Systematic Review of Abstinence-Plus HIV Prevention Programs in High-Income Countries

Background Abstinence-plus (comprehensive) interventions promote sexual abstinence as the best means of preventing HIV, but also encourage condom use and other safer-sex practices. Some critics of abstinence-plus programs have suggested that promoting safer sex along with abstinence may undermine abstinence messages or confuse program participants; conversely, others have suggested that promoting abstinence might undermine safer-sex messages. We conducted a systematic review to investigate the effectiveness of abstinence-plus interventions for HIV prevention among any participants in high-income countries as defined by the World Bank. Methods and Findings Cochrane Collaboration systematic review methods were used. We included randomized and quasi-randomized controlled trials of abstinence-plus programs for HIV prevention among any participants in any high-income country; trials were included if they reported behavioural or biological outcomes. We searched 30 electronic databases without linguistic or geographical restrictions to February 2007, in addition to contacting experts, hand-searching conference abstracts, and cross-referencing papers. After screening 20,070 abstracts and 325 full published and unpublished papers, we included 39 trials that included approximately 37,724 North American youth. Programs were based in schools (10), community facilities (24), both schools and community facilities (2), health care facilities (2), and family homes (1). Control groups varied. All outcomes were self-reported. Quantitative synthesis was not possible because of heterogeneity across trials in programs and evaluation designs. Results suggested that many abstinence-plus programs can reduce HIV risk as indicated by self-reported sexual behaviours. Of 39 trials, 23 found a protective program effect on at least one sexual behaviour, including abstinence, condom use, and unprotected sex (baseline n = 19,819). No trial found adverse program effects on any behavioural outcome, including incidence of sex, frequency of sex, sexual initiation, or condom use. This suggests that abstinence-plus approaches do not undermine program messages encouraging abstinence, nor do they undermine program messages encouraging safer sex. Findings consistently favoured abstinence-plus programs over controls for HIV knowledge outcomes, suggesting that abstinence-plus programs do not confuse participants. Results for biological outcomes were limited by floor effects. Three trials assessed self-reported diagnosis or treatment of sexually transmitted infection; none found significant effects. Limited evidence from seven evaluations suggested that some abstinence-plus programs can reduce pregnancy incidence. No trial observed an adverse biological program effect. Conclusions Many abstinence-plus programs appear to reduce short-term and long-term HIV risk behaviour among youth in high-income countries. Programs did not cause harm. Although generalisability may be somewhat limited to North American adolescents, these findings have critical implications for abstinence-based HIV prevention policies. Suggestions are provided for improving the conduct and reporting of trials of abstinence-plus and other behavioural interventions to prevent HIV.

[1]  P. Aggleton,et al.  Sexuality Education and Young People's Sexual Behavior , 1997, Journal of adolescent research.

[2]  B. Stanton,et al.  Influence of prior sexual risk experience on response to intervention targeting multiple risk behaviors among adolescents. , 2005, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[3]  A. O'Leary,et al.  Reflections on the design and reporting of STD/HIV behavioral intervention research. , 1997, AIDS education and prevention : official publication of the International Society for AIDS Education.

[4]  B. Stanton,et al.  Trial of an urban adolescent sexual risk-reduction intervention for rural youth: a promising but imperfect fit. , 2006, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[5]  N. Assefi,et al.  School-based teenage pregnancy prevention programs: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials. , 2005, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[6]  H. Jaffe Whatever Happened to the U.S. AIDS Epidemic? , 2004, Science.

[7]  B. Flay,et al.  Impact of a school-based AIDS prevention program on risk and protective behavior for newly sexually active students. , 1995, The Journal of school health.

[8]  Daniel Romer,et al.  “Talking” computers: A reliable and private method to conduct interviews on sensitive topics with children , 1997 .

[9]  K. Ethier,et al.  Behavioral interventions to reduce incidence of HIV, STD, and pregnancy among adolescents: a decade in review. , 2004, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[10]  B. Stanton,et al.  The complex business of adapting effective interventions to new populations: an urban to rural transfer. , 2005, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[11]  Renee F Wilson,et al.  Long-term reductions in sexual initiation and sexual activity among urban middle schoolers in the reach for health service learning program. , 2002, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[12]  L. Hedges,et al.  Meta‐analysis of the Effects of Behavioral HIV Prevention Interventions on the Sexual Risk Behavior of Sexually Experienced Adolescents in Controlled Studies in the United States , 2002, Journal of acquired immune deficiency syndromes.

