Counterfactual thinking: The temporal order effect

People often think about how things might have happened differently. Their counterfactual thoughts tend to mentally undo the most recent event in an independent sequence. Consider a game in which two players must each pick the same color card, both red or both black. The first picks black and the second picks red and so they lose. People think, “If only the second player had picked black.” Our study tested the idea that the ways in which the players could have won provide counterfactual alternatives to the facts. In three experiments, the same set of facts (both players picked black cards), and the same winning conditions (to win in this new game they must pick different color cards) were presented, but thedescription of the winning conditions varied (e.g., “if one or the other but not both picks a red card” vs. “if one or the other but not both picks a black card”). The results showed that the temporal order effect can be produced or reversed by different descriptions. The descriptions make accessible different elements of the winning possibilities. A theory of the mental representations and cognitive processes underlying counterfactual thinking in the temporal order effect is described.

[1]  Robert Stalnaker.  A Theory of Conditionals , 2019, Knowledge and Conditionals.

[2]  Donald Nute,et al.  Counterfactuals , 1975, Notre Dame J. Formal Log..

[3]  A. Tversky,et al.  The simulation heuristic , 1982 .

[4]  T. Au,et al.  Chinese and English counterfactuals: The Sapir-Whorf hypothesis revisited , 1983, Cognition.

[5]  Dale T. Miller,et al.  Norm theory: Comparing reality to its alternatives , 1986 .

[6]  J. Landman.  Regret and Elation Following Action and Inaction , 1987 .

[7]  G. Wells,et al.  The undoing of scenarios. , 1987 .

[8]  J. Baron.  Thinking and Deciding , 2023 .

[9]  Dale T. Miller,et al.  The counterfactual fallacy: Confusing what might have been with what ought to have been , 1990 .

[10]  Dale T. Miller,et al.  Temporal order and the perceived mutability of events: implications for blame assignment , 1990 .

[11]  P. Legrenzi,et al.  Event controllability in counterfactual thinking , 1991 .

[12]  P. Johnson-Laird,et al.  Focussing in reasoning and decision making , 1993, Cognition.

[13]  K. Markman,et al.  The Mental Simulation of Better and Worse Possible Worlds , 1993 .

[14]  N. Roese.  The Functional Basis of Counterfactual Thinking , 1994 .

[15]  P. Niedenthal,et al.  "If only I weren't" versus "if only I hadn't": distinguishing shame and guilt in counterfactual thinking. , 1994, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[16]  N. Roese,et al.  What Might Have Been: The Social Psychology of Counterfactual Thinking , 1995 .

[17]  T. Gilovich,et al.  The experience of regret: what, when, and why. , 1995, Psychological review.

[18]  Nyla R. Branscombe,et al.  Mental Simulation and Causal Attribution: When Simulating an Event Does Not Affect Fault Assignment , 1995 .

[19]  Christopher G. Davis,et al.  The Undoing of Traumatic Life Events , 1995 .

[20]  Marcia Grabowecky,et al.  Escape from linear time: Prefrontal cortex and conscious experience , 1995 .

[21]  S. Sherman,et al.  The Role of Counterfactual Thinking in Reasoning , 1996 .

[22]  D. R. Lehman,et al.  Counterfactual thinking and ascriptions of cause and preventability. , 1996, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[23]  P. Harris,et al.  Children's use of counterfactual thinking in causal reasoning , 1996, Cognition.

[24]  Ruth M. J. Byrne,et al.  Cognitive Processes in Counterfactual Thinking about what Might Have Been , 1997 .

[25]  Nyla R. Branscombe,et al.  When Does Action Elicit More Regret Than Inaction and Is Counterfactual Mutation the Mediator of This Effect , 1997 .

[26]  A. Manstead,et al.  Undoing Regret on Dutch Television: Apologizing for Interpersonal Regrets Involving Actions or Inactions , 1998 .

[27]  John McCarthy,et al.  Useful Counterfactuals , 1999, Electron. Trans. Artif. Intell..

[28]  K. Teigen,et al.  Good luck and bad luck: how to tell the difference , 1999 .

[29]  Ruth M. J. Byrne,et al.  Deductive reasoning with factual, possible, and counterfactual conditionals , 1999, Memory & cognition.

[30]  J. Baron.  Thinking and deciding, 3rd ed. , 2000 .

[31]  R. Byrne,et al.  Counterfactual thinking about actions and failures to act. , 2000, Journal of experimental psychology. Learning, memory, and cognition.

[32]  Ruth M. J. Byrne,et al.  The temporality effect in counterfactual thinking about what might have been , 2000, Memory & cognition.

[33]  R. Byrne,et al.  Counterfactual thinking about controllable events , 2000, Memory & cognition.

[34]  R. Byrne,et al.  A Computational Model of Counterfactual Thinkin: The Temporal Order Effect , 2001 .

[35]  P. Tetlock,et al.  Poking Counterfactual Holes in Covering Laws: Cognitive Styles and Historical Reasoning , 2001, American Political Science Review.

[36]  R. Byrne,et al.  Temporal and causal order effects in thinking about what might have been , 2002, The Quarterly journal of experimental psychology. A, Human experimental psychology.

[37]  Mark T. Keane,et al.  Conditionals: a theory of meaning, pragmatics, and inference. , 2002, Psychological review.

[38]  N. Schwarz,et al.  When debiasing backfires: accessible content and accessibility experiences in debiasing hindsight. , 2002, Journal of experimental psychology. Learning, memory, and cognition.

[39]  R. Byrne.  Mental models and counterfactual thoughts about what might have been , 2002, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[40]  C. Walsh.  The role of context in counterfactual thinking , 2002 .

[41]  Valerie A Thompson,et al.  Reasoning counterfactually: making inferences about things that didn't happen. , 2002, Journal of experimental psychology. Learning, memory, and cognition.

[42]  David R. Mandel.  Counterfactuals, emotions, and context , 2003, Cognition & emotion.

[43]  Ruth M. J. Byrne,et al.  Reasoning with deontic and counterfactual conditionals , 2003 .

[44]  G. Wells,et al.  Mental Simulation of Causality , 1989 .

[45]  Ran R. Hassin,et al.  The New Unconscious , 2006 .