Review of possible modulation‐dependent biological effects of radiofrequency fields

The biological effects of modulated radiofrequency (RF) electromagnetic fields have been a subject of debate since early publications more than 30 years ago, suggesting that relatively weak amplitude-modulated RF electromagnetic fields have specific biological effects different from the well-known thermal effects of RF energy. This discussion has been recently activated by the increasing human exposure to RF fields from wireless communication systems. Modulation is used in all wireless communication systems to enable the signal to carry information. A previous review in 1998 indicated that experimental evidence for modulation-specific effects of RF energy is weak. This article reviews recent studies (published after 1998) on the biological effects of modulated RF fields. The focus is on studies that have compared the effects of modulated and unmodulated (continuous wave) RF fields, or compared the effects of different kinds of modulations; studies that used only one type of signal are not included. While the majority of recent studies have reported no modulation-specific effects, there are a few interesting exceptions indicating that there may be specific effects from amplitude-modulated RF fields on the human central nervous system. These findings warrant follow-up studies.

[1]  Giorgio Alfonso Lovisolo,et al.  Effects of 900 MHz electromagnetic fields exposure on cochlear cells' functionality in rats: Evaluation of distortion product otoacoustic emissions , 2005, Bioelectromagnetics.

[2]  Hans Wilhelm Pau,et al.  Can mobile phone emissions affect auditory functions of cochlea or brain stem? , 2005, Otolaryngology--head and neck surgery : official journal of American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery.

[3]  N. Kuster,et al.  1800 MHz radiofrequency (mobile phones, different Global System for Mobile communication modulations) does not affect apoptosis and heat shock protein 70 level in peripheral blood mononuclear cells from young and old donors , 2004, International journal of radiation biology.

[4]  René de Seze,et al.  Effects of radiofrequency exposure on the GABAergic system in the rat cerebellum: clues from semi-quantitative immunohistochemistry , 2001, Brain Research.

[5]  T. Koenig,et al.  Effects of weak mobile phone—Electromagnetic fields (GSM, UMTS) on event related potentials and cognitive functions , 2008, Bioelectromagnetics.

[6]  R J Croft,et al.  Effects of 2G and 3G mobile phones on human alpha rhythms: Resting EEG in adolescents, young adults, and the elderly , 2010, Bioelectromagnetics.

[7]  Patrick McEvoy,et al.  Mobile phone ‘talk-mode’ signal delays EEG-determined sleep onset , 2007, Neuroscience Letters.

[8]  Maila Hietanen,et al.  Hypersensitivity symptoms associated with exposure to cellular telephones: No causal link , 2002, Bioelectromagnetics.

[9]  Eduardo G Moros,et al.  Measurement of DNA Damage and Apoptosis in Molt-4 Cells after In Vitro Exposure to Radiofrequency Radiation , 2004, Radiation research.

[10]  Christina M Krause,et al.  Effects of pulsed and continuous wave 902 MHz mobile phone exposure on brain oscillatory activity during cognitive processing , 2007, Bioelectromagnetics.

[11]  Jukka Juutilainen,et al.  Combined effects of 872 MHz radiofrequency radiation and ferrous chloride on reactive oxygen species production and DNA damage in human SH‐SY5Y neuroblastoma cells , 2010, Bioelectromagnetics.

[12]  Val Gebski,et al.  Effect of long‐term mobile communication microwave exposure on vascular permeability in mouse brain , 2002, Pathology.

[13]  E. Moros,et al.  Measurement of DNA Damage in Mammalian Cells Exposed In Vitro to Radiofrequency Fields at SARs of 3–5 W/kg , 2001, Radiation research.

[14]  M. Dauphinée,et al.  IRIDIUM exposure increases c-fos expression in the mouse brain only at levels which likely result in tissue heating , 1999, Neuroscience.

[15]  A W Wood,et al.  Effects of mobile phone type signals on calcium levels within human leukaemic T-cells (Jurkat cells) , 2001, International journal of radiation biology.

[16]  Yngve Hamnerius,et al.  Exposure of Cultured Astroglial and Microglial Brain Cells to 900 MHz Microwave Radiation , 2006, Radiation research.

