What types of COVID-19 conspiracies are populated by Twitter bots?

With people moving out of physical public spaces due to containment measures to tackle the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic, online platforms become even more prominent tools to understand social discussion. Studying social media can be informative to assess how we are collectively coping with this unprecedented global crisis. However, social media platforms are also populated by bots, automated accounts that can amplify certain topics of discussion at the expense of others. In this paper, we study 43.3M English tweets about COVID-19 and provide early evidence of the use of bots to promote political conspiracies in the United States, in stark contrast with humans who focus on public health concerns.

[1]  Guido Caldarelli,et al.  Science vs Conspiracy: Collective Narratives in the Age of Misinformation , 2014, PloS one.

[2]  Nicholas Berente,et al.  Is that social bot behaving unethically? , 2017, CACM.

[3]  Emilio Ferrara,et al.  Measuring Bot and Human Behavioral Dynamics , 2018, Frontiers in Physics.

[4]  Kristina Lerman,et al.  COVID-19: The First Public Coronavirus Twitter Dataset , 2020, ArXiv.

[5]  Danai Koutra,et al.  BotWalk: Efficient Adaptive Exploration of Twitter Bot Networks , 2017, 2017 IEEE/ACM International Conference on Advances in Social Networks Analysis and Mining (ASONAM).

[6]  Venkata Rama Kiran Garimella,et al.  Political hashtag hijacking in the U.S. , 2013, WWW.

[7]  Hossein Hamooni,et al.  DeBot: Twitter Bot Detection via Warped Correlation , 2016, 2016 IEEE 16th International Conference on Data Mining (ICDM).

[8]  Todd Graham,et al.  Discursive Equality and Everyday Talk Online: The Impact of "Superparticipants" , 2014, J. Comput. Mediat. Commun..

[9]  Manlio De Domenico,et al.  Assessing the risks of 'infodemics' in response to COVID-19 epidemics. , 2020, Nature human behaviour.

[10]  Samuel C. Woolley,et al.  Algorithms, bots, and political communication in the US 2016 election: The challenge of automated political communication for election law and administration , 2018 .

[11]  Fabrício Benevenuto,et al.  Reverse engineering socialbot infiltration strategies in Twitter , 2014, 2015 IEEE/ACM International Conference on Advances in Social Networks Analysis and Mining (ASONAM).

[12]  Juan Echeverria,et al.  Discovery, Retrieval, and Analysis of the 'Star Wars' Botnet in Twitter , 2017, ASONAM.

[13]  Kate Starbird,et al.  Examining the Alternative Media Ecosystem Through the Production of Alternative Narratives of Mass Shooting Events on Twitter , 2017, ICWSM.

[14]  Kristina Lerman,et al.  Who Falls for Online Political Manipulation? , 2018, WWW.

[15]  Paul DiMaggio,et al.  Adapting computational text analysis to social science (and vice versa) , 2015, Big Data Soc..

[16]  Alessandro Flammini,et al.  Unveiling Coordinated Groups Behind White Helmets Disinformation , 2020, WWW.

[17]  Kate Starbird,et al.  Keeping Up with the Tweet-dashians: The Impact of 'Official' Accounts on Online Rumoring , 2016, CSCW.

[18]  Ciro Cattuto,et al.  Dynamical classes of collective attention in twitter , 2011, WWW.

[19]  D. Lazer,et al.  Fake news on Twitter during the 2016 U.S. presidential election , 2019, Science.

[20]  Gabriele Cosentino,et al.  From Pizzagate to the Great Replacement: The Globalization of Conspiracy Theories , 2020 .

[21]  Emilio Ferrara,et al.  Social Bots Distort the 2016 US Presidential Election Online Discussion , 2016, First Monday.

[22]  B. Nyhan,et al.  Exposure to untrustworthy websites in the 2016 U.S. election , 2020, Nature Human Behaviour.

[23]  Gabriele Cosentino,et al.  Polarize and Conquer: Russian Influence Operations in the United States , 2020 .

[24]  Timothy R. Tangherlini,et al.  Conspiracy in the Time of Corona: Automatic detection of Covid-19 Conspiracy Theories in Social Media and the News , 2020, ArXiv.

[25]  G. Caldarelli,et al.  The spreading of misinformation online , 2016, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[26]  Stefan Stieglitz,et al.  Do Social Bots Dream of Electric Sheep? A Categorisation of Social Media Bot Accounts , 2017, ACIS.

[27]  Filippo Menczer,et al.  Prevalence of Low-Credibility Information on Twitter During the COVID-19 Outbreak , 2020, ICWSM Workshops.

[28]  Filippo Menczer,et al.  Arming the public with artificial intelligence to counter social bots , 2019, Human Behavior and Emerging Technologies.

[29]  Filippo Menczer,et al.  Scalable and Generalizable Social Bot Detection through Data Selection , 2019, AAAI.

[30]  Amos Azaria,et al.  The DARPA Twitter Bot Challenge , 2016, Computer.

[31]  Matteo Cinelli,et al.  The COVID-19 social media infodemic , 2020, Scientific reports.

[32]  Seungmin Rho,et al.  Social media signal detection using tweets volume, hashtag, and sentiment analysis , 2018, Multimedia Tools and Applications.

[33]  Claude Chaudet,et al.  Malevolent Creativity and Social Media: Creating Anti-immigration Communities on Twitter , 2020 .

[34]  Robert Gorwa,et al.  Unpacking the Social Media Bot: A Typology to Guide Research and Policy , 2018, Policy & Internet.

[35]  P. Metaxas,et al.  Social Media and the Elections , 2012, Science.

[36]  Gianluca Stringhini,et al.  LOBO: Evaluation of Generalization Deficiencies in Twitter Bot Classifiers , 2018, ACSAC.

[37]  Kristina Lerman,et al.  Tracking Social Media Discourse About the COVID-19 Pandemic: Development of a Public Coronavirus Twitter Data Set , 2020, JMIR public health and surveillance.

[38]  Huan Liu,et al.  Is the Sample Good Enough? Comparing Data from Twitter's Streaming API with Twitter's Firehose , 2013, ICWSM.

[39]  Emilio Ferrara,et al.  #COVID-19 on Twitter: Bots, Conspiracies, and Social Media Activism , 2020, ArXiv.

[40]  Sinan Aral,et al.  The spread of true and false news online , 2018, Science.

[41]  Filippo Menczer,et al.  Uncovering Coordinated Networks on Social Media , 2020, ArXiv.

[42]  Silvia Giordano,et al.  Detecting Troll Behavior via Inverse Reinforcement Learning: A Case Study of Russian Trolls in the 2016 US Election , 2020, ICWSM.

[43]  Jeremy Blackburn,et al.  "Go eat a bat, Chang!": An Early Look on the Emergence of Sinophobic Behavior on Web Communities in the Face of COVID-19 , 2020, ArXiv.

[44]  Richard Bonneau,et al.  Detecting Bots on Russian Political Twitter , 2017, Big Data.

[45]  David A. Broniatowski,et al.  Detecting and Characterizing Bot-Like Behavior on Twitter , 2018, SBP-BRiMS.

[46]  D. Ruths,et al.  Social media for large studies of behavior , 2014, Science.

[47]  Jon Crowcroft,et al.  Classification of Twitter Accounts into Automated Agents and Human Users , 2017, 2017 IEEE/ACM International Conference on Advances in Social Networks Analysis and Mining (ASONAM).

[48]  Samuel C. Woolley,et al.  Automating power: Social bot interference in global politics , 2016, First Monday.

[49]  Emilio Ferrara,et al.  The history of digital spam , 2019, Commun. ACM.

[50]  Gregory N. Mandel,et al.  The Polarizing Impact of Science Literacy and Numeracy on Perceived Climate Change Risks , 2012 .

[51]  Emilio Ferrara,et al.  Bots increase exposure to negative and inflammatory content in online social systems , 2018, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[52]  Tim Mackey,et al.  Data Mining and Content Analysis of the Chinese Social Media Platform Weibo During the Early COVID-19 Outbreak: Retrospective Observational Infoveillance Study , 2020, JMIR public health and surveillance.

[53]  S. Lindstrom,et al.  First Case of 2019 Novel Coronavirus in the United States , 2020, The New England journal of medicine.

[54]  Florian Daniel,et al.  On Twitter Bots Behaving Badly: A Manual and Automated Analysis of Python Code Patterns on GitHub , 2019, J. Web Eng..

[55]  Emilio Ferrara,et al.  "Manipulation and abuse on social media" by Emilio Ferrara with Ching-man Au Yeung as coordinator , 2015, SIGWEB Newsl..

[56]  D. Lazer,et al.  The Parable of Google Flu: Traps in Big Data Analysis , 2014, Science.

