When the music's over. Does music skill transfer to children's and young adolescents' cognitive and academic skills? A meta-analysis

Music training has been recently claimed to enhance children and young adolescents' cognitive and academic skills. However, substantive research on transfer of skills suggests that far-transfer - i.e., the transfer of skills between two areas only loosely related to each other - occurs rarely. In this meta-analysis, we examined the available experimental evidence regarding the impact of music training on children and young adolescents' cognitive and academic skills. The results of the random-effects models showed (a) a small overall effect size (d¯=0.16); (b) slightly greater effect sizes with regard to intelligence (d¯=0.35) and memory-related outcomes (d¯=0.34); and (c) an inverse relation between the size of the effects and the methodological quality of the study design. These results suggest that music training does not reliably enhance children and young adolescents' cognitive or academic skills, and that previous positive findings were probably due to confounding variables.

[1]  Jennifer Krizman,et al.  Music training alters the course of adolescent auditory development , 2015, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[2]  A. Hunt.  'Have you brought your singing voice?' : an investigation into whether a small group singing intervention can improve phonological discrimination in young children , 2012 .

[3]  A. Schwaninger,et al.  Does musical training improve school performance? , 2009 .

[4]  R. Viertl.  On the Future of Data Analysis , 2002 .

[5]  Effects of a Preschool Music and Movement Curriculum on Children's Language Skills. , 2009 .

[6]  Donna Coch,et al.  Music training and working memory: An ERP study , 2011, Neuropsychologia.

[7]  Susanne M. Jaeggi,et al.  Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience Neuronal Effects following Working Memory Training , 2022 .

[8]  M. Mitchelmore,et al.  Possible Effects of Early Childhood Music on Mathematical Achievement. , 1996 .

[9]  A. Harlow.  Beginning the Day with the IWB in an Early Childhood Classroom. , 2010 .

[10]  G. Schwarzer,et al.  The influence of two years of school music training in secondary school on visual and auditory memory , 2011 .

[11]  E. Brand,et al.  Underlying mechanisms linking music education and cognitive modifiability , 2009 .

[12]  C. Begg,et al.  Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias. , 1994, Biometrics.

[13]  Betty Ann Levy,et al.  Relations among musical skills, phonological processing, and early reading ability in preschool children. , 2002, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[14]  N. Rickard,et al.  Absence of widespread psychosocial and cognitive effects of school-based music instruction in 10–13-year-old students , 2012 .

[15]  E. Spelke,et al.  Two Randomized Trials Provide No Consistent Evidence for Nonmusical Cognitive Benefits of Brief Preschool Music Enrichment , 2013, PloS one.

[16]  J. Bransford,et al.  How People Learn: Bridging Research and Practice , 2013 .

[17]  Gudrun Schwarzer,et al.  The Effect of a Music Program on Phonological Awareness in Preschoolers , 2011, Front. Psychology.

[18]  W. Trost,et al.  How musical training affects cognitive development: rhythm, reward and other modulating variables , 2014, Front. Neurosci..

[19]  Richard Lynn,et al.  Simple musical tests as measures of Spearman's g , 1989 .

[20]  E. Schellenberg,et al.  Music Lessons Enhance IQ , 2004, Psychological science.

[21]  Michael A. McDaniel,et al.  The Validity of Conscientiousness Is Overestimated in the Prediction of Job Performance , 2015, PloS one.

[22]  Kylie Peppler,et al.  In Harmony: A technology-based music education model to enhance musical understanding and general learning skills , 2014 .

[23]  E. Schellenberg,et al.  Long-Term Positive Associations between Music Lessons and IQ. , 2006 .

[24]  F. Rauscher,et al.  Classroom Keyboard Instruction Improves Kindergarten Children's Spatial-Temporal Performance: A Field Experiment. , 2000 .

[25]  E. Bialystok,et al.  Musical expertise, bilingualism, and executive functioning. , 2009, Journal of experimental psychology. Human perception and performance.

[26]  Shu Fai Cheung,et al.  Dependent effect sizes in meta-analysis: incorporating the degree of interdependence. , 2004, The Journal of applied psychology.

[27]  Tammo H. A. Bijmolt,et al.  Meta-Analysis in Marketing when Studies Contain Multiple Measurements , 2001 .

[28]  N. Kraus,et al.  Longitudinal Effects of Group Music Instruction on Literacy Skills in Low-Income Children , 2014, PloS one.

[29]  John R. Anderson.  Cognitive Psychology and Its Implications , 1980 .

[30]  Fernand Gobet,et al.  Do the benefits of chess instruction transfer to academic and cognitive skills? A meta-analysis , 2016 .

[31]  Deanna C. Friesen,et al.  Effect of Music Training on Promoting Preliteracy Skills: Preliminary Causal Evidence , 2011 .

[32]  Gunter Kreutz,et al.  Does music training enhance working memory performance? Findings from a quasi-experimental longitudinal study , 2014 .

[33]  T. Könen,et al.  Effects of Music Training on Attention, Processing Speed and Cognitive Music Abilities—Findings from a Longitudinal Study , 2014 .

[34]  E. Schellenberg,et al.  Group Music Training and Children's Prosocial Skills , 2015, PloS one.

[35]  Usha Goswami,et al.  A Rhythmic Musical Intervention for Poor Readers: A Comparison of Efficacy With a Letter‐Based Intervention , 2013 .

[36]  Mark W. Lipsey,et al.  Practical Meta-Analysis , 2000 .

[37]  G. Schlaug,et al.  THE RELATION BETWEEN MUSIC AND PHONOLOGICAL PROCESSING IN NORMAL-READING CHILDREN AND CHILDREN WITH DYSLEXIA , 2008 .

[38]  Joyce Eastlund Gromko,et al.  The Effect of Music Training on Preschoolers' Spatial-Temporal Task Performance , 1998 .

