Good intentions are not enough: how informatics interventions can worsen inequality

Health informatics interventions are designed to help people avoid, recover from, or cope with disease and disability, or to improve the quality and safety of healthcare. Unfortunately, they pose a risk of producing intervention-generated inequalities (IGI) by disproportionately benefiting more advantaged people. In this perspective paper, we discuss characteristics of health-related interventions known to produce IGI, explain why health informatics interventions are particularly vulnerable to this phenomenon, and describe safeguards that can be implemented to improve health equity. We provide examples in which health informatics interventions produced inequality because they were more accessible to, heavily used by, adhered to, or effective for those from socioeconomically advantaged groups. We provide a brief outline of precautions that intervention developers and implementers can take to guard against creating or worsening inequality through health informatics. We conclude by discussing evaluation approaches that will ensure that IGIs are recognized and studied.

[1]  Wolfgang Stroebe,et al.  Social Psychology and Health , 1995 .

[2]  M. Petticrew,et al.  Erratum to: Are interventions to promote healthy eating equally effective for all? Systematic review of socioeconomic inequalities in impact , 2015, BMC Public Health.

[3]  Dana P. Goldman,et al.  A Theory of Health Disparities and Medical Technology , 2005 .

[4]  Brian A. King,et al.  Current Cigarette Smoking Among Adults — United States, 2016 , 2015, MMWR. Morbidity and mortality weekly report.

[5]  Sunmoo Yoon,et al.  Sometimes more is more: iterative participatory design of infographics for engagement of community members with varying levels of health literacy , 2016, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[6]  Jianhua Li,et al.  Digital Partnerships for Health: Steps to develop a community-specific health portal aimed at promoting health and well-being , 2007, AMIA.

[7]  Thomas N Friemel,et al.  The digital divide has grown old: Determinants of a digital divide among seniors , 2016, New Media Soc..

[8]  J. Weinstein,et al.  Communities in Action: Pathways to Health Equity , 2017 .

[9]  H. Bersani,et al.  Disability and Public Health , 2009 .

[10]  Gerard P. van Galen,et al.  The Role of Size of an Augmented Force Field in Computer-Aided Target Acquisition Tasks , 2005, International journal of human computer interactions.

[11]  Michael B. Spring,et al.  Designing websites for persons with cognitive deficits: Design and usability of a psychoeducational intervention for persons with severe mental illness. , 2007, Psychological services.

[12]  Lyndal Trevena,et al.  Exploring patient involvement in healthcare decision making across different education and functional health literacy groups. , 2009, Social science & medicine.

[13]  N. Barengo,et al.  Weight loss by mobile phone: a 1-year effectiveness study , 2009, Public Health Nutrition.

[14]  Jessica S. Ancker,et al.  Access policy and the digital divide in patient access to medical records , 2017 .

[15]  E. Rogers,et al.  Diffusion of innovations , 1964, Encyclopedia of Sport Management.

[16]  Bob Lee,et al.  Age differences in constraints encountered by seniors in their use of computers and the internet , 2011, Comput. Hum. Behav..

[17]  Bruce G. Link,et al.  Is Racism a Fundamental Cause of Inequalities in Health , 2015 .

[18]  C. Botella,et al.  Predictors of treatment dropout in self-guided web-based interventions for depression: an ‘individual patient data’ meta-analysis , 2015, Psychological Medicine.

[19]  Anke Oenema,et al.  Short- and Medium-Term Efficacy of a Web-Based Computer-Tailored Nutrition Education Intervention for Adults Including Cognitive and Environmental Feedback: Randomized Controlled Trial , 2015, Journal of medical Internet research.

[20]  Michitaka Hirose,et al.  Elderly User Evaluation of Mobile Touchscreen Interactions , 2011, INTERACT.

[21]  J. Mackenbach,et al.  Material, psychosocial, and behavioural factors in the explanation of educational inequalities in mortality in the Netherlands , 2005, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health.

