Pathobiology of liver fibrosis: a translational success story

Reversibility of hepatic fibrosis and cirrhosis following antiviral therapy for hepatitis B or C has advanced the prospect of developing antifibrotic therapies for patients with chronic liver diseases, especially non-alcoholic steatohepatitis. Mechanisms of fibrosis have focused on hepatic stellate cells, which become fibrogenic myofibroblasts during injury through ‘activation’, and are at the nexus of efforts to define novel drug targets. Recent studies have clarified pathways of stellate cell gene regulation and epigenetics, emerging pathways of fibrosis regression through the recruitment and amplification of fibrolytic macrophages, nuanced responses of discrete inflammatory cell subsets and the identification of the ‘ductular reaction’ as a marker of severe injury and repair. Based on our expanded knowledge of fibrosis pathogenesis, attention is now directed towards strategies for antifibrotic therapies and regulatory challenges for conducting clinical trials with these agents. New therapies are attempting to: 1) Control or cure the primary disease or reduce tissue injury; 2) Target receptor-ligand interactions and intracellular signaling; 3) Inhibit fibrogenesis; and 4) Promote resolution of fibrosis. Progress is urgently needed in validating non-invasive markers of fibrosis progression and regression that can supplant biopsy and shorten the duration of clinical trials. Both scientific and clinical challenges remain, however the past three decades of steady progress in understanding liver fibrosis have contributed to an emerging translational success story, with realistic hopes for antifibrotic therapies to treat patients with chronic liver disease in the near future.

[1]  T. Sauerbruch,et al.  HSC-specific inhibition of Rho-kinase reduces portal pressure in cirrhotic rats without major systemic effects. , 2012, Journal of hepatology.

[2]  K. Iwaisako,et al.  Origin of myofibroblasts in the fibrotic liver in mice , 2014, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[3]  L. Galluzzi,et al.  Decoding cell death signals in liver inflammation. , 2013, Journal of hepatology.

[4]  G. Svegliati-Baroni,et al.  Dysbiosis contributes to fibrogenesis in the course of chronic liver injury in mice , 2014, Hepatology.

[5]  L. Marchionni,et al.  In Vivo Liver Regeneration Potential of Human Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells from Diverse Origins , 2011, Science Translational Medicine.

[6]  Chihiro Morishima,et al.  Fibrosis progression in chronic hepatitis C: Morphometric image analysis in the HALT‐C trial , 2009, Hepatology.

[7]  A. Baranova,et al.  Adipocytokine expression associated with miRNA regulation and diagnosis of NASH in obese patients with NAFLD , 2015, Liver international : official journal of the International Association for the Study of the Liver.

[8]  B. Neuschwander‐Tetri,et al.  Pioglitazone, vitamin E, or placebo for nonalcoholic steatohepatitis. , 2010, The New England journal of medicine.

[9]  W. Jeong,et al.  Retinoic acid signaling sensitizes hepatic stellate cells to NK cell killing via upregulation of NK cell activating ligand RAE1. , 2007, American journal of physiology. Gastrointestinal and liver physiology.

[10]  J. Fallowfield,et al.  Liver fibrosis and repair: immune regulation of wound healing in a solid organ , 2014, Nature Reviews Immunology.

[11]  R. Evans,et al.  A Vitamin D Receptor/SMAD Genomic Circuit Gates Hepatic Fibrotic Response , 2013, Cell.

[12]  Christopher K. Glass,et al.  Myofibroblasts revert to an inactive phenotype during regression of liver fibrosis , 2012, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[13]  J. Nattermann,et al.  Angiotensin‐II type 1 receptor‐mediated Janus kinase 2 activation induces liver fibrosis , 2014, Hepatology.

[14]  G. Kanel,et al.  Role of differentiation of liver sinusoidal endothelial cells in progression and regression of hepatic fibrosis in rats. , 2012, Gastroenterology.

[15]  D. Brenner,et al.  GIV/Girdin is a central hub for pro-fibrogenic signalling networks during liver fibrosis , 2014, Nature Communications.

[16]  T. Roskams,et al.  Obeticholic acid, a farnesoid X receptor agonist, improves portal hypertension by two distinct pathways in cirrhotic rats , 2014, Hepatology.

[17]  O. Pappo,et al.  A continuous 13C methacetin breath test for noninvasive assessment of intrahepatic inflammation and fibrosis in patients with chronic HCV infection and normal ALT , 2008, Journal of viral hepatitis.

[18]  S. Friedman,et al.  Human hepatic stellate cell lines, LX-1 and LX-2: new tools for analysis of hepatic fibrosis , 2004, Gut.

[19]  S. Friedman,et al.  Hepatic stellate cells and liver fibrosis. , 2013, Comprehensive Physiology.

[20]  L. P. Van den Heuvel,et al.  Cysteamine: an old drug with new potential. , 2013, Drug discovery today.

[21]  Alexander A. Morgan,et al.  Computational Repositioning of the Anticonvulsant Topiramate for Inflammatory Bowel Disease , 2011, Science Translational Medicine.

[22]  S. Friedman Liver fibrosis in 2012: Convergent pathways that cause hepatic fibrosis in NASH , 2013, Nature Reviews Gastroenterology &Hepatology.

[23]  W. Blaner,et al.  Liver X receptors balance lipid stores in hepatic stellate cells through Rab18, a retinoid responsive lipid droplet protein , 2015, Hepatology.

[24]  T. Luedde,et al.  miR-133a mediates TGF-β-dependent derepression of collagen synthesis in hepatic stellate cells during liver fibrosis. , 2013, Journal of hepatology.

[25]  I. Okazaki,et al.  Collagenase activity in experimental hepatic fibrosis , 1974, Nature.

[26]  Michael Simons,et al.  Divergent angiocrine signals from vascular niche balance liver regeneration and fibrosis , 2013, Nature.

[27]  M. Bulsara,et al.  Image analysis of liver biopsy samples measures fibrosis and predicts clinical outcome. , 2014, Journal of hepatology.

[28]  G. Gores,et al.  Cathepsin B inactivation attenuates hepatocyte apoptosis and liver damage in steatotic livers after cold ischemia-warm reperfusion injury. , 2005, American journal of physiology. Gastrointestinal and liver physiology.

[29]  A. Feldstein,et al.  Caspase 1-mediated regulation of fibrogenesis in diet-induced steatohepatitis , 2011, Laboratory Investigation.

[30]  Dieter Häussinger,et al.  Hepatic stellate cells contribute to progenitor cells and liver regeneration. , 2014, The Journal of clinical investigation.

[31]  D. Schuppan,et al.  Evolving therapies for liver fibrosis. , 2013, The Journal of clinical investigation.

[32]  Ziwei Gu,et al.  Acetyl-CoA Carboxylase 2−/− Mutant Mice are Protected against Fatty Liver under High-fat, High-carbohydrate Dietary and de Novo Lipogenic Conditions* , 2012, The Journal of Biological Chemistry.

[33]  B. Gao,et al.  Liver natural killer and natural killer T cells: immunobiology and emerging roles in liver diseases , 2009, Journal of leukocyte biology.

[34]  Jeffrey E. Thatcher,et al.  Myocardin-Related Transcription Factor-A Controls Myofibroblast Activation and Fibrosis in Response to Myocardial Infarction , 2010, Circulation research.

[35]  S. Friedman,et al.  Antifibrotic Activity of Sorafenib in Experimental Hepatic Fibrosis: Refinement of Inhibitory Targets, Dosing, and Window of Efficacy In Vivo , 2012, Digestive Diseases and Sciences.

[36]  Julien Vergniol,et al.  Relative performances of FibroTest, Fibroscan, and biopsy for the assessment of the stage of liver fibrosis in patients with chronic hepatitis C: a step toward the truth in the absence of a gold standard. , 2012, Journal of hepatology.

[37]  K. Iwaisako,et al.  The nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate oxidase (NOX) homologues NOX1 and NOX2/gp91phox mediate hepatic fibrosis in mice , 2011, Hepatology.

[38]  Douglas A. Simonetto,et al.  Vascular endothelial growth factor promotes fibrosis resolution and repair in mice. , 2014, Gastroenterology.

[39]  S. Lowe,et al.  Senescence of Activated Stellate Cells Limits Liver Fibrosis , 2008, Cell.

[40]  Caroline L. Wilson,et al.  Multigenerational Epigenetic Adaptation of the Hepatic Wound-Healing Response , 2012, Nature Medicine.

