The use of numerical methods such as finite elements to make accurate predictions of failure or collapse of geomaterials must utilize a suitable failure criterion that is able to represent the shear strength for all stress paths likely to be encountered. The best-known failure criterion is that of Mohr-Coulomb, but several others have been proposed. Using a dimensionless form of principal stress space, this paper reviews some of these other criteria in a unified way by presenting them in terms of the equivalent Mohr-Coulomb friction angle implied at various locations on their periphery. Circular conical surfaces in stress space can greatly overestimate the strength of soil for certain stress paths, and sometimes contain singularities as implied by an equivalent friction angle of 90°. Noncircular conical surfaces have also been considered. These give a more acceptable range of equivalent friction angles, as they are based on actual test data. These “sophisticated” criteria can still predict equivalent friction angles that differ from each other by several degrees, however.
[1]
A. Bishop.
The Strength of Soils as Engineering Materials
,
1966
.
[2]
Zenon Mróz,et al.
On the description of anisotropic workhardening
,
1967
.
[3]
P. A. Vermeer,et al.
A double hardening model for sand
,
1978
.
[4]
Jean H. Prevost,et al.
A simple plasticity theory for frictional cohesionless soils
,
1985
.
[5]
D. V. Griffiths.
Some theoretical observations on conical failure criteria in principal stress space
,
1986
.
[6]
D. V. Griffiths,et al.
The properties of anisotropic conical failure surfaces in relation to the Mohr–Coulomb criterion
,
1988
.
[7]
D. V. Griffiths,et al.
Programming the finite element method (2nd ed.)
,
1988
.