Liquidity versus Wealth in Household Debt Obligations: Evidence from Housing Policy in the Great Recession

We exploit variation in mortgage modifications to disentangle the impact of reducing long-term obligations with no change in short-term payments (“wealth”), and reducing short-term payments with no change in long-term obligations (“liquidity”). Using regression discontinuity and difference-in-differences research designs with administrative data measuring default and consumption, we find that principal reductions that increase wealth without affecting liquidity have no effect, while maturity extensions that increase only liquidity have large effects. This suggests that liquidity drives default and consumption decisions for borrowers in our sample and that distressed debt restructurings can be redesigned with substantial gains to borrowers, lenders, and taxpayers. (JEL E21, G21, G51, R38)

[1]  Stijn Van Nieuwerburgh,et al.  Financial Fragility with SAM? , 2020, The Journal of Finance.

[2]  João F. Cocco,et al.  Structuring Mortgages for Macroeconomic Stability , 2020, The Journal of Finance.

[3]  Arpita Gupta,et al.  Selection, Leverage, and Default in the Mortgage Market , 2020, The Review of Financial Studies.

[4]  Yan Ji.  Job Search under Debt: Aggregate Implications of Student Loans , 2020, Journal of Monetary Economics.

[5]  Wei Xiong,et al.  Economic Consequences of Housing Speculation , 2019, The Review of Financial Studies.

[6]  Timothy J McQuade,et al.  How Do Foreclosures Exacerbate Housing Downturns? , 2019, The Review of Economic Studies.

[7]  Taylor D. Nadauld,et al.  Monthly Payment Targeting and the Demand for Maturity , 2019, The Review of Financial Studies.

[8]  Itzik Fadlon,et al.  Household Responses to Transfers and Liquidity: Evidence from Social Security’s Survivors Benefits , 2019 .

[9]  Joseph Vavra,et al.  Regional Heterogeneity and the Refinancing Channel of Monetary Policy* , 2018, The Quarterly Journal of Economics.

[10]  Thomas Schelkle.  Mortgage Default during the U.S. Mortgage Crisis , 2018, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking.

[11]  Amir Sufi,et al.  Credit Supply and Housing Speculation , 2018, The Review of Financial Studies.

[12]  A. McKay,et al.  Housing Wealth Effects: The Long View , 2018, The Review of Economic Studies.

[13]  A. Krishnamurthy,et al.  Mortgage Design in an Equilibrium Model of the Housing Market , 2018, Journal of Finance.

[14]  A. Fuster,et al.  How Do Mortgage Refinances Affect Debt, Default, and Spending? Evidence from HARP , 2018, American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics.

[15]  Peter Ganong,et al.  Mortgage Modifications after the Great Recession: New Evidence and Implications for Policy , 2017 .

[16]  Aditya Aladangady.  Housing Wealth and Consumption: Evidence from Geographically-Linked Microdata , 2017 .

[17]  Marco Di Maggio,et al.  Interest Rate Pass-Through: Mortgage Rates, Household Consumption, and Voluntary Deleveraging , 2017 .

[18]  G. Violante,et al.  The Housing Boom and Bust: Model Meets Evidence , 2017, Journal of Political Economy.

[19]  G. De Giorgi,et al.  Credit Growth and the Financial Crisis: A New Narrative , 2017, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[20]  Brian T. Melzer,et al.  Unemployment Insurance as a Housing Market Stabilizer , 2017 .

[21]  Jae Song,et al.  Targeted Debt Relief and the Origins of Financial Distress: Experimental Evidence from Distressed Credit Card Borrowers , 2017, American Economic Review.

[22]  Charles G. Nathanson,et al.  Speculative Dynamics of Prices and Volume , 2017, Journal of Financial Economics.

[23]  Adrien Auclert.  Monetary Policy and the Redistribution Channel , 2017, American Economic Review.

[24]  Virgiliu Midrigin,et al.  Liquidity Constraints in the U.S. Housing Market , 2017, The Review of Economic Studies.

[25]  G. Maturana.  When Are Modifications of Securitized Loans Beneficial to Investors? , 2017 .

[26]  A. DeFusco,et al.  Homeowner Borrowing and Housing Collateral: New Evidence from Expiring Price Controls , 2017 .

[27]  H. Kleven,et al.  The Effect of House Prices on Household Borrowing: A New Approach , 2017, American Economic Review.

[28]  Charles G. Nathanson,et al.  Arrested Development: Theory and Evidence of Supply-Side Speculation in the Housing Market , 2018, The Journal of Finance.

