Quantification of an Adverse Outcome Pathway Network by Bayesian Regression and Bayesian Network Modeling

The Adverse Outcome Pathway (AOP) framework has gained international recognition as a systematic approach linking mechanistic processes to toxicity endpoints. Nevertheless, successful implementation into risk assessments is still limited by the lack of quantitative AOP models (qAOPs) and assessment of uncertainties. The few published qAOP models so far are typically based on data-demanding systems biology models. Here, we propose a less data-demanding approach for quantification of AOPs and AOP networks, based on regression modelling and Bayesian networks. We demonstrate this approach with the proposed AOP #245 "Uncoupling of photophosphorylation leading to reduced ATP production associated growth inhibition", using a small experimental dataset from exposure of Lemna minor to the pesticide 3,5-dichlorophenol. The AOP-BN reflects the network structure of AOP #245 containing two molecular initiating events (MIEs), three key events (KEs) and one adverse outcome (AO). First, for each dose-response and response-response (KE) relationship, we quantify the causal relationship by Bayesian regression modelling. The regression models correspond to dose-response functions commonly applied in ecotoxicology. Secondly, we apply the fitted regression models with associated uncertainty to simulate 10,000 response values along the predictor gradient. Thirdly, we use the simulated values to parameterise the conditional probability tables of the BN model. The quantified AOP-BN model can be run in several directions. (1) prognostic inference: run forward from the stressor node to predict the AO level, 2: diagnostic inference: run backward from the AO node, and (3) omnidirectionally: run from the intermediate MIEs and/or KEs. Internal validation shows that the AOP-BN can obtain a high accuracy rate, when the run from intermediate nodes, and when a low resolution is acceptable for the AO. While the performance of this AOP-BN is limited by the small dataset, our study demonstrates a proof-of-concept: the combined use of Bayesian regression modelling and Bayesian network modelling for quantifying AOPs. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

[1]  Sharon Munn,et al.  Adverse outcome pathway networks I: Development and applications , 2018, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[2]  Maria Hänninen,et al.  A probabilistic approach for a cost-benefit analysis of oil spill management under uncertainty: A Bayesian network model for the Gulf of Finland. , 2015, Journal of environmental management.

[3]  Sakari Kuikka,et al.  Bene-Eia: A Bayesian Approach to Expert Judgment Elicitation with Case Studies on Climate Change Impacts on Surface Waters , 1997 .

[4]  Frederic Yves Bois,et al.  Quantitative AOP based teratogenicity prediction for mixtures of azole fungicides , 2019, Computational Toxicology.

[5]  Stephen W. Edwards,et al.  A Case Study Application of the Aggregate Exposure Pathway (AEP) and Adverse Outcome Pathway (AOP) Frameworks to Facilitate the Integration of Human Health and Ecological End Points for Cumulative Risk Assessment (CRA). , 2018, Environmental science & technology.

[6]  Carlie A. LaLone,et al.  Quantitative Response-response Relationships Linking Aromatase Inhibition to Decreased Fecundity are Conserved Across Three Fishes with Asynchronous Oocyte Development. , 2019, Environmental science & technology.

[7]  André Gergs,et al.  Linking Adverse Outcome Pathways to Dynamic Energy Budgets: A Conceptual Model , 2018 .

[8]  Judy Strickland,et al.  Bayesian integrated testing strategy (ITS) for skin sensitization potency assessment: a decision support system for quantitative weight of evidence and adaptive testing strategy , 2015, Archives of Toxicology.

[9]  Sharon Munn,et al.  Advancing the adverse outcome pathway framework—An international horizon scanning approach , 2017, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[10]  Roger M Nisbet,et al.  Quantitative Adverse Outcome Pathway Analysis of Hatching in Zebrafish with CuO Nanoparticles. , 2015, Environmental science & technology.

[11]  M. Otto,et al.  Metabolic Effect Level Index Links Multivariate Metabolic Fingerprints to Ecotoxicological Effect Assessment. , 2015, Environmental science & technology.