[22]  Chuan Zhou,et al.  Engagement in "My Child's Asthma", an interactive web-based pediatric asthma management intervention , 2011, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[23]  L. Iezzoni,et al.  Eliminating health and health care disparities among the growing population of people with disabilities. , 2011, Health affairs.

[24]  Tiffany C. Veinot,et al.  User acceptance of location-tracking technologies in health research: Implications for study design and data quality , 2018, J. Biomed. Informatics.

[25]  Ilkka Korhonen,et al.  Personal Health Technologies in Employee Health Promotion: Usage Activity, Usefulness, and Health-Related Outcomes in a 1-Year Randomized Controlled Trial , 2013, JMIR mHealth and uHealth.

[26]  Andy J. King,et al.  Utilization of Internet Technology by Low-Income Adults , 2010, Journal of aging and health.

[27]  Panayiotis Zaphiris,et al.  Interactive Software Technology for Deaf Users: Mapping the HCI Research Landscape that Focuses on Accessibility , 2015, HCI.

[28]  Andrew J. Campbell,et al.  Research: Ageing, social capital and the Internet: Findings from an exploratory study of Australian ‘silver surfers’ , 2008, Australasian journal on ageing.

[29]  Stuart Linke,et al.  Internet-Based Interactive Health Intervention for the Promotion of Sensible Drinking: Patterns of Use and Potential Impact on Members of the General Public , 2007, Journal of medical Internet research.

[30]  R. Street,et al.  Increasing patient involvement in choosing treatment for early breast cancer , 1995, Cancer.

[31]  Kathryn Zickuhr,et al.  Who’s Not Online and Why , 2013 .

[32]  Ingoo Han,et al.  The role of trust belief and its antecedents in a community-driven knowledge environment , 2009, J. Assoc. Inf. Sci. Technol..

[33]  C. Schnohr,et al.  Risk factors for not completing health interventions and the potential impact on health inequalities between educational groups – a mixed method study from Denmark , 2016, International Journal for Equity in Health.

[34]  Thomas Strothotte,et al.  Interactive Graphical Reading Aids for Functional IIIiterate Web Users , 2001, Mensch & Computer.

[35]  Brian G Danaher,et al.  Comparing Two Web-Based Smoking Cessation Programs: Randomized Controlled Trial , 2008, Journal of medical Internet research.

[36]  Tim Evans,et al.  Applying an equity lens to interventions: using PROGRESS ensures consideration of socially stratifying factors to illuminate inequities in health. , 2014, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[37]  Courtney R. Lyles,et al.  Brief communication: Patient-provider communication and trust in relation to use of an online patient portal among diabetes patients: The Diabetes and Aging Study , 2013, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[38]  Hans-Heinrich Bothe Human Computer Interaction and Communication Aids for Hearing-Impaired, Deaf and Deaf-Blind People: Introduction to the Special Thematic Session , 2008, ICCHP.

[39]  Michael D. Crandall,et al.  Opportunity for All: How the American Public Benefits from Internet Access at U.S. Libraries. , 2010 .

[40]  Ossi Rahkonen,et al.  Multiple measures of socioeconomic circumstances and common mental disorders. , 2006, Social science & medicine.

[41]  Bruce G. Link,et al.  Trends in education gradients of 'preventable' mortality: a test of fundamental cause theory. , 2015, Social science & medicine.

[42]  Theresa Devine,et al.  Designing Health Literate Mobile Apps , 2014 .

[43]  B. Grant,et al.  Epidemiology of major depressive disorder: results from the National Epidemiologic Survey on Alcoholism and Related Conditions. , 2005, Archives of general psychiatry.

[44]  Stephen A. Brewster,et al.  SoundBar: exploiting multiple views in multimodal graph browsing , 2006, NordiCHI '06.