[39]  N. Charness,et al.  Expert Performance Its Structure and Acquisition , 2002 .

[40]  D. Moher,et al.  Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. , 2010, International journal of surgery.

[41]  E. Schellenberg,et al.  Music training and emotion comprehension in childhood. , 2012, Emotion.

[42]  Hilda M. Fehd,et al.  Does Music Training Enhance Literacy Skills? A Meta-Analysis , 2015, Front. Psychol..

[43]  Sylvia Defior,et al.  Effects of phonological and musical training on the reading readiness of native- and foreign-Spanish-speaking children , 2011 .

[44]  M. Besson,et al.  Musical training influences linguistic abilities in 8-year-old children: more evidence for brain plasticity. , 2009, Cerebral cortex.

[45]  Min-ju Lu,et al.  Effects of skill training on working memory capacity , 2007 .

[46]  Ellen Winner,et al.  The Arts and Academic Achievement: What the Evidence Shows , 2001 .

[47]  D. Hambrick,et al.  On Behalf Of: Association for Psychological Science Onlinefirst Version of Record >> Deliberate Practice and Performance in Music, Games, Sports, Education, and Professions: a Meta-analysis the Current Meta-analysis Effect Sizes Meta-analytic Procedure , 2022 .

[48]  G. Kreutz,et al.  Effects of a School-Based Instrumental Music Program on Verbal and Visual Memory in Primary School Children: A Longitudinal Study , 2012, Front. Psychology.

[49]  Hugo Cogo-Moreira,et al.  Effectiveness of Music Education for the Improvement of Reading Skills and Academic Achievement in Young Poor Readers: A Pragmatic Cluster-Randomized, Controlled Clinical Trial , 2013, PloS one.

[50]  D. Moher,et al.  Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. , 2010, International journal of surgery.

[51]  D. Register,et al.  The effects of live music groups versus an educational children's television program on the emergent literacy of young children. , 2004, Journal of music therapy.

[52]  Fernand Gobet,et al.  “No level up!”: no effects of video game specialization and expertise on cognitive performance , 2014, Front. Psychol..

[53]  E. Costa-Giomi,et al.  Effects of Three Years of Piano Instruction on Children’s Academic Achievement, School Performance and Self-Esteem , 2004 .

[54]  Kathryn Vaughn,et al.  Music and Mathematics: Modest Support for the Oft-Claimed Relationship. , 2000 .

[55]  Olivia Sagan,et al.  Can music lessons increase the performance of preschool children in IQ tests? , 2013, Cognitive Processing.

[56]  Leif D. Nelson,et al.  p-Curve and Effect Size , 2014, Perspectives on psychological science : a journal of the Association for Psychological Science.

[57]  M. Barnes,et al.  A meta-analysis of mathematics and working memory: Moderating effects of working memory domain, type of mathematics skill, and sample characteristics , 2016 .

[58]  Renjie Li,et al.  Perceptual Learning During Action Video Game Playing , 2010, Top. Cogn. Sci..

[59]  Joyce Eastlund Gromko.  The Effect of Music Instruction on Phonemic Awareness in Beginning Readers , 2005 .

[60]  J. Mestre.  Transfer of learning from a modern multidisciplinary perspective , 2005 .

[61]  Monica Melby-Lervåg,et al.  There is no convincing evidence that working memory training is effective: A reply to Au et al. (2014) and Karbach and Verhaeghen (2014) , 2015, Psychonomic Bulletin & Review.

[62]  Terry D. Bilhartz,et al.  The effect of early music training on child cognitive development , 1999 .

[63]  E. Schellenberg,et al.  Decoding speech prosody: do music lessons help? , 2004, Emotion.

[64]  Alexandre Pouget,et al.  Improved Probabilistic Inference as a General Learning Mechanism with Action Video Games , 2010, Current Biology.

[65]  L. Hedges,et al.  Introduction to Meta‐Analysis , 2009, International Coaching Psychology Review.

[66]  K. Hole.  The impact of an auditory training programme (The Listening Programme) on the auditory processing and reading skills of mainstream school children , 2013 .

[67]  Monica Melby-Lervåg,et al.  Is working memory training effective? A meta-analytic review. , 2013, Developmental psychology.

[68]  Andrew R. A. Conway,et al.  Individual differences in working memory capacity: more evidence for a general capacity theory. , 1996, Memory.

[69]  S Duval,et al.  Trim and Fill: A Simple Funnel‐Plot–Based Method of Testing and Adjusting for Publication Bias in Meta‐Analysis , 2000, Biometrics.

[70]  L. R. Smith,et al.  Music training and mathematics achievement. , 1999, Adolescence.

[71]  Susan M. Barnett,et al.  When and where do we apply what we learn? A taxonomy for far transfer. , 2002, Psychological bulletin.

[72]  Patricia B. Elmore,et al.  Correlational Meta-Analysis: Independent and Nonindependent Cases , 1992 .

[73]  Diane M. Cardarelli.  The effects of music instrumental training on performance on the reading and mathematics portions of the Florida Comprehensive Achievement Test for third grade students , 2003 .

[74]  E. Bialystok,et al.  Effects of short-term music and second-language training on executive control. , 2016, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[75]  John E. Hunter,et al.  Methods of Meta-Analysis: Correcting Error and Bias in Research Findings , 1991 .

[76]  I. Deary,et al.  Intelligence and educational achievement , 2007 .

[77]  M. Wolf,et al.  Links between early rhythm skills, musical training, and phonological awareness , 2013 .

[78]  L. Thompson,et al.  Predicting academic achievement with cognitive ability , 2007 .

[79]  E. Thorndike,et al.  The influence of improvement in one mental function upon the efficiency of other functions. (I). , 1901 .