[17]  Riccardo Russo,et al.  Exposure to Mobile Phone Electromagnetic Fields and Subjective Symptoms: A Double-Blind Study , 2008, Psychosomatic medicine.

[18]  B. Everitt,et al.  Are some people sensitive to mobile phone signals? Within participants double blind randomised provocation study , 2006, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[19]  Franz Adlkofer,et al.  Non-thermal DNA breakage by mobile-phone radiation (1800 MHz) in human fibroblasts and in transformed GFSH-R17 rat granulosa cells in vitro. , 2005, Mutation research.

[20]  H. Hinrikus,et al.  Effect of 7, 14 and 21 Hz modulated 450 MHz microwave radiation on human electroencephalographic rhythms , 2008, International journal of radiation biology.

[21]  J. Juutilainen,et al.  Enhancement of chemically induced reactive oxygen species production and DNA damage in human SH-SY5Y neuroblastoma cells by 872 MHz radiofrequency radiation. , 2009, Mutation research.

[22]  E. Fabbri,et al.  HSP70 Expression in Human Trophoblast Cells Exposed to Different 1.8 GHz Mobile Phone Signals , 2008, Radiation research.

[23]  A W Preece,et al.  Effect of a 915-MHz simulated mobile phone signal on cognitive function in man. , 1999, International journal of radiation biology.

[24]  W F Pickard,et al.  Proto-oncogene mRNA levels and activities of multiple transcription factors in C3H 10T 1/2 murine embryonic fibroblasts exposed to 835.62 and 847.74 MHz cellular phone communication frequency radiation. , 1999, Radiation research.

[25]  E. Moros,et al.  Radiofrequency Electromagnetic Fields do not Alter the Cell Cycle Progression of C3H 10T and U87MG Cells , 2001, Radiation research.

[26]  K. Fritze,et al.  Effect of global system for mobile communication (GSM) microwave exposure on blood-brain barrier permeability in rat , 1997, Acta Neuropathologica.

[27]  J. Juutilainen,et al.  Ornithine decarboxylase activity is affected in primary astrocytes but not in secondary cell lines exposed to 872 MHz RF radiation , 2007, International journal of radiation biology.

[28]  J P McNamee,et al.  No Evidence for Genotoxic Effects from 24 h Exposure of Human Leukocytes to 1.9 GHz Radiofrequency Fields , 2003, Radiation research.

[29]  J. Juutilainen,et al.  Radiofrequency radiation does not significantly affect ornithine decarboxylase activity, proliferation, or caspase-3 activity of fibroblasts in different physiological conditions , 2008, International journal of radiation biology.

[30]  E. Moros,et al.  Neoplastic Transformation in C3H 10T½ Cells after Exposure to 835.62 MHz FDMA and 847.74 MHz CDMA Radiations , 2001, Radiation research.

[31]  Päivi Heikkinen,et al.  Chronic Exposure to 50-HZ Magnetic fields or 900-MHz Electromagnetic fields Does not alter Nocturnal 6-Hydroxymelatonin Sulfate Secretion in CBNS Mice , 1999 .

[32]  E. Moros,et al.  Evaluation of Parameters of Oxidative Stress after In Vitro Exposure to FMCW- and CDMA-Modulated Radiofrequency Radiation Fields , 2004, Radiation research.

[33]  Anthony T Barker,et al.  The effect of GSM and TETRA mobile handset signals on blood pressure, catechol levels and heart rate variability. , 2007, Bioelectromagnetics.

[34]  Hiie Hinrikus,et al.  Effect of low frequency modulated microwave exposure on human EEG: Individual sensitivity , 2008, Bioelectromagnetics.

[35]  T. Nojima,et al.  Mobile phone base station‐emitted radiation does not induce phosphorylation of Hsp27 , 2007, Bioelectromagnetics.

[36]  Bertil R. R. Persson,et al.  Blood‐brain barrier permeability in rats exposed to electromagnetic fields used in wireless communication , 1997, Wirel. Networks.

[37]  B E Stuck,et al.  Comparative effects of extremely high power microwave pulses and a brief CW irradiation on pacemaker function in isolated frog heart slices. , 2000, Bioelectromagnetics.

