Quantifying the interplay of experimental constraints in analyses of parton distributions

Parton distribution functions (PDFs) play a central role in calculations for the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). To gain a deeper understanding of the emergence and interplay of constraints on the PDFs in the global QCD analyses, it is important to examine the relative significance and mutual compatibility of the experimental data sets included in the PDF fits. Toward this goal, we discuss the L2 sensitivity, a convenient statistical indicator for exploring the statistical pulls of individual data sets on the best-fit PDFs and identifying tensions between competing data sets. Unlike the Lagrange Multiplier method, the L2 sensitivity can be quickly computed for a range of PDFs and momentum fractions using the published Hessian error sets. We employ the L2 sensitivity as a common metric to study the relative importance of data sets in the recent ATLAS, CTEQ-TEA, MSHT, and reduced PDF4LHC21 PDF analyses at NNLO and approximate N3LO. We illustrate how this method can aid the users of PDFs to identify data sets that are important for a PDF at a given kinematic point, to study quark flavor composition and other detailed features of the PDFs, and to compare the data pulls on the PDFs for various perturbative orders and functional forms. We also address the feasibility of computing the sensitivities using Monte Carlo error PDFs. Together with the article, we present a companion interactive website with a large collection of plotted L2 sensitivities for eight recent PDF releases.

[1]  S. Dulat,et al.  Precision studies of the post-CT18 LHC Drell-Yan data in the CTEQ-TEA global analysis , 2023, Physical Review D.

[2]  T. Hobbs,et al.  The Photon Content of the Neutron , 2023, 2305.10497.

[3]  D. Stump,et al.  High-energy neutrino deeply inelastic scattering cross sections from 100 GeV to 1000 EeV , 2023, 2303.13607.

[4]  Tie-Jiun Hou,et al.  Impact of lattice strangeness asymmetry data in the CTEQ-TEA global analysis , 2022, Physical Review D.

[5]  J. Huston,et al.  The persistent nonperturbative charm enigma , 2022, Physics Letters B.

[6]  J. McGowan,et al.  Approximate N$$^{3}$$LO parton distribution functions with theoretical uncertainties: MSHT20aN$$^3$$LO PDFs , 2022, The European Physical Journal C.

[7]  Alan D. Martin,et al.  The MSHT20 Parton Distribution Functions , 2022, SciPost Physics Proceedings.

[8]  P. Nadolsky,et al.  Parton distributions need representative sampling , 2022, Physical Review D.

[9]  S. G. Wang,et al.  Publisher Correction: The asymmetry of antimatter in the proton , 2022, Nature.

[10]  J. H. Weber,et al.  Snowmass 2021 Whitepaper: Proton Structure at the Precision Frontier , 2022, Acta Physica Polonica B.

[11]  J. Huston,et al.  The PDF4LHC21 combination of global PDF fits for the LHC Run III* , 2022, Journal of Physics G: Nuclear and Particle Physics.

[12]  Atlas Collaboration.  Determination of the parton distribution functions of the proton using diverse ATLAS data from $pp$ collisions at $\sqrt{s} = 7$, 8 and 13 TeV , 2021, 2112.11266.

[13]  A. Martin,et al.  QED parton distribution functions in the MSHT20 fit , 2021, The European Physical Journal C.

[14]  P. Nadolsky,et al.  CTEQ-TEA group updates: Photon PDF and Impact from heavy flavors in the CT18 global analysis , 2021, Proceedings of The European Physical Society Conference on High Energy Physics — PoS(EPS-HEP2021).

[15]  T. Cridge.  PDF4LHC21: Update on the benchmarking of the CT, MSHT and NNPDF global PDF fits , 2021, SciPost Physics Proceedings.

[16]  Jun Gao,et al.  General heavy-flavor mass scheme for charged-current DIS at NNLO and beyond , 2021, Physical Review D.

[17]  C. Yuan,et al.  Photon PDF within the CT18 global analysis , 2021, Physical Review D.

[18]  A. Martin,et al.  An investigation of the $$\alpha _S$$ and heavy quark mass dependence in the MSHT20 global PDF analysis , 2021, 2106.10289.

[19]  P. Nadolsky,et al.  Deuterium scattering experiments in CTEQ global QCD analyses: a comparative investigation , 2021, The European Physical Journal C.

