Joint modelling of time-to-event and multivariate longitudinal outcomes: recent developments and issues

BackgroundAvailable methods for the joint modelling of longitudinal and time-to-event outcomes have typically only allowed for a single longitudinal outcome and a solitary event time. In practice, clinical studies are likely to record multiple longitudinal outcomes. Incorporating all sources of data will improve the predictive capability of any model and lead to more informative inferences for the purpose of medical decision-making.MethodsWe reviewed current methodologies of joint modelling for time-to-event data and multivariate longitudinal data including the distributional and modelling assumptions, the association structures, estimation approaches, software tools for implementation and clinical applications of the methodologies.ResultsWe found that a large number of different models have recently been proposed. Most considered jointly modelling linear mixed models with proportional hazard models, with correlation between multiple longitudinal outcomes accounted for through multivariate normally distributed random effects. So-called current value and random effects parameterisations are commonly used to link the models. Despite developments, software is still lacking, which has translated into limited uptake by medical researchers.ConclusionAlthough, in an era of personalized medicine, the value of multivariate joint modelling has been established, researchers are currently limited in their ability to fit these models routinely. We make a series of recommendations for future research needs.

[1]  Scott L. Zeger,et al.  Latent Variable Model for Joint Analysis of Multiple Repeated Measures and Bivariate Event Times , 2001 .

[2]  Fang Liu,et al.  A Bayesian model for joint analysis of multivariate repeated measures and time to event data in crossover trials , 2016, Statistical methods in medical research.

[3]  Nikos Pantazis,et al.  Bivariate modelling of longitudinal measurements of two human immunodeficiency type 1 disease progression markers in the presence of informative drop‐outs , 2005 .

[4]  N M Laird,et al.  Increasing efficiency from censored survival data by using random effects to model longitudinal covariates , 1998, Statistical methods in medical research.

[5]  Paul S Albert,et al.  AN APPROACH FOR JOINTLY MODELING MULTIVARIATE LONGITUDINAL MEASUREMENTS AND DISCRETE TIME-TO-EVENT DATA. , 2010, The annals of applied statistics.

[6]  D. Rubin,et al.  Statistical Analysis with Missing Data. , 1989 .

[7]  Dimitris Rizopoulos,et al.  The R Package JMbayes for Fitting Joint Models for Longitudinal and Time-to-Event Data using MCMC , 2014, 1404.7625.

[8]  F. Hsieh,et al.  Joint Modeling of Survival and Longitudinal Data: Likelihood Approach Revisited , 2006, Biometrics.

[9]  Anastasios A. Tsiatis,et al.  Joint Modeling of Longitudinal and Time-to-Event Data : An Overview , 2004 .

[10]  Geert Verbeke,et al.  Pairwise Fitting of Mixed Models for the Joint Modeling of Multivariate Longitudinal Profiles , 2006, Biometrics.

[11]  M. Escobar.  Estimating Normal Means with a Dirichlet Process Prior , 1994 .

[12]  Simon G Thompson,et al.  Joint modelling of longitudinal and time-to-event data with application to predicting abdominal aortic aneurysm growth and rupture , 2011, Biometrical journal. Biometrische Zeitschrift.

[13]  Eleni-Rosalina Andrinopoulou,et al.  Joint modeling of two longitudinal outcomes and competing risk data , 2014, Statistics in medicine.

[14]  R Henderson,et al.  Joint modelling of longitudinal measurements and event time data. , 2000, Biostatistics.

[15]  Nian-Sheng Tang,et al.  Semiparametric Bayesian joint models of multivariate longitudinal and survival data , 2014, Comput. Stat. Data Anal..

[16]  Hongtu Zhu,et al.  Bayesian Influence Measures for Joint Models for Longitudinal and Survival Data , 2012, Biometrics.

[17]  Amanda G Chetwynd,et al.  Joint modelling of repeated measurements and time‐to‐event outcomes: The fourth Armitage lecture , 2008, Statistics in medicine.