[13]  H. Handoll,et al.  Interventions for replacing missing teeth: different times for loading dental implants. , 2004, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[14]  Moberg Dp,et al.  The Healthy for Life Project: Sexual Risk Behavior Outcomes. , 1998 .

[15]  B. Stanton,et al.  Challenges and Rewards of Involving Community in Research: An Overview of the "Focus on Kids" HIV Risk Reduction Program , 1996, Health education quarterly.

[16]  S. Gregorich,et al.  Draw the line/respect the line: a randomized trial of a middle school intervention to reduce sexual risk behaviors. , 2004, American journal of public health.

[17]  Mark Thomas,et al.  Abstinence-based programs for prevention of adolescent pregnancies. A review. , 2000, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[18]  M. Rotheram-Borus,et al.  Prevention of HIV Among Adolescents , 2000, Prevention Science.

[19]  J. Frost,et al.  Understanding the impact of effective teenage pregnancy prevention programs. , 1995, Family planning perspectives.

[20]  G. Makulowich European approaches to adolescent sexual behavior. , 1999, AIDS patient care and STDs.

[21]  N. Goldman,et al.  Teenage pregnancy in developed countries: determinants and policy implications. , 1985, Family planning perspectives.

[22]  S. Ferguson Peer Counseling in a Culturally Specific Adolescent Pregnancy Prevention Program , 1998, Journal of health care for the poor and underserved.

[23]  B. Stanton,et al.  Parental underestimates of adolescent risk behavior: a randomized, controlled trial of a parental monitoring intervention. , 2000, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[24]  L. Jemmott,et al.  HIV risk reduction behavioral interventions with heterosexual adolescents. , 2000, AIDS.

[25]  D. Kirby The impact of schools and school programs upon adolescent sexual behavior , 2002, Journal of sex research.

[26]  L. O'donnell,et al.  The effectiveness of the Reach for Health Community Youth Service learning program in reducing early and unprotected sex among urban middle school students. , 1999, American journal of public health.

[27]  S. Casswell,et al.  What is meant by intention to treat analysis? Survey of published randomised controlled trials , 1999 .

[28]  Lauritsen Jl,et al.  The Consistency of Self-Reported Initiation of Sexual Activity , 1997 .

[29]  M. Somerfield,et al.  Consistency of adolescents' self-report of sexual behavior in a longitudinal study , 1993 .

[30]  F. Mccarty,et al.  An exploration of social cognitive theory mediators of father-son communication about sex. , 2006, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[31]  K. Underhill,et al.  Abstinence-only programs for HIV infection prevention in high-income countries. , 2007, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[32]  D. Kirby,et al.  The Impact of Sex and HIV Education Programs in Schools and Communities on Sexual Behaviors among Young Adults , 2006 .

[33]  Kristin Haglund Sexually abstinent African American adolescent females' descriptions of abstinence. , 2003, Journal of nursing scholarship : an official publication of Sigma Theta Tau International Honor Society of Nursing.

[34]  R. Gold,et al.  States' implementation of the Section 510 abstinence education program, FY 1999. , 2001, Family planning perspectives.

[35]  J. Dilley,et al.  Risk of HIV infection attributable to oral sex among men who have sex with men and in the population of men who have sex with men. , 2002, AIDS.

[36]  Paul Montgomery,et al.  Sexual abstinence only programmes to prevent HIV infection in high income countries: systematic review , 2007, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[37]  G. Fong,et al.  Abstinence and safer sex HIV risk-reduction interventions for African American adolescents: a randomized controlled trial. , 1998, JAMA.

[38]  D. Piper,et al.  The Healthy for Life Project: Behavioral Outcomes , 2000, Journal of Primary Prevention.

[39]  J. Phillips,et al.  The meaning of abstinence for college students. , 1998 .

[40]  Janet L. Lauritsen,et al.  The consistency of self-reported initiation of sexual activity. , 1997, Family planning perspectives.

[41]  G. T. Fong,et al.  Reducing HIV risk-associated sexual behavior among african american adolescents: Testing the generality of intervention effects , 1999, American journal of community psychology.

[42]  Deirdre A. Fullerton,et al.  Sexual health education interventions for young people: a methodological review , 1995, BMJ.

[43]  D. Koniak-Griffin,et al.  Evaluating the Outcomes of Parent-Child Family Life Education , 1999, Scholarly Inquiry for Nursing Practice.

[44]  B. Flay,et al.  Impact of a school-based AIDS prevention program on young adolescents' self-efficacy skills , 1995 .

