Enhancing the reliability of benefit transfer over heterogeneous sites: A meta-analysis of international coral reef values

We estimate a meta-analysis of willingness to pay for tropical coral reef recreation and evaluate its potential for international benefit transfer. The goal is improved value surface estimation and benefit transfer reliability. We compare model results to those of Brander, L., P. van Beukering and H. Cesar. 2007. The recreational value of coral reefs: A meta-analysis. Ecological Economics, 63(1), to our knowledge the only prior published meta-analysis of coral reef values. We seek to improve upon this prior model through (1) stricter attendance to methodological guidance in the meta-analysis literature, (2) greater attention to metadata uniformity, and (3) supplementation of primary study metadata with additional information obtained through secondary sources, such as information on reef characteristics from international coral reef databases. The estimated models provide value surface insights unavailable elsewhere and improve benefit transfer reliability. Results also highlight challenges in benefit transfer across heterogeneous sites and provide insight into the relevance of welfare consistency for meta-analysis. While the analysis suggests that substantial improvements in transfer reliability may be achieved through closer adherence to guidance from the meta-analysis literature, resulting transfers may still be subject to considerable errors.

[1]  Robert J. Johnston,et al.  What Determines Willingness to Pay per Fish? A Meta-Analysis of Recreational Fishing Values , 2006, Marine Resource Economics.

[2]  Marisol Rivera-Planter,et al.  Fees for Reefs: Economic Instruments to Protect Mexico’s Marine Natural Areas , 2005 .

[4]  Mahfuzuddin Ahmed,et al.  Economic valuation and policy priorities for sustainable management of coral reefs , 2004 .

[5]  Brett Day,et al.  Benefit Transfer in Europe: How Reliable Are Transfers between Countries? , 2004 .

[6]  T. Park,et al.  Valuing snorkeling visits to the Florida Keys with stated and revealed preference models. , 2002, Journal of environmental management.

[7]  G. Parsons,et al.  Valuing Changes in the Quality of Coral Reef Ecosystems: A Stated Preference Study of SCUBA Diving in the Bonaire National Marine Park , 2008 .

[8]  Luke Brander,et al.  The recreational value of coral reefs: A meta-analysis , 2007 .

[9]  John B. Loomis,et al.  Panel Stratification in Meta-Analysis of Economic Studies: An Investigation of Its Effects in the Recreation Valuation Literature , 2000, Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics.

[10]  John B. Loomis,et al.  Reducing barriers in future benefit transfers: Needed improvements in primary study design and reporting , 2006 .

[11]  George Van Houtven,et al.  Benefit Transfer via Preference Calibration: “Prudential Algebra” for Policy , 2002, Land Economics.

[12]  Klaus Moeltner,et al.  Predicting Resource Policy Outcomes via Meta-Regression: Data Space, Model Space, and the Quest for 'Optimal Scope' , 2008 .

[13]  John C. Bergstrom,et al.  Using meta-analysis for benefits transfer: Theory and practice , 2006 .

[14]  H. Cesar,et al.  Economic Valuation of the Coral Reefs of Hawai'i , 2004 .

[15]  B. H. Yeo.  The recreational benefits of coral reefs: a case study of Pulau Payar Marine Park, Kedah, Malaysia , 2004 .

[16]  R. Johnston,et al.  Methods, Trends and Controversies in Contemporary Benefit Transfer , 2009 .

[17]  Subhrendu K. Pattanayak,et al.  Is Meta-Analysis a Noah's Ark for Non-Market Valuation? , 2002 .

[18]  Mizna Mohamed.  Economic valuation of coral reefs: a case study of the costs and benefits of improved management of Dhigali Haa, a marine protected area in Baa atoll, Maldives , 2008 .

[19]  George Van Houtven,et al.  Valuing water quality improvements in the United States using meta-analysis: Is the glass half-full or half-empty for national policy analysis? , 2007 .

[20]  John B. Loomis,et al.  Testing a meta-analysis model for benefit transfer in international outdoor recreation , 2001 .

[21]  Robert J. Johnston,et al.  Systematic Variation in Willingness to Pay for Aquatic Resource Improvements and Implications for Benefit Transfer: A Meta-Analysis , 2005 .

[22]  B. Hasler,et al.  Making Benefit Transfers Work: Deriving and Testing Principles for Value Transfers for Similar and Dissimilar Sites Using a Case Study of the Non-Market Benefits of Water Quality Improvements Across Europe , 2011 .

[23]  Klaus Moeltner,et al.  Meta-analysis and benefit transfer for resource valuation-addressing classical challenges with Bayesian modeling , 2007 .

[24]  Mahfuzuddin Ahmed,et al.  Valuing recreational and conservation benefits of coral reefs—The case of Bolinao, Philippines , 2007 .

[25]  Ian J. Bateman,et al.  Contrasting conventional with multi-level modelling approaches to meta-analysis: expectation consistency in UK woodland recreation values. , 2003 .