[18]  Andrew Thomas,et al.  The BUGS project: Evolution, critique and future directions , 2009, Statistics in medicine.

[19]  J. Ibrahim,et al.  A Bayesian semiparametric joint hierarchical model for longitudinal and survival data. , 2003, Biometrics.

[20]  Peter J Diggle,et al.  Joint modelling of repeated measurement and time-to-event data: an introductory tutorial. , 2015, International journal of epidemiology.

[21]  M. Wulfsohn,et al.  A joint model for survival and longitudinal data measured with error. , 1997, Biometrics.

[22]  Dimitris Rizopoulos,et al.  JM: An R package for the joint modelling of longitudinal and time-to-event data , 2010 .

[23]  Dimitris Rizopoulos,et al.  Joint Models for Longitudinal and Time-to-Event Data: With Applications in R , 2012 .

[24]  Mulugeta Gebregziabher,et al.  A Joint Modeling Approach for Right Censored High Dimensional Multivariate Longitudinal Data. , 2014, Journal of biometrics & biostatistics.

[25]  Chi-Hong Tseng,et al.  Joint analysis of bivariate longitudinal ordinal outcomes and competing risks survival times with nonparametric distributions for random effects , 2012, Statistics in medicine.

[26]  S. Luo,et al.  Bayesian hierarchical model for multiple repeated measures and survival data: an application to Parkinson's disease , 2014, Statistics in medicine.

[27]  Bradley P Carlin,et al.  Separate and Joint Modeling of Longitudinal and Event Time Data Using Standard Computer Packages , 2004 .

[28]  Bradley P. Carlin,et al.  Combining Dynamic Predictions From Joint Models for Longitudinal and Time-to-Event Data Using Bayesian Model Averaging , 2013, 1303.2797.

[29]  D. Commenges,et al.  Joint Modeling of the Clinical Progression and of the Biomarkers' Dynamics Using a Mechanistic Model , 2011, Biometrics.

[30]  Geert Verbeke,et al.  Predicting renal graft failure using multivariate longitudinal profiles. , 2008, Biostatistics.

[31]  Geert Verbeke,et al.  A Semi‐Parametric Shared Parameter Model to Handle Nonmonotone Nonignorable Missingness , 2009, Biometrics.

[32]  Cécile Proust-Lima,et al.  Joint modeling of repeated multivariate cognitive measures and competing risks of dementia and death: a latent process and latent class approach , 2014, Statistics in medicine.

[33]  D. Thomas,et al.  Simultaneously modelling censored survival data and repeatedly measured covariates: a Gibbs sampling approach. , 1996, Statistics in medicine.

[34]  Marie Davidian,et al.  A Semiparametric Likelihood Approach to Joint Modeling of Longitudinal and Time‐to‐Event Data , 2002, Biometrics.

[35]  Sheng Luo,et al.  A Bayesian approach to joint analysis of multivariate longitudinal data and parametric accelerated failure time , 2014, Statistics in medicine.

[36]  Damon Berridge,et al.  Robust joint modeling of longitudinal measurements and time to event data using normal/independent distributions: A Bayesian approach , 2013, Biometrical journal. Biometrische Zeitschrift.

[37]  Dimitris Rizopoulos,et al.  A Bayesian semiparametric multivariate joint model for multiple longitudinal outcomes and a time‐to‐event , 2011, Statistics in medicine.

[38]  J. Ibrahim,et al.  A Flexible B‐Spline Model for Multiple Longitudinal Biomarkers and Survival , 2005, Biometrics.

[39]  Charles E McCulloch,et al.  Maximum likelihood estimation in the joint analysis of time‐to‐event and multiple longitudinal variables , 2002, Statistics in medicine.

[40]  Bradley P Carlin,et al.  Joint Modeling of Multiple Longitudinal Patient-Reported Outcomes and Survival , 2011, Journal of biopharmaceutical statistics.

[41]  Ping Wang,et al.  Joint modeling of longitudinal outcomes and survival using latent growth modeling approach in a mesothelioma trial , 2012, Health Services and Outcomes Research Methodology.