[45]  Anke Oenema,et al.  A Mobile Phone App Intervention Targeting Fruit and Vegetable Consumption: The Efficacy of Textual and Auditory Tailored Health Information Tested in a Randomized Controlled Trial , 2017 .

[46]  Nawaz Khan,et al.  Interactive visualization for low literacy users: from lessons learnt to design , 2012, CHI.

[47]  J. Ancker,et al.  Focus Section Health IT Usability: Applying a Task-Technology Fit Model to Adapt an Electronic Patient Portal for Patient Work , 2018, Applied Clinical Informatics.

[48]  Hein de Vries,et al.  Exploring the Efficacy and Moderators of Two Computer-Tailored Physical Activity Interventions for Older Adults: A Randomized Controlled Trial , 2010, Annals of behavioral medicine : a publication of the Society of Behavioral Medicine.

[49]  Adam Drewnowski,et al.  Does social class predict diet quality? , 2008, The American journal of clinical nutrition.

[50]  Robert Hurling,et al.  Rates and Determinants of Uptake and Use of an Internet Physical Activity and Weight Management Program in Office and Manufacturing Work Sites in England: Cohort Study , 2008, Journal of medical Internet research.

[51]  Warren J. Winkelman,et al.  Research Paper: Patient-Perceived Usefulness of Online Electronic Medical Records: Employing Grounded Theory in the Development of Information and Communication Technologies for Use by Patients Living with Chronic Illness , 2005, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[52]  Terrance R. Campbell,et al.  A question of trust: user-centered design requirements for an informatics intervention to promote the sexual health of African-American youth. , 2013, Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association : JAMIA.

[53]  D. Hawthorn,et al.  Possible implications of aging for interface designers , 2000, Interact. Comput..

[54]  Bruce G. Link,et al.  Stigma as a fundamental cause of population health inequalities. , 2013, American journal of public health.

[55]  Kathryn Oliver,et al.  Adverse effects of public health interventions: a conceptual framework , 2013, Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health.

[56]  Andrew Sears and Julie A. Jacko The human-computer interaction handbook , 2013 .

[57]  George Demiris,et al.  Review: Considerations for the Design of a Web-based Clinical Monitoring and Educational System for Elderly Patients , 2001, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[58]  Susannah Fox,et al.  Mobile health 2012 , 2012 .

[59]  H. L. García,et al.  Patrones de diseño para mejorar la accesibilidad y uso de aplicaciones sociales para adultos mayores , 2015 .

[60]  D. Magliano,et al.  The effect of obesity prevention interventions according to socioeconomic position: a systematic review , 2013, Obesity reviews : an official journal of the International Association for the Study of Obesity.

[61]  Alex Burdorf,et al.  Initial and Sustained Participation in an Internet-delivered Long-term Worksite Health Promotion Program on Physical Activity and Nutrition , 2012, Journal of medical Internet research.

[62]  J. Ancker Addressing Health Literacy and Numeracy Through Systems Approaches , 2017 .

[63]  S. Zbikowski,et al.  Utilization of a Web-Based vs Integrated Phone/Web Cessation Program Among 140,000 Tobacco Users: An Evaluation Across 10 Free State Quitlines , 2015, Journal of medical Internet research.

[64]  S. Kirkpatrick,et al.  Rose's population strategy of prevention need not increase social inequalities in health. , 2010, International journal of epidemiology.

[65]  T. Laveist,et al.  Attitudes about Racism, Medical Mistrust, and Satisfaction with Care among African American and White Cardiac Patients , 2000, Medical care research and review : MCRR.

[66]  J. H. Gelderblom,et al.  Designing technology for young children: guidelines grounded in a literature investigation on child development and children's technology , 2008 .

[67]  Tiffany C. Veinot,et al.  Transforming consumer health informatics through a patient work framework: connecting patients to context , 2015, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[68]  Alexa T McCray,et al.  Application of Information Technology: Promoting Health Literacy , 2005, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[69]  S. Alfonsson,et al.  Motivation and Treatment Credibility Predicts Dropout, Treatment Adherence, and Clinical Outcomes in an Internet-Based Cognitive Behavioral Relaxation Program: A Randomized Controlled Trial , 2016, Journal of medical Internet research.

