Safety of telephone triage in out-of-hours care: A systematic review

Objective.Telephone triage in patients requesting help may compromise patient safety, particularly if urgency is underestimated and the patient is not seen by a physician. The aim was to assess the research evidence on safety of telephone triage in out-of-hours primary care. Methods. A systematic review was performed of published research on telephone triage in out-of-hours care, searching in PubMed and EMBASE up to March 2010. Studies were included if they concerned out-of-hours medical care and focused on telephone triage in patients with a first request for help. Study inclusion and data extraction were performed by two researchers independently. Post-hoc two types of studies were distinguished: observational studies in contacts with real patients (unselected and highly urgent contacts), and prospective observational studies using high-risk simulated patients (with a highly urgent health problem). Results. Thirteen observational studies showed that on average triage was safe in 97% (95% CI 96.5–97.4%) of all patients contacting out-of-hours care and in 89% (95% CI 86.7–90.2%) of patients with high urgency. Ten studies that used high-risk simulated patients showed that on average 46% (95% CI 42.7–49.8%) were safe. Adverse events described in the studies included mortality (n = 6 studies), hospitalisations (n = 5), attendance at emergency department (n=1), and medical errors (n = 6). Conclusions. There is room for improvement in safety of telephone triage in patients who present symptoms that are high risk. As these have a low incidence, recognition of these calls poses a challenge to health care providers in daily practice.

[1]  M. Leach.  Out-of-hours care. , 2013, The British journal of general practice : the journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners.

[2]  S. Hunskaar,et al.  Minor ailments in out-of-hours primary care: An observational study , 2011, Scandinavian journal of primary health care.

[3]  R. Winkens,et al.  ‘Quod scripsi, scripsi.’ The quality of the report of telephone consultations at Dutch out-of-hours centres , 2010, Quality and Safety in Health Care.

[4]  J Dowell,et al.  The quality, safety and content of telephone and face-to-face consultations: a comparative study , 2010, Quality and Safety in Health Care.

[5]  G. Karabatsos,et al.  How safe is telenursing from home? , 2009, Collegian.

[6]  Michel Wensing,et al.  Out-of-hours care in western countries: assessment of different organizational models , 2009, BMC health services research.

[7]  J André Knottnerus,et al.  Quality of clinical aspects of call handling at Dutch out of hours centres: cross sectional national study , 2008, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[8]  A. Sheikh,et al.  Telephone triage in out of hours call centres , 2008, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[9]  E. D. de Vries,et al.  The incidence and nature of in-hospital adverse events: a systematic review , 2008, Quality & Safety in Health Care.

[10]  R. Grol,et al.  Safety of telephone triage in general practitioner cooperatives: do triage nurses correctly estimate urgency? , 2007, Quality and Safety in Health Care.

[11]  Katherine G. Sandford,et al.  Patient safety in after-hours telephone medicine. , 2007, Family medicine.

[12]  Daniel A. Hirsh,et al.  The Host Hospital 24-Hour Underreferral Rate: An Automated Measure of Call-Center Safety , 2007, Pediatrics.

[13]  B. Stewart,et al.  Review of calls to NHS Direct related to attendance in the paediatric emergency department , 2006, Emergency Medicine Journal.

[14]  C. V. van Uden,et al.  After-hours care in the United Kingdom, Denmark, and the Netherlands: new models. , 2006, Health affairs.

[15]  Douglas H. Fernald,et al.  Harm resulting from inappropriate telephone triage in primary care. , 2006, Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine : JABFM.

[16]  David Magid,et al.  How Safe Is Triage by an After-Hours Telephone Call Center? , 2006, Pediatrics.

[17]  I. St George,et al.  Healthline: do primary care doctors agree with the advice? , 2005, The New Zealand medical journal.

[18]  J. Dale,et al.  Safety of telephone consultation for “non-serious” emergency ambulance service patients , 2004, Quality and Safety in Health Care.

[19]  F Bunn,et al.  Telephone consultation and triage: effects on health care use and patient satisfaction. , 2004, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[20]  A. Luberti,et al.  Outcomes of Children Referred to an Emergency Department by an After-Hours Call Center , 2004, Pediatric emergency care.

[21]  Peter Sprivulis,et al.  Compliance with advice and appropriateness of emergency presentation following contact with the HealthDirect telephone triage service. , 2004, Emergency medicine Australasia : EMA.

[22]  H. Moriarty,et al.  Mystery shopping in health service evaluation. , 2003, The British journal of general practice : the journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners.

[23]  A. Luberti,et al.  Outcomes associated with pediatric after-hours care by call centers: a multicenter study. , 2003, Ambulatory pediatrics : the official journal of the Ambulatory Pediatric Association.

[24]  J. Labarère,et al.  Patient compliance with medical advice given by telephone. , 2003, The American journal of emergency medicine.

