Microcatheter Tip Enhancement in Fluoroscopy: A Comparison of Techniques

We compared three techniques for enhancement of microcatheter tips in fluoroscopic images: conventional subtraction technique (CST); averaged image subtraction technique (AIST), which we have developed; and double average filtering (DAF) technique, which uses nonlinear background estimates. A pulsed fluoroscopic image sequence was obtained as a microcatheter was passed through a carotid phantom that was on top of a head phantom. The carotid phantom was a silicone cylinder containing a simulated vessel with the shape and curvatures of the internal carotid artery. The three techniques were applied to the images of the sequence, then the catheter tip was manually identified in each image, and 100 x 100 pixel images, centered at the indicated microcatheter tip positions, were extracted for the evaluations. The signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) was calculated in each of the extracted images from which the mean value of the SNR and its standard deviation (SD) were calculated for each technique. The mean values and the standard deviations were 4.36 (SD 3.40) for CST, 6.34 (SD 3.62) for AIST, and 3.55 (SD 1.27) for DAF. AIST had a higher SNR compared to CST in almost all frames. Although DAF yielded the smallest mean SNR value, it yielded the best SNR in those frames in which the microcatheter tip did not move between frames. We conclude that AIST provides the best SNR for a moving microcatheter tip and that DAF is optimal for a temporarily stationary microcatheter tip.