Expertise and Intuition: A Tale of Three Theories

Several authors have hailed intuition as one of the defining features of expertise. In particular, while disagreeing on almost anything that touches on human cognition and artificial intelligence, Hubert Dreyfus and Herbert Simon agreed on this point. However, the highly influential theories of intuition they proposed differed in major ways, especially with respect to the role given to search and as to whether intuition is holistic or analytic. Both theories suffer from empirical weaknesses. In this paper, we show how, with some additions, a recent theory of expert memory (the template theory) offers a coherent and wide-ranging explanation of intuition in expert behaviour. It is shown that the theory accounts for the key features of intuition: it explains the rapid onset of intuition and its perceptual nature, provides mechanisms for learning, incorporates processes showing how perception is linked to action and emotion, and how experts capture the entirety of a situation. In doing so, the new theory addresses the issues problematic for Dreyfus’s and Simon’s theories. Implications for research and practice are discussed.

[1]  Fernand Gobet,et al.  Mental imagery and chunks: Empirical and computational findings , 2008, Memory & cognition.

[2]  H A Simon,et al.  The theory of learning by doing. , 1979, Psychological review.

[3]  Fernand Gobet,et al.  Perception and memory in chess: Heuristics of the professional eye , 1996 .

[4]  P. Langley,et al.  Production system models of learning and development , 1987 .

[5]  Peter J. Jansen,et al.  Using knowledge about the opponent in game-tree search , 1992 .

[6]  Caroline E. Zsambok,et al.  Characteristics of Skilled Option Generation in Chess , 1995 .

[7]  Christopher F. Chabris,et al.  Visualization, pattern recognition, and forward search: effects of playing speed and sight of the position on grandmaster chess errors , 2003, Cogn. Sci..

[8]  R. I. Reynolds.  Search heuristics of chess players of different calibers. , 1982, The American journal of psychology.

[9]  H. Simon,et al.  The mind's eye in chess. , 1973 .

[10]  Marvin Minsky,et al.  Semantic Information Processing , 1968 .

[11]  Pertti Saariluoma,et al.  Chess players' thinking : a cognitive psychological approach , 1995 .

[12]  Hans Gruber,et al.  Expertise and hierarchical knowledge representation in chess , 1992 .

[13]  Allen Newell,et al.  Human Problem Solving. , 1973 .

[14]  H.L.J. van der Maas,et al.  Stagewise cognitive development: an application of catastrophe theory. , 1992, Psychological review.

[15]  H. Simon,et al.  Models of Thought , 1979 .

[16]  A. Newell.  Unified Theories of Cognition , 1990 .

[17]  P. Holcomb,et al.  Electrophysiological evidence for the efficiency of spoken word processing , 2002, Biological Psychology.

[18]  Dorothea P. Simon,et al.  Expert and Novice Performance in Solving Physics Problems , 1980, Science.

[19]  Hubert L. Dreyfus,et al.  Mind over Machine: The Power of Human Intuition and Expertise in the Era of the Computer , 1987, IEEE Expert.

[20]  J. Pine,et al.  Chunking mechanisms in human learning , 2001, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[21]  Alexandre Linhares,et al.  An Active Symbols Theory of Chess Intuition , 2005, Minds and Machines.

[22]  Fernand Gobet,et al.  Published online in Wiley InterScience (www.interscience.wiley.com) DOI: 10.1002/acp.1110 Chunking Models of Expertise: Implications for Education FERNAND GOBET* , 2022 .

[23]  Herbert A. Simon,et al.  Templates in Chess Memory: A Mechanism for Recalling Several Boards , 1996, Cognitive Psychology.

[24]  F. Paas,et al.  The robustness of medical expertise: clinical case processing by medical experts and subexperts. , 2002, American Journal of Psychology.

[25]  S. Dreyfus,et al.  Peripheral Vision , 2005 .

[26]  de Cornelis Glopper,et al.  Het oog van de meester , 1990 .

[27]  Fernand Gobet,et al.  The role of constraints in expert memory. , 2003, Journal of experimental psychology. Learning, memory, and cognition.

[28]  G. Tesauro.  Practical Issues in Temporal Difference Learning , 1992 .

[29]  F. Bartlett,et al.  Remembering: A Study in Experimental and Social Psychology , 1932 .

[30]  Francis Page Hardaway.  The Psychology of Chess and of Learning to Play it. , .

[31]  Hubert L. Dreyfus,et al.  From Socrates to Expert Systems: The Limits of Calculative Rationality , 1986 .

[32]  O. Tikhomirov,et al.  An Investigation of Visual Search as a Means of Analyzing Heuristics , 1966 .

[33]  D. Holding.  The Psychology of Chess Skill , 1985 .

[34]  E. Rolls.  Vision, emotion and memory: from neurophysiology to computation , 2003 .

[35]  M. D’Esposito.  Working memory. , 2008, Handbook of clinical neurology.

[36]  Christopher F. Chabris,et al.  Visualization, pattern recognition, and forward search: effects of playing speed and sight of the position on grandmaster chess errors , 2003 .

[37]  Gary Klein,et al.  Sources of Power: How People Make Decisions , 2017 .

[38]  B. Burns.  The Effects of Speed on Skilled Chess Performance , 2004, Psychological science.

[39]  Peter J. Jansen.  KQKR: Awareness of a Fallible Opponent , 1992, J. Int. Comput. Games Assoc..

[40]  S. Dreyfus.  Totally Model-Free Learned Skillful Coping , 2004 .