[70]  Carol M. Mangione,et al.  Disparities in health and health care , 2001, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[71]  Urmimala Sarkar,et al.  Barriers and Facilitators to Online Portal Use Among Patients and Caregivers in a Safety Net Health Care System: A Qualitative Study , 2015, Journal of medical Internet research.

[72]  Christina R. Victor,et al.  A Primary Care Nurse-Delivered Walking Intervention in Older Adults: PACE (Pedometer Accelerometer Consultation Evaluation)-Lift Cluster Randomised Controlled Trial , 2015, PLoS medicine.

[73]  Andrea Barsevick,et al.  The Personal Patient Profile-Prostate decision support for men with localized prostate cancer: a multi-center randomized trial. , 2013, Urologic oncology.

[74]  Rik Crutzen,et al.  Investigating Predictors of Visiting, Using, and Revisiting an Online Health-Communication Program: A Longitudinal Study , 2010, Journal of medical Internet research.

[75]  Beenish Chaudry,et al.  Mobile interface design for low-literacy populations , 2012, IHI '12.

[76]  Cindy Brach,et al.  Developing and testing the health literacy universal precautions toolkit. , 2011, Nursing outlook.

[77]  I. White,et al.  Attrition Revisited: Adherence and Retention in a Web-Based Alcohol Trial , 2013, Journal of medical Internet research.

[78]  P. Verboon,et al.  Long-term effects of a web-based cancer aftercare intervention on moderate physical activity and vegetable consumption among early cancer survivors: a randomized controlled trial , 2017, International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity.

[79]  Rik Crutzen,et al.  Effects of a Web-Based Computer-Tailored Game to Reduce Binge Drinking Among Dutch Adolescents: A Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial , 2016, Journal of Medical Internet Research.

[80]  Joseph Sharit,et al.  Usability of an Electronic Personal Health Record (PHR) Among a Diverse Group of Adults , 2014 .

[81]  Ricardo Mendoza-González,et al.  Design Patterns to Enhance Accessibility and Use of Social Applications for Older Adults , 2015 .

[82]  B. Crabtree,et al.  Doing Qualitative Research , 1999 .

[83]  P M Garvey,et al.  Age differences in dynamic contrast thresholds. , 1992, Journal of gerontology.

[84]  S. Macintyre Inequalities in health in Scotland: what are they and what can we do about them , 2007 .

[85]  M. Farage,et al.  Design Principles to Accommodate Older Adults , 2012, Global journal of health science.

[86]  E. V. van Sluijs,et al.  Exploring equity in primary-care-based physical activity interventions using PROGRESS-Plus: a systematic review and evidence synthesis , 2016, International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity.

[87]  Peter Gregor,et al.  Information technology for cognitive support , 2002 .

[88]  Peter Tugwell,et al.  What types of interventions generate inequalities? Evidence from systematic reviews , 2012, Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health.

[89]  Thea van der Geest,et al.  Testing the visual consistency of web sites , 2005 .

[90]  Bruce G. Link,et al.  Sexual Orientation Disparities in Preventable Disease: A Fundamental Cause Perspective. , 2016, American journal of public health.

[91]  Maulik S Joshi,et al.  Progress toward meaningful use: hospitals' adoption of electronic health records. , 2011, The American journal of managed care.

[92]  H. de Vries,et al.  The differentiated effectiveness of a printed versus a Web-based tailored physical activity intervention among adults aged over 50. , 2014, Health education research.

[93]  A. Bauman,et al.  Improved eating behaviours mediate weight gain prevention of young adults: moderation and mediation results of a randomised controlled trial of TXT2BFiT, mHealth program , 2016, International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity.

