35 years of studies on business failure: an overview of the classic statistical methodologies and their related problems

Over the last 35 years, the topic of business failure prediction has developed to a major research domain in corporate finance. A gigantic number of academic researchers from all over the world have been developing corporate failure prediction models, based on various modelling techniques. The ‘classical cross-sectional statistical’ methods have appeared to be most popular. Numerous ‘singleperiod’ or ‘static’ models have been developed, especially multivariate discriminant models and logit models. As to date, a clear overview and discussion of the application of the classical cross-sectional statistical methods in corporate failure prediction is still lacking, this paper extensively elaborates on the application of (1) univariate analysis, (2) risk index models, (3) multivariate discriminant analysis, and (4) conditional probability models, such as logit, probit and linear probability models. It discusses the main features of these methods and their specific assumptions, advantages and disadvantages and it gives an overview of a large number of academically developed corporate failure prediction models. Despite the popularity of the classical statistical methods, there have appeared to be several problems related to the application of these methods to the topic of corporate failure prediction. However, in the existing literature there is no clear and comprehensive analysis of the diverse problems. Therefore, this paper brings together all criticisms and problems and extensively enlarges upon each of these issues. So as to give a clear overview, the diverse problems are categorized into a number of broad topics: problems related to (1) the dichotomous dependent variable, (2) the sampling method, (3) non-stationarity and data instability, (4) the use of annual account information, (5) the selection of the independent variables, and (6) the time dimension. This paper contributes towards a thorough understanding of the features of the classical statistical business failure prediction models and their related problems.

[1]  Anthony M. Santomero.  Financial crisis, institutions and markets in a fragile environment: Edward I. Altman and Arnold W. Sametz, eds., (John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1977) pp. xv + 288 , 1978 .

[2]  Teija Laitinen,et al.  Comparative analysis of failure prediction methods: the Finnish case , 1999 .

[3]  Marc Blum.  FAILING COMPANY DISCRIMINANT-ANALYSIS , 1974 .

[4]  Kevin Keasey,et al.  Multilogit approach to predicting corporate failure—Further analysis and the issue of signal consistency , 1990 .

[5]  Bart Clarysse,et al.  Cost-effectiveness of Herceptin®: A standard cost model for breast-cancer treatment in a Belgian university hospital , 2005, International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care.

[6]  Didier Van Caillie,et al.  Business Failure Prediction Models : What is the Theory looking for ? , 1999 .

[7]  Dirk Van den Poel,et al.  Customer base analysis: partial defection of behaviourally loyal clients in a non-contractual FMCG retail setting , 2005, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[8]  Amir F. Atiya,et al.  Bankruptcy prediction for credit risk using neural networks: A survey and new results , 2001, IEEE Trans. Neural Networks.

[9]  B. Clarysse,et al.  Do Intangible Assets and Pre-Founding R&D Efforts Matter for Innovation Speed in Start-Ups? , 2004 .

[10]  D. Hosmer,et al.  Applied Logistic Regression , 1991 .

[11]  E. Laitinen.  FINANCIAL RATIOS AND DIFFERENT FAILURE PROCESSES , 1991 .

[12]  G. Peersman.  What Caused the Early Millennium Slowdown? Evidence Based on Vector Autoregressions , 2003 .

[13]  E. Altman,et al.  ZETATM analysis A new model to identify bankruptcy risk of corporations , 1977 .

[14]  Dirk Van den Poel,et al.  The impact of sample bias on consumer credit scoring performance and profitability , 2005, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[15]  Bernard Micha,et al.  Analysis of business failures in France , 1984 .

[16]  J Casey Cornelius,et al.  CASH FLOW - IT'S NOT THE BOTTOM LINE , 1984 .

[17]  Katherine Schipper,et al.  Application of Classification Techniques in Business, Banking and Finance. , 1983 .

[18]  James C. Flagg,et al.  PREDICTING CORPORATE BANKRUPTCY USING FAILING FIRMS , 1991 .

[19]  Paul Newbold,et al.  CLASSIFYING BANKRUPT FIRMS WITH FUNDS FLOW COMPONENTS , 1985 .

[20]  Abdul Aziz,et al.  BANKRUPTCY PREDICTION ‐ AN INVESTIGATION OF CASH FLOW BASED MODELS[1] , 1988 .