[41]  Joseph E LeDoux.  The emotional brain , 1996 .

[42]  Fernand Gobet,et al.  Adaptive Expert Decision Making: Skilled Chess Players Search More and Deeper , 2004, J. Int. Comput. Games Assoc..

[43]  C. Tanner,et al.  Expertise in Nursing Practice: Caring, Clinical Judgment and Ethics , 1996 .

[44]  Jos W. H. M. Uiterwijk,et al.  Advances in computer chess 8 , 1994 .

[45]  Bob Welham.  What computers still can’t do: a critique of artificial reason , 1994 .

[46]  R. Berndt,et al.  Working memory retention systems: a state of activated long-term memory. , 2003, The Behavioral and brain sciences.

[47]  H. Simon,et al.  Recall of rapidly presented random chess positions is a function of skill , 1996, Psychonomic bulletin & review.

[48]  J. Patton.  Intuition in decisions , 2003 .

[49]  P. Benner.  From novice to expert. , 1984, The American journal of nursing.

[50]  H A Simon,et al.  Information-processing analysis of perceptual processes in problem solving. , 1969, Psychological review.

[51]  Fernand Gobet,et al.  A pattern-recognition theory of search in expert problem solving , 1997 .

[52]  Dorothea P. Simon,et al.  Individual Differences in Solving Physics Problems (1978) , 1978 .

[53]  R. Siegler.  Children's Thinking : What Develops? , 1978 .

[54]  W. Chase,et al.  Visual information processing. , 1974 .

[55]  F. Gobet,et al.  Moves in Mind: The Psychology of Board Games , 2004 .

[56]  John R. Anderson.  Acquisition of cognitive skill. , 1982 .

[57]  Adrianus Dingeman de Groot.  Intuition in Chess , 1986, J. Int. Comput. Games Assoc..

[58]  Joseph G. Johnson,et al.  Take The First: Option-generation and resulting choices , 2003 .

[59]  Hans Gruber,et al.  Zweierlei Experten: Problemisten, Partiespieler und Novizen beim Lösen von Schachproblemen , 1989 .

[60]  Lindley Darden,et al.  Is Artificial Intelligence a Degenerating Program?: A Review of Hubert Dreyfus' What Computers Still Can't Do , 1996, Artif. Intell..

[61]  Marvin Minsky,et al.  A framework for representing knowledge , 1974 .

[62]  Fernand Gobet,et al.  A model of emotional influence on memory processing. , 2005 .

[63]  Alexander Kotov.  Think Like A Grandmaster , 1971 .

[64]  H. Simon,et al.  A simulation of memory for chess positions. , 1973 .

[65]  F. Gobet,et al.  Towards an alternative to Benner's theory of expert intuition in nursing: a discussion paper. , 2008, International journal of nursing studies.

[66]  Pat Langley,et al.  Learning, development, and production systems , 1987 .

[67]  H. Simon,et al.  EPAM-like Models of Recognition and Learning , 1984, Cogn. Sci..

[68]  John McCarthy,et al.  Programs with common sense , 1960 .

[69]  Patrick Henry Winston,et al.  The psychology of computer vision , 1976, Pattern Recognit..

[70]  Paul J. Feltovich,et al.  The Cambridge handbook of expertise and expert performance , 2006 .

[71]  Herbert A. Simon,et al.  Five seconds or sixty? Presentation time in expert memory , 2000 .

[72]  Herbert A. Simon,et al.  The Roles of Recognition Processes and Look-Ahead Search in Time-Constrained Expert Problem Solving: Evidence From Grand-Master-Level Chess , 1996 .

[73]  F. Gobet,et al.  Expertise, models of learning and computer-based tutoring , 1999, Comput. Educ..

[74]  R. Davidson,et al.  The functional neuroanatomy of emotion and affective style , 1999, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[75]  M. Buro,et al.  HOW MACHINES HAVE REARNEA TO PLAY OTHELLO , 1999 .

[76]  Murray Campbell,et al.  Deep Blue , 2002, Artif. Intell..

[77]  E. J. Anderson,et al.  Working memory in chess , 1996, Memory & cognition.

[78]  H. Simon,et al.  Applications and Misapplications of Cognitive Psychology to Mathematics Education , 2000 .

[79]  Fernand Gobet,et al.  In search of templates , 2002, Cognitive Systems Research.

[80]  H. Simon,et al.  An information-processing theory of some effects of similarity, familiarization, and meaningfulness in verbal learning , 1964 .

[81]  R. K. Lindsay.  What Computers Can't Do. A Critique of Artificial Reason. Hubert L. Dreyfus. Harper and Row, New York, 1972. xxxvi, 260 pp. $8.95 , 1972 .

[82]  Alfred A. Cleveland.  The Psychology of Chess and of Learning to Play It , 1907 .

[83]  A. Damasio,et al.  Deciding Advantageously Before Knowing the Advantageous Strategy , 1997, Science.

[84]  B Crandall,et al.  Critical decision method: A technique for eliciting concrete assessment indicators from the intuition of NICU nurses , 1993, ANS. Advances in nursing science.

[85]  Paul J. Feltovich,et al.  Categorization and Representation of Physics Problems by Experts and Novices , 1981, Cogn. Sci..

[86]  M. Eimer.  Event-related brain potentials distinguish processing stages involved in face perception and recognition , 2000, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[87]  Hubert L. Dreyfus,et al.  From Socrates to expert systems , 1984 .