The real stakes of virtual publishing: The transformation of E-Biomed into PubMed central

In May 1999, National Institutes of Health (NIH) Director Harold Varmus proposed an electronic repository for biomedical research literature server called "E-biomed." E-biomed reflected the visions of scholarly electronic publishing advocates: It would be fully searchable, be free to readers, and contain full-text versions of both preprint and postpublication biomedical research articles. However, within 4 months, the E-biomed proposal was radically transformed: The preprint section was eliminated, delays were instituted between article publication and posting to the archive, and the name was changed to "PubMed Central." This case study examines the remarkable transformation of the E-biomed proposal to PubMed Central by analyzing comments about the proposal that were posted to an online E-biomed forum created by the NIH, and discussions that took place in other face-to-face forums where E-biomed deliberations took place. We find that the transformation of the E-biomed proposal into PubMed Central was the result of highly visible and highly influential position statements made by scientific societies against the proposal. The literature about scholarly electronic publishing usually emphasizes a binary conflict between (trade) publishers and scholars/scientists. We conclude that: (1)scientific societies and the individual scientists they represent do not always have identical interests in regard to scientific e-publishing; (2) stakeholder politics and personal interests reign supreme in e-publishing debates, even in a supposedly status-free online forum; and (3) multiple communication forums must be considered in examinations of e-publishing deliberations.

[1]  Bob Calandra.  Bioinformatics knowledge vital to careers , 2002 .

[2]  E Marshall.  PNAS to Join PubMed Central--On Condition , 1999, Science.

[3]  Nancy Ross-Flanigan.  THE VIRTUES (AND VICES) OF VIRTUAL COLLEAGUES , 1998 .

[4]  北村 聖.  "The New England Journal of Medicine". , 1962, British medical journal.

[5]  Timothy Thomas.  Archives in a New Paradigm of Scientific Publishing: Physical Review Online Archives (PROLA) , 1998, D Lib Mag..

[6]  E Marshall,et al.  NIH's Online Publishing Venture Ready for Launch , 1999, Science.

[7]  Barry P. Markovitz,et al.  Electronic Journals: Time for a New Paradigm in Biomedical Communication , 1998 .

[8]  Eliot Marshall.  View From the Top of a Biomedical Empire , 1999, Science.

[9]  P. Ginsparg.  Winners and Losers in the Global Research Village , 1997 .

[10]  F E Bloom,et al.  Just a Minute, Please , 1999, Science.

[11]  Gregory B. Newby,et al.  Scholarly publishing: the electronic frontier , 1996 .

[12]  Declan Butler,et al.  Mixed response to NIH's web journal plan , 1999, Nature.

[13]  Paula Roberts,et al.  Electronic Democracy , 2000, Woman, Work and Computerization.

[14]  Joseph Y. Halpern,et al.  Repository : Promoting the Rapid Dissemination and Archiving of Computer Science Research , 2000 .

[15]  Paul Ginsparg,et al.  First steps towards electronic research communication , 1994 .

[16]  Dennis Normile,et al.  Responsive sculpture , 1996 .

[17]  E. Marshall.  NIH Weighs Bold Plan for Online Preprint Publishing , 1999, Science.

[18]  Herb Brody,et al.  Wired science , 1996 .

[19]  Alastair G. Smith,et al.  Scholarly publishing: The electronic frontier , 1996 .

[20]  Michael Jacobson.  Biomedical Publishing and the Internet—the Message of the Medium , 1998 .

[21]  Madeleine Jacobs.  VARMUS PUSHES HARD FOR E-BIOMED , 1999 .

[22]  S. Hilgartner.  Biomolecular Databases , 1995 .

[23]  Andrew M. Odlyzko,et al.  Tragic Loss or Good Riddance? The Impending Demise of Traditional Scholary Journals , 1996, J. Univers. Comput. Sci..

[24]  Stevan Harnad,et al.  Free at Last: The Future of Peer-Reviewed Journals , 1999, D Lib Mag..

[25]  Stevan Harnad.  Interactive publication: Extending the American Physical Society's discipline-specific model for electronic publishing , 1992 .

[26]  Rob Kling,et al.  Not just a matter of time: Field differences and the shaping of electronic media in supporting scientific communication , 1999, J. Am. Soc. Inf. Sci..

[27]  R Koenig.  Publishers Discuss European E-Print Site , 2000, Science.

[28]  E Marshall.  Varmus Defends E-biomed Proposal, Prepares to Push Ahead , 1999, Science.

[29]  E Marshall.  U.S., European Backers Differ on E-biomed Plan , 1999, Science.

[30]  Stevan Harnad.  Electronic Scholarly Publication: Quo Vadis? , 1995 .

[31]  Edgar Kiser,et al.  The Revival of Narrative in Historical Sociology: What Rational Choice Theory can Contribute , 1996 .

[32]  E Marshall.  Varmus to Leave NIH in December to Run Sloan-Kettering , 1999, Science.

[33]  Definition of "sole contribution". , 1969, The New England journal of medicine.

[34]  A. Relman,et al.  The NIH "E-biomed" proposal--a potential threat to the evaluation and orderly dissemination of new clinical studies. , 1999, The New England journal of medicine.

[35]  D. Butler.  US biologists propose launch of electronic preprint archive , 1999, Nature.

[36]  P. Smaglik.  E-BIOMED BECOMES PUBMED CENTRAL , 1999 .

[37]  R E LaPorte,et al.  The death of biomedical journals , 1995, BMJ.

[38]  Thomas J. Walker,et al.  Free Internet Access to Traditional Journals , 1998 .

[39]  Rob Kling,et al.  Locally Controlled Scholarly Publishing Via the Internet: The Guild Model , 2002 .

[40]  Rob Kling,et al.  a Bit More to It: Scholarly Communication Forums as Socio-technical Interaction Networks , 2003, J. Assoc. Inf. Sci. Technol..

[41]  Declan Butler.  NIH plan brings global electronic journal a step nearer reality , 1999, Nature.

[42]  E Marshall.  E-biomed Morphs to E-biosci, Focus Shifts to Reviewed Papers , 1999, Science.

[43]  E Marshall.  Varmus Circulates Proposal for NIH-Backed Online Venture , 1999, Science.

[44]  R Smith,et al.  Netprints: the next phase in the evolution of biomedical publishing , 1999, BMJ.

[45]  Eliott Marshall.  Researchers Plan Free Global Preprint Archive , 1999, Science.

[46]  Gregory K. Youngen,et al.  Citation Patterns to Traditional and Electronic Preprints in the Published Literature , 1998 .