Water Freezes Differently on Positively and Negatively Charged Surfaces of Pyroelectric Materials

Freezing Supercool Water Under equilibrium conditions, water will freeze at 0°C, but, under certain conditions, it can be kept in a supercooled liquid form below this temperature. Ehre et al. (p. 672) present a careful and detailed study of the freezing of water drops on both positively and negatively charged pyroelectric surfaces using a combination of optical microscopy and x-ray diffraction: Supercooled water froze at different temperatures, depending on the charge of the substrate with the initial freezing occurring at the liquid-substrate interface on a positively charged substrate and at the air-water interface on a negatively charged substrate. Thus, freezing could be induced upon heating when the substrate charge also changed from negative to positive. Supercooled water on a surface can freeze upon heating in response to surface charge switching from negative to positive. Although ice melts and water freezes under equilibrium conditions at 0°C, water can be supercooled under homogeneous conditions in a clean environment down to –40°C without freezing. The influence of the electric field on the freezing temperature of supercooled water (electrofreezing) is of topical importance in the living and inanimate worlds. We report that positively charged surfaces of pyroelectric LiTaO3 crystals and SrTiO3 thin films promote ice nucleation, whereas the same surfaces when negatively charged reduce the freezing temperature. Accordingly, droplets of water cooled down on a negatively charged LiTaO3 surface and remaining liquid at –11°C freeze immediately when this surface is heated to –8°C, as a result of the replacement of the negative surface charge by a positive one. Furthermore, powder x-ray diffraction studies demonstrated that the freezing on the positively charged surface starts at the solid/water interface, whereas on a negatively charged surface, ice nucleation starts at the air/water interface.