Autograft or allograft for reconstruction of anterior cruciate ligament: a health economics perspective

PurposeTo assess the clinical and cost-effectiveness of allografts versus autografts in the reconstruction of anterior cruciate ligaments.MethodsSystematic review of comparative clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness analysis.ResultsBoth autograft and allograft reconstruction are highly effective. Recent studies show little difference in failure rates between autografts and allografts (about 6% and 7%, respectively). In cost-effectiveness analysis, the price differential is the main factor, making autografts the first choice. However, there will be situations, particularly in revision ACL reconstruction, where an allograft may be preferred, or may be the only reasonable option available.ConclusionIn ACL reconstruction, clinical results with autografts are as good as or slightly better than with allografts. Allografts cost more, indicating that autografts are more cost-effective and should usually be first choice.Level of evidenceII.

[1]  B. Cole,et al.  Hamstring autograft versus soft-tissue allograft in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. , 2014, Arthroscopy : the journal of arthroscopic & related surgery : official publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association.

[2]  C. Kaeding,et al.  Comparison of the hospital cost of autograft versus allograft soft-tissue anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions. , 2010, Arthroscopy : the journal of arthroscopic & related surgery : official publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association.

[3]  K. Spindler,et al.  A Systematic Review of Failed Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction With Autograft Compared With Allograft in Young Patients , 2015, Sports health.

[4]  T. Schlegel,et al.  A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Comparing 3 Anterior Cruciate Ligament Graft Types , 2012, The American journal of sports medicine.

[5]  L. Engebretsen,et al.  Patient demographic and surgical characteristics in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a description of registries from six countries , 2018, British Journal of Sports Medicine.

[6]  Timothy E Hewett,et al.  Autograft Versus Nonirradiated Allograft Tissue for Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction , 2014, The American journal of sports medicine.

[7]  B. Bach,et al.  Economic Analyses in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction , 2016, The American journal of sports medicine.

[8]  S. Tejwani,et al.  Revision Risk After Allograft Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction , 2015, The American journal of sports medicine.

[9]  B. Waterman,et al.  Septic Arthritis After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: Clinical and Functional Outcomes Based on Graft Retention or Removal , 2018, Orthopaedic journal of sports medicine.

[10]  Shu-guang Gao,et al.  Autograft Versus Allograft in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Meta-analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials and Systematic Review of Overlapping Systematic Reviews. , 2016, Arthroscopy : the journal of arthroscopic & related surgery : official publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association.

[11]  J. Tokish,et al.  Autograft Versus Allograft Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction , 2015, The American journal of sports medicine.

[12]  J. Brazier,et al.  Populating an economic model with health state utility values: moving toward better practice. , 2010, Value in health : the journal of the International Society for Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes Research.

[13]  P. Neyret,et al.  Autograft superior to both irradiated and non-irradiated allograft for primary ACL reconstruction: a systematic review , 2017, Journal of ISAKOS.

[14]  R. Becker,et al.  Clinical Comparison of the Tutoplast Allograft and Autologous Patellar Tendon (Bone-Patellar Tendon-Bone) for the Reconstruction of the Anterior Cruciate Ligament , 2005, The American journal of sports medicine.

[15]  C. Hulet,et al.  The use of allograft tendons in primary ACL reconstruction , 2019, Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy.

[16]  V. Y. Moraes,et al.  Surgical interventions (microfracture, drilling, mosaicplasty, and allograft transplantation) for treating isolated cartilage defects of the knee in adults. , 2016, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[17]  R. Brophy,et al.  Meta-analysis of the Risk of Infections After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction by Graft Type: Response , 2018, The American journal of sports medicine.

[18]  D. Lintner,et al.  The Cost-Effectiveness of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction in Competitive Athletes , 2017, The American journal of sports medicine.

[19]  M. Mardani-Kivi,et al.  Hamstring tendon autograft versus fresh-frozen tibialis posterior allograft in primary arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a retrospective cohort study with three to six years follow-up , 2016, International Orthopaedics.

[20]  J. Seon,et al.  Comparison of clinical outcomes and second-look arthroscopic findings after ACL reconstruction using a hamstring autograft or a tibialis allograft , 2016, Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy.

[21]  M. Cowie.  National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. , 2015, European heart journal.

[22]  G. Ning,et al.  Autograft versus allograft in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction , 2016, Medicine.