[20]  D. H. Morton,et al.  The asymmetry of antimatter in the proton , 2021, Nature.

[21]  W. Y. Chan,et al.  Determination of the parton distribution functions of the proton from ATLAS measurements of differential W± and Z boson production in association with jets , 2021, Journal of High Energy Physics.

[22]  Alan D. Martin,et al.  Parton distributions from LHC, HERA, Tevatron and fixed target data: MSHT20 PDFs , 2020, The European Physical Journal C.

[23]  P. Nadolsky,et al.  Testing momentum dependence of the nonperturbative hadron structure in a global QCD analysis , 2020, 2011.10078.

[24]  B. Yoon,et al.  Probing nucleon strange and charm distributions with lattice QCD , 2020, Physical Review D.

[25]  J. Huston,et al.  New CTEQ global analysis of quantum chromodynamics with high-precision data from the LHC , 2019, 1912.10053.

[26]  S. Dulat,et al.  Updating and optimizing error parton distribution function sets in the Hessian approach. II. , 2019, Physical Review D.

[27]  L. Harland-Lang,et al.  Differential top quark pair production at the LHC: Challenges for PDF fits , 2019, The European Physical Journal C.

[28]  Pedro Antonio Gutiérrez,et al.  Measurement of the cross-section and charge asymmetry of W bosons produced in proton–proton collisions at $$\sqrt{s}=8~\text {TeV}$$ with the ATLAS detector , 2019, The European Physical Journal C.

[29]  Atlas Collaboration.  Measurements of top-quark pair differential and double-differential cross-sections in the $$\ell $$+jets channel with pp collisions at $$\sqrt{s}=13$$ TeV using the ATLAS detector , 2019, The European Physical Journal C.

[30]  R. Thorne,et al.  Updates of PDFs using the MMHT framework , 2019, Proceedings of XXVII International Workshop on Deep-Inelastic Scattering and Related Subjects — PoS(DIS2019).

[31]  R. Sarpong,et al.  Bio-inspired synthesis of xishacorenes A, B, and C, and a new congener from fuscol† †Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c9sc02572c , 2019, Chemical science.

[32]  D. Soper,et al.  Hadronic structure in high-energy collisions , 2019, 1905.06957.

[33]  W. Y. Chan,et al.  Measurement of the ratio of cross sections for inclusive isolated-photon production in pp collisions at √s = 13 and 8 TeV with the ATLAS detector , 2019 .

[34]  P. Nadolsky,et al.  Charting the coming synergy between lattice QCD and high-energy phenomenology , 2019, Physical Review D.

[35]  J. Pumplin,et al.  Updating and optimizing error parton distribution function sets in the Hessian approach , 2018, Physical Review D.

[36]  Alan D. Martin,et al.  Ad Lucem: The photon in the MMHT PDFs , 2018, Proceedings of XXVI International Workshop on Deep-Inelastic Scattering and Related Subjects — PoS(DIS2018).

[37]  Z. A. Ibrahim,et al.  Combination and QCD analysis of charm and beauty production cross-section measurements in deep inelastic ep scattering at HERA , 2018, Proceedings of The 39th International Conference on High Energy Physics — PoS(ICHEP2018).

[38]  Jun Gao,et al.  Mapping the sensitivity of hadronic experiments to nucleon structure , 2018, Physical Review D.

[39]  A. Gehrmann-De Ridder,et al.  Next-to-Next-to-Leading-Order QCD Corrections to the Transverse Momentum Distribution of Weak Gauge Bosons. , 2017, Physical review letters.

[40]  Alan D. Martin,et al.  The impact of LHC jet data on the MMHT PDF fit at NNLO , 2017, The European Physical Journal C.

[41]  A. Mitov,et al.  Top-pair production at the LHC through NNLO QCD and NLO EW , 2017, 1705.04105.

[42]  A. Mitov,et al.  fastNLO tables for NNLO top-quark pair differential distributions , 2017, 1704.08551.

[43]  A. Sirunyan.  Measurement of double-differential cross sections for top quark pair production in pp collisions at $\sqrt{s}$ = 8 TeV and impact on parton distribution functions , 2017 .

[44]  C. Focke,et al.  Color-singlet production at NNLO in MCFM , 2016, The European Physical Journal C.

