Knowledge of results and motor learning: a review and critical reappraisal.

Previous analyses of knowledge of results (KR) and motor learning have generally confounded the transient performance effects as shown when KR is present and the relatively permanent (i.e., learned) effects that we argue should be evaluated on a transfer test without KR. In this review, we classify investigations according to this distinction, and a number of new relations emerge between KR and both learning and performance. In addition to the motivational and associational roles of KR, we emphasize that it also acts as guidance, enhancing performance when it is present but degrading learning if it is given too frequently.

[1]  W. James,et al.  The Principles of Psychology. , 1983 .

[2]  G. F. Arps.  Work with knowledge of results versus work without knowledge of results: Awareness and partial awareness as factors conditioning efficiency. , 1920 .

[3]  E L Thorndike.  EDUCATIONAL PSYCHOLOGY. , 1923, Science.

[4]  S. L. Crawley.  An experimental investigation of recovery from work , 1926 .

[5]  E. Thorndike.  The law of effect. , 1927 .

[6]  C. Murchison.  The foundations of experimental psychology , 1929 .

[7]  M. Mayer.  Foundations of experimental psychology , 1930 .

[8]  M. H. Trowbridge,et al.  An Experimental Study of Thorndike's Theory of Learning , 1932 .

[9]  F. W. Irwin.  Purposive Behavior in Animals and Men , 1932, The Psychological Clinic.

[10]  Edward L. Thorndike,et al.  The influence of delay in the aftereffect of a connection , 1935 .

[11]  G. C. Grindley,et al.  THE EFFECT OF KNOWLEDGE OF RESULTS ON LEARNING AND PERFORMANCE: I. A CO-ORDINATED MOVEMENT OF THE TWO HANDS , 1938 .

[12]  Alex Bavelas,et al.  The functioning of knowledge of results in Thorndike's line-drawing experiment. , 1941 .

[13]  How psychology can facilitate military training—a concrete example. , 1942 .

[14]  B. Skinner,et al.  Principles of Behavior , 1944 .

[15]  C. L. Hull.  Principles of Behavior , 1945 .

[16]  W. O. Jenkins,et al.  Partial reinforcement: a review and critique. , 1950, Psychological bulletin.

[17]  Robert B. Ammons,et al.  Motor Skills , 1951 .

[18]  G. C. Grindley,et al.  The Effect of Knowledge of Results on Learning and Performance IV. The Direction of the Error in Very Simple Skills , 1951 .

[19]  J. A. Adams,et al.  Effect of distribution and shift in distribution of practice within a single training session. , 1953, Journal of experimental psychology.

[20]  E A BILODEAU,et al.  Speed of acquiring a simple motor response as a function of the systematic transformation of knowledge of results. , 1953, The American journal of psychology.

[21]  W. F. Battig,et al.  The effect of kinesthetic, verbal, and visual cues on the acquisition of a lever-positioning skill. , 1954, Journal of experimental psychology.

[22]  J. A. Adams,et al.  Effect of shift in distribution of practice conditions following interpolated rest. , 1954, Journal of experimental psychology.

[23]  R S LINCOLN,et al.  Learning a rate of movement. , 1954, Journal of experimental psychology.

[24]  C. Noble,et al.  Effects of complex transformations of feedback upon simple instrumental behavior. , 1955, Journal of Experimental Psychology.

[25]  I. J. Saltzman,et al.  Delay of Reward and Human Motor Learning , 1955 .

[26]  E. Archer,et al.  Effect of long-term practice and time-on-target information feedback on a complex tracking task. , 1956, Journal of Experimental Psychology.

[27]  R. Ammons.  Effects of Knowledge of Performance: A Survey and Tentative Theoretical Formulation , 1956 .

[28]  J. Greenspoon,et al.  Effect of delay of knowledge of results on learning a motor task. , 1956, Journal of Experimental Psychology.

[29]  I. Bilodeau,et al.  Accuracy of a simple positioning response with variation in the number of trials by which knowledge of results is delayed. , 1956, The American journal of psychology.

[30]  Maxwell L. Howell.  Use of Force-Time Graphs for Performance Analysis in Facilitating Motor Learning , 1956 .

[31]  C. M. Solley.  Reduction of error with practice in perception of the postural vertical. , 1956, Journal of experimental psychology.

[32]  John Annett,et al.  Knowledge of results and skilled performance. , 1957 .

[33]  L. E. Bourne,et al.  Effects of delay of information feedback and task complexity on the identification of concepts. , 1957, Journal of experimental psychology.

[34]  I. Bilodeau,et al.  Variation of temporal intervals among critical events in five studies of knowledge of results. , 1958, Journal of experimental psychology.