[21]  Sofie Balcaen,et al.  Are failure prediction models transferable from one country to another? An empirical study using financial statements , 2002 .

[22]  Cecilio Mar-Molinero,et al.  THE DISTRIBUTIONAL PROPERTIES OF FINANCIAL RATIOS IN UK MANUFACTURING COMPANIES , 1990 .

[23]  K. Keasey,et al.  Financial Distress Prediction Models: A Review of Their Usefulness1 , 1991 .

[24]  Hubert Ooghe,et al.  Determinanten van faling : verklaring en predictie , 1982 .

[25]  W. R. Lane,et al.  An application of the cox proportional hazards model to bank failure , 1986 .

[26]  S. Schiller,et al.  Disclosure of improvement activities related to tangible assets , 2003 .

[27]  D. Buyens,et al.  Making Sense of a New Employment Relationship: Psychological Contract-Related Information Seeking and the Role of Work Values and Locus of Control , 2005 .

[28]  K. Schoors,et al.  Gradualism versus Big Bang: Evidence from Transition Countries , 2004 .

[29]  Panayiotis Theodossiou,et al.  Predicting Corporate Financial Distress: A Time-Series CUSUM Methodology , 1998 .

[30]  R. O. Edmister,et al.  JOURNAL OF FINANCIAL AND QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS March 1972 AN EMPIRICAL TEST OF FINANCIAL RATIO ANALYSIS FOR SMALL BUSINESS FAILURE PREDICTION , 2009 .

[31]  Sofie Balcaen,et al.  The Ooghe-Joos-De Vos failure prédiction models: a cross-industry validation , 2003 .

[32]  E. Altman.  The success of business failure prediction models: An international survey , 1984 .

[33]  Bert De Reyck,et al.  A hybrid scatter search/electromagnetism meta-heuristic for project scheduling , 2006, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[34]  Van Frederikslust,et al.  Predictability of corporate failure : models for prediction of corporate failure and for evaluation of debt capacity , 1980 .

[35]  Lieven Baele.  Volatility Spillover Effects in European Equity Markets , 2004, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis.

[36]  M. Peel,et al.  Some Further Empirical Evidence on Predicting Private Company Failure , 1987 .

[37]  Paul Barnes,et al.  The Analysis and Use of Financial Ratios: A Review Article , 1987 .

[38]  Jenifer Piesse,et al.  The Information Value of Mda Based Financial Indicators , 1987 .

[39]  G. Peersman,et al.  Determinants of consumption smoothing , 2004 .

[40]  Evelyn Hayden,et al.  Are Credit Scoring Models Sensitive with Respect to Default Definitions? Evidence from the Austrian Market , 2003 .

[41]  D. De Clercq,et al.  When Do Venture Capital Firms Learn from Their Portfolio Companies? , 2005 .

[42]  David D. Williams,et al.  Cash Flow in Bankruptcy Prediction , 1987 .

[43]  Abdul Aziz,et al.  Cash Flow Reporting and Financial Distress Models: Testing of Hypotheses , 1989 .

[44]  D. De Clercq,et al.  Human capital, social capital, and innovation: a multi-country study , 2004 .

[45]  Johan Christiaens.  Een praktijkonderzoek naar de gemeentelijke financiering van het deeltijds kunstonderwijs in Vlaanderen , 2004 .

[46]  Eddy Omey,et al.  What determines measured overeducation , 2004 .

[47]  E. Altman.  Examining Moyer's Re-examination of Forecasting Financial Failure , 1978 .

[48]  Marjorie B. Platt,et al.  Predicting corporate financial distress: Reflections on choice-based sample bias , 2002 .

[49]  Frederick M. Richardson,et al.  ON LINEAR DISCRIMINATION WITH ACCOUNTING RATIOS , 1984 .

[50]  Tom Verbeke,et al.  Environmental policy uncertainty, policy coordination and relocation decisions , 2003 .

[51]  Paul Newbold,et al.  Funds Flow Components, Financial Ratios, and Bankruptcy , 1987 .

[52]  L. Becchetti,et al.  Bankruptcy risk and productive efficiency in manufacturing firms , 2003 .

