Comprehension of wh-questions and declarative sentences in agrammatic aphasia: The set partition hypothesis

Abstract Problematic trace-antecedent relations between deep and surface structure have been a dominant theme in sentence comprehension in agrammatism. We challenge this view and propose that the comprehension in agrammatism in declarative sentences and wh-questions stems from impaired processing in logical form. We present new data from wh-questions and declarative sentences and advance a new hypothesis which we call the set partition hypothesis. We argue that elements that signal set partition operations influence sentence comprehension while trace-antecedent relations remain intact.

[1]  T. Harley.  The psychology of language: From data to theory, 2nd ed. , 2001 .

[2]  Miseon Lee,et al.  Agrammatic aphasic production and comprehension of unaccusative verbs in sentence contexts , 2004, Journal of Neurolinguistics.

[3]  T. Gallagher,et al.  WH-Questions: Responses by Aphasic Patients , 1977, Cortex.

[4]  Harold Goodglass,et al.  The effect of syntactic encoding on sentence comprehension in aphasia , 1979, Brain and Language.

[5]  Maria Mercedes Piñango,et al.  Semantic Operations in Aphasic Comprehension: Implications for the Cortical Organization of Language , 2001, Brain and Language.

[6]  Angela D. Friederici,et al.  Thematic roles as event structure relations , 2006 .

[7]  X. Seron,et al.  Sentence understanding and knowledge of the world: Evidences from a sentence-picture matching task performed by aphasic patients , 1981, Brain and Language.

[8]  Eva Neuhaus,et al.  Production and comprehension of wh-questions in German Broca's aphasia , 2008, Journal of Neurolinguistics.

[9]  R H Brookshire,et al.  Verification of active and passive sentences by aphasic and nonaphasic subjects. , 1980, Journal of speech and hearing research.

[10]  David Swinney,et al.  Neurological Distribution of Processing Resources Underlying Language Comprehension , 1996, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[11]  D. Swinney,et al.  An On-Line Analysis of Syntactic Processing in Broca′s and Wernicke′s Aphasia , 1993, Brain and Language.

[12]  Henk J. Haarmann,et al.  Syntactic priming in broca's aphasics: Evidence for slow activation , 1991 .

[13]  R. May.  Logical Form: Its Structure and Derivation , 1985 .

[14]  C. R. Flowers,et al.  Aphasic adults' use of heuristic and structural linguistic cues for sentence analysis , 1982, Brain and Language.

[15]  Renate Bartsch,et al.  The Semantics and Syntax of Number and Numbers , 1973 .

[16]  Friedemann Pulvermüller,et al.  Agrammatism: behavioral description and neurobiological explanation. , 1995, Journal of cognitive neuroscience.

[17]  P. Doyle,et al.  Lexical access rate of closed-class elements during auditory sentence comprehension in adults with aphasia , 2002 .

[18]  Naama Friedmann,et al.  Sentence comprehension and working memory limitation in aphasia: A dissociation between semantic-syntactic and phonological reactivation , 2003, Brain and Language.

[19]  Y. Grodzinsky.  A Restrictive Theory of Agrammatic Comprehension , 1995, Brain and Language.

[20]  M Black,et al.  Sentence processing deficits: a replication of therapy. , 1991, The British journal of disorders of communication.

[21]  J. Hayes.  Cognition and the development of language , 1970 .

[22]  G. Hickok,et al.  Comprehension of Wh-Questions in Two Broca's Aphasics , 1996, Brain and Language.

[23]  K Poeck,et al.  The fluency-non fluency dimension in the classification of aphasic speech. , 1972, Cortex; a journal devoted to the study of the nervous system and behavior.

[24]  Noam Chomsky.  Language and Responsibility , 1979 .

[25]  Norbert Hornstein,et al.  Logical Form: From Gb to Minimalism , 1995 .

[26]  Emily B. Myers,et al.  Selectional restriction and semantic priming effects in normals and Broca's aphasics , 2005, Journal of Neurolinguistics.

[27]  Y. Grodzinsky.  The neurology of syntax: Language use without Broca's area , 2000, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[28]  H. Kolk,et al.  On-line Sensitivity to Subject-Verb Agreement Violations in Broca′s Aphasics: The Role of Syntactic Complexity and Time , 1994, Brain and Language.

[29]  Alice G. B. ter Meulen,et al.  The representation of (in)definiteness , 1989 .

[30]  E. Williams.  A reassignment of the function of LF , 1986 .

[31]  Ray Jackendoff,et al.  The Architecture of the Language Faculty , 1996 .

[32]  S. Edwards,et al.  Pronominal reference and agrammatic comprehension , 2003, Brain and Language.

[33]  Dominique Sportiche,et al.  The position of subjects , 1991 .

[34]  K. Ballard,et al.  Agrammatic Aphasic Subjects' Comprehension of Subject and Object ExtractedWhQuestions , 1999, Brain and Language.

[35]  Yosef Grodzinsky,et al.  Grammatical Disorders in Aphasia: A Neurolinguistic Perspective , 2000 .

