Systematic selection between age and household structure for models aimed at emerging epidemic predictions

Numerous epidemic models have been developed to capture aspects of human contact patterns, making model selection challenging when they fit (often-scarce) early epidemic data equally well but differ in predictions. Here we consider the invasion of a novel directly transmissible infection and perform an extensive, systematic and transparent comparison of models with explicit age and/or household structure, to determine the accuracy loss in predictions in the absence of interventions when ignoring either or both social components. We conclude that, with heterogeneous and assortative contact patterns relevant to respiratory infections, the model’s age stratification is crucial for accurate predictions. Conversely, the household structure is only needed if transmission is highly concentrated in households, as suggested by an empirical but robust rule of thumb based on household secondary attack rate. This work serves as a template to guide the simplicity/accuracy trade-off in designing models aimed at initial, rapid assessment of potential epidemic severity. Models of emerging epidemics can be exceedingly helpful in planning the response, but early on model selection is a difficult task. Here, the authors explore the joint contribution of age stratification and household structure on epidemic spread, and provides a rule of thumb to guide model choice.

[1]  Joel C. Miller,et al.  Epidemic size and probability in populations with heterogeneous infectivity and susceptibility. , 2007, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[2]  R. Simpson,et al.  Infectiousness of communicable diseases in the household (measles, chickenpox, and mumps). , 1952, Lancet.

[3]  H. Andersson,et al.  Stochastic Epidemic Models and Their Statistical Analysis , 2000 .

[4]  Simon Cauchemez,et al.  new approach to characterising infectious disease transmission dynamics from entinel surveillance : Application to the Italian 2009 – 2010 A / H 1 N 1 influenza andemic , 2012 .

[5]  Jeffrey W. Eaton,et al.  HIV Treatment as Prevention: Systematic Comparison of Mathematical Models of the Potential Impact of Antiretroviral Therapy on HIV Incidence in South Africa , 2012, PLoS medicine.

[6]  D. Cummings,et al.  Strategies for mitigating an influenza pandemic , 2006, Nature.

[7]  Francesco Checchi,et al.  Exposure-Specific and Age-Specific Attack Rates for Ebola Virus Disease in Ebola-Affected Households, Sierra Leone , 2016, Emerging infectious diseases.

[8]  Alessandro Vespignani,et al.  Comparing large-scale computational approaches to epidemic modeling: Agent-based versus structured metapopulation models , 2010, BMC infectious diseases.

[9]  Benjamin J Cowling,et al.  Household Transmission of 2009 Pandemic Influenza A (H1N1): A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis , 2012, Epidemiology.

[10]  C. Macken,et al.  Modeling targeted layered containment of an influenza pandemic in the United States , 2008, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[11]  Mikiko Senga,et al.  Ebola virus disease in West Africa--the first 9 months of the epidemic and forward projections. , 2014, The New England journal of medicine.

[12]  M. Jit,et al.  Vaccination against pandemic influenza A/H1N1v in England: a real-time economic evaluation. , 2010, Vaccine.

[13]  Frank Ball,et al.  A general model for stochastic SIR epidemics with two levels of mixing. , 2002, Mathematical biosciences.

[14]  Alicia Karspeck,et al.  Real-Time Influenza Forecasts during the 2012–2013 Season , 2013, Nature Communications.

[15]  Viggo Andreasen,et al.  The Final Size of an Epidemic and Its Relation to the Basic Reproduction Number , 2011, Bulletin of mathematical biology.

[16]  Lorenzo Pellis,et al.  Epidemic growth rate and household reproduction number in communities of households, schools and workplaces , 2011, Journal of mathematical biology.

[17]  Eben Kenah,et al.  Contact intervals, survival analysis of epidemic data, and estimation of R(0). , 2009, Biostatistics.

[18]  Gail E. Potter,et al.  Household members do not contact each other at random: implications for infectious disease modelling , 2017, bioRxiv.

[19]  S. Riley Large-Scale Spatial-Transmission Models of Infectious Disease , 2007, Science.

[20]  Jane M Blazeby,et al.  ORAL PRESENTATIONS , 1993, European Surgical Research.

[21]  Frank Ball,et al.  Reproduction numbers for epidemic models with households and other social structures. I. Definition and calculation of R0 , 2012, Mathematical biosciences.

[22]  S. Merler,et al.  Model predictions and evaluation of possible control strategies for the 2009 A/H1N1v influenza pandemic in Italy , 2010, Epidemiology and Infection.

[23]  Niel Hens,et al.  Different transmission patterns in the early stages of the influenza A(H1N1)v pandemic: a comparative analysis of 12 European countries. , 2011, Epidemics.

[24]  Thomas House,et al.  Estimation of outbreak severity and transmissibility: Influenza A(H1N1)pdm09 in households , 2012, BMC Medicine.

[25]  R. Anderson,et al.  For Personal Use. Only Reproduce with Permission from the Lancet Publishing Group , 2022 .

[26]  Household epidemic models with varying infection response , 2010, Journal of mathematical biology.

[27]  Yong Shi,et al.  Preface: Some Advanced Techniques in Data Science , 2015 .

[28]  Thomas Smith,et al.  Ensemble Modeling of the Likely Public Health Impact of a Pre-Erythrocytic Malaria Vaccine , 2012, PLoS medicine.

[29]  M. Kretzschmar,et al.  Using data on social contacts to estimate age-specific transmission parameters for respiratory-spread infectious agents. , 2006, American journal of epidemiology.

[30]  Christl A. Donnelly,et al.  A review of epidemiological parameters from Ebola outbreaks to inform early public health decision-making , 2015, Scientific Data.