[35]  E. Archer,et al.  Pursuit rotor performance as a function of delay of information feedback. , 1958, Journal of experimental psychology.

[36]  L. E. Bourne,et al.  Concept identification as a function of completeness and probability of information feed back. , 1958, Journal of experimental psychology.

[37]  C. Noble,et al.  Human delayed-reward learning with different lengths of task. , 1958, Journal of experimental psychology.

[38]  I. Bilodeau,et al.  Variable frequency of knowledge of results and the learning of a simple skill. , 1958, Journal of experimental psychology.

[39]  Mcguigan Fj.  The effect of precision, delay, and schedule of knowledge of results on performance. , 1959 .

[40]  Adaptive processes determining proprioceptive perception of verticality. , 1959, Journal of experimental psychology.

[41]  F. J. McGuigan,et al.  The effect of precision, delay, and schedule of knowledge of results on performance. , 1959, Journal of experimental psychology.

[42]  John Annett,et al.  Learning a Pressure under Conditions of Immediate and Delayed Knowledge of Results , 1959 .

[43]  F. J. McGuigan.  Delay of Knowledge of Results: A Problem in Design , 1959 .

[44]  E A BILODEAU,et al.  Some effects of introducing and withdrawing knowledge of results early and late in practice. , 1959, Journal of experimental psychology.

[45]  Partial reinforcement: a selective review of the literature since 1950. , 1960, Psychological bulletin.

[46]  E A BILODEAU,et al.  A test for interaction of delay of knowledge of results and two types of interpolated activity. , 1960, Journal of experimental psychology.

[47]  Supplementary report: Delay of knowledge of results, knowledge of task, and intertrial interval , 1960 .

[48]  F. J. McGuigan,et al.  The Effect of Knowledge of Results Before and After a Response , 1960 .

[49]  Darwin P. Hunt,et al.  The Effect of the Precision of Informational Feedback on Human Tracking Performance1 , 1961 .

[50]  John J. Boren,et al.  Resistance to extinction as a function of the fixed ratio. , 1961 .

[51]  Y. Brackbill,et al.  Delay of reinforcement and retention. , 1962, Journal of comparative and physiological psychology.

[52]  J. J. Lavery.  Retention of simple motor skills as a function of type of knowledge of results. , 1962 .

[53]  A TAYLOR,et al.  Acquisition and Extinction Phenomena in Human Trial-and-Error Learning under Different Schedules of Reinforcing Feedback , 1962, Perceptual and motor skills.

[54]  J J LAVERY,et al.  Retention of Simple Motor Skills as a Function of the Number of Trials by Which KR is Delayed , 1962, Perceptual and motor skills.

[55]  The effect of amount of training on retention of a simple motor skill with 0- and 5-trial delays of knowledge of results. , 1962, Canadian journal of psychology.

[56]  Countertraining of a simple skill with immediate and 1-week delays of informative feedback. , 1962, Journal of experimental psychology.

[57]  Y. Brackbill,et al.  Delay of Reinforcement and the Retention of Unfamiliar, Meaningless Material , 1962 .

[58]  C. Bunderson,et al.  Effects of delay of informative feedback and length of postfeedback interval on concept identification. , 1963, Journal of experimental psychology.

[59]  Paul W. Becker,et al.  Intertrial Interval, Delay of Knowledge of Results, and Motor Performance , 1963, Perceptual and motor skills.

[60]  K. Blick,et al.  Interpolated activity and the learning of a simple skill. , 1963, Journal of experimental psychology.

[61]  Bourne Le,et al.  Effects of delay of informative feedback and length of postfeedback interval on concept identification. , 1963 .

[62]  A. Smith.  Effects of Continuous and Intermittent Feedback on Precision in Applying Pressure , 1963, Perceptual and Motor Skills.

[63]  Y. Brackbill,et al.  Amplitude of response and the delay-retention effect. , 1963, Journal of experimental psychology.

[64]  VARIATION OF POSTFEEDBACK INTERVAL IN SIMPLE MOTOR LEARNING. , 1964, Journal of experimental psychology.

[65]  Y. Brackbill,et al.  Feedback delay and the teaching machine , 1964 .

[66]  Francis J. DeMatteo,et al.  Human Learning , 2020, Delivering Psycho-educational Evaluation Results to Parents.

[67]  Retention of a Skill as a Function of Display/Hand Movement Ratio during Training , 1964, Perceptual and motor skills.

[68]  Lavery Jj.  THE EFFECT OF ONE-TRIAL DELAY IN KNOWLEDGE OF RESULTS ON THE ACQUISITION AND RETENTION OF A TOSSING SKILL. , 1964 .

[69]  Y. Brackbill.  The impairment of learning under immediate reinforcement , 1964 .