[41]  V. de Lédinghen,et al.  Staging chronic hepatitis C in seven categories using fibrosis biomarker (FibroTest™) and transient elastography (FibroScan®). , 2014, Journal of hepatology.

[42]  B. Neuschwander‐Tetri,et al.  Farnesoid X nuclear receptor ligand obeticholic acid for non-cirrhotic, non-alcoholic steatohepatitis (FLINT): a multicentre, randomised, placebo-controlled trial , 2015, The Lancet.

[43]  A. Burroughs,et al.  Collagen proportionate area is superior to other histological methods for sub-classifying cirrhosis and determining prognosis. , 2014, Journal of hepatology.

[44]  R. Schwabe,et al.  Deactivation of hepatic stellate cells during liver fibrosis resolution in mice. , 2012, Gastroenterology.

[45]  A. Shen,et al.  Myocardin related transcription factor A programs epigenetic activation of hepatic stellate cells. , 2015, Journal of hepatology.

[46]  L. DeLeve,et al.  Liver sinusoidal endothelial cells and liver regeneration. , 2013, The Journal of clinical investigation.

[47]  Lakshmi A Devi,et al.  AT1R–CB1R heteromerization reveals a new mechanism for the pathogenic properties of angiotensin II , 2011, The EMBO journal.

[48]  C. Gandhi,et al.  miR-122 regulates collagen production via targeting hepatic stellate cells and suppressing P4HA1 expression. , 2013, Journal of hepatology.

[49]  L. J. Lee,et al.  Epigenetic regulation of connective tissue growth factor by MicroRNA‐214 delivery in exosomes from mouse or human hepatic stellate cells , 2014, Hepatology.

[50]  L. Adorini,et al.  Farnesoid X receptor targeting to treat nonalcoholic steatohepatitis. , 2012, Drug discovery today.

[51]  F. Tacke,et al.  Roles for chemokines in liver disease. , 2014, Gastroenterology.

[52]  I. N. Crispe,et al.  Immune tolerance in liver disease , 2014, Hepatology.

[53]  S. Friedman,et al.  Scraping fibrosis: Expressway to the core of fibrosis , 2011, Nature Medicine.

[54]  D. Mann Epigenetics in liver disease , 2014, Hepatology.

[55]  C. Bocca,et al.  Cellular and molecular mechanisms in liver fibrogenesis. , 2014, Archives of biochemistry and biophysics.

[56]  S. Forbes,et al.  Systematic review: the effects of autologous stem cell therapy for patients with liver disease , 2014, Alimentary pharmacology & therapeutics.

[57]  Ramon Planas,et al.  Hepatic venous pressure gradient predicts clinical decompensation in patients with compensated cirrhosis. , 2007, Gastroenterology.

[58]  D. Hum,et al.  Hepatoprotective effects of the dual peroxisome proliferator‐activated receptor alpha/delta agonist, GFT505, in rodent models of nonalcoholic fatty liver disease/nonalcoholic steatohepatitis , 2013, Hepatology.

[59]  Lan Wei,et al.  Molecular MR imaging of liver fibrosis: a feasibility study using rat and mouse models. , 2012, Journal of hepatology.

[60]  S. Friedman,et al.  Reversal, maintenance or progression: what happens to the liver after a virologic cure of hepatitis C? , 2014, Antiviral research.

[61]  J. Hoefs,et al.  Quantitative liver function tests improve the prediction of clinical outcomes in chronic hepatitis C: Results from the hepatitis C antiviral long‐term treatment against cirrhosis trial , 2012, Hepatology.

[62]  D. Mann,et al.  Clinical evidence for the regression of liver fibrosis. , 2012, Journal of hepatology.

[63]  N. Rosenthal,et al.  Preparing the ground for tissue regeneration: from mechanism to therapy , 2014, Nature Medicine.

[64]  P. Tontonoz,et al.  Liver X receptor signaling is a determinant of stellate cell activation and susceptibility to fibrotic liver disease. , 2011, Gastroenterology.

[65]  F. Bellanti,et al.  Free radical biology for medicine: learning from nonalcoholic fatty liver disease. , 2013, Free radical biology & medicine.

[66]  R. Perez-Tamayo Cirrhosis of the liver: a reversible disease? , 1979, Pathology annual.