[38]  D. Bamiou,et al.  Mobile telephone use effects on peripheral audiovestibular function: A case–control study , 2008, Bioelectromagnetics.

[39]  G. Obe,et al.  Effects of high-frequency electromagnetic fields on human lymphocytes in vitro. , 1997, Mutation research.

[40]  W. R. Adey,et al.  EFFECTS OF MODULATED VHF FIELDS ON THE CENTRAL NERVOUS SYSTEM * , 1975, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[41]  Riccardo Russo,et al.  Does acute exposure to mobile phones affect human attention? , 2006, Bioelectromagnetics.

[42]  A. Bitz,et al.  Effects of mobile phone electromagnetic fields at nonthermal SAR values on melatonin and body weight of Djungarian hamsters (Phodopus sungorus) , 2008, Journal of pineal research.

[43]  T. Nojima,et al.  DNA strand breaks are not induced in human cells exposed to 2.1425 GHz band CW and W‐CDMA modulated radiofrequency fields allocated to mobile radio base stations , 2006, Bioelectromagnetics.

[44]  N. Kuster,et al.  Continuous wave and simulated GSM exposure at 1.8 W/kg and 1.8 GHz do not induce hsp16‐1 heat‐shock gene expression in Caenorhabditis elegans , 2008, Bioelectromagnetics.

[45]  M Hietanen,et al.  Human brain activity during exposure to radiofrequency fields emitted by cellular phones. , 2000, Scandinavian journal of work, environment & health.

[46]  S. Simmens,et al.  The Effects of 860 MHz Radiofrequency Radiation on the Induction or Promotion of Brain Tumors and Other Neoplasms in Rats , 2001, Radiation research.

[47]  M Simkó,et al.  Hsp70 expression and free radical release after exposure to non-thermal radio-frequency electromagnetic fields and ultrafine particles in human Mono Mac 6 cells. , 2006, Toxicology letters.

[48]  N. Kuster,et al.  Exposure to pulse‐modulated radio frequency electromagnetic fields affects regional cerebral blood flow , 2005, The European journal of neuroscience.

[49]  W F Pickard,et al.  Radiofrequency electromagnetic fields have no effect on the in vivo proliferation of the 9L brain tumor. , 1999, Radiation research.

[50]  E. Moros,et al.  The Heat-Shock Factor is not Activated in Mammalian Cells Exposed to Cellular Phone Frequency Microwaves , 2005, Radiation research.

[51]  D. Lloyd,et al.  Exposure to low level GSM 935 MHZ radiofrequency fields does not induce apoptosis in proliferating or differentiated murine neuroblastoma cells. , 2008, Radiation protection dosimetry.

[52]  N. Kuster,et al.  High frequency electromagnetic fields (GSM signals) affect gene expression levels in tumor suppressor p53‐deficient embryonic stem cells , 2004, Bioelectromagnetics.

[53]  Peter Achermann,et al.  Pulsed radio frequency radiation affects cognitive performance and the waking electroencephalogram , 2007, Neuroreport.

[54]  Isabelle Lagroye,et al.  Effects of Radiofrequency Electromagnetic Fields on the Human Nervous System , 2009, Journal of toxicology and environmental health. Part B, Critical reviews.

[55]  E. Moros,et al.  Gene Expression does not Change Significantly in C3H 10T½ Cells after Exposure to 847.74 CDMA or 835.62 FDMA Radiofrequency Radiation , 2006, Radiation research.

[56]  Jukka Juutilainen,et al.  Proliferation, Oxidative Stress and Cell Death in Cells Exposed to 872 MHz Radiofrequency Radiation and Oxidants , 2008, Radiation research.

[57]  P. Heikkinen,et al.  Micronucleus frequency in erythrocytes of mice after long-term exposure to radiofrequency radiation , 2007, International journal of radiation biology.

[58]  Guglielmo d'Ambrosio,et al.  Cytogenetic damage in human lymphocytes following GMSK phase modulated microwave exposure , 2002, Bioelectromagnetics.

[59]  W F Pickard,et al.  Measurement of DNA damage after exposure to electromagnetic radiation in the cellular phone communication frequency band (835.62 and 847.74 MHz). , 1997, Radiation research.

[60]  Michael R Murphy,et al.  Effects of high power microwave pulses on synaptic transmission and long term potentiation in hippocampus. , 2003, Bioelectromagnetics.

[61]  L. Verschaeve,et al.  Cytogenetic effects of 900 MHz (GSM) microwaves on human lymphocytes. , 2001, Bioelectromagnetics.

[62]  Giorgi Bit-Babik,et al.  Computational Electromagnetic Analysis in a Human Head Model with EEG Electrodes and Leads Exposed to RF-Field Sources at 915 MHz and 1748 MHz , 2010, Radiation research.

[63]  C K Chou,et al.  Auditory response to pulsed radiofrequency energy , 2003, Bioelectromagnetics.

[64]  Michael R Murphy,et al.  Comparison of dose dependences for bioeffects of continuous-wave and high-peak power microwave emissions using gel-suspended cell cultures. , 2002, Bioelectromagnetics.

[65]  T Suhara,et al.  Phosphorylation and gene expression of p53 are not affected in human cells exposed to 2.1425 GHz band CW or W‐CDMA modulated radiation allocated to mobile radio base stations , 2006, Bioelectromagnetics.

[66]  Robert A. Jones,et al.  DNA damage in Molt-4 T-lymphoblastoid cells exposed to cellular telephone radiofrequency fields in vitro , 1998 .

[67]  Riccardo Russo,et al.  Effects of mobile phone electromagnetic fields on an auditory order threshold task , 2007, Bioelectromagnetics.

[68]  P. Heikkinen,et al.  Effects of mobile phone radiation on UV-induced skin tumourigenesis in ornithine decarboxylase transgenic and non-transgenic mice , 2003, International journal of radiation biology.

[69]  G. Ziegelberger,et al.  International commission on non-ionizing radiation protection. , 2006, Progress in biophysics and molecular biology.

[70]  N. Kuster,et al.  ROS release and Hsp70 expression after exposure to 1,800 MHz radiofrequency electromagnetic fields in primary human monocytes and lymphocytes , 2006, Radiation and environmental biophysics.

[71]  Modest increase in temperature affects ODC activity in L929 cells: low-level radiofrequency radiation does not , 2006, Radiation and environmental biophysics.

[72]  Effects of exposure to DAMPS and GSM signals on ornithine decarboxylase (ODC) activity: I. L-929 mouse fibroblasts , 2009, International journal of radiation biology.

[73]  Gastone Castellani,et al.  In Vitro Exposure of Human Lymphocytes to 900 MHz CW and GSM Modulated Radiofrequency: Studies of Proliferation, Apoptosis and Mitochondrial Membrane Potential , 2004, Radiation research.

[74]  J. Elder,et al.  Induction of calcium-ion efflux from brain tissue by radiofrequency radiation: effect of sample number and modulation frequency on the power-density window. , 1980, Bioelectromagnetics.

[75]  N Kuster,et al.  Effect of global system for mobile communication microwave exposure on the genomic response of the rat brain , 1997, Neuroscience.

[76]  J. Juutilainen,et al.  Ornithine decarboxylase activity of L929 cells after exposure to continuous wave or 50 Hz modulated radiofrequency radiation—a replication study , 2007, Bioelectromagnetics.

[77]  P. Heikkinen,et al.  Effects of Mobile Phone Radiation on X-Ray-Induced Tumorigenesis in Mice , 2001, Radiation research.

[78]  T Koenig,et al.  Effects of weak mobile Phone—Electromagnetic fields (GSM, UMTS) on well‐being and resting EEG , 2008, Bioelectromagnetics.

[79]  Antti Juvonen,et al.  Mobile Phone Radiation and the Developing Brain: Behavioral and Morphological Effects in Juvenile Rats , 2007, Radiation research.

[80]  E. Moros,et al.  The number of genes changing expression after chronic exposure to Code Division Multiple Access or Frequency DMA radiofrequency radiation does not exceed the false‐positive rate , 2006, Proteomics.

[81]  Guglielmo d'Ambrosio,et al.  Formation of Reactive Oxygen Species in L929 Cells after Exposure to 900 MHz RF Radiation with and without Co-exposure to 3-Chloro-4-(dichloromethyl)-5-hydroxy-2(5H)-furanone , 2007, Radiation research.

[82]  Quirino Balzano,et al.  Absence of nonlinear responses in cells and tissues exposed to RF energy at mobile phone frequencies using a doubly resonant cavity , 2010, Bioelectromagnetics.

[83]  A. Sannino,et al.  Lack of Genotoxic Effects (Micronucleus Induction) in Human Lymphocytes Exposed In Vitro to 900 MHz Electromagnetic Fields , 2003, Radiation research.

[84]  Francesca Apollonio,et al.  Acute exposure to low‐level CW and GSM‐modulated 900 MHz radiofrequency does not affect Ba2+ currents through voltage‐gated calcium channels in rat cortical neurons , 2007, Bioelectromagnetics.

[85]  Vijayalaxmi.  Cytogenetic Studies in Human Blood Lymphocytes Exposed In Vitro to 2.45 GHz or 8.2 GHz Radiofrequency Radiation , 2006, Radiation research.

[86]  C. Yardin,et al.  Microwave exposure of neuronal cells in vitro: Study of apoptosis , 2006, International journal of radiation biology.

[87]  B. Persson,et al.  Microwaves from UMTS/GSM mobile phones induce long‐lasting inhibition of 53BP1/γ‐H2AX DNA repair foci in human lymphocytes , 2009, Bioelectromagnetics.

[88]  M. Simkó,et al.  Free Radical Release and HSP70 Expression in Two Human Immune-Relevant Cell Lines after Exposure to 1800 MHz Radiofrequency Radiation , 2006, Radiation research.

[89]  D. McRee,et al.  Genotoxicity of radiofrequency signals. I. Investigation of DNA damage and micronuclei induction in cultured human blood cells , 2002, Bioelectromagnetics.

[90]  Anthony T Barker,et al.  Effect of 900 MHz Electromagnetic Fields on Nonthermal Induction of Heat-Shock Proteins in Human Leukocytes , 2005, Radiation research.

[91]  Jukka Juutilainen,et al.  Apoptosis induced by ultraviolet radiation is enhanced by amplitude modulated radiofrequency radiation in mutant yeast cells , 2004, Bioelectromagnetics.

[92]  N. Kuster,et al.  Electromagnetic fields, such as those from mobile phones, alter regional cerebral blood flow and sleep and waking EEG , 2002, Journal of sleep research.

[93]  R. Spessert,et al.  No short-term effects of high-frequency electromagnetic fields on the mammalian pineal gland. , 1997 .

[94]  M. Taki,et al.  Effect of high-frequency electromagnetic fields with a wide range of SARs on chromosomal aberrations in murine m5S cells. , 2005, Mutation research.

[95]  Eduardo G Moros,et al.  The Effect of Chronic Exposure to 835.62 MHz FDMA or 847.74 MHz CDMA Radiofrequency Radiation on the Incidence of Spontaneous Tumors in Rats , 2003, Radiation research.

[96]  Eduardo G. Moros,et al.  The Effect of 835.62 MHz FDMA or 847.74 MHz CDMA Modulated Radiofrequency Radiation on the Induction of Micronuclei in C3H 10T½ Cells , 2002, Radiation research.

[97]  E. Moros,et al.  Expression of the Proto-oncogene Fos after Exposure to Radiofrequency Radiation Relevant to Wireless Communications , 2005, Radiation Research.

[98]  R. de Seze,et al.  Biological effects of amplitude-modulated radiofrequency radiation. , 1998, Scandinavian journal of work, environment & health.

[99]  Kenneth R Foster,et al.  Biological Effects of Radiofrequency Fields: Does Modulation Matter? , 2004, Radiation research.

[100]  I. Cosic,et al.  Comparison of the effects of continuous and pulsed mobile phone like RF exposure on the human EEG , 2007, Australasian Physics & Engineering Sciences in Medicine.

[101]  Matti Laine,et al.  Pulsed and continuous wave mobile phone exposure over left versus right hemisphere: Effects on human cognitive function , 2007, Bioelectromagnetics.