The no miracles argument without the base rate fallacy

According to an argument by Colin Howson, the no-miracles argument (NMA) is contingent on committing the base-rate fallacy and is therefore bound to fail. We demonstrate that Howson’s argument only applies to one of two versions of the NMA. The other version, which resembles the form in which the argument was initially presented by Putnam and Boyd, remains unaffected by his line of reasoning. We provide a formal reconstruction of that version of the NMA and show that it is valid. Finally, we demonstrate that the use of subjective priors is consistent with the realist implication of the NMA and show that a core worry with respect to the suggested form of the NMA can be dispelled.

[1]  J. Sprenger.  The probabilistic no miracles argument , 2015, European journal for philosophy of science.

[2]  David Hume's no-miracles argument begets a valid No-Miracles Argument. , 2015, Studies in history and philosophy of science.

[3]  C. Menke.  Does the miracle argument embody a base rate fallacy? , 2014, Studies in history and philosophy of science.

[4]  The Miraculous Choice Argument for Realism , 2002 .

[5]  L. Laudan.  A Confutation of Convergent Realism , 1981, Philosophy of Science.

[6]  Cliff Hooker,et al.  Images of Science: Essays on Realism and Empiricism , 1992 .

[7]  J. Worrall.  Miracles and Models: Why reports of the death of Structural Realism may be exaggerated , 2007, Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement.

[8]  A. Musgrave,et al.  The Ultimate Argument for Scientific Realism , 1988 .

[9]  Mandy Eberhart,et al.  The Scientific Image , 2016 .

[10]  C. Howson.  Hume's problem: induction and the justification of belief , 2000 .

[11]  S. Psillos.  Knowing the Structure of Nature , 2009 .

[12]  P. Magnus,et al.  Realist Ennui and the Base Rate Fallacy* , 2004, Philosophy of Science.

[13]  Richard Dawid.  Scientific Prediction and the Underdetermination of Scientific Theory Building , 2008 .

[14]  H. Putnam.  What is mathematical truth , 1975 .

[15]  C. Howson.  Exhuming the No-Miracles Argument , 2013 .

[16]  P. Stanford.  Exceeding Our Grasp: Science, History, and the Problem of Unconceived Alternatives , 2006 .

[17]  Bas C. van Fraassen,et al.  The Scientific Image , 1980 .

[18]  P. Kyle Stanford,et al.  Exceeding Our Grasp , 2006 .

[19]  Leah Henderson.  The no miracles argument and the base rate fallacy , 2015, Synthese.