[31]  Benjamin J Cowling,et al.  Comparative epidemiology of pandemic and seasonal influenza A in households. , 2010, The New England journal of medicine.

[32]  Graeme Garner,et al.  Ensemble modelling and structured decision-making to support Emergency Disease Management. , 2017, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[33]  Madhav V. Marathe,et al.  Mathematical Tools for Understanding Infectious Disease Dynamics. Princeton Series in Theoretical and Computational Biology. By Odo Diekmann, Hans Heesterbeek and Tom Britton. xiv + 502 pp. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. 2014. $90.00 (cloth and e‐book). , 2013 .

[34]  Ellen Brooks-Pollock,et al.  Measured Dynamic Social Contact Patterns Explain the Spread of H1N1v Influenza , 2012, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[35]  N. Ferguson,et al.  Planning for smallpox outbreaks , 2003, Nature.

[36]  Matthew J Ferrari,et al.  Decision-making for foot-and-mouth disease control: Objectives matter. , 2016, Epidemics.

[37]  Maik Kschischo,et al.  Potassium Starvation in Yeast: Mechanisms of Homeostasis Revealed by Mathematical Modeling , 2012, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[38]  R. Mikolajczyk,et al.  Social Contacts and Mixing Patterns Relevant to the Spread of Infectious Diseases , 2008, PLoS medicine.

[39]  Ả. Svensson A note on generation times in epidemic models. , 2007, Mathematical Biosciences.

[40]  M. Keeling,et al.  Deterministic epidemic models with explicit household structure. , 2008, Mathematical biosciences.

[41]  Xiaojing Wang,et al.  Corrigendum: Proteomic analysis of colon and rectal carcinoma using standard and customized databases , 2015, Scientific Data.

[42]  Michael A. Irvine,et al.  Predicting lymphatic filariasis transmission and elimination dynamics using a multi-model ensemble framework , 2017, Epidemics.

[43]  W. Team Ebola Virus Disease in West Africa — The First 9 Months of the Epidemic and Forward Projections , 2014 .

[44]  Odo Diekmann,et al.  Mathematical Tools for Understanding Infectious Disease Dynamics , 2012 .

[45]  J. Wallinga,et al.  Inferring R0 in emerging epidemics—the effect of common population structure is small , 2016, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[46]  E. Lyons,et al.  Pandemic Potential of a Strain of Influenza A (H1N1): Early Findings , 2009, Science.

[47]  David J Gerberry,et al.  An exact approach to calibrating infectious disease models to surveillance data: The case of HIV and HSV-2. , 2017, Mathematical biosciences and engineering : MBE.

[48]  S. Dowell,et al.  Transmission of Ebola hemorrhagic fever: a study of risk factors in family members, Kikwit, Democratic Republic of the Congo, 1995. Commission de Lutte contre les Epidémies à Kikwit. , 1999, The Journal of infectious diseases.

[49]  T D Hollingsworth,et al.  Learning from multi-model comparisons: Collaboration leads to insights, but limitations remain. , 2017, Epidemics.

[50]  M. Keeling,et al.  Modeling Infectious Diseases in Humans and Animals , 2007 .

[51]  Mosoka P. Fallah,et al.  Exposure Patterns Driving Ebola Transmission in West Africa: A Retrospective Observational Study , 2016, PLoS medicine.

[52]  L. Bécu,et al.  Evidence for three-dimensional unstable flows in shear-banding wormlike micelles. , 2007, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[53]  Derek A T Cummings,et al.  Influenza transmission in households during the 1918 pandemic. , 2011, American journal of epidemiology.

[54]  C. Fraser,et al.  Transmission Dynamics of the Etiological Agent of SARS in Hong Kong: Impact of Public Health Interventions , 2003, Science.

[55]  Reto Knutti,et al.  The use of the multi-model ensemble in probabilistic climate projections , 2007, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences.

[56]  Thomas House,et al.  How big is an outbreak likely to be? Methods for epidemic final-size calculation , 2013, Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences.

[57]  J. Shaman,et al.  Forecasting seasonal outbreaks of influenza , 2012, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[58]  Thomas Smith,et al.  Consensus modelling evidence to support the design of mass drug administration programmes: A report by the Malaria Modelling Consortium (MMC) for the Malaria Policy Advisory Committee (MPAC), World Health Organization, 16–18 September 2015, Geneva, Switzerland, Background document for Session 1 , 2015 .

[59]  Matt J. Keeling,et al.  Networks and the Epidemiology of Infectious Disease , 2010, Interdisciplinary perspectives on infectious diseases.

[60]  Marc Lipsitch,et al.  Inference of seasonal and pandemic influenza transmission dynamics , 2015, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[61]  F. Ball,et al.  Reproduction numbers for epidemic models with households and other social structures II: Comparisons and implications for vaccination. , 2014, Mathematical biosciences.

[62]  M. Delgado-Rodríguez,et al.  Systematic review and meta-analysis. , 2017, Medicina intensiva.

[63]  Reto Knutti,et al.  Challenges in Combining Projections from Multiple Climate Models , 2010 .

[64]  Stefan J. Kiebel,et al.  A Bayesian Attractor Model for Perceptual Decision Making , 2015, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[65]  Michael J. Tildesley,et al.  A Bayesian Ensemble Approach for Epidemiological Projections , 2015, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[66]  C. Fraser,et al.  Household transmission of 2009 pandemic influenza A (H1N1) virus in the United States. , 2009, The New England journal of medicine.