[67]  J. Pawlotsky,et al.  Liver stiffness diminishes with antiviral response in chronic hepatitis C , 2011, Alimentary pharmacology & therapeutics.

[68]  K. Yoshizato,et al.  Down‐regulation of cyclin E1 expression by microrna‐195 accounts for interferon‐β‐induced inhibition of hepatic stellate cell proliferation , 2011, Journal of cellular physiology.

[69]  S. Friedman,et al.  A novel murine model to deplete hepatic stellate cells uncovers their role in amplifying liver damage in mice , 2013, Hepatology.

[70]  David Hecht,et al.  Oral IDN‐6556, an antiapoptotic caspase inhibitor, may lower aminotransferase activity in patients with chronic hepatitis C , 2007, Hepatology.

[71]  S. Forbes,et al.  Links between hepatic fibrosis, ductular reaction, and progenitor cell expansion. , 2014, Gastroenterology.

[72]  S. Robson,et al.  Purinergic Signaling in Liver Disease , 2014, Digestive Diseases.

[73]  K. Kodys,et al.  IL-1 receptor antagonist ameliorates inflammasome-dependent alcoholic steatohepatitis in mice. , 2012, The Journal of clinical investigation.

[74]  R. Schwabe,et al.  Gene expression profiles during hepatic stellate cell activation in culture and in vivo. , 2007, Gastroenterology.

[75]  R. Schwabe,et al.  Absence of hepatic stellate cell retinoid lipid droplets does not enhance hepatic fibrosis but decreases hepatic carcinogenesis , 2011, Gut.

[76]  S. Friedman,et al.  Regression of Fibrosis and Reversal of Cirrhosis in Rats by Galectin Inhibitors in Thioacetamide-Induced Liver Disease , 2013, PloS one.

[77]  Amitabh Chandra,et al.  Ensuring the fiscal sustainability of health care reform. , 2010, The New England journal of medicine.

[78]  A. Wree,et al.  From NAFLD to NASH to cirrhosis—new insights into disease mechanisms , 2013, Nature Reviews Gastroenterology &Hepatology.

[79]  C. Piantadosi,et al.  Hedgehog controls hepatic stellate cell fate by regulating metabolism. , 2012, Gastroenterology.

[80]  G. Karaca,et al.  Smoothened is a master regulator of adult liver repair. , 2013, The Journal of clinical investigation.

[81]  S. Friedman,et al.  Autophagy releases lipid that promotes fibrogenesis by activated hepatic stellate cells in mice and in human tissues. , 2012, Gastroenterology.

[82]  P. Jares,et al.  Ghrelin attenuates hepatocellular injury and liver fibrogenesis in rodents and influences fibrosis progression in humans , 2010, Hepatology.

[83]  M. Layne,et al.  Myocardin-related Transcription Factor-A Complexes Activate Type I Collagen Expression in Lung Fibroblasts* , 2011, The Journal of Biological Chemistry.

[84]  D. Schuppan,et al.  Novel engineered targeted interferon‐gamma blocks hepatic fibrogenesis in mice , 2011, Hepatology.

[85]  M. Robson,et al.  Multiparametric magnetic resonance for the non-invasive diagnosis of liver disease , 2014, Journal of hepatology.

[86]  J. Fallowfield,et al.  Edinburgh Research Explorer Differential Ly-6C expression identifies the recruited macrophage phenotype, which orchestrates the regression of murine liver fibrosis Differential Ly-6C expression identi fi es the recruited macrophage phenotype, which orchestrates the regression of murine liver fi brosis , 2022 .

[87]  D. Hume,et al.  Macrophage therapy for murine liver fibrosis recruits host effector cells improving fibrosis, regeneration, and function , 2011, Hepatology.

[88]  S. Friedman,et al.  Contributions of metabolic dysregulation and inflammation to nonalcoholic steatohepatitis, hepatic fibrosis, and cancer , 2014, Current opinion in oncology.

[89]  T. Hibi,et al.  Free cholesterol accumulation in hepatic stellate cells: Mechanism of liver fibrosis aggravation in nonalcoholic steatohepatitis in mice , 2014, Hepatology.

[90]  S. Werner,et al.  Endoplasmic reticulum stress induces fibrogenic activity in hepatic stellate cells through autophagy. , 2013, Journal of hepatology.