[94]  F. Altice,et al.  Effectiveness of antiretroviral therapy among HIV-infected prisoners: reincarceration and the lack of sustained benefit after release to the community. , 2004, Clinical infectious diseases : an official publication of the Infectious Diseases Society of America.

[95]  E. Im,et al.  Quota sampling in internet research: practical issues. , 2011, Computers, informatics, nursing : CIN.

[96]  Katherine M Flegal,et al.  Obesity and socioeconomic status in children and adolescents: United States, 2005-2008. , 2010, NCHS data brief.

[97]  Quality,et al.  National Healthcare Disparities Report , 2014 .

[98]  K. Hesketh,et al.  A Review of the Relationship Between Socioeconomic Position and the Early-Life Predictors of Obesity , 2015, Current Obesity Reports.

[99]  Terrance R. Campbell,et al.  A question of trust: user-centered design requirements for an informatics intervention to promote the sexual health of African-American youth. , 2013, Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association : JAMIA.

[100]  Charles Senteio,et al.  Trying to Make Things Right , 2014, Qualitative health research.

[101]  Helen Osborne,et al.  Health Literacy: How Visuals Can Help Tell the Healthcare Story , 2006, Journal of visual communication in medicine.

[102]  Matt Huenerfauth,et al.  Evaluating American Sign Language generation through the participation of native ASL signers , 2007, Assets '07.

[103]  Jessica S. Ancker,et al.  Use of an Electronic Patient Portal Among Disadvantaged Populations , 2011, Journal of general internal medicine.

[104]  W. Silverman,et al.  Predictors of treatment dropout , 2012 .

[105]  K. G I S K E S,et al.  Applying an Equity Lens to Tobacco-Control Policies and Their Uptake in Six Western-European Countries , 2007 .

[106]  Bruce G. Link,et al.  Social Conditions as Fundamental Causes of Health Inequalities: Theory, Evidence, and Policy Implications , 2010, Journal of health and social behavior.

[107]  J. Simoni,et al.  Are Peer Interventions for HIV Efficacious? A Systematic Review , 2011, AIDS and Behavior.

[108]  Anne Collins McLaughlin,et al.  Designing Displays for Older Adults , 2010 .

[109]  T. Eikemo,et al.  Technological innovations and the rise of social inequalities in health , 2017, Scandinavian journal of public health.

[110]  E. Katkin,et al.  Randomized Controlled Trial of an Interactive Internet Smoking Cessation Program with Long-Term Follow-up , 2010, Annals of behavioral medicine : a publication of the Society of Behavioral Medicine.

[111]  G. Parker,et al.  Feasibility and Effectiveness of a Web-Based Positive Psychology Program for Youth Mental Health: Randomized Controlled Trial , 2014, Journal of medical Internet research.

[112]  Simon P. Kim,et al.  Health Literacy and Shared Decision Making for Prostate Cancer Patients with Low Socioeconomic Status , 2001, Cancer investigation.

[113]  A. Jawaid Literacy and Misunderstanding Prescription Drug Labels , 2007, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[114]  Kirsikka Kaipainen,et al.  Mindless Eating Challenge: Retention, Weight Outcomes, and Barriers for Changes in a Public Web-Based Healthy Eating and Weight Loss Program , 2012, Journal of medical Internet research.

[115]  Trisha Greenhalgh,et al.  Health literacy: towards system level solutions , 2015, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[116]  Jessica S Ancker,et al.  Review Paper: Rethinking Health Numeracy: A Multidisciplinary Literature Review , 2007, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[117]  Ichiro Kawachi,et al.  Health disparities by race and class: why both matter. , 2005, Health affairs.

[118]  Nicol Nijland,et al.  Factors Influencing the Use of a Web-Based Application for Supporting the Self-Care of Patients with Type 2 Diabetes: A Longitudinal Study , 2011, Journal of medical Internet research.