[12]  W. Landis,et al.  Don't be fooled—A no‐observed‐effect concentration is no substitute for a poor concentration–response experiment , 2016, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[13]  Sharon Munn,et al.  Adverse outcome pathway networks II: Network analytics , 2018, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[14]  Stephen W. Edwards,et al.  Reverse engineering adverse outcome pathways , 2011, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[15]  Cheryl A Murphy,et al.  Adverse outcome pathways and ecological risk assessment: Bridging to population‐level effects , 2011, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[16]  Wayne G Landis,et al.  The Origin, Development, Application, Lessons Learned, and Future Regarding the Bayesian Network Relative Risk Model for Ecological Risk Assessment , 2020, Integrated environmental assessment and management.

[17]  Cheryl A. Murphy,et al.  A Systems Biology Approach to Advancing Adverse Outcome Pathways for Risk Assessment , 2018, Springer International Publishing.

[18]  Christian Ritz,et al.  Toward a unified approach to dose–response modeling in ecotoxicology , 2010, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[19]  T. Gomes,et al.  Linking mode of action of the model respiratory and photosynthesis uncoupler 3,5-dichlorophenol to adverse outcomes in Lemna minor. , 2018, Aquatic toxicology.

[20]  Anne Lyche Solheim,et al.  Integrated assessment of ecological status and misclassification of lakes: The role of uncertainty and index combination rules , 2015 .

[21]  N. Ohad,et al.  Mutations in the D1 subunit of photosystem II distinguish between quinone and herbicide binding sites. , 1992, The Plant cell.

[22]  J. F. Carriger,et al.  A Bayesian network approach to refining ecological risk assessments: Mercury and the Florida panther (Puma concolor coryi). , 2020, Ecological modelling.

[23]  Early effect of sodium pentachlorophenate on photosynthetic activity of the alga Chlorella pyrenoidosa Chick. S-39 , 2008, Biology Bulletin.

[24]  Song S. Qian,et al.  A continuous variable Bayesian networks model for water quality modeling: A case study of setting nitrogen criterion for small rivers and streams in Ohio, USA , 2015, Environ. Model. Softw..

[25]  T. Huttula,et al.  Statistical Dimensioning of Nutrient Loading Reduction: LLR Assessment Tool for Lake Managers , 2015, Environmental Management.

[26]  Francis J Doyle,et al.  Chemical hazard prediction and hypothesis testing using quantitative adverse outcome pathways. , 2019, ALTEX.

[27]  Jiqiang Guo,et al.  Stan: A Probabilistic Programming Language. , 2017, Journal of statistical software.

[28]  Edward J. Perkins,et al.  Quantitative Adverse Outcome Pathways and Their Application to Predictive Toxicology. , 2017, Environmental science & technology.

[29]  J. Stark,et al.  Integrating Metapopulation Dynamics into a Bayesian Network Relative Risk Model: Assessing Risk of Pesticides to Chinook Salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) in an Ecological Context , 2020, Integrated environmental assessment and management.

[30]  W. Schmitt,et al.  Mechanistic TK/TD-model simulating the effect of growth inhibitors on Lemna populations , 2013 .

[31]  R. Nisbet,et al.  Relating suborganismal processes to ecotoxicological and population level endpoints using a bioenergetic model. , 2015, Ecological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America.

[32]  Mark E. Borsuk,et al.  Improving water quality assessments through a hierarchical Bayesian analysis of variability. , 2010, Environmental science & technology.

[33]  Igor Linkov,et al.  A modular approach for assembly of quantitative adverse outcome pathways. , 2019, ALTEX.

[34]  R. Couture,et al.  Climate change, cyanobacteria blooms and ecological status of lakes: A Bayesian network approach , 2016 .