[25]  D. Dunt,et al.  A systematic review of the effect of different models of after-hours primary medical care services on clinical outcome, medical workload, and patient and GP satisfaction. , 2003, Family practice.

[26]  John M Westfall,et al.  After-hours telephone triage affects patient safety. , 2003, The Journal of family practice.

[27]  A. Glasper,et al.  Overnight calls in primary care: randomised controlled trial of management using nurse telephone consultation , 1999, BMJ.

[28]  D. Schriger,et al.  Effect of visual cues, vital signs, and protocols on triage: a prospective randomized crossover trial. , 1998, Annals of emergency medicine.

[29]  Joanne Turnbull,et al.  Safety and effectiveness of nurse telephone consultation in out of hours primary care: randomised controlled trial , 1998 .

[30]  I. Jacobs,et al.  Emergency department telephone advice , 1998, The Medical journal of Australia.

[31]  J. Dale,et al.  Telephone triage--how good are the decisions? (Part 2). , 1998, Nursing standard (Royal College of Nursing (Great Britain) : 1987).

[32]  F. Olesen,et al.  Out of hours service in Denmark: evaluation five years after reform , 1998, BMJ.

[33]  J. Dale,et al.  Telephone triage--identifying the demand (Part 1). , 1998, Nursing standard (Royal College of Nursing (Great Britain) : 1987).

[34]  F. Poole,et al.  Review of a computer based telephone Helpline in an A&E department. , 1996, Journal of accident & emergency medicine.

[35]  J. E. George,et al.  Emergency department telephone advice. , 1995, Journal of emergency nursing: JEN : official publication of the Emergency Department Nurses Association.

[36]  J Leprohon,et al.  The role of protocols and professional judgement in emergency medical dispatching. , 1995, European journal of emergency medicine : official journal of the European Society for Emergency Medicine.

[37]  M. J. Carey,et al.  Telephone advice about an infant given by after-hours clinics and emergency departments. , 1995, The New Zealand medical journal.

[38]  R. Kunkler,et al.  Advice over the telephone. , 1994, Nursing times.

[39]  Y. Waisman,et al.  Pediatric telephone advice: a new medical service in Israel. , 1994, Israel journal of medical sciences.

[40]  R. Koster,et al.  Telephone triage of cardiac emergency calls by dispatchers: a prospective study of 1386 emergency calls. , 1994, British heart journal.

[41]  A. Cope,et al.  Use of a telephone advise line in an accident and emergency department , 1994, BMJ.

[42]  T. Carruth,et al.  After-hours telephone coverage: the application of an area-wide telephone triage and advice system for pediatric practices. , 1993, Pediatrics.

[43]  T. Rainer,et al.  Telephone advice in the accident and emergency department: a survey of current practice. , 1993, Archives of emergency medicine.

[44]  L. Alexander.  Pediatric telephone advice in the emergency department: Results of a mock scenario: Isaacman DJ, Verdile VP, Kohen FP, et al Pediatrics 89:35–39 Jan 1992 , 1992 .

[45]  D J Balaban,et al.  Telephone triage by primary care physicians. , 1992, Pediatrics.

[46]  D. Isaacman,et al.  Pediatric telephone advice in the emergency department: results of a mock scenario. , 1992, Pediatrics.

[47]  T. Miller,et al.  Urgent care center pediatric telephone advice. , 1990, The American journal of emergency medicine.

[48]  P. Paris,et al.  Emergency department telephone advice. , 1989, Annals of emergency medicine.

[49]  C J McDonald,et al.  After-hours Telephone Access to Physicians With Access to Computerized Medical Records: Experience in an Inner-city General Medicine Clinic , 1985, Medical care.

[50]  E. B. Wilson.  Probable Inference, the Law of Succession, and Statistical Inference , 1927 .

[51]  G. Vanzetto,et al.  Inappropriate dispatcher decision for emergency medical service users with acute myocardial infarction. , 2011, The American journal of emergency medicine.

[52]  J. Carroll.  The diagnosis-related group (DRG) system. , 2010, Quality management in health care.

[53]  St Anthony 's Hospital.  After hours care. , 2003, Texas dental journal.

[54]  P. Vedsted,et al.  The effect of an out-of-hours reform on attendance at casualty wards. The Danish example. , 2001, Scandinavian journal of primary health care.

[55]  A. Glasper,et al.  Safety and effectiveness of nurse telephone consultation in out of hours primary care: randomised controlled trial. The South Wiltshire Out of Hours Project (SWOOP) Group. , 1998, BMJ.

[56]  P. Rautava,et al.  Out-of-hours utilization in primary and secondary care. A favourable experience in a Finnish health centre. , 1998, Scandinavian journal of primary health care.

[57]  RESEARCH ARTICLE Open Access Patient safety in out-of-hours primary care: a review of patient records , 2022 .