[119]  Anton J. Kuzel,et al.  Sampling in qualitative inquiry. , 1992 .

[120]  David C. Kaelber,et al.  Patient portals and broadband internet inequality , 2017, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[121]  K. Stronks,et al.  Explaining educational differences in mortality: the role of behavioral and material factors. , 1999, American journal of public health.

[122]  Alain B Labrique,et al.  Tailored, interactive text messages for enhancing weight loss among African American adults: the TRIMM randomized controlled trial. , 2015, The American journal of medicine.

[123]  S. Babones Social inequality and public health , 2009 .

[124]  Stephan Rössner,et al.  The Change in Eating Behaviors in a Web-Based Weight Loss Program: A Longitudinal Analysis of Study Completers , 2014, Journal of medical Internet research.

[125]  Bruce G. Link,et al.  Controlling disease and creating disparities: a fundamental cause perspective. , 2005, The journals of gerontology. Series B, Psychological sciences and social sciences.

[126]  Wayne Katon,et al.  Socioeconomic status, depression disparities, and financial strain: what lies behind the income-depression relationship? , 2005, Health economics.

[127]  Hironobu Takagi,et al.  Making multimedia content accessible for screen reader users , 2007, W4A '07.

[128]  G. Bolte,et al.  Impact of universal interventions on social inequalities in physical activity among older adults: an equity-focused systematic review , 2017, International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity.

[129]  K. Glanz,et al.  Diffusion of innovations , 2008 .

[130]  Suzanne M. Miller,et al.  A Web‐based communication aid for patients with cancer , 2013, Cancer.

[131]  A. Vandal,et al.  Participant Recruitment and Engagement in Automated eHealth Trial Registration: Challenges and Opportunities for Recruiting Women Who Experience Violence , 2016, Journal of medical Internet research.

[132]  Susan S. Woods,et al.  Barriers and drivers of health information technology use for the elderly, chronically ill, and underserved. , 2008, Evidence report/technology assessment.

[133]  H. Egeth,et al.  Using pictographs to enhance recall of spoken medical instructions II. , 1998, Patient education and counseling.

[134]  Susanne Pedersen,et al.  Attrition and Adherence in a Web-Based Distress Management Program for Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillator Patients (WEBCARE): Randomized Controlled Trial , 2014, Journal of medical Internet research.

[135]  J. Heffner,et al.  Predictors of Utilization of a Novel Smoking Cessation Smartphone App. , 2015, Telemedicine journal and e-health : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[136]  Jessica S. Ancker,et al.  Expanding access to high-quality plain-language patient education information through context-specific hyperlinks , 2016, AMIA.

[137]  B. Klein,et al.  Pretreatment Attrition and Formal Withdrawal During Treatment and Their Predictors: An Exploratory Study of the Anxiety Online Data , 2014, Journal of medical Internet research.

[138]  Judith H Hibbard,et al.  How engaged are consumers in their health and health care, and why does it matter? , 2008, Research brief.

[139]  Sarah M. Greene,et al.  The Role of Engagement in a Tailored Web-Based Smoking Cessation Program: Randomized Controlled Trial , 2008, Journal of medical Internet research.

[140]  Brian A. King,et al.  Current Cigarette Smoking Among Adults - United States, 2005-2015. , 2016, MMWR. Morbidity and mortality weekly report.

[141]  Peter Heywood,et al.  How and why do interventions that increase health overall widen inequalities within populations , 2009 .

[142]  T. Veinot,et al.  Comparative Analysis of Recruitment Strategies in a Study of Men Who Have Sex with Men (MSM) in Metropolitan Detroit , 2018, AIDS and Behavior.

[143]  W. Horner-Johnson,et al.  Chapter 8Health of People with Disabilities: Determinants and Disparities , 2009 .

[144]  Robert Nguyen,et al.  Social disparities in internet patient portal use in diabetes: evidence that the digital divide extends beyond access , 2011, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..