[45]  K. Roghmann,et al.  Self-reported honesty among middle and high school students responding to a sexual behavior questionnaire. , 1998, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[46]  G. Parcel,et al.  The "Safer Choices" intervention: its impact on the sexual behaviors of different subgroups of high school students. , 2004, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[47]  B. Stanton,et al.  A randomized, controlled effectiveness trial of an AIDS prevention program for low-income African-American youths. , 1996, Archives of pediatrics & adolescent medicine.

[48]  S. M. Rogers,et al.  Adolescent sexual behavior, drug use, and violence: increased reporting with computer survey technology. , 1998, Science.

[49]  T. Brasfield,et al.  Sexual risk reduction and anger management interventions for incarcerated male adolescents: a randomized controlled trial of two interventions. , 1999 .

[50]  J. Reinisch,et al.  Would you say you "had sex" if...? , 1999, JAMA.

[51]  D. Kirby Emerging Answers: Research Findings on Programs to Reduce Teen Pregnancy (Summary) , 2001 .

[52]  M. Pitts,et al.  Which Behaviors Constitute “Having Sex” Among University Students in the UK? , 2001, Archives of sexual behavior.

[53]  B. Huberman,et al.  Lessons Learned: European Approaches to Adolescent Sexual Behavior and Responsibility , 2000 .

[54]  D. Piper,et al.  The Healthy for Life project: sexual risk behavior outcomes. , 1998, AIDS education and prevention : official publication of the International Society for AIDS Education.

[55]  T. Cheng,et al.  A STD/HIV Prevention Trial Among Adolescents in Managed Care , 1999, Pediatrics.

[56]  L. Kann,et al.  Assessing health risk behaviors among adolescents: the effect of question wording and appeals for honesty. , 2004, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[57]  D. Kirby,et al.  An impact evaluation of project SNAPP: an AIDS and pregnancy prevention middle school program. , 1997, AIDS education and prevention : official publication of the International Society for AIDS Education.

[58]  A. O'Leary,et al.  Measurement of condom use self-efficacy and outcome expectancies in a geographically diverse group of STD patients. , 1997, AIDS education and prevention : official publication of the International Society for AIDS Education.

[59]  R. Schleifer Ignorance Only: HIV/AIDS, Human Rights, and Federally Funded Abstinence-Only Programs in the United States. Texas: A Case Study. , 2002 .

[60]  K. Underhill,et al.  Reporting deficiencies in trials of abstinence-only programmes for HIV prevention. , 2007, AIDS.

[61]  R. DiClemente Preventing sexually transmitted infections among adolescents: a clash of ideology and science. , 1998, JAMA.

[62]  K. Resnicow,et al.  Keepin' It R.E.A.L.!: Results of a Mother-Adolescent HIV Prevention Program , 2006, Nursing research.

[63]  Mónica Silva The effectiveness of school-based sex education programs in the promotion of abstinent behavior: a meta-analysis. , 2002, Health education research.

[64]  J. Jemmott,et al.  A randomized controlled trial testing an HIV prevention intervention for Latino youth. , 2006, Archives of pediatrics & adolescent medicine.

[65]  B. Fiese,et al.  HIV Sexual Risk-Reduction Interventions for Youth: A Review and Methodological Critique of Randomized Controlled Trials , 2003, Behavior modification.

[66]  J. Rosenbaum Reborn a virgin: adolescents' retracting of virginity pledges and sexual histories. , 2006, American journal of public health.

[67]  R. Walgate Bush's AIDS plan criticised for emphasising abstinence and forbidding condoms , 2004, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[68]  Justine Wheeler,et al.  Impacts of Four Title V Section 510 Abstinence Education Programs , 2007 .

[69]  W A Fisher,et al.  Changing AIDS-risk behavior. , 1992, Psychological bulletin.

[70]  P. Vernazza,et al.  Sexual transmission of HIV: infectiousness and prevention. , 1999, AIDS.

[71]  S. Blake,et al.  Effects of a parent-child communications intervention on young adolescents' risk for early onset of sexual intercourse. , 2001, Family planning perspectives.

[72]  D. Moher,et al.  The CONSORT statement: revised recommendations for improving the quality of reports of parallel-group randomised trials , 2001, The Lancet.

[73]  K. Coyle,et al.  School-based Programs to Reduce Sexual Risk-taking Behavior 1 1 This article has been adapted from , 1997 .

[74]  D. Orr,et al.  Validity of Self‐Reported Sexual Behaviors in Adolescent Women Using Biomarker Outcomes , 1997, Sexually transmitted diseases.

[75]  G. Parcel,et al.  Safer Choices: Reducing Teen Pregnancy, HIV, and STDs , 2001, Public health reports.

