Can Middle-School Science textbooks help students learn important ideas? Findings from project 2061's curriculum evaluation study: Life Science

The transfer of matter and energy from one organism to another and between organisms and their physical setting is a fundamental concept in life science. Not surprisingly, this concept is common to the Benchmarks for Science Literacy (American Association for the Advancement of Science, 1993), the National Science Education Standards (National Research Council, 1996), and most state frameworks and likely to appear in any middle-school science curriculum material. Nonetheless, while topics such as photosynthesis and cellular respiration have been taught for many years, research on student learning indicates that students have difficulties learning these ideas. In this study, nine middle-school curriculum materials—both widely used and newly developed—were examined in detail for their support of student learning ideas concerning matter and energy transformations in ecosystems specified in the national standards documents. The analysis procedure used in this study was previously developed and field tested by Project 2061 of the AAAS on a variety of curriculum materials. According to our findings, currently available curriculum materials provide little support for the attainment of the key ideas chosen for this study. In general, these materials do not take into account students' prior knowledge, lack representations to clarify abstract ideas, and are deficient in phenomena that can be explained by the key ideas and hence can make them plausible. This article concludes with a discussion of the implications of this study to curriculum development, teaching, and science education research based on shortcomings in today's curricula. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Res Sci Teach 41: 538–568, 2004

[1]  James R. Okey,et al.  A meta-analysis of the effects of various science teaching strategies on achievement , 1983 .

[2]  S. Kesidou Aligning Curriculum Materials with National Science Standards: The Role of Project 2061's Curriculum-Materials Analysis Procedure in Professional Development , 2001 .

[3]  C. W. Anderson,et al.  Changing middle school students' conceptions of matter and molecules , 1990 .

[4]  Jo Ellen Roseman,et al.  Project 2061 analyses of middle-school science textbooks: A response to holliday , 2003 .

[5]  Edmund A. Marek,et al.  An educational theory base for science teaching , 1990 .

[6]  Miles Barker,et al.  Teaching and learning about photosynthesis. Part 1: An assessment in terms of students’ prior knowledge , 1989 .

[7]  James H. Wandersee,et al.  Can the history of science help science educators anticipate students' misconceptions? , 1986 .

[8]  William H. Schmidt,et al.  A splintered vision : an investigation of U.S. science and mathematics education , 1997 .

[9]  Ruth Stavy,et al.  How students aged 13‐15 understand photosynthesis , 1987 .

[10]  Audrey B. Champagne,et al.  Instructional Consequences of Students' Knowledge about Physical Phenomena. , 1986 .

[11]  Charles W. Anderson,et al.  The Effects of Instruction on College Nonmajors' Conceptions of Respiration and Photosynthesis. Research Series No. 164. , 1990 .

[12]  Carol L. Smith,et al.  Understanding models and their use in science: Conceptions of middle and high school students and experts , 1991 .

[13]  D. B. Guralnik,et al.  Webster's New World college dictionary , 1997 .

[14]  Lillian C. McDermott,et al.  Millikan Lecture 1990: What we teach and what is learned—Closing the gap , 1991 .

[15]  D. Ball,et al.  Using Textbooks and Teachers' Guides: A Dilemma for Beginning Teachers and Teacher Educators , 1988 .

[16]  Jo Ellen Roseman,et al.  How well do middle school science programs measure up? Findings from Project 2061's curriculum review , 2002 .

[17]  A. Ahlgren,et al.  Science for all Americans , 1990 .

[18]  Pamela Joy Mulhall,et al.  What is the purpose of this experiment? Or can students learn something from doing experiments? , 2000 .

[19]  J. Shea National Science Education Standards , 1995 .

[20]  Charles W. Anderson,et al.  The Power Plant: Teacher's Guide to Photosynthesis. Occasional Paper No. 112. , 1987 .

[21]  L. Shulman Knowledge and Teaching: Foundations of the New Reform , 1987 .

[22]  John W. Renner,et al.  Understandings and misunderstandings of eighth graders of five chemistry concepts found in textbooks , 1992 .

[23]  John Leach,et al.  Children's ideas about ecology 2: ideas found in children aged 5‐16 about the cycling of matter , 1996 .

[24]  Charles W. Anderson,et al.  Student conceptions of natural selection and its role in evolution , 1986 .

[25]  R. Driver,et al.  Making Sense of Secondary Science: Research into children’s ideas , 1993 .

[26]  Rand J. Spiro,et al.  Multiple analogies for complex concepts: antidotes for analogy-induced misconception in advanced knowledge acquisition , 1988 .

[27]  Britta Carlsson Ecological understanding 2: Transformation - a key to ecological understanding , 2002 .

[28]  Rand J. Spiro,et al.  Cognitive flexibility theory : advanced knowledge acquisition in ill-structured domains , 1988 .

[29]  P. Thagard,et al.  Analogy, Explanation, and Education. , 1992 .

[30]  Edmund A. Marek,et al.  Understandings and Misconceptions of Biology Concepts Held by Students Attending Small High Schools and Students Attending Large High Schools. , 1988 .

[31]  Ann L. Brown,et al.  How people learn: Brain, mind, experience, and school. , 1999 .

[32]  P. Hewson,et al.  Accommodation of a scientific conception: Toward a theory of conceptual change , 1982 .

[33]  Janet F. Eaton,et al.  Students' Misconceptions Interfere with Science Learning: Case Studies of Fifth-Grade Students , 1984, The Elementary School Journal.

[34]  Mary Ann Brearton,et al.  Racing a Comet. , 1999 .

[35]  John Leach,et al.  Children's ideas about ecology 3: ideas found in children aged 5‐16 about the interdependency of organisms , 1996 .

[36]  Luli Stern Reply: Analysis of students' assessments in curriculum materials: Fidelity to national standards , 2003 .

[37]  Ruth Stavy,et al.  Using analogy to overcome misconceptions about conservation of matter , 1991 .

[38]  Comment: Aiming precisely at standards that are not there: Kinetic molecular theory, scientific theories, and national standards , 2003 .

[39]  Edmund A. Marek,et al.  Understandings and misunderstandings of eighth graders of four physics concepts found in textbooks , 1990 .

[40]  Luli Stern,et al.  Analysis of students' assessments in middle school curriculum materials: Aiming precisely at benchmarks and standards , 2002 .

[41]  Edward L. Smith,et al.  Teaching strategies associated with conceptual change learning in Science , 1993 .

[42]  Britta Carlsson,et al.  Ecological understanding 1: Ways of experiencing photosynthesis , 2002 .