[45]  J. Campbell,et al.  Direct Photon Production at Next-to-Next-to-Leading Order. , 2016, Physical review letters.

[46]  A. Mitov,et al.  Pinning down the large-x gluon with NNLO top-quark pair differential distributions , 2016, Journal of High Energy Physics.

[47]  Andrei,et al.  Measurement of top quark pair differential cross sections in the dilepton channel in pp collisions at ffiffi s p = 7 and 8 TeV with ATLAS , 2016, 1607.07281.

[48]  E. Glover,et al.  Next-to-Next-to Leading Order QCD Predictions for Single Jet Inclusive Production at the LHC. , 2016, Physical review letters.

[49]  Pedro Antonio Gutiérrez,et al.  Measurements of top-quark pair differential cross-sections in the lepton+jets channel in pp collisions at $$\sqrt{s}=8\,~{\mathrm {TeV}}$$ s = 8 TeV using the ATLAS detector , 2016, The European Physical Journal C.

[50]  J. Huston,et al.  CTEQ-TEA parton distribution functions and HERA Run i and II combined data , 2016, 1609.07968.

[51]  T. Tuuva,et al.  Measurement and QCD analysis of double-differential inclusive jet cross-sections in pp collisions at sqrt(s) = 8 TeV and ratios to 2.76 and 7 TeV , 2016, 1609.05331.

[52]  M. P. Casado,et al.  Measurement of the double-differential high-mass Drell-Yan cross section in pp collisions at s=8$$ \sqrt{s}=8 $$ TeV with the ATLAS detector , 2016 .

[53]  V. M. Ghete,et al.  Measurement of the differential cross section and charge asymmetry for inclusive [Formula: see text] production at [Formula: see text] TeV. , 2016, The European physical journal. C, Particles and fields.

[54]  J. Huston,et al.  Reconstruction of Monte Carlo replicas from Hessian parton distributions , 2016, 1607.06066.

[55]  Scoap.  Measurement of the transverse momentum and ϕη∗ distributions of Drell–Yan lepton pairs in proton–proton collisions at s=8 TeV with the ATLAS detector , 2016 .

[56]  A. A. Ocampo Rios,et al.  Measurement of the inclusive jet cross section in pp collisions at $$\sqrt{s} = 2.76\,\text {TeV}$$s=2.76TeV , 2016 .

[57]  S. Forte,et al.  Specialized minimal PDFs for optimized LHC calculations , 2016, The European physical journal. C, Particles and fields.

[58]  Atlas Collaboration.  Measurement of the transverse momentum and $\phi^*_{\eta}$ distributions of Drell-Yan lepton pairs in proton-proton collisions at $\sqrt{s}=8$ TeV with the ATLAS detector , 2015, 1512.02192.

[59]  C. Focke,et al.  Z-Boson Production in Association with a Jet at Next-To-Next-To-Leading Order in Perturbative QCD. , 2015, Physical review letters.

[60]  A. Gehrmann-De Ridder,et al.  Precise QCD Predictions for the Production of a Z Boson in Association with a Hadronic Jet. , 2015, Physical review letters.

[61]  Z. A. Ibrahim,et al.  Combination of measurements of inclusive deep inelastic $${e^{\pm }p}$$e±p scattering cross sections and QCD analysis of HERA data , 2015 .

[62]  K. Peters.  Higgs boson production at the LHC , 2015 .

[63]  J. Latorre,et al.  An unbiased Hessian representation for Monte Carlo PDFs , 2015, The European Physical Journal C.

[64]  S. M. Etesami,et al.  Measurement of the differential cross section for top quark pair production in pp collisions at $$\sqrt{s} = 8\,\text {TeV} $$s=8TeV , 2015 .

[65]  John M. Campbell,et al.  A multi-threaded version of MCFM , 2015, The European Physical Journal C.

[66]  Alan D. Martin,et al.  Parton distributions in the LHC era: MMHT 2014 PDFs , 2014, The European physical journal. C, Particles and fields.

[67]  J. T. Childers,et al.  Measurement of the inclusive jet cross-section in proton-proton collisions at s=7$$ \sqrt{s}=7 $$ TeV using 4.5 fb−1 of data with the ATLAS detector , 2014, 1410.8857.