[42]  Inês Sousa,et al.  A review on joint modelling of longitudinal measurements and time-to-event , 2011 .

[43]  Wei Shen,et al.  JMFit: A SAS Macro for Joint Models of Longitudinal and Survival Data. , 2016, Journal of statistical software.

[44]  Cécile Proust-Lima,et al.  The International Journal of Biostatistics Pattern Mixture Models and Latent Class Models for the Analysis of Multivariate Longitudinal Data with Informative Dropouts , 2011 .

[45]  Nikos Pantazis,et al.  Robustness of a parametric model for informatively censored bivariate longitudinal data under misspecification of its distributional assumptions: A simulation study , 2007, Statistics in medicine.

[46]  Joseph G Ibrahim,et al.  Joint Models for Multivariate Longitudinal and Multivariate Survival Data , 2006, Biometrics.

[47]  Jiin Choi,et al.  Prediction of transplant-free survival in idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis patients using joint models for event times and mixed multivariate longitudinal data , 2014, Journal of applied statistics.

[48]  N. Pantazis,et al.  Differences in HIV RNA levels before the initiation of antiretroviral therapy among 1864 individuals with known HIV-1 seroconversion dates , 2004, AIDS.

[49]  D.,et al.  Regression Models and Life-Tables , 2022 .

[50]  Hélène Jacqmin-Gadda,et al.  Joint modelling of bivariate longitudinal data with informative dropout and left‐censoring, with application to the evolution of CD4+ cell count and HIV RNA viral load in response to treatment of HIV infection , 2005, Statistics in medicine.

[51]  Damon Berridge,et al.  Joint modeling of multivariate longitudinal mixed measurements and time to event data using a Bayesian approach , 2014 .

[52]  Marie Davidian,et al.  An estimator for the proportional hazards model with multiple longitudinal covariates measured with error. , 2002, Biostatistics.

[53]  Joseph G Ibrahim,et al.  Basic concepts and methods for joint models of longitudinal and survival data. , 2010, Journal of clinical oncology : official journal of the American Society of Clinical Oncology.

[54]  J. R. Lockwood,et al.  Fitting Value-Added Models in R , 2006 .

[55]  Adele H. Marshall,et al.  Advances in Joint Modelling: A Review of Recent Developments with Application to the Survival of End Stage Renal Disease Patients , 2013 .

[56]  Eleni-Rosalina Andrinopoulou,et al.  Combined dynamic predictions using joint models of two longitudinal outcomes and competing risk data , 2017, Statistical methods in medical research.

[57]  Geert Molenberghs,et al.  Shared parameter models under random effects misspecification , 2008 .

[58]  Liang Li,et al.  Joint multiple imputation for longitudinal outcomes and clinical events that truncate longitudinal follow‐up , 2016, Statistics in medicine.

[59]  M. Wulfsohn,et al.  Modeling the Relationship of Survival to Longitudinal Data Measured with Error. Applications to Survival and CD4 Counts in Patients with AIDS , 1995 .

[60]  S. Luo,et al.  Joint modeling of multivariate longitudinal measurements and survival data with applications to Parkinson’s disease , 2016, Statistical methods in medical research.

[61]  Geert Molenberghs,et al.  The analysis of multivariate longitudinal data: A review , 2014, Statistical methods in medical research.

[62]  P. Ghisletta,et al.  Application of a joint multivariate longitudinal-survival analysis to examine the terminal decline hypothesis in the Swiss Interdisciplinary Longitudinal Study on the Oldest Old. , 2008, The journals of gerontology. Series B, Psychological sciences and social sciences.

[63]  J. Ware,et al.  Random-effects models for longitudinal data. , 1982, Biometrics.

[64]  S. Lipsitz,et al.  Slope estimation for bivariate longitudinal outcomes adjusting for informative right censoring by using a discrete survival model: application to the renal transplant cohort , 2011, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series A,.