[76]  D. Kirby School-based programs to reduce sexual risk-taking behaviors. , 1992, The Journal of school health.

[77]  G. Parcel,et al.  Schoolwide Effects of a Multicomponent HIV, STD, and Pregnancy Prevention Program for High School Students , 2001, Health education & behavior : the official publication of the Society for Public Health Education.

[78]  S. Chaiken,et al.  The psychology of attitudes. , 1993 .

[79]  Walter W. Hauck,et al.  Effects of Interviewer Gender, Interviewer Choice, and Item Wording on Responses to Questions Concerning Sexual Behavior , 1996 .

[80]  K. Resnicow,et al.  Keepin’ It R.E.A.L.!: Program Description and Results of Baseline Assessment , 2002, Health education & behavior : the official publication of the Society for Public Health Education.

[81]  T. Raine,et al.  Postponing sexual intercourse among urban junior high school students-a randomized controlled evaluation. , 2000, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[82]  J. Jemmott,et al.  Recruitment and retention of Latino adolescents to a research study: lessons learned from a randomized clinical trial. , 2006, Journal for specialists in pediatric nursing : JSPN.

[83]  Neff Walker,et al.  The global impact of HIV/AIDS , 2001, Nature.

[84]  Emily West,et al.  Preventing pregnancy and improving health care access among teenagers: an evaluation of the children's aid society-carrera program. , 2002, Perspectives on sexual and reproductive health.

[85]  Helen H. Cagampang,et al.  The impact of the Postponing Sexual Involvement curriculum among youths in California. , 1997, Family planning perspectives.

[86]  R. Rector The Effectiveness of Abstinence Education Programs in Reducing Sexual Activity Among Youth , 2002 .

[87]  K. Dickersin,et al.  Effectiveness of the 40 adolescent AIDS-risk reduction interventions: a quantitative review. , 1997, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[88]  Ron Haskins,et al.  Abstinence Education under Welfare Reform , 1997 .

[89]  Douglas G. Altman,et al.  The CONSORT statement: revised recommendations for improving the quality of reports of parallel-group randomised trials , 2001, The Lancet.

[90]  J. Udry,et al.  Adolescents' Honesty in a Survey of Sexual Behavior , 1988 .

[91]  S. Tortolero,et al.  Challenges in replicating interventions. , 2007, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[92]  Mike Clarke,et al.  Is Evidence-Based Medicine Relevant to the Developing World? , 2005, Evidence-based complementary and alternative medicine : eCAM.

[93]  F. J. Smith,et al.  Abstinence, protection, and decision-making: experimental trials on prototypic AIDS programs , 1990 .

[94]  R. Winett,et al.  Outcomes of a randomized, controlled community-level HIV prevention intervention for adolescents in low-income housing developments , 2005, AIDS.

[95]  B. Stanton,et al.  Randomized trial of a parent intervention: parents can make a difference in long-term adolescent risk behaviors, perceptions, and knowledge. , 2004, Archives of pediatrics & adolescent medicine.

[96]  A. O'Connor The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews , 2004 .

[97]  G. Parcel,et al.  Short-term impact of safer choices: a multicomponent, school-based HIV, other STD, and pregnancy prevention program. , 1999, The Journal of school health.

[98]  Blair T. Johnson,et al.  Interventions to reduce sexual risk for the human immunodeficiency virus in adolescents, 1985-2000: a research synthesis. , 2003, Archives of pediatrics & adolescent medicine.

[99]  K. Underhill,et al.  Abstinence-plus programs for HIV infection prevention in high-income countries. , 2007, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[100]  E. J. O'keefe,et al.  Sexually transmitted infections, blood-borne viruses and risk behaviour in an Australian senior high school population--the SHLiRP study. , 2005, Sexual health.

[101]  James N Gribble,et al.  Interview Mode and Measurement of Sexual Behaviors: Methodological Issues. , 1999, Journal of sex research.

[102]  D. Paulhus,et al.  Socially desirable responding and sexuality self‐reports , 1998 .

[103]  B. Stanton,et al.  Sustaining and broadening intervention impact: a longitudinal randomized trial of 3 adolescent risk reduction approaches. , 2003, Pediatrics.

[104]  K. Crittenden,et al.  Mothers' effectiveness as HIV risk reduction educators for adolescent daughters , 2006, Journal of health care for the poor and underserved.

[105]  I. de Vincenzi,et al.  Probabilities of sexual HIV‐1 transmission , 1996, AIDS.

[106]  M. Kennedy,et al.  The effect of tailoring a model HIV prevention program for local adolescent target audiences. , 2000, AIDS education and prevention : official publication of the International Society for AIDS Education.