[57]  Alfred Hermida,et al.  Content Analysis in an Era of Big Data: A Hybrid Approach to Computational and Manual Methods , 2013 .

[58]  Emilio Ferrara,et al.  Measuring social spam and the effect of bots on information diffusion in social media , 2017, ArXiv.

[59]  Jon Crowcroft,et al.  An in-depth characterisation of Bots and Humans on Twitter , 2017, ArXiv.

[60]  Alice E. Marwick,et al.  Media Manipulation and Disinformation Online , 2017 .

[61]  Sree Priyanka Uppu,et al.  E-Cigarette Surveillance With Social Media Data: Social Bots, Emerging Topics, and Trends , 2017, JMIR public health and surveillance.

[62]  David A. Broniatowski,et al.  Weaponized Health Communication: Twitter Bots and Russian Trolls Amplify the Vaccine Debate , 2018, American journal of public health.

[63]  Marcello Balduccini,et al.  “Information Warfare” and Online News Commenting: Analyzing Forces of Social Influence Through Location-Based Commenting User Typology , 2017 .

[64]  Emilio Ferrara,et al.  Red Bots Do It Better:Comparative Analysis of Social Bot Partisan Behavior , 2019, WWW.

[65]  Dietram A. Scheufele,et al.  Science audiences, misinformation, and fake news , 2019, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[66]  Konstantin Beznosov,et al.  Design and analysis of a social botnet , 2013, Comput. Networks.

[67]  Kristina Lerman,et al.  Analyzing the Digital Traces of Political Manipulation: The 2016 Russian Interference Twitter Campaign , 2018, 2018 IEEE/ACM International Conference on Advances in Social Networks Analysis and Mining (ASONAM).

[68]  David G. Rand,et al.  Fighting COVID-19 Misinformation on Social Media: Experimental Evidence for a Scalable Accuracy-Nudge Intervention , 2020, Psychological science.

[69]  M. Gentzkow,et al.  Social Media and Fake News in the 2016 Election , 2017 .

[70]  Konstantin Beznosov,et al.  The socialbot network: when bots socialize for fame and money , 2011, ACSAC '11.

[71]  Filippo Menczer,et al.  BotOrNot: A System to Evaluate Social Bots , 2016, WWW.

[72]  Emilio Ferrara,et al.  Evolution of bot and human behavior during elections , 2019, First Monday.

[73]  P. S. Dodds,et al.  How the world’s collective attention is being paid to a pandemic: COVID-19 related n-gram time series for 24 languages on Twitter , 2021, PloS one.

[74]  Yi Wang,et al.  Mental health problems and social media exposure during COVID-19 outbreak , 2020, PloS one.

[75]  Max Nanis,et al.  Socialbots: voices from the fronts , 2012, INTR.

[76]  Kate Starbird,et al.  How Information Snowballs: Exploring the Role of Exposure in Online Rumor Propagation , 2016, CSCW.

[77]  David W. McDonald,et al.  Dissecting a Social Botnet: Growth, Content and Influence in Twitter , 2015, CSCW.

[78]  AbdulMalik S. Al-Salman,et al.  Twitter turing test: Identifying social machines , 2016, Inf. Sci..

[79]  Emilio Ferrara,et al.  Deep Neural Networks for Bot Detection , 2018, Inf. Sci..

[80]  Maximilian Mozes,et al.  Measuring Emotions in the COVID-19 Real World Worry Dataset , 2020, NLPCOVID19.

[81]  Ethan Zuckerman,et al.  QAnon and the Emergence of the Unreal , 2019, Issue 6: Unreal.

[82]  Deen Freelon,et al.  Assessing the Russian Internet Research Agency’s impact on the political attitudes and behaviors of American Twitter users in late 2017 , 2019, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[83]  Dawn Xiaodong Song,et al.  Suspended accounts in retrospect: an analysis of twitter spam , 2011, IMC '11.

[84]  Filippo Menczer,et al.  The rise of social bots , 2014, Commun. ACM.

[85]  Emilio Ferrara,et al.  Disinformation and Social Bot Operations in the Run Up to the 2017 French Presidential Election , 2017, First Monday.

[86]  Emily K. Vraga,et al.  A first look at COVID-19 information and misinformation sharing on Twitter , 2020, ArXiv.

[87]  Jeannette Sutton,et al.  Health Communication Trolls and Bots Versus Public Health Agencies' Trusted Voices. , 2018, American journal of public health.