[65]  Joseph G Ibrahim,et al.  Sample size and power determination in joint modeling of longitudinal and survival data , 2011, Statistics in medicine.

[66]  Joseph G. Ibrahim,et al.  BAYESIAN METHODS FOR JOINT MODELING OF LONGITUDINAL AND SURVIVAL DATA WITH APPLICATIONS TO CANCER VACCINE TRIALS , 2004 .

[67]  Martyn Plummer,et al.  JAGS: A program for analysis of Bayesian graphical models using Gibbs sampling , 2003 .

[68]  Francesco Bartolucci,et al.  A discrete time event‐history approach to informative drop‐out in mixed latent Markov models with covariates , 2015, Biometrics.

[69]  Jammbe Z Musoro,et al.  A joint model for repeated events of different types and multiple longitudinal outcomes with application to a follow‐up study of patients after kidney transplant , 2015, Biometrical journal. Biometrische Zeitschrift.

[70]  J. Robins,et al.  Adjusting for Nonignorable Drop-Out Using Semiparametric Nonresponse Models , 1999 .

[71]  An-Min Tang,et al.  Semiparametric Bayesian inference on skew–normal joint modeling of multivariate longitudinal and survival data , 2015, Statistics in medicine.

[72]  J. Douglas,et al.  Item response models for joint analysis of quality of life and survival , 2002, Statistics in medicine.

[73]  S L Zeger,et al.  The Evaluation of Multiple Surrogate Endpoints , 2001, Biometrics.

[74]  H Putter,et al.  Tutorial in biostatistics: competing risks and multi‐state models , 2007, Statistics in medicine.

[75]  Joseph G Ibrahim,et al.  Joint modeling of survival and longitudinal non‐survival data: current methods and issues. Report of the DIA Bayesian joint modeling working group , 2015, Statistics in medicine.

[76]  J. Dupuy,et al.  Joint Modeling of Event Time and Nonignorable Missing Longitudinal Data , 2002, Lifetime data analysis.

[77]  Nicole A. Lazar,et al.  Statistical Analysis With Missing Data , 2003, Technometrics.

[78]  N M Laird,et al.  Model-based approaches to analysing incomplete longitudinal and failure time data. , 1997, Statistics in medicine.

[79]  D. Rubin,et al.  Maximum likelihood from incomplete data via the EM - algorithm plus discussions on the paper , 1977 .

[80]  Cécile Proust-Lima,et al.  Joint latent class models for longitudinal and time-to-event data: A review , 2014, Statistical methods in medical research.

[81]  Geoff Jones,et al.  Book Review: Joint Models for Longitudinal and Time-to-Event Data: With Applications in R, by Dimitris Rizopoulos , 2013 .

[82]  Keith R. Abrams,et al.  Joint Modeling of Longitudinal and Survival Data , 2013 .

[83]  Annie Chu,et al.  SOCR Analyses: Implementation and Demonstration of a New Graphical Statistics Educational Toolkit. , 2009, Journal of statistical software.

[84]  P. Royston,et al.  Flexible parametric proportional‐hazards and proportional‐odds models for censored survival data, with application to prognostic modelling and estimation of treatment effects , 2002, Statistics in medicine.

[85]  Roderick J. A. Little,et al.  Modeling the Drop-Out Mechanism in Repeated-Measures Studies , 1995 .

[86]  Yudi Pawitan,et al.  Modeling a Marker of Disease Progression and Onset of Disease , 1992 .

[87]  A. Farcomeni,et al.  A discrete time event-history approach to informative drop-out in multivariate latent Markov models with covariates , 2013, 1306.1678.

[88]  D. Rizopoulos,et al.  Repeated Measurements of NT-pro-B-Type Natriuretic Peptide, Troponin T or C-Reactive Protein Do Not Predict Future Allograft Rejection in Heart Transplant Recipients , 2015, Transplantation.

[89]  Cécile Proust-Lima,et al.  Joint modelling of multivariate longitudinal outcomes and a time-to-event: A nonlinear latent class approach , 2009, Comput. Stat. Data Anal..