[70]  J. J. Lavery.  THE EFFECT OF ONE-TRIAL DELAY IN KNOWLEDGE OF RESULTS ON THE ACQUISITION AND RETENTION OF A TOSSING SKILL. , 1964, The American journal of psychology.

[71]  L. Boulter.  EVALUATION OF MECHANISMS IN DELAY OF KNOWLEDGE OF RESULTS. , 1964, Canadian journal of psychology.

[72]  Retention of a Skill following Training with and without Instructions to Retain , 1964, Perceptual and motor skills.

[73]  THE RETROACTIVE INTERFERENCE OF MOTOR ACTIVITY WITH KNOWLEDGE OF RESULTS. , 1964, The Journal of general psychology.

[74]  D. H. Holding,et al.  Principles of Training , 1965 .

[75]  D. Justesen,et al.  CONCEPT IDENTIFICATION: THE EFFECTS OF VARYING LENGTH AND INFORMATIONAL COMPONENTS OF THE INTERTRIAL INTERVAL. , 1965, Journal of experimental psychology.

[76]  J. A. Dyal,et al.  Acquisition and Extinction of a Simple Motor Skill as a Function of Delay of Knowledge of Results , 1965 .

[77]  J. A. Dyal.  Effects of delay of knowledge of results and subject response bias on extinction of a simple motor skill. , 1966, Journal of experimental psychology.

[78]  J. A. Adams,et al.  Short-term memory for motor responses. , 1966, Journal of experimental psychology.

[79]  Edward A. Bilodeau,et al.  Acquisition of Skill , 1967 .

[80]  J. Adams.  Response feedback and learning. , 1968 .

[81]  S. Freedman.  The Neuropsychology of spatially oriented behavior , 1968 .

[82]  M Robb,et al.  Feedback and skill learning. , 1968, Research quarterly.

[83]  E. A. Locke,et al.  Motivational effects of knowledge of results: A goal-setting phenomenon? , 1968 .

[84]  Earl A. Alluisi,et al.  Principles of skill acquisition , 1969 .

[85]  Paul W. Fox,et al.  Acquisition of a simple motor response as influenced by the presence or absence of action visual feedback. , 1969, Journal of motor behavior.

[87]  P Dunham,et al.  Learning and performance. , 1971, Research quarterly.

[88]  J. Adams,et al.  A closed-loop theory of motor learning. , 1971, Journal of motor behavior.

[89]  J. G. P. Williams,et al.  “Motor Learning and Human Performance” , 1971 .

[90]  The effects of video-taped feedback on form, accuracy, and latency in an open and closed environment. , 1971, Journal of motor behavior.

[91]  R. Schmidt,et al.  Evidence for an error detection mechanism in motor skills. , 1972, Journal of motor behavior.

[92]  The development and control of behavior in sport and physical education , 1972 .

[93]  A. Gentile.  A Working Model of Skill Acquisition with Application to Teaching , 1972 .

[94]  F L Smoll,et al.  Effects of precision of information feedback upon acquisition of a motor skill. , 1972, Research quarterly.

[95]  Effects of Frequency and Specificity of Information Feedback on Acquisition and Extinction of a Positioning Task , 1972 .

[96]  R. W. Tomlinson,et al.  Control impedance and precision of feedback as parameters in sensori-motor learning. , 1972, Ergonomics.

[97]  J. A. Adams,et al.  Response feedback and motor learning. , 1972, Journal of experimental psychology.

[98]  R. B. Payne,et al.  Facilitation of psychomotor learning by classically differentiated supplementary feedback cues. , 1972, Journal of motor behavior.

[99]  Preresponse Intervals Versus Postinformative Feedback Intervals in Concept Identification. , 1972 .

[100]  R. Magill.  The post-kr interval. , 1973, Journal of motor behavior.

[101]  The effect of different post knowledge of results intervals and interpolated verbal activity on performance and retention of a motor skill , 1973 .

[102]  G. Salvendy,et al.  EFFECTS OF DIFFERENT MODES OF FEEDBACK ON THE ACQUISITION AND RETENTION OF PSYCHOMOTOR SKILLS , 1973 .

[103]  W. Kappauf.  Studying the Relationship of Task Performance to the Variables of Chronological Age, Mental Age, and IQ , 1973 .

[104]  Jean-Louis Boucher,et al.  Higher processes in motor learning. , 1974, Journal of motor behavior.

[105]  R. M. Tarpy,et al.  Reinforcement delay: A selective review of the last decade. , 1974 .

[106]  K. Newell,et al.  Motor response recognition. , 1974, Journal of motor behavior.

[107]  C. Rogers,et al.  Feedback precision and postfeedback interval duration. , 1974, Journal of experimental psychology.