[68]  C. Collaboration,et al.  Measurement of the ratio of inclusive jet cross sections using the anti-kt algorithm with radius parameters R = 0.5 and 0.7 in pp collisions at sqrt(s) = 7 TeV , 2014, 1406.0324.

[69]  S. Lee,et al.  Measurement of the W boson production charge asymmetry in pp̄→W+X→eν+X events at √s=1.96  TeV. , 2014, Physical review letters.

[70]  D. Whiteson,et al.  Combination of measurements of the top-quark pair production cross section from the Tevatron Collider , 2013, 1309.7570.

[71]  H. Paukkunen,et al.  PDF reweighting in the Hessian matrix approach , 2014, 1402.6623.

[72]  J. Huston,et al.  CT10 next-to-next-to-leading order global analysis of QCD , 2014 .

[73]  V. M. Ghete,et al.  Measurement of associated W + charm production in pp collisions at $ \sqrt{s} $ = 7 TeV , 2014 .

[74]  Jun Gao,et al.  A meta-analysis of parton distribution functions , 2013, 1401.0013.

[75]  A. A. Ocampo Rios,et al.  Measurement of the t t-bar production cross section in the dilepton channel in pp collisions at sqrt(s)=8 TeV , 2013, 1312.7582.

[76]  M. Z. Mehta,et al.  Measurement of the differential and double-differential Drell-Yan cross sections in proton-proton collisions at $ \sqrt{s} $ = 7 TeV , 2013 .

[77]  H. Prosper,et al.  Bayesian reweighting for global fits , 2013, 1310.1089.

[78]  J. T. Childers,et al.  Measurement of the high-mass Drell--Yan differential cross-section in pp collisions at sqrt(s)=7 TeV with the ATLAS detector , 2013, 1305.4192.

[79]  T. Becher,et al.  Electroweak Sudakov effects inW,Zandγproduction at large transverse momentum , 2013, 1305.4202.

[80]  M. Jarvis.  Measurement of the electron charge asymmetry in inclusive W production in pp collisions at √s = 7 TeV in the CMS experiment. , 2013 .

[81]  J. Huston,et al.  Parton distribution benchmarking with LHC data , 2012, 1211.5142.

[82]  A. Martin,et al.  Extended parameterisations for MSTW PDFs and their effect on lepton charge asymmetry from W decays , 2012, 1211.1215.

[83]  Z. A. Ibrahim,et al.  Combination and QCD analysis of charm production cross section measurements in deep-inelastic ep scattering at HERA , 2012, 1211.1182.

[84]  S. Dittmaier,et al.  Weak radiative corrections to dijet production at hadron colliders , 2012, 1210.0438.

[85]  Frank Petriello,et al.  Combining QCD and electroweak corrections to dilepton production in the framework of the FEWZ simulation code , 2012, 1208.5967.

[86]  K. Rabbertz,et al.  New features in version 2 of the fastNLO project , 2012, 1208.3641.

[87]  R. S. Thorne,et al.  Study of Monte Carlo approach to experimental uncertainty propagation with MSTW 2008 PDFs , 2012, 1205.4024.

[88]  J. Latorre,et al.  Second erratum to "Reweighting NNPDFs: The W lepton asymmetry" [Nucl. Phys. B 849 (1) (2011) 112-143] , 2012 .

[89]  Ye Li,et al.  W physics at the LHC with FEWZ 2.1 , 2012, Comput. Phys. Commun..

[90]  Atlas Collaboration.  Measurement of the inclusive W+- and Z/gamma cross sections in the electron and muon decay channels in pp collisions at sqrt(s) = 7 TeV with the ATLAS detector , 2011, 1109.5141.

[91]  J. Latorre,et al.  Reweighting and unweighting of parton distributions and the LHC W lepton asymmetry data , 2011, 1108.1758.

[92]  J. Campbell,et al.  Vector boson pair production at the LHC , 2011, 1105.0020.

[93]  Serguei Chatrchyan,et al.  Measurement of the lepton charge asymmetry ininclusive W production in pp collisions at √s = 7TeV , 2011 .

[94]  J. G. Contreras,et al.  Measurement of the inclusive e±p scattering cross section at high inelasticity y and of the structure function FL , 2010, 1012.4355.