[29]  Samuel Kruger.  The Effect of Mortgage Securitization on Foreclosure and Modification , 2016, Journal of Financial Economics.

[30]  Hui Shan,et al.  Consumer Ruthlessness and Mortgage Default During the 2007 to 2009 Housing Bust , 2016 .

[31]  S. Shore,et al.  The Effect of Negative Equity on Mortgage Default: Evidence From HAMP’s Principal Reduction Alternative , 2016 .

[32]  David Berger,et al.  Stimulating Housing Markets , 2016, The Journal of Finance.

[33]  G. Violante,et al.  Non-Durable Consumption and Housing Net Worth in the Great Recession: Evidence from Easily Accessible Data , 2016, Journal of Public Economics.

[34]  Gabriel Ehrlich,et al.  Do Large-Scale Refinancing Programs Reduce Mortgage Defaults? Evidence from a Regression Discontinuity Design , 2015 .

[35]  David Berger,et al.  House Prices and Consumer Spending , 2015 .

[36]  Sumit Agarwal,et al.  Access to Home Equity and Consumption: Evidence from a Policy Experiment , 2015, Review of Economics and Statistics.

[37]  C. Palmer.  Why Did So Many Subprime Borrowers Default During the Crisis: Loose Credit or Plummeting Prices? , 2015 .

[38]  Kyle F. Herkenhoff,et al.  The Impact of Foreclosure Delay on U.S. Employment , 2015, Review of Economic Dynamics.

[39]  J. Stroebel,et al.  Do Banks Pass Through Credit Expansions to Consumers Who Want To Borrow? , 2015 .

[40]  L. Goodman,et al.  Loss Severity on Residential Mortgages: Evidence from Freddie Mac’s Newest Data , 2015, The Journal of Fixed Income.

[41]  Sumit Agarwal,et al.  Mortgage Refinancing, Consumer Spending, and Competition: Evidence from the Home Affordable Refinancing Program , 2015 .

[42]  Aaron Hedlund.  Failure to Launch: Housing, Debt Overhang, and the Inflation Option During the Great Recession , 2015 .

[43]  Felipe Severino,et al.  Loan Originations and Defaults in the Mortgage Crisis: The Role of the Middle Class , 2015 .

[44]  Sebastian Calonico,et al.  Robust Nonparametric Confidence Intervals for Regression‐Discontinuity Designs , 2014 .

[45]  Janice C. Eberly,et al.  Efficient Credit Policies in a Housing Debt Crisis , 2014 .

[46]  Jae Song,et al.  The Nature of Countercyclical Income Risk , 2012, Journal of Political Economy.

[47]  Timothy F. Geithner.  Stress Test: Reflections on Financial Crises , 2014 .

[48]  Amir Sufi,et al.  House Price Gains and U.S. Household Spending from 2002 to 2006 , 2014 .

[49]  Hui Chen,et al.  Houses as Atms? Mortgage Refinancing and Macroeconomic Uncertainty , 2013, The Journal of Finance.

[50]  Andreas Fuster,et al.  Payment Size, Negative Equity, and Mortgage Default , 2012 .

[51]  Kyle F. Herkenhoff,et al.  Unemployment, Negative Equity, and Strategic Default , 2013 .

[52]  Amir Sufi,et al.  Household Balance Sheets, Consumption, and the Economic Slump* , 2013 .

[53]  Giorgio E. Primiceri,et al.  Household Leveraging and Deleveraging , 2013 .

[54]  Florian Zettelmeyer,et al.  Are Consumers Myopic? Evidence from New and Used Car Purchases , 2013 .

[55]  Sumit Agarwal,et al.  Policy Intervention in Debt Renegotiation: Evidence from the Home Affordable Modification Program , 2012, Journal of Political Economy.

[56]  Gauti B. Eggertsson,et al.  Debt, Deleveraging, and the Liquidity Trap: A Fisher-Minsky-Koo Approach* , 2012 .

[57]  Joseph S. Tracy,et al.  Payment Changes and Default Risk: The Impact of Refinancing on Expected Credit Losses , 2012 .

[58]  Guido Lorenzoni,et al.  Credit Crises, Precautionary Savings, and the Liquidity Trap , 2011 .

[59]  João F. Cocco,et al.  A Model of Mortgage Default , 2011, The Journal of Finance.

[60]  Joseph S. Tracy,et al.  Real Estate Investors, the Leverage Cycle, and the Housing Market Crisis , 2011 .

[61]  John D. Worth,et al.  The HAMP NPV Model: Development and Early Performance , 2011 .