[35]  Igor Linkov,et al.  Increasing Scientific Confidence in Adverse Outcome Pathways: Application of Tailored Bradford-Hill Considerations for Evaluating Weight of Evidence. , 2015, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP.

[36]  Wayne G Landis,et al.  Integration of Chlorpyrifos Acetylcholinesterase Inhibition, Water Temperature, and Dissolved Oxygen Concentration into a Regional Scale Multiple Stressor Risk Assessment Estimating Risk to Chinook Salmon , 2020, Integrated environmental assessment and management.

[37]  R. Schwarzenbach,et al.  Uptake, speciation, and uncoupling activity of substituted phenols in energy transducing membranes , 1996 .

[38]  Edward J Perkins,et al.  Building and Applying Quantitative Adverse Outcome Pathway Models for Chemical Hazard and Risk Assessment , 2019, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[39]  S. Baldwin,et al.  An introduction to using Bayesian linear regression with clinical data. , 2017, Behaviour research and therapy.

[40]  Carmel Pollino,et al.  Increased Use of Bayesian Network Models Will Improve Ecological Risk Assessments , 2008 .

[41]  Walter Schmitt,et al.  How TK‐TD and population models for aquatic macrophytes could support the risk assessment for plant protection products , 2016, Integrated environmental assessment and management.

[42]  Gerald T. Ankley,et al.  Linking mechanistic toxicology to population models in forecasting recovery from chemical stress: A case study from Jackfish Bay, Ontario, Canada , 2015, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[43]  Anders L. Madsen,et al.  Development of a hybrid Bayesian network model for predicting acute fish toxicity using multiple lines of evidence , 2020, Environ. Model. Softw..

[44]  Paul Jennings,et al.  Application of three approaches for quantitative AOP development to renal toxicity , 2019, Computational Toxicology.

[45]  John F Carriger,et al.  Bayesian Networks Improve Causal Environmental Assessments for Evidence-Based Policy. , 2016, Environmental science & technology.

[46]  Mark E. Borsuk,et al.  A Bayesian network of eutrophication models for synthesis, prediction, and uncertainty analysis , 2004 .

[47]  Irvin R. Schultz,et al.  The Development of Quantitative AOPs , 2018 .

[48]  Jaeseong Jeong,et al.  Developing adverse outcome pathways on silver nanoparticle-induced reproductive toxicity via oxidative stress in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans using a Bayesian network model , 2018, Nanotoxicology.

[49]  Stephen W. Edwards,et al.  Aggregate Exposure Pathways in Support of Risk Assessment. , 2018, Current opinion in toxicology.

[50]  A. Hunka,et al.  Ecological risk assessment of pesticides in the EU: what factors and groups influence policy changes? , 2015 .

[51]  Antti Taskinen,et al.  Probabilistic Evaluation of Ecological and Economic Objectives of River Basin Management Reveals a Potential Flaw in the Goal Setting of the EU Water Framework Directive , 2017, Environmental Management.

[52]  D. de Zwart,et al.  Species sensitivity distributions for use in environmental protection, assessment, and management of aquatic ecosystems for 12 386 chemicals , 2019, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[53]  Daniel L Villeneuve,et al.  Adverse outcome pathways: A conceptual framework to support ecotoxicology research and risk assessment , 2010, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[54]  J. Pinnegar,et al.  Predicting ecosystem responses to changes in fisheries catch, temperature, and primary productivity with a dynamic Bayesian network model , 2017 .

[55]  Sakari Kuikka,et al.  Assessing the roles of environmental factors in coastal fish production in the northern Baltic Sea: A Bayesian network application , 2012, Integrated environmental assessment and management.

[56]  Laura Kaikkonen,et al.  Bayesian Networks in Environmental Risk Assessment: A Review , 2020, Integrated environmental assessment and management.

[57]  Nathan Pollesch,et al.  Predicting the Probability that a Chemical Causes Steatosis Using Adverse Outcome Pathway Bayesian Networks (AOPBNs) , 2019, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis.