Seeking Behaviors and Interest in Internet, Cell Phone, and Text Use , 2013, Journal of Community Health.

[96]  J. Sallis,et al.  Ecological models of health behavior. , 2008 .

[97]  Sanjay Arora,et al.  Perceptions of Successful Cues to Action and Opportunities to Augment Behavioral Triggers in Diabetes Self-Management: Qualitative Analysis of a Mobile Intervention for Low-Income Latinos With Diabetes , 2014, Journal of medical Internet research.

[98]  M. Carras,et al.  Use of Mobile Phones, Computers and Internet Among Clients of an Inner-City Community Psychiatric Clinic , 2014, Journal of psychiatric practice.

[99]  Katie A. Siek,et al.  Designing mobile snack application for low socioeconomic status families , 2012, 2012 6th International Conference on Pervasive Computing Technologies for Healthcare (PervasiveHealth) and Workshops.

[100]  K. Glanz,et al.  Improving Dietary Self-Monitoring and Adherence with Hand-Held Computers: A Pilot Study , 2006, American journal of health promotion : AJHP.

[101]  Sanjay Arora,et al.  Gender Differences in Diabetes Self-Management: A Mixed-Methods Analysis of a Mobile Health Intervention for Inner-City Latino Patients , 2013, Journal of diabetes science and technology.

[102]  M. Pavel,et al.  Advancing Models and Theories for Digital Behavior Change Interventions. , 2016, American journal of preventive medicine.

[103]  C. Boyer,et al.  Development and Pretesting Multimedia HIV‐Prevention Text Messages for Mobile Cell Phone Delivery , 2011, The Journal of the Association of Nurses in AIDS Care : JANAC.

[104]  Dori M. Steinberg,et al.  Daily Text Messaging for Weight Control Among Racial and Ethnic Minority Women: Randomized Controlled Pilot Study , 2013, Journal of medical Internet research.

[105]  W. Keith Edwards,et al.  Intersectional HCI: Engaging Identity through Gender, Race, and Class , 2017, CHI.

[106]  Sheana Bull,et al.  Enhancing a Teen Pregnancy Prevention Program with text messaging: engaging minority youth to develop TOP ® Plus Text. , 2014, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[107]  Nicole L. Nollen,et al.  Mobile technology for obesity prevention: a randomized pilot study in racial- and ethnic-minority girls. , 2014, American journal of preventive medicine.

[108]  Susan McRoy,et al.  An open architecture for messaging-based consumer-health question-answering , 2012, IHI '12.

[109]  Mark D Hayward,et al.  Trends and group differences in the association between educational attainment and U.S. adult mortality: implications for understanding education's causal influence. , 2015, Social science & medicine.

[110]  Michelle R. Broaddus,et al.  Text Messaging for Sexual Communication and Safety Among African American Young Adults , 2013, Qualitative health research.

[111]  Shelagh A. Mulvaney,et al.  Development and Feasibility of a Text Messaging and Interactive Voice Response Intervention for Low-Income, Diverse Adults with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus , 2013, Journal of diabetes science and technology.

[112]  J. Champion,et al.  Assessment of mobile device and SMS Use for Diet and Exercise Information Among Rural Mexican-American adolescents. , 2014, Journal of pediatric nursing.

[113]  Maria E. Fernandez,et al.  When Promotoras and Technology Meet , 2012, Health education & behavior : the official publication of the Society for Public Health Education.

[114]  Steve Hasley,et al.  Improving Influenza Vaccination Rates in Pregnancy Through Text Messaging: A Randomized Controlled Trial , 2013, Obstetrics and gynecology.

[115]  L. Clark,et al.  The Use of Cell Phone Support for Non-adherent HIV-Infected Youth and Young Adults: An Initial Randomized and Controlled Intervention Trial , 2014, AIDS and Behavior.

[116]  C. Wenham,et al.  Epidemiology and the people’s health: theory and context , 2015 .

[117]  E. Fowles,et al.  The feasibility of personal digital assistants (PDAs) to collect dietary intake data in low-income pregnant women. , 2008, Journal of nutrition education and behavior.

[118]  Shantanu Nundy,et al.  Feasibility and Usability of a Text Message-Based Program for Diabetes Self-Management in an Urban African-American Population , 2011, Journal of diabetes science and technology.

[119]  Karthik Natarajan,et al.  Text4Health: impact of text message reminder-recalls for pediatric and adolescent immunizations. , 2012, American journal of public health.