[26]  R. Kramer,et al.  Divers’ willingness to pay to visit marine sanctuaries: an exploratory study ☆ , 2002 .

[27]  T. Hundloe.  Measuring the value of the Great Barrier Reef. , 1990 .

[28]  Kevin J. Boyle,et al.  Valuing public goods: discrete versus continuous contingent-valuation responses. , 1996 .

[29]  C. Oh,et al.  The Economic Value of Scuba-Diving Use of Natural and Artificial Reef Habitats , 2008 .

[30]  John A. List,et al.  What Experimental Protocol Influence Disparities Between Actual and Hypothetical Stated Values? , 2001 .

[31]  Peter E. Kennedy,et al.  The Use (and Abuse) of Meta-analysis in Environmental and Natural Resource Economics: an Assessment , 2022 .

[32]  Jean C. Buzby,et al.  Differences between continuous and discrete contingent value estimates , 1996 .

[33]  B. Salvat.  Coral reefs — a challenging ecosystem for human societies , 1992 .

[34]  R. Mendelsohn,et al.  Valuing Coral Reefs: A Travel Cost Analysis of the Great Barrier Reef , 2003, Ambio.

[35]  Randall S. Rosenberger,et al.  Selection Effects in Meta-Analysis and Benefit Transfer: Avoiding Unintended Consequences , 2009, Land Economics.

[36]  Randall S. Rosenberger,et al.  Measurement, generalization, and publication: Sources of error in benefit transfers and their management , 2006 .

[37]  J. Dixon,et al.  Meeting ecological and economic goals: marine parks in the Caribbean , 1993 .

[38]  U. Seenprachawong.  Economic valuation of coral reefs at Phi Phi Islands, Thailand , 2003 .

[39]  Clive Wilkinson,et al.  Status of the coral reefs of the world: 2008 , 2008 .

[40]  I. Langford,et al.  Valuing marine parks in a developing country: a case study of the Seychelles , 2003, Environment and Development Economics.

[41]  David F. Layton,et al.  Embracing Model Uncertainty: Strategies for Response Pooling and Model Averaging , 2006 .

[42]  Robert J. Johnston,et al.  Meta-Analysis, Benefit Transfer, and Methodological Covariates: Implications for Transfer Error , 2009 .

[43]  R. Johnston,et al.  Valuing Farmland Protection: Do Empirical Results and Policy Guidance Depend on the Econometric Fine Print? , 2011 .

[44]  Ian J. Bateman,et al.  Elicitation and truncation effects in contingent valuation studies , 1995 .

[45]  S. Navrud,et al.  Environmental Valuation – To Use or Not to Use? A Comparative Study of the United States and Europe , 1997 .

[46]  Alan T. White,et al.  Using integrated coastal management and economics to conserve coastal tourism resources in Sri Lanka. , 1997 .

[47]  Richard T. Carson,et al.  Contingent Valuation and Revealed Preference Methodologies: Comparing the Estimates for Quasi-Public Goods , 1995 .

[48]  Henrik Lindhjem,et al.  How Reliable are Meta-Analyses for International Benefit Transfers? , 2007 .

[49]  Robert J. Johnston,et al.  Willingness to Pay for Water Quality Improvements in the United States and Canada: Considering Possibilities for International Meta-Analysis and Benefit Transfer , 2010, Agricultural and Resource Economics Review.

[50]  Andrew Schmitz,et al.  The Welfare Economics of Public Policy: A Practical Approach to Project and Policy Evaluation , 2005 .

[51]  Klaus Moeltner,et al.  Meta-Modeling and Benefit Transfer: The Empirical Relevance of Source-Consistency in Welfare Measures , 2013, Environmental and Resource Economics.

[52]  Yong-Suhk Wui,et al.  The economic value of wetland services: a meta-analysis , 2001 .

[53]  Roy Brouwer,et al.  The Validity of Environmental Benefits Transfer: Further Empirical Testing , 1999 .

[54]  Trudy Ann Cameron,et al.  Combining Contingent Valuation and Travel Cost Data for the Valuation of Nonmarket Goods , 1992 .

[55]  James J. Murphy,et al.  A Meta-analysis of Hypothetical Bias in Stated Preference Valuation , 2003 .

[56]  Nick Hanley,et al.  How Can We Reduce the Errors from Benefits Transfer? An Investigation Using the Choice Experiment Method , 2008, Land Economics.

[57]  M. Bhat.  Application of non-market valuation to the Florida Keys marine reserve management. , 2003, Journal of environmental management.

[58]  J. Asafu-Adjaye,et al.  A contingent valuation study of scuba diving benefits: Case study in Mu Ko Similan Marine National Park, Thailand , 2008 .

[59]  J. Andersson.  The recreational cost of coral bleaching -- A stated and revealed preference study of international tourists , 2007 .

[60]  Ståle Navrud,et al.  International benefit transfer: Methods and validity tests , 2006 .