论文信息 - The DNA database search controversy.

The DNA database search controversy.

A recent article in Biometrics (Stockmarr, 1999, 55, 671-677) has generated correspondence (56, 1274-1277; 57, 976-980) reigniting a controversy started by a 1996 report on DNA profile evidence issued by the U.S. National Research Council (NRC). The issue concerns the evidential weight of a DNA profile match when the match results from a search through a profile database. The views of both Stockmarr and the NRC report conflict with those of many statisticians working in the area, and the differing viewpoints lead to dramatically different assessments of evidence. I outline reasons why Stockmarr and the NRC report are wrong. I also briefly discuss possible reasons why forensic applications tend to be problematic for statisticians.

David J Balding

[1] A. P. Dawid,et al. Coherent Analysis of Forensic Identification Evidence , 1996 .

[2] S. Fienberg,et al. Census 2000 Controversies , 2000 .

[3] I. Evett,et al. Interpreting DNA Evidence: Statistical Genetics for Forensic Scientists , 1998 .

[4] A P Dawid,et al. Comment on Stockmarr's "Likelihood ratios for evaluating DNA evidence when the suspect is found through a database search". , 2001, Biometrics.

[5] P Donnelly,et al. DNA database searches and the legal consumption of scientific evidence. , 1997, Michigan law review.

[6] B Devlin. The evidentiary value of a DNA database search. , 2000, Biometrics.

[7] D J Balding,et al. Evaluating DNA profile evidence when the suspect is identified through a database search. , 1996, Journal of forensic sciences.

[8] B S Weir. The second National Research Council report on forensic DNA evidence. , 1996, American journal of human genetics.

[9] A Stockmarr,et al. Likelihood Ratios for Evaluating DNA Evidence When the Suspect is Found Through a Database Search , 1999, Biometrics.

[10] William G. Hill,et al. The Evaluation of Forensic DNA Evidence. By Committee on DNA Forensic Science: an Update, National Research Council. National Academy Press, 1996. 254 pages. Price £30.95, hard cover. ISBN 0 309 05395 1. , 1997 .

[11] Peter Donnelly,et al. Inference in Forensic Identification , 1995 .

[12] I W Evett,et al. To the Editor of Biometrics: , 2000, Biometrics.