[95]  J. Latorre,et al.  Reweighting NNPDFs : the W lepton asymmetry , 2010, 1012.0836.

[96]  Ye Li,et al.  FEWZ 2.0: A code for hadronic Z production at next-to-next-to-leading order , 2010, Comput. Phys. Commun..

[97]  J. Campbell,et al.  MCFM for the Tevatron and the LHC , 2010, 1007.3492.

[98]  J. Latorre,et al.  Fitting parton distribution data with multiplicative normalization uncertainties , 2009, 0912.2276.

[99]  Mark Sutton,et al.  A posteriori inclusion of parton density functions in NLO QCD final-state calculations at hadron colliders: the APPLGRID project , 2009, 0911.2985.

[100]  Z. A. Ibrahim,et al.  Combined measurement and QCD analysis of the inclusive e±p scattering cross sections at HERA , 2009 .

[101]  T. Aaltonen,et al.  Measurement of dσ/dy of Drell–Yan e+e− pairs in the Z mass region from collisions at , 2009, 0908.3914.

[102]  Zeus Collaboration.  Measurement of the Longitudinal Proton Structure Function at HERA , 2009, 0904.1092.

[103]  E. al.,et al.  Measurement of the Inclusive Jet Cross Section in pp Collisions at √s = 1.96 TeV , 2008, 1110.3771.

[104]  E. al.,et al.  Measurement of the electron charge asymmetry in pp̄→W+X→ eν+X events at s=1.96TeV , 2008, 0807.3367.

[105]  E. al.,et al.  Measurement of the inclusive jet cross section at the Fermilab Tevatron pp collider using a cone-based jet algorithm , 2008, 0807.2204.

[106]  J. G. Contreras,et al.  Measurement of the proton structure function F-L(x, Q(2)) at low x , 2008 .

[107]  J. G. Contreras,et al.  Measurement of the proton structure function FL ( x , Q 2 ) at low x H 1 Collaboration , 2008 .

[108]  J. Huston,et al.  Implications of CTEQ global analysis for collider observables , 2008, 0802.0007.

[109]  E. al.,et al.  Measurement of the muon charge asymmetry from W boson decays , 2007, 0709.4254.

[110]  R. S. Thorne,et al.  Parton distributions for the LHC , 2007, 0901.0002.

[111]  E. al.,et al.  Measurement of the shape of the boson rapidity distribution for pp̄→Z/γ*→e+e-+X events produced at s of 1.96 TeV , 2007, hep-ex/0702025.

[112]  T. Kluge,et al.  FastNLO: Fast pQCD calculations for PDF fits , 2006, hep-ph/0609285.

[113]  D. Mason,et al.  Measurement of the strange-antistrange asymmetry at NLO in QCD from NuTeV dimuon data , 2006 .

[114]  T. Okusawa,et al.  Measurement of nucleon structure functions in neutrino scattering , 2006 .

[115]  A. Bodek,et al.  Precise measurement of neutrino and anti-neutrino differential cross sections , 2005, hep-ex/0509010.

[116]  R. Henderson,et al.  Measurement of F2(cc) and F2(bb) at high Q2 using the H1 vertex dector at HERA. , 2005 .

[117]  Andreev,et al.  Measurement of F-2(c(c)over-bar) and F-2(b(b)over-bar) at high Q(2) using the H1 vertex detector at HERA , 2005 .

[118]  Z. Nagy.  Next-to-leading order calculation of three jet observables in hadron hadron collision , 2003, hep-ph/0307268.

[119]  J. Webb.  MEASUREMENT OF CONTINUUM DIMUON PRODUCTION IN 800-GEV/C PROTON-NUCLEON COLLISIONS , 2003, hep-ex/0301031.

[120]  J. Huston,et al.  New generation of parton distributions with uncertainties from global QCD analysis , 2002, hep-ph/0201195.

[121]  P. Nadolsky,et al.  PDF Uncertainties in WH Production at Tevatron , 2001, hep-ph/0110378.

[122]  P. Mackenzie,et al.  Constrained curve fitting , 2001, hep-lat/0110175.

[123]  J. Collins,et al.  Tests of goodness of fit to multiple data sets , 2001, hep-ph/0105207.

[124]  Z. F. Wang,et al.  Improved measurement of the d̄/ū asymmetry in the nucleon sea , 2001, hep-ex/0103030.

[125]  J. Huston,et al.  Uncertainties of predictions from parton distribution functions. I. The Lagrange multiplier method , 2001, hep-ph/0101051.

[126]  J. Huston,et al.  Uncertainties of predictions from parton distribution functions. II. The Hessian method , 2001, hep-ph/0101032.

[127]  M. Spiropulu,et al.  Measurement of the Lepton charge asymmetry in W-Boson decays produced in pp̄ collisions , 1998 .

[128]  W. Giele,et al.  Implications of Hadron Collider Observables on Parton Distribution Function Uncertainties , 1998, hep-ph/9803393.

[129]  E. al.,et al.  Improved Determination of alphas From Neutrino-Nucleon Scattering , 1997, hep-ex/9701017.

[130]  Lord,et al.  Proton and deuteron structure functions in muon scattering at 470 GeV. , 1995, Physical review. D, Particles and fields.

[131]  D. Soper,et al.  Issues in the Determination of Parton Distribution Functions , 1994, hep-ph/9411214.

[132]  G. D'Agostini,et al.  On the use of the covariance matrix to fit correlated data , 1994 .

[133]  S. Dasu,et al.  Precise measurements of the proton and deuteron structure functions from a global analysis of the SLAC deep inelastic electron scattering cross sections , 1992 .

[134]  H. Abramowicz,et al.  A measurement of differential cross-sections and nucleon structure functions in charged-current neutrino interactions on iron , 1991 .

[135]  Luk,et al.  Dimuon production in proton-copper collisions at sqrt s =38.8 GeV. , 1991, Physical review. D, Particles and fields.

[136]  A. Bodek,et al.  A precise extraction of R=σL/σT from a global analysis of the SLAC deep inelastic e-p and e-d scattering cross sections , 1990 .

[137]  G. Smadja,et al.  A High Statistics Measurement of the Proton Structure Functions F(2) (x, Q**2) and R from Deep Inelastic Muon Scattering at High Q**2 , 1989 .

[138]  R. Thorne,et al.  An investigation of the α S and heavy quark mass dependence in the MSHT20 global PDF analysis , 2021 .

[139]  T. Aaltonen,et al.  Measurement of dσ/dy of Drell-Yan e+e- pairs in the Z mass region from pp ̄ collisions at √s=1.96 TeV , 2021 .

[140]  Measurements of top-quark pair differential and double-differential cross- sections in the l+jets channel with pp collisions at √s=13 TeV using the ATLAS detector , 2019 .

[141]  A. Bodek,et al.  Fe b 20 01 Precise Measurement of Dimuon Production Cross-Sections in ν μ Fe and ν̄ μ Fe Deep Inelastic Scattering at the Tevatron , 2018 .

[142]  V. Veckalns.  Measurement of the Differential Cross Section and Charge Asymmetry for Inclusive pp → W ± + X production at √s = 8 TeV , 2016 .

[143]  C. LHCb,et al.  Measurement of forward W and Z boson production in $pp$ collisions at $ \sqrts=8 $ TeV , 2016 .

[144]  U. Schneekloth.  Combination of Measurements of Inclusive Deep Inelastic ep Scattering Cross Sections and QCD Analysis of HERA Data , 2015 .

[145]  W. H. Smith,et al.  Measurement of the muon charge asymmetry in inclusive pp → W + X production at √ s = 7 TeV and an improved determination of light parton distribution functions , 2014 .

[146]  S. Gollapinni,et al.  Measurement of the rapidity and transverse momentum distributions of Z bosons , 2012 .

[147]  T. Aaltonen,et al.  Direct Measurement of the W Production Charge Asymmetry in pp Collisions at √s = 1.96 Te V , 2009 .

[148]  J. Adelman,et al.  Measurement of the inclusive jet cross section using the k{sub T} algorithm in pp collisions at â(s)=1.96 TeV with the CDF II detector , 2007 .

[149]  Giulio D'Agostini,et al.  BAYESIAN REASONING IN HIGH-ENERGY PHYSICS: PRINCIPLES AND APPLICATIONS , 1999 .

[150]  I. Miyazaki,et al.  AND T , 2022 .