[91]  M. Braddock,et al.  The role of fibroblast growth factor 21 in the pathogenesis of liver disease: a novel predictor and therapeutic target , 2014, Expert opinion on therapeutic targets.

[92]  W. Jeong,et al.  Alcohol dehydrogenase III exacerbates liver fibrosis by enhancing stellate cell activation and suppressing natural killer cells in mice , 2014, Hepatology.

[93]  Taotao Ma,et al.  DNMT1-mediated PTEN hypermethylation confers hepatic stellate cell activation and liver fibrogenesis in rats. , 2012, Toxicology and applied pharmacology.

[94]  J. Duffield,et al.  PRM-151 (recombinant human serum amyloid P/pentraxin 2) for the treatment of fibrosis. , 2010, Drug news & perspectives.

[95]  J. Sicklick,et al.  Sustained activation of Rac1 in hepatic stellate cells promotes liver injury and fibrosis in mice , 2006, Hepatology.

[96]  J. Sninsky,et al.  Role of a cirrhosis risk score for the early prediction of fibrosis progression in hepatitis C patients with minimal liver disease. , 2009, Journal of hepatology.

[97]  John P Iredale,et al.  Elastin accumulation is regulated at the level of degradation by macrophage metalloelastase (MMP‐12) during experimental liver fibrosis , 2012, Hepatology.

[98]  H. Koga,et al.  Adiponectin suppresses endoplasmic reticulum stress in nonalcoholic steatohepatitis. , 2011, Experimental and therapeutic medicine.

[99]  Lan Wei,et al.  Molecular MRI of collagen to diagnose and stage liver fibrosis. , 2013, Journal of hepatology.

[100]  Junfeng Zhang,et al.  The Autoregulatory Feedback Loop of MicroRNA-21/Programmed Cell Death Protein 4/Activation Protein-1 (MiR-21/PDCD4/AP-1) as a Driving Force for Hepatic Fibrosis Development* , 2013, The Journal of Biological Chemistry.

[101]  D. Griggs,et al.  Selective αv integrin depletion identifies a core, targetable molecular pathway that regulates fibrosis across solid organs , 2013, Nature Network Boston.

[102]  V. Paradis,et al.  A morphometric and immunohistochemical study to assess the benefit of a sustained virological response in hepatitis C virus patients with cirrhosis , 2012, Hepatology.

[103]  Jaw-Town Lin,et al.  Improvement of Nonalcoholic Fatty Liver Disease After Bariatric Surgery in Morbidly Obese Chinese Patients , 2012, Obesity Surgery.

[104]  W. Mehal The Gordian Knot of dysbiosis, obesity and NAFLD , 2013, Nature Reviews Gastroenterology &Hepatology.

[105]  John F. Flaherty,et al.  Regression of cirrhosis during treatment with tenofovir disoproxil fumarate for chronic hepatitis B: a 5-year open-label follow-up study , 2013, The Lancet.

[106]  Tse-Ching Chen,et al.  Imatinib Mesylate Improves Liver Regeneration and Attenuates Liver Fibrogenesis in CCL4-Treated Mice , 2012, Journal of Gastrointestinal Surgery.

[107]  V. Ratziu Starting the battle to control non-alcoholic steatohepatitis , 2015, The Lancet.

[108]  Sushant Bhatnagar,et al.  Fibroblast Growth Factor-19, a Novel Factor That Inhibits Hepatic Fatty Acid Synthesis* , 2009, Journal of Biological Chemistry.

[109]  J. Fallowfield,et al.  Using non-invasive biomarkers to identify hepatic fibrosis in people with type 2 diabetes mellitus: the Edinburgh type 2 diabetes study. , 2014, Journal of hepatology.

[110]  A. Mallat,et al.  Cannabinoid signaling and liver therapeutics. , 2013, Journal of hepatology.

[111]  R. Schwabe,et al.  Fate-tracing reveals hepatic stellate cells as dominant contributors to liver fibrosis independent of its etiology , 2013, Nature Communications.

[112]  D. Lorrain,et al.  A novel, orally active LPA1 receptor antagonist inhibits lung fibrosis in the mouse bleomycin model , 2010, British journal of pharmacology.

[113]  Qingjian Wang,et al.  Cooperative interaction of CTGF and TGF-β in animal models of fibrotic disease , 2011, Fibrogenesis & tissue repair.

[114]  M. Ebrahimkhani,et al.  Stimulating healthy tissue regeneration by targeting the 5-HT2B receptor in chronic liver disease , 2011, Nature Medicine.

[115]  Tsutomu Masaki,et al.  Imatinib mesylate (STI-571) attenuates liver fibrosis development in rats. , 2005, American journal of physiology. Gastrointestinal and liver physiology.

[116]  T. Luedde,et al.  Pharmacological inhibition of the chemokine C‐C motif chemokine ligand 2 (monocyte chemoattractant protein 1) accelerates liver fibrosis regression by suppressing Ly‐6C+ macrophage infiltration in mice , 2014, Hepatology.

[117]  M. Manns,et al.  Association between sustained virological response and all-cause mortality among patients with chronic hepatitis C and advanced hepatic fibrosis. , 2012, JAMA.

[118]  K. Yoshizato,et al.  MicroRNA-221/222 upregulation indicates the activation of stellate cells and the progression of liver fibrosis , 2012, Gut.

[119]  S. Reif,et al.  Amplified Inhibition of Stellate Cell Activation Pathways by PPAR-γ, RAR and RXR Agonists , 2013, PloS one.

[120]  Alexander A. Morgan,et al.  Supplementary Materials for Computational Repositioning of the Anticonvulsant Topiramate for Inflammatory Bowel Disease , 2011 .

[121]  L. Marín-Gómez,et al.  GATA4 loss in the septum transversum mesenchyme promotes liver fibrosis in mice , 2014, Hepatology.

[122]  D. Thabut,et al.  Origins and functions of liver myofibroblasts. , 2013, Biochimica et biophysica acta.

[123]  D. Mann,et al.  NF-kappaB signalling: embracing complexity to achieve translation. , 2010, Journal of hepatology.

[124]  Derek Marshall,et al.  Allosteric inhibition of lysyl oxidase–like-2 impedes the development of a pathologic microenvironment , 2010, Nature Medicine.

[125]  B. Gao,et al.  Natural killer and natural killer T cells in liver fibrosis. , 2013, Biochimica et biophysica acta.

[126]  P. Weinreb,et al.  Inhibition of Integrin αvβ6, an Activator of Latent Transforming Growth Factor-β, Prevents Radiation-induced Lung Fibrosis , 2008 .

[127]  F. Ginhoux,et al.  Hepatic recruitment of the inflammatory Gr1+ monocyte subset upon liver injury promotes hepatic fibrosis , 2009, Hepatology.

[128]  K. Zatloukal,et al.  Farnesoid X receptor critically determines the fibrotic response in mice but is expressed to a low extent in human hepatic stellate cells and periductal myofibroblasts. , 2009, The American journal of pathology.

[129]  Christopher J. Parsons,et al.  Antifibrotic effects of a tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinase‐1 antibody on established liver fibrosis in rats , 2004, Hepatology.

[130]  L. DeLeve Liver sinusoidal endothelial cells in hepatic fibrosis , 2015, Hepatology.

[131]  S. Mudaliar,et al.  Efficacy and safety of the farnesoid X receptor agonist obeticholic acid in patients with type 2 diabetes and nonalcoholic fatty liver disease. , 2013, Gastroenterology.

[132]  Frank Tacke,et al.  Macrophage heterogeneity in liver injury and fibrosis. , 2014, Journal of hepatology.

[133]  H. Bonkovsky,et al.  Novel role of nuclear receptor rev‐erbα in hepatic stellate cell activation: Potential therapeutic target for liver injury , 2014, Hepatology.

[134]  A. Miyajima,et al.  Hepatic Stellate Cell-derived Delta-like Homolog 1 (DLK1) Protein in Liver Regeneration* , 2012, The Journal of Biological Chemistry.

[135]  S. Friedman,et al.  Now there are many (stages) where before there was one: In search of a pathophysiological classification of cirrhosis , 2010, Hepatology.

[136]  T. Luedde,et al.  Micro‐RNA profiling reveals a role for miR‐29 in human and murine liver fibrosis , 2011, Hepatology.

[137]  Kristian Helin,et al.  Chromatin proteins and modifications as drug targets , 2013, Nature.