[53]  J. L. Westbrook,et al.  Financial Characteristics of Businesses in Bankruptcy , 2000 .

[54]  B. Rime.  The New Basel Accord: Implications of the Co-existence between the Standardized Approach and the Internal Ratings-based Approach , 2003 .

[55]  Dieter Verhaest,et al.  The Impact of Overeducation and its Measurement , 2006 .

[56]  Y. Eom,et al.  Failure Prediction: Evidence from Korea , 1995 .

[57]  Marjorie B. Platt,et al.  DEVELOPMENT OF A CLASS OF STABLE PREDICTIVE VARIABLES: THE CASE OF BANKRUPTCY PREDICTION , 1990 .

[58]  Sabien Dobbelaere,et al.  Ownership, firm size and rent sharing in a transition country , 2003 .

[59]  Hubert Ooghe,et al.  Het type controleverslag: resultaten van een empirisch onderzoek in België/La nature du rapport de révision: résultats d'une étude empirique en Belgique , 2003 .

[60]  R. Vander Vennet,et al.  Bank Risk Strategies and Cyclical Variation in Bank Stock Returns , 2004 .

[61]  Kaisa Sere,et al.  Choosing Bankruptcy Predictors Using Discriminant Analysis, Logit Analysis, and Genetic Algorithms , 1996 .

[62]  P. Gemmel,et al.  The waiting experience and consumer perception of service quality in outpatient clinics , 2004 .

[63]  Ross L. Watts,et al.  Positive Accounting Theory , 2006 .

[64]  Mark L. DeFond,et al.  Debt covenant violation and manipulation of accruals , 1994 .

[65]  M. Wright,et al.  WHY DO VENTURE CAPITAL COMPANIES SYNDICATE , 2004 .

[66]  E. J. Bijnen,et al.  Corporate Prediction Models, Ratios or Regression Analysis , 1994 .

[67]  Panayiotis Theodossiou.  Predicting Shifts in the Mean of a Multivariate Time Series Process: An Application in Predicting Business Failures , 1993 .

[68]  Gerdie Everaert,et al.  Inflation and human capital formation: theory and panel data evidence , 2003 .

[69]  R. Taffler,et al.  The Assessment of Company Solvency and Performance using a Statistical Model , 1983 .

[70]  A. Saunders,et al.  Credit risk measurement: Developments over the last 20 years , 1997 .

[71]  Hubert Ooghe,et al.  Oorzaken van faling en falingspaden: literatuuroverzicht en conceptueel verklaringsmodel , 2004 .

[72]  T. Ward,et al.  A Note on Selecting a Response Measure for Financial Distress , 1997 .

[73]  G. Rayp,et al.  Inequality and Growth: Does Time Change Anything? , 2004 .

[74]  M. Dacorogna,et al.  Credit Risk Models – Do They Deliver Their Promises? A Quantitative Assessment , 2003 .

[75]  Marc Deloof,et al.  The Debt Maturity Structure of Small Firms in a Creditor Oriented Environment , 2003 .

[76]  Edward I. Altman,et al.  Financial Applications of Discriminant Analysis: A Clarification , 1978 .

[77]  Erkki K. Laitinen,et al.  Survival analysis as a tool for company failure prediction , 1991 .

[78]  Constantin Zopounidis,et al.  A survey of business failures with an emphasis on prediction methods and industrial applications , 1996 .

[79]  R. Moyer.  Forecasting Financial Failure: A Re-Examination , 1977 .

[80]  A. P. Sweeney,et al.  Debt-covenant violations and managers' accounting responses , 1994 .

[81]  D. McFadden.  Conditional logit analysis of qualitative choice behavior , 1972 .

[82]  C. Van Wymeersch,et al.  La "trajectoire de faillite" des entreprises: une analyse chronologique sur base des comptes annuels , 1996 .

[83]  R. Lussier.  A Nonfinancial Business Success versus Failure Prediction Model for Young Firms , 1995 .

[84]  C. Charalambous,et al.  Predicting Corporate Failure: Empirical Evidence for the UK by , 2001 .

[85]  R. Zeckhauser,et al.  Earnings Management to Exceed Thresholds , 1999 .