[23]  T. Hewett,et al.  Clinical Outcomes in Revision Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Meta-analysis. , 2018, Arthroscopy : the journal of arthroscopic & related surgery : official publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association.

[24]  D. Dahm,et al.  A meta-analysis of patellar tendon autograft versus patellar tendon allograft in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. , 2008, Arthroscopy : the journal of arthroscopic & related surgery : official publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association.

[25]  Steven B Cohen,et al.  Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with bone-patellar tendon-bone autograft versus allograft in skeletally mature patients aged 25 years or younger , 2016, Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy.

[26]  G. Poehling,et al.  Cost comparison of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: autograft versus allograft. , 2005, Arthroscopy : the journal of arthroscopic & related surgery : official publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association.

[27]  Yan Wang,et al.  Arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with at least 2.5 years' follow-up comparing hamstring tendon autograft and irradiated allograft. , 2011, Arthroscopy : the journal of arthroscopic & related surgery : official publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association.

[28]  R. Brophy,et al.  Meta-analysis of the Risk of Infections After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction by Graft Type , 2018, The American journal of sports medicine.

[29]  M. Drakos,et al.  Effect of Graft Selection on the Incidence of Postoperative Infection in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction , 2010, The American journal of sports medicine.

[30]  Stephen M. Howell,et al.  The effect of graft tissue on anterior cruciate ligament outcomes: a multicenter, prospective, randomized controlled trial comparing autograft hamstrings with fresh-frozen anterior tibialis allograft. , 2012, Arthroscopy : the journal of arthroscopic & related surgery : official publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association.

[31]  Brian J Cole,et al.  Is there a higher failure rate of allografts compared with autografts in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a systematic review of overlapping meta-analyses. , 2015, Arthroscopy : the journal of arthroscopic & related surgery : official publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association.

[32]  S. Zaffagnini,et al.  Does the type of graft affect the outcome of revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction?: A META‐ANALYSIS OF 32 STUDIES , 2017, The bone & joint journal.

[33]  M. Swiontkowski,et al.  Autograft versus allograft: an economic cost comparison of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. , 2011, Arthroscopy : the journal of arthroscopic & related surgery : official publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association.

[34]  P. Greis,et al.  Tibialis anterior or posterior allograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction versus hamstring autograft reconstruction: an economic analysis in a hospital-based outpatient setting. , 2012, Arthroscopy : the journal of arthroscopic & related surgery : official publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association.

[35]  M. Inacio,et al.  Increased Risk of Revision After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction With Bone–Patellar Tendon–Bone Allografts Compared With Autografts , 2017, The American journal of sports medicine.

[36]  A. Hardy,et al.  Complications following harvesting of patellar tendon or hamstring tendon grafts for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: Systematic review of literature. , 2017, Orthopaedics & traumatology, surgery & research : OTSR.

[37]  Steven B Cohen,et al.  Incidence and Characterization of Hypoesthesia in the Distribution of the Infrapatellar Branch of the Saphenous Nerve after Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Prospective Study of Patient-Reported Numbness , 2017, The Journal of Knee Surgery.

[38]  K. Sun,et al.  Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with bone-patellar tendon-bone autograft versus allograft. , 2009, Arthroscopy : the journal of arthroscopic & related surgery : official publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association.

[39]  Jie Wei,et al.  A meta-analysis of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with autograft compared with nonirradiated allograft. , 2015, The Knee.

[40]  S. Song,et al.  Comparison between hamstring autograft and free tendon Achilles allograft: minimum 2-year follow-up after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using EndoButton and Intrafix , 2011, Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy.

[41]  Kang Sun,et al.  Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with BPTB autograft, irradiated versus non-irradiated allograft: a prospective randomized clinical study , 2009, Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy.

[42]  Huiyong Shen,et al.  Comparison of Knee Stability and Synovial Fluid Alterations in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction With a Hamstring Autograft or an Allograft. , 2017, Orthopedics.

[43]  D. Whelan,et al.  Analysis of Irradiation on the Clinical Effectiveness of Allogenic Tissue When Used for Primary Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction , 2015, The American journal of sports medicine.

[44]  Chao Zhang,et al.  Patellar tendon autograft versus patellar tendon allograft in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a systematic review and meta-analysis , 2015, European Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery & Traumatology.

[45]  Matthew J. Brown,et al.  ACL Allograft: Advantages and When to Use , 2018, Sports medicine and arthroscopy review.