[62]  C. Mayer,et al.  Mortgage Modification and Strategic Behavior: Evidence from a Legal Settlement with Countrywide , 2011 .

[63]  Douglas D. Evanoff,et al.  The Role of Securitization in Mortgage Renegotiation , 2011 .

[64]  Paola Sapienza,et al.  The Determinants of Attitudes towards Strategic Default on Mortgages , 2011 .

[65]  C. Carroll,et al.  How Large are Housing and Financial Wealth Effects? A New Approach , 2010, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[66]  Søren Leth-Petersen,et al.  Intertemporal Consumption and Credit Constraints: Does Total Expenditure Respond to an Exogenous Shock to Credit? , 2010 .

[67]  Ning Zhu,et al.  Did Bankruptcy Reform Cause Mortgage Default to Rise? , 2010 .

[68]  Joseph S. Tracy,et al.  Second Chances: Subprime Mortgage Modification and Re-Default , 2009 .

[69]  Amir Sufi,et al.  House Prices, Home Equity-Based Borrowing, and the U.S. Household Leverage Crisis , 2009 .

[70]  C. Mulligan.  Means-Tested Mortgage Modification: Homes Saved or Income Destroyed? , 2009 .

[71]  David S. Lee,et al.  Regression Discontinuity Designs in Economics , 2009 .

[72]  Christopher L. Foote,et al.  Negative Equity and Foreclosure: Theory and Evidence , 2008 .

[73]  J. Poterba,et al.  Tax Expenditures for Owner-Occupied Housing: Deductions for Property Taxes and Mortgage Interest and the Exclusion of Imputed Rental Income , 2008 .

[74]  Justin McCrary,et al.  Manipulation of the Running Variable in the Regression Discontinuity Design: A Density Test , 2007 .

[75]  Alexei Tchistyi,et al.  Optimal Mortgage Design , 2006 .

[76]  A. Díaz,et al.  On the user cost and homeownership , 2006 .

[77]  C. Carroll,et al.  The Method of Endogenous Gridpoints for Solving Dynamic Stochastic Optimization Problems , 2006 .

[78]  João F. Cocco,et al.  How Do House Prices Affect Consumption? Evidence from Micro Data , 2004 .

[79]  M. Cagetti,et al.  Wealth Accumulation Over the Life Cycle and Precautionary Savings , 2003 .

[80]  E. Glaeser,et al.  Working Paper No. 05-10 Owner-occupied Housing as a Hedge against Rent Risk , 2005 .

[81]  N. Wallace,et al.  Mortgage Choice: What's the Point? , 1998 .

[82]  David I. Laibson,et al.  Golden Eggs and Hyperbolic Discounting , 1997 .

[83]  C. Carroll,et al.  Buffer-Stock Saving and the Life Cycle/Permanent Income Hypothesis , 1996 .

[84]  R. Jagannathan,et al.  Uninsured Idiosyncratic Risk and Aggregate Saving , 1994 .

[85]  J. Angrist,et al.  Identification and Estimation of Local Average Treatment Effects , 1994 .

[86]  Donald C. Keenan,et al.  Transaction Costs, Suboptimal Termination and Default Probabilities , 1993 .

[87]  S. Zeldes.  Consumption and Liquidity Constraints: An Empirical Investigation , 1989, Journal of Political Economy.

[88]  A. Ando.  [Consumption, Income, and Interest Rates: Reinterpreting the Time Series Evidence]: Comment , 1989, NBER Macroeconomics Annual.

[89]  John Y. Campbell,et al.  Consumption, Income, and Interest Rates: Reinterpreting the Time Series Evidence , 1989, NBER Macroeconomics Annual.

[90]  I. Fisher.  The Debt-Deflation Theory of Great Depressions , 1933 .

[91]  Asaf Bernstein.  Negative Equity, Household Debt Overhang, and Labor Supply , 2018 .

[92]  E. Hembre.  HAMP, Home Attachment, and Mortgage Default , 2014 .

[93]  Christopher D. Carroll,et al.  Solution Methods for Microeconomic Dynamic Stochastic Optimization Problems , 2012 .

[94]  Christopher R. Taber,et al.  Estimating the Effect of Student Aid on College Enrollment: Evidence from a Government Grant Policy Reform , 2008, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[95]  Petra E. Todd,et al.  IDENTIFICATION AND ESTIMATION OF TREATMENT EFFECTS WITH A REGRESSION-DISCONTINUITY DESIGN , 2001 .

[96]  C. Carroll.  The Buffer-Stock Theory of Saving: Some Macroeconomic Evidence , 1992 .