[86]  J. Sheppard.  Strategy and Bankruptcy: An Exploration in to Organizational Death , 1994 .

[87]  P. Barnes.  METHODOLOGICAL IMPLICATIONS OF NON‐NORMALLY DISTRIBUTED FINANCIAL RATIOS , 1982 .

[88]  Stewart Thornhill,et al.  Learning About Failure: Bankruptcy, Firm Age, and the Resource-Based View , 2003, Organ. Sci..

[89]  T. Marchant.  Rationing : dynamic considerations, equivalent sacrifice and links between the two approaches , 2004 .

[90]  Bruno Merlevede,et al.  A Note on Reform Reversals and Output Growth in Transition Economies , 2003 .

[91]  Edward I. Altman,et al.  Application of Classification Techniques in Business, Banking and Finance. , 1983 .

[92]  P. Chalos.  Financial Distress - A Comparative-Study Of Individual, Model, And Committee Assessments , 1985 .

[93]  Kaisa Sere,et al.  The Effect of Sample Size on Different Failure Prediction Methods , 1998 .

[94]  Kenneth B. Schwartz,et al.  PREDICTING BANKRUPTCY FOR FIRMS IN FINANCIAL DISTRESS , 1990 .

[95]  Oscar Pastor,et al.  Comparative Evaluation of Functional Size Measurement Methods: An Experimental Analysis , 2004 .

[96]  H. Theil.  Principles of econometrics , 1971 .

[97]  Yvo Dirickx,et al.  Statistical failure prevision problems , 1994 .

[98]  Erkki K. Laitinen,et al.  Prediction of failure of a newly founded firm , 1992 .

[99]  Paul Newbold,et al.  Predicting Bankruptcy: If Cash Flow’s Not the Bottom Line, What Is? , 1985 .

[100]  Marc Declerc,et al.  Flux financiers et prévision de faillite: une analyse comportementale de l'entreprise , 1992 .

[101]  P.P.M. Joos,et al.  Financial distress models in Belgium: the results of a decade of empirical research , 1995 .

[102]  Marc Declerc,et al.  The use of value added ratios in statistical failure prediction models: some evidence on Belgian annual accounts , 1992 .

[103]  Rebecca L. Rosner.  Earnings Manipulation in Failing Firms , 2003 .

[104]  Gordon V. Karels,et al.  Multivariate Normality and Forecasting of Business Bankruptcy , 1987 .

[105]  L. Pozzi,et al.  Imperfect information and the excess sensitivity of private consumption to government expenditures , 2003 .

[106]  Nadine Meskens,et al.  Business failure prediction : A review and Analysis of the Literature , 2002 .

[107]  James A. Ohlson.  FINANCIAL RATIOS AND THE PROBABILISTIC PREDICTION OF BANKRUPTCY , 1980 .

[108]  Edward I. Altman,et al.  An International Survey of Business Failure Classification Models , 1997 .

[109]  Olivier Thas,et al.  Correcting Standard Errors in Two-Stage Estimation Procedures with Generated Regressands , 2005 .

[110]  Valerie Decoene,et al.  Strategic alignment of manufacturing processes in a Balanced Scorecard-based compensation plan: a theory illustration case , 2003 .

[111]  Erkki K. Laitinen,et al.  Traditional versus operating cash flow in failure prediction , 1994 .

[112]  Sean Holly,et al.  Macro Economic Instability and Business Exit: Determinants of Failures and Acquisitions of Large UK Firms , 2002 .

[113]  Didier Van Caillie,et al.  The concept of "Economic Added Result", a new tool to prevent bankruptcy ? , 2002 .

[114]  Jenifer Piesse,et al.  Issues in assessing MDA models of corporate failure: A research note , 1992 .

[115]  I. G. Dambolena,et al.  Ratio Stability and Corporate Failure , 1980 .

[116]  R. Taffler.  Empirical models for the monitoring of UK corporations , 1984 .

[117]  M. Wright,et al.  Spinning Out New Ventures: A Typology of Incubation Strategies from European Research Institutions , 2005 .

[118]  Hian Chye Koh,et al.  THE SENSITIVITY OF OPTIMAL CUTOFF POINTS TO MISCLASSIFICATION COSTS OF TYPE I AND TYPE II ERRORS IN THE GOING‐CONCERN PREDICTION CONTEXT , 1992 .

[119]  S. McLeay,et al.  THE SENSITIVITY OF PREDICTION MODELS TO THE NON-NORMALITY OF BOUNDED AND UNBOUNDED FINANCIAL RATIOS☆ , 2000 .

[120]  Marjorie B. Platt,et al.  A note on the use of industry-relative ratios in bankruptcy prediction , 1991 .

[121]  K. Keasey,et al.  Non‐Financial Symptoms and the Prediction of Small Company Failure: A Test of Argenti's Hypotheses , 1987 .

[122]  Edward I. Altman,et al.  FINANCIAL RATIOS, DISCRIMINANT ANALYSIS AND THE PREDICTION OF CORPORATE BANKRUPTCY , 1968 .

[123]  Mario Vanhoucke.  New computational results for the discrete time/cost trade-off problem with time-switch constraints , 2005 .

[124]  Patricia Janina Cybinski,et al.  Description, explanation, prediction – the evolution of bankruptcy studies? , 2001 .

[125]  James H. Scott.  The probability of bankruptcy: A comparison of empirical predictions and theoretical models , 1981 .

[126]  Ilia D. Dichev,et al.  Earnings Management to Avoid Earnings Decreases and Losses , 1997 .

[127]  R. Taffler,et al.  Forecasting Company Failure in the Uk Using Discriminant Analysis and Financial Ratio Data , 1982 .

[128]  D. Buyens,et al.  Information seeking about the psychological contract: the impact on newcomers' evaluations of their employment relationship , 2004 .

[129]  Cecilio Mar Molinero,et al.  Predicting Corporate Failure in the UK: A Multidimensional Scaling Approach , 2004 .

[130]  Patricia G. Lobingier,et al.  The Impact of Recession on the Prediction of Corporate Failure , 1998 .

[131]  Rebel A. Cole,et al.  Separating the likelihood and timing of bank failure , 1995 .

[132]  Dirk Van de gaer,et al.  Mobility as distributional difference , 2003 .

[133]  Harry J. Turtle,et al.  An Empirical Comparison of Bankruptcy Models , 1998 .

[134]  Erik Schokkaert,et al.  Equality of Opportunity versus Equality of Opportunity Sets , 2007, Soc. Choice Welf..

[135]  Y. Mensah.  AN EXAMINATION OF THE STATIONARITY OF MULTIVARIATE BANKRUPTCY PREDICTION MODELS - A METHODOLOGICAL STUDY , 1984 .

[136]  Patricia Janina Cybinski,et al.  The Path to Failure: Where are Bankruptcy Studies at Now? , 2000 .

[137]  Elton Scott,et al.  On the Financial Application of Discriminant Analysis: Comment , 1978 .

[138]  O. Maurice Joy,et al.  OF FINANCIAL AND QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS DECEMBER 1975 ON THE FINANCIAL APPLICATIONS OF DISCRIMINANT ANALYSIS , 2009 .

[139]  Kjell G. Nyborg,et al.  A Comparison of US, UK, and German Insolvency Codes , 1996 .

[140]  G. Hall,et al.  FACTORS DISTINGUISHING SURVIVORS FROM FAILURES AMONGST SMALL FIRMS IN THE UK CONSTRUCTION SECTOR , 1994 .

[141]  B. Lehmann.  Is it Worth the While? The Relevance of Qualitative Information in Credit Rating , 2003 .

[142]  Hubert Ooghe,et al.  Methodologie bij het opstellen en beoordelen van kredietclassificatiemodellen , 1998 .

[143]  M. Zmijewski.  METHODOLOGICAL ISSUES RELATED TO THE ESTIMATION OF FINANCIAL DISTRESS PREDICTION MODELS , 1984 .

[144]  Koen Vanhoof,et al.  Credit classification: A comparison of logit models and decision trees , 1998 .

[145]  Jagdip Singh,et al.  Vlerick Leuven Gent Working Paper Series 2003/29 PSYCHOLOGICAL EMPOWERMENT IN THE WORKPLACE: REVIEWING THE EMPOWERMENT EFFECTS ON CRITICAL WORK OUTCOMES , 2003 .

[146]  Marjorie B. Platt,et al.  BANKRUPTCY DISCRIMINATION WITH REAL VARIABLES , 1994 .

[147]  Su‐Jane Hsieh,et al.  A NOTE ON THE OPTIMAL CUTOFF POINT IN BANKRUPTCY PREDICTION MODELS , 1993 .

[148]  Lenos Trigeorgis,et al.  Option-Based Bankruptcy Prediction , 2000 .

[149]  Kevin Keasey,et al.  THE FAILURE OF UK INDUSTRIAL FIRMS FOR THE PERIOD 1976–1984, LOGISTIC ANALYSIS AND ENTROPY MEASURES , 1990 .

[150]  C. Zavgren.  ASSESSING THE VULNERABILITY TO FAILURE OF AMERICAN INDUSTRIAL FIRMS: A LOGISTIC ANALYSIS , 1985 .

[151]  Dirk Van den Poel,et al.  Investigating the role of product features in preventing customer churn, by using survival analysis and choice modeling: The case of financial services , 2004, Expert Syst. Appl..

[152]  W. Beaver.  Financial Ratios As Predictors Of Failure , 1966 .

[153]  Elsy Verhofstadt,et al.  The impact of education on job satisfaction in the first job , 2003 .

[154]  O. Maurice Joy,et al.  OF FINANCIAL AND QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS March 1978 SOME CLARIFYING COMMENTS ON DISCRIMINANT ANALYSIS 0 , 2009 .

[155]  Erkki K. Laitinen,et al.  Financial predictors for different phases of the failure process , 1993 .

[156]  Robert A. Eisenbeis,et al.  PITFALLS IN THE APPLICATION OF DISCRIMINANT ANALYSIS IN BUSINESS, FINANCE, AND ECONOMICS , 1977 .

[157]  C. Zopounidis,et al.  A Multicriteria Discrimination Method for the Prediction of Financial Distress: The Case of Greece , 1999 .

[158]  A. Shenhar,et al.  Beyond the Balanced Scorecard:: Refining the Search for Organizational Success Measures , 2003 .

[159]  C. Zavgren,et al.  The prediction of corporate failure: The state of the art , 1983 .

[160]  Tom Verbeke,et al.  The Environmental Kuznets Curve: some really disturbing Monte Carlo evidence , 2004 .

[161]  E. Deakin.  Discriminant Analysis Of Predictors Of Business Failure , 1972 .

[162]  B. Clarysse,et al.  Institutional Change and the Resource Flows going to Spin off Projects: The case of IMEC , 2004 .

[163]  Hubert Ooghe,et al.  Risico-indicator voor een onderneming aan de hand van falingspredictie-modellen , 1993 .

[164]  F Jones,et al.  CURRENT TECHNIQUES IN BANKRUPTCY PREDICTION , 1987 .

[165]  Constantin Zopounidis,et al.  Application of the Rough Set Approach to Evaluation of Bankruptcy Risk , 1995 .

[166]  J. Betts,et al.  The Effectiveness of Incorporating Stability Measures In Company Failure Models , 1987 .

[167]  C. Johnson.  RATIO ANALYSIS AND THE PREDICTION OF FIRM FAILURE , 1970 .

[168]  Oscar Pastor,et al.  Faculteit Economie En Bedrijfskunde Hoveniersberg 24 B-9000 Gent Functional Size Measurement Method for Object-oriented Conceptual Schemas: Design and Evaluation Issues a Functional Size Measurement Method for Object-oriented Conceptual Schemas: Design and Evaluation Issues , 2022 .

[169]  Kevin Keasey,et al.  The Prediction of Small Company Failure: Some Behavioural Evidence for the UK , 1986 .

[170]  J. Argenti.  Corporate Collapse: The Causes and Symptoms , 1976 .

[171]  R. Lattimore,et al.  Business Failure and Change: An Australian Perspective , 2001 .

[172]  Errol R. Iselin,et al.  The Relative Relevance of Cash Flow and Accrual Information for Solvency Assessments: A Multi-Method Approach , 2003 .

[173]  Tyler Shumway.  Forecasting Bankruptcy More Accurately: A Simple Hazard Model , 1999 .