[108]  A note on motor learning without post-response knowledge of results. , 1975, Journal of motor behavior.

[109]  R. Schmidt.  A schema theory of discrete motor skill learning. , 1975 .

[110]  D. Gill.  Knowledge of results precision and motor skill acquisition. , 1975, Journal of Motor Behavior.

[111]  A note on delay of knowledge of results in positioning responses. , 1976, Journal of motor behavior.

[112]  Post-KR delay intervals and mental practice: a test of Adams' closed loop theory. , 1976, Research quarterly.

[113]  R. Schmidt.  The Schema as a Solution to Some Persistent Problems in Motor Learning Theory , 1976 .

[114]  K M Newell,et al.  On processing the information from knowledge of results. , 1976, Journal of motor behavior.

[115]  H Zelaznik,et al.  Feedback in response recognition and production. , 1976, Journal of motor behavior.

[116]  K M Newell,et al.  Motor learning without knowledge of results through the development of a response recognition mechanism. , 1976, Journal of motor behavior.

[117]  E. Taub.  Movement In Nonhuman Primates Deprived Of Somatosensory Feedback , 1976, Exercise and sport sciences reviews.

[118]  K. Newell.  Knowledge Of Results And Motor Learning , 1976, Exercise and sport sciences reviews.

[119]  John B. Shea,et al.  The effects on skill acquisition of an interpolated motor short-term memory task during the kr-delay interval. , 1976, Journal of motor behavior.

[120]  Knowledge of results and motor learning in preschool children. , 1977, Research quarterly.

[121]  R A Magill,et al.  The processing of knowledge of results information for a serial-motor task. , 1977, Journal of motor behavior.

[122]  K. Newell,et al.  Knowledge of Results and Children's Motor Learning. , 1978 .

[123]  J. Adams.  Theoretical Issues for Knowledge of Results , 1978 .

[124]  Alan D. Baddeley,et al.  THE TROUBLE WITH LEVELS: A REEXAMINATION OF CRAIK AND LOCKHART'S FRAMEWORK FOR MEMORY RESEARCH , 1978 .

[125]  J. Shea,et al.  Effects of Relative Frequency of Knowledge of Results on Retention of a Motor Skill , 1978, Perceptual and motor skills.

[126]  J C Hogan,et al.  The role of verbal estimates of movement error in ballistic skill acquisition. , 1978, Journal of motor behavior.

[127]  Michael T. Turvey,et al.  Skill Acquisition: An Event Approach with Special Reference to Searching for the Optimum of a Function of Several Variables , 1978 .

[128]  R. Christina,et al.  Psychology of motor behavior and sport , 1978 .

[129]  Edmund Fantino,et al.  The experimental analysis of behavior : a biological perspective , 1979 .

[130]  S. A. Wallace,et al.  Knowledge of performance and the learning of a closed motor skill. , 1979, Research quarterly.

[131]  J. Shea,et al.  Contextual interference effects on the acquisition, retention, and transfer of a motor skill. , 1979 .

[132]  C. G. Koch,et al.  Recall and recognition processes in motor memory: effects of feedback and knowledge of results delay. , 1979, Journal of motor behavior.

[133]  Effects of varying post-KR intervals upon children' motor performance. , 1980, Journal of motor behavior.

[134]  Developmental trends in motor response recognition. , 1980 .

[135]  R. Singer.  Motor learning and human performance : an application to motor skills and movement behaviors , 1980 .

[136]  M. Picado,et al.  Effects of precision of knowledge of results on performance of a gross motor coincidence-anticipation task. , 1981, Journal of motor behavior.

[137]  C. B. Walter,et al.  Kinematic and kinetic parameters as information feedback in motor skill acquisition , 1981 .

[138]  Jimmy P. Timmons.  Motor skill acquisition as a function of the post-knowledge of results delay interval and task complexity , 1982 .

[139]  Jane E. Clark,et al.  The Development of Movement Control and Coordination , 1982 .

[140]  Timothy D. Lee,et al.  Motor Control and Learning: A Behavioral Emphasis , 1982 .

[141]  R. Magill,et al.  Activity during the Post-KR Interval: Effects upon Performance or Learning?. , 1983 .

[142]  A. Salmoni,et al.  Knowledge of results and perceptual-motor learning , 1983 .

[143]  J. Adams.  On Integration of the Verbal and Motor Domains , 1983 .

[144]  John B. Shea,et al.  Context Effects in Memory and Learning Movement Information , 1983 .

[145]  R. Magill,et al.  American Psychological Association, Inc. The Locus of Contextual Interference in Motor-Skill Acquisition i , 2022 .

[146]  The Post Knowledge of Results Interval: Effects of Interpolated Activity on Cognitive Information Processing. , 1983 .