[36]  Noam Chomsky.  Knowledge of language: its nature, origin, and use , 1988 .

[37]  Trevor A. Harley,et al.  The psychology of language : from data to theory , 2001 .

[38]  Douglas Biber,et al.  Frequency Analysis of English Vocabulary and Grammar , 1991 .

[39]  C. Thompson,et al.  The resolution and recovery of filler-gap dependencies in aphasia: Evidence from on-line anomaly detection , 2004, Brain and Language.

[40]  J. D. Saddy.  Variables and Events in the Syntax of Agrammatic Speech , 1995, Brain and Language.

[41]  R. D. Bleser,et al.  Does morphology make the difference? Agrammatic sentence comprehension in German , 2003, Brain and Language.

[42]  Myrna F. Schwartz,et al.  ‘Agrammatic’ comprehension it's not: Alternatives and implications , 1988 .

[43]  Angela D. Friederici,et al.  Semantic role universals and argument linking: Theoretical, typological and psycholinguistic perspectives , 2006 .

[44]  Noam Chomsky,et al.  Lectures on Government and Binding , 1981 .

[45]  Markus Werning,et al.  The Compositionality of Meaning and Content. Volume I - Foundational Issues, , 2005 .

[46]  Ernest Lepore,et al.  The compositionality papers , 2002 .

[47]  D. Caplan,et al.  Syntactic determinants of sentence comprehension in aphasia , 1985, Cognition.

[48]  F. Cuetos,et al.  Understanding Disorders in Agrammatic Patients: Capacity or Structural Deficits? , 1998, Brain and Language.

[49]  J. Fodor,et al.  The structure of a semantic theory , 1963 .

[50]  L. Tyler,et al.  Dissociations of lexical function: Semantics, syntax, and morphology , 1995 .

[51]  M. Piñango,et al.  The role of the anterior left hemisphere in real-time sentence comprehension: Evidence from split intransitivity , 2003, Brain and Language.

[52]  S. Avrutin.  Comprehension of Discourse-Linked and Non-Discourse-Linked Questions by Children and Broca's Aphasics , 2000 .

[53]  David Swinney,et al.  Language and the brain : representation and processing , 2000 .

[54]  Angela D. Friederici,et al.  Structural Prominence and Agrammatic Theta-Role Assignment: A Reconsideration of Linear Strategies , 1998, Brain and Language.

[55]  D. Bolinger.  The Atomization of Meaning , 1965 .

[56]  Liliane Haegeman,et al.  Introduction to Government and Binding Theory , 1991 .

[57]  M. Piñango.  Chapter 17 – Canonicity in Broca's Sentence Comprehension: The Case of Psychological Verbs* , 2000 .

[58]  Susan Edwards,et al.  Word order and finiteness in Dutch and English Broca’s and Wernicke’s aphasia , 2004, Brain and Language.

[59]  Tracy Love,et al.  On the Categorization of Aphasic Typologies: The SOAP (A Test of Syntactic Complexity) , 2002, Journal of psycholinguistic research.

[60]  M. Linebarger.  Agrammatism as Evidence About Grammar , 1995, Brain and Language.

[61]  A. Caramazza,et al.  Dissociation of algorithmic and heuristic processes in language comprehension: Evidence from aphasia , 1976, Brain and Language.

[62]  Irene Heim,et al.  The semantics of definite and indefinite noun phrases : a dissertation , 1982 .

[63]  Noam Chomsky,et al.  The Minimalist Program , 1992 .

[64]  Angela D. Friederici,et al.  Strategy and Impairment in Sentence Understanding by Broca's and Wernicke's Aphasics , 1985, Cortex.

[65]  W. O'grady,et al.  A mapping theory of agrammatic comprehension deficits , 2005, Brain and Language.

[66]  Sándor G. J. Hervey.  Axiomatic semantics : a theory of linguistic semantics , 1979 .

[67]  John Lyons,et al.  Linguistic Semantics: An Introduction , 1995 .

[68]  Irene Heim,et al.  Semantics in generative grammar , 1998 .

[69]  Angela D. Friederici,et al.  Temporal Constraints on Language Processing: Syntactic Priming in Broca's Aphasia , 1989, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[70]  R. Montague.  Formal philosophy; selected papers of Richard Montague , 1974 .

[71]  Susan Edwards,et al.  Pronominal and anaphoric reference in agrammatism , 2007, Journal of Neurolinguistics.

[72]  S. Blumstein,et al.  Syntactic priming effects in aphasia: An investigation of local syntactic dependencies , 1991, Brain and Language.

[73]  C. C. Mitchum,et al.  Patterns of Sentence Comprehension in Aphasia: A Consideration of Three Hypotheses , 1997, Brain and Language.

[74]  Y. Grodzinsky.  Language deficits and the theory of syntax , 1986, Brain and Language.

[75]  S. Blumstein,et al.  On-Line Processing of Filler–Gap Constructions in Aphasia , 1998, Brain and Language.