Critical realist review: exploring the real, beyond the empirical

This article defines the ‘critical realist review’, a literature-based methodological approach to critical analysis of health care studies (or any discipline charged with social interventions) that is robust, insightful and essential for the complexities of twenty-first century evidence-based health and social care. We argue that this approach, underpinned by a critical realist philosophy and methodology, will facilitate students and researchers to employ relevant theoretical insights from a range of disciplines that have necessary contributions to make to our understanding of health and social care practice and provision. We explore the limitations of randomised controlled trials (RCTs) and the systematic review for informing evidence-based health and social care. The article also offers some suggestions on method, although, as we argue, the approach deliberately eschews a ‘cookbook’ approach. A glossary of terms is provided in the Appendix.

[1]  C. Gastmans,et al.  Nursing and Euthanasia: a Review of Argument-Based Ethics Literature , 2009, Nursing ethics.

[2]  R. Bhaskar Scientific Realism and Human Emancipation , 1986 .

[3]  J. Coverdale,et al.  Argument-based medical ethics: a formal tool for critically appraising the normative medical ethics literature. , 2004, American journal of obstetrics and gynecology.

[4]  M. Meldrum,et al.  A brief history of the randomized controlled trial. From oranges and lemons to the gold standard. , 2000, Hematology/oncology clinics of North America.

[5]  M. Avis,et al.  Meta-analysis: the glass eye of evidence-based practice? , 2002, Nursing inquiry.

[6]  G. Rolfe Nursing and the art of radical critique. , 2008, Nurse education today.

[7]  E. Manias,et al.  A critical review of daily sedation interruption in the intensive care unit. , 2009, Journal of clinical nursing.

[8]  S. Lundgren,et al.  Students' expectations, concerns and comprehensions when writing theses as part of their nursing education. , 2009, Nurse education today.

[9]  M. Grace A logical point of view , 2003, British Dental Journal.

[10]  A. Pilnick,et al.  On the remarkable persistence of asymmetry in doctor/patient interaction: a critical review. , 2007, Social science & medicine.

[11]  T. Greenhalgh,et al.  Realist synthesis - an introduction , 2004 .

[12]  S. Clegg Evidence‐based practice in educational research: a critical realist critique of systematic review , 2005 .

[13]  G. Rolfe Insufficient evidence: the problems of evidence-based nursing. , 1999, Nurse education today.

[14]  A. Sayer System, Lifeworld and Gender: Associational Versus Counterfactual Thinking , 2000 .

[15]  J. Rattray,et al.  Emotional outcome after intensive care: literature review. , 2008, Journal of advanced nursing.

[16]  P. Pettit The Possibility of Naturalism. , 1981 .

[17]  J. Ussher Are We Medicalizing Women’s Misery? A Critical Review of Women’s Higher Rates of Reported Depression , 2010 .

[18]  J. Holmwood Gender and Critical Realism: A Critique of Sayer , 2001 .

[19]  P. McGuire,et al.  Cannabis and anxiety: a critical review of the evidence , 2009, Human psychopharmacology.

[20]  Craig Morgan,et al.  Environment and schizophrenia: environmental factors in schizophrenia: childhood trauma--a critical review. , 2006, Schizophrenia bulletin.

[21]  R. Sanson-Fisher,et al.  Measuring the psychosocial health of adolescent and young adult (AYA) cancer survivors: a critical review , 2010, Health and quality of life outcomes.

[22]  D. Ciliska,et al.  Implementing evidence-based nursing: some misconceptions , 1998 .

[23]  Tony N. Brown,et al.  Evaluating the Health Belief Model: A critical review of studies predicting mammographic and pap screening , 2010 .

[24]  K. Adams,et al.  A critical review of the literature on social and leisure activity and wellbeing in later life , 2010, Ageing and Society.

[25]  Daniel Strech,et al.  How to write a systematic review of reasons , 2011, Journal of Medical Ethics.

[26]  D. Anthony Evidence-based Policy: A Realist Perspective , 2007 .

[27]  MNursSci Rn L. Bates Ba,et al.  Confronting Goffman: how can mental health nurses effectively challenge stigma? A critical review of the literature , 2012 .

[28]  T. Greenhalgh,et al.  Realist review - a new method of systematic review designed for complex policy interventions , 2005, Journal of health services research & policy.

[29]  A. Assiter,et al.  Feminist Politics and Human Nature , 1985 .

[30]  Martyn Hammersley,et al.  Ethnography : Principles in Practice , 1983 .

[31]  J. Manthorpe,et al.  The evolution of social work education in England: a critical review of its connections and commonalities with nurse education. , 2005, Nurse education today.

[32]  Andrew Collier Critical Realism: An Introduction to Roy Bhaskar's Philosophy , 1994 .

[33]  Andrew Sayer,et al.  Method in Social Science: A Realist Approach , 1984 .

[34]  W. Quine The two dogmas of empiricism , 1951 .

[35]  I. Holloway,et al.  Qualitative Research for Nurses , 1996 .

[36]  J. Westermeyer,et al.  Measuring trauma and health status in refugees: a critical review. , 2002, JAMA.

[37]  P. Bjorklund Taking Responsibility: Toward an Understanding of Morality in Practice A Critical Review of the Empirical and Selected Philosophical Literature on the Social Organization of Responsibility , 2006, ANS. Advances in nursing science.

[38]  M. Dixon-Woods,et al.  Conducting a critical interpretive synthesis of the literature on access to healthcare by vulnerable groups , 2006 .

[39]  A. Edgley,et al.  Measuring quality of life in thai women with breast cancer. , 2011, Asian Pacific journal of cancer prevention : APJCP.

[40]  A. Sayer,et al.  Realism and Social Science , 1999 .

[41]  J. Repper,et al.  The politics of recovery in mental health: A left libertarian policy analysis , 2012 .

[42]  A. Jinks Methodological considerations of undertaking research with clinical mentors in the UK: a critical review of the literature. , 2007, Nurse education today.

[43]  Maria J Grant,et al.  A typology of reviews: an analysis of 14 review types and associated methodologies. , 2009, Health information and libraries journal.

[44]  Margaret McAllister,et al.  The importance of teaching and learning resilience in the health disciplines: a critical review of the literature. , 2009, Nurse education today.