[107]  R. DiClemente The Emergence of Adolescents as a Risk Group for Human Immunodeficiency Virus Infection , 1990 .

[108]  Xiaoming Li,et al.  Parental monitoring intervention: practice makes perfect. , 2002, Journal of the National Medical Association.

[109]  J. Jemmott,et al.  Designing a culturally based intervention to reduce HIV sexual risk for Latino adolescents. , 2005, The Journal of the Association of Nurses in AIDS Care : JANAC.

[110]  P. Aggleton,et al.  HIV Prevention in Industrialized Countries , 2000 .

[111]  Jill R. Glassman,et al.  All4You! A randomized trial of an HIV, other STDs, and pregnancy prevention intervention for alternative school students. , 2006, AIDS education and prevention : official publication of the International Society for AIDS Education.

[112]  G. Guyatt,et al.  Interventions to reduce unintended pregnancies among adolescents: systematic review of randomised controlled trials , 2002, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[113]  A Shirley,et al.  Cognitive-behavioral intervention to reduce African American adolescents' risk for HIV infection. , 1995, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[114]  Douglas Kirby,et al.  Effective approaches to reducing adolescent unprotected sex, pregnancy, and childbearing , 2002, Journal of sex research.

[115]  Brown Ss National campaign to prevent teen pregnancy. , 1996 .

[116]  L. Zabin,et al.  Adolescent sexual attitudes and behavior: are they consistent? , 1984, Family planning perspectives.

[117]  T. Sheldon,et al.  Preventing unintended teenage pregnancies and reducing their adverse effects. , 1997, Quality in health care : QHC.

[118]  B. Miller Impact Evaluation of FACTS & Feelings: A Home-Based Video Sex Education Curriculum. , 1993 .

[119]  J. S. St. Lawrence,et al.  Reducing STD and HIV risk behavior of substance-dependent adolescents: a randomized controlled trial. , 2002, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[120]  D. Roth,et al.  Adult identity mentoring: reducing sexual risk for African-American seventh grade students. , 2005, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[121]  J. Shoveller,et al.  Preventing HIV/AIDS Risk Behavior Among Youth , 2002, AIDS and Behavior.

[122]  C. Franklin,et al.  Effectiveness of prevention programs for adolescent pregnancy : A meta-analysis , 1997 .

[123]  G. Fong,et al.  Reductions in HIV risk-associated sexual behaviors among black male adolescents: effects of an AIDS prevention intervention. , 1992, American journal of public health.

[124]  Joseph A. Catania,et al.  Respondents' Understanding of the Words Used in Sexual Behavior Questions , 1998 .

[125]  D. Celentano,et al.  The social epidemiology of human immunodeficiency virus/acquired immunodeficiency syndrome. , 2004, Epidemiologic reviews.

[126]  J. S. St. Lawrence,et al.  Comparison of education versus behavioral skills training interventions in lowering sexual HIV-risk behavior of substance-dependent adolescents. , 1995, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[127]  D. Kirby Sexuality education: a more realistic view of its effects. , 1985, The Journal of school health.

[128]  L. Hedges,et al.  A Protocol for the Analytical Aspects of a Systematic Review of HIV Prevention Research , 2002, Journal of acquired immune deficiency syndromes.

[129]  B. Flay,et al.  Does parental involvement make a difference? The impact of parent interactive activities on students in a school-based AIDS prevention program. , 1997, AIDS education and prevention : official publication of the International Society for AIDS Education.

[130]  R. Devellis,et al.  The reliability of high-risk adolescent girls' report of their sexual history. , 1996, Journal of pediatric health care : official publication of National Association of Pediatric Nurse Associates & Practitioners.

[131]  L. Remez Oral sex among adolescents: is it sex or is it abstinence? , 2000, Family planning perspectives.

[132]  M. Smith Teen Incentives Program: evaluation of a health promotion model for adolescent pregnancy prevention. , 1994, Journal of health education.

[133]  S. Potthoff,et al.  The Validity of Self‐Reported Condom Use Among Adolescents , 1997, Sexually transmitted diseases.

[134]  Anne Gienapp,et al.  Using randomized designs to evaluate client-centered programs to prevent adolescent pregnancy. , 2000, Family planning perspectives.

[135]  M. Greenlick,et al.  Reproductive health counseling for young men: what does it do? , 1990, Family planning perspectives.

[136]  M. Goldberg,et al.  School-Based Screening for Chlamydia Trachomatis and Neisseria Gonorrhoeae Among Philadelphia Public High School Students